p.2 #1Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Juha Kannisto wrote:
...
It's been a long while since I used my 50/2 Heliar classic, I need to give it a fresh run to refresh my memories on how it works I think central sharpness at f2 is similar to Heliar classic 50/1.5 at f2....
I almost picked up a copy of the 50/2 Heliar at Map Camera but let it go when a pristine 1938 5cm Summar showed up. After a while with the Summar, I would say of newer lenses, it reminds me most of the Heliar 50/1.5. Like the Heliar/1.5, the glow with the Summar is heavily dependent on the predominant wavelength in focus. The later Summitar is in the same league.
The Heliar 50/1.5 has more contrast and zero veiling flare compared to the uncoated Summar obviously. Given the above I'd guess that Cosina has a definite interest in the reprise of classic formulas, with modern coatings added perhaps. Probably tweeking the formula to accentuate specific wavelengths. I'd agree, it does look like the Heliar 50/2 provides the same rendering as the 50/1.5, at f/2.
p.2 #2Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
mapgraphs wrote: Juha Kannisto wrote...
It's been a long while since I used my 50/2 Heliar classic, I need to give it a fresh run to refresh my memories on how it works I think central sharpness at f2 is similar to Heliar classic 50/1.5 at f2....I almost picked up a copy of the 50/2 Heliar at Map Camera but let it go when a pristine 1938 5cm Summar showed up. After a while with the Summar, I would say of newer lenses, it reminds me most of the Heliar 50/1.5. Like the Heliar/1.5, the glow with the Summar is heavily dependent on the predominant wavelength in focus. The later Summitar is in the same league.
The Heliar 50/1.5 has more contrast and zero veiling flare compared to the uncoated Summar obviously. Given the above I'd guess that Cosina has a definite interest in the reprise of classic formulas, with modern coatings added perhaps. Probably tweeking the formula to accentuate specific wavelengths. I'd agree, it does look like the Heliar 50/2 provides the same rendering as the 50/1.5, at f/2. ...Show more →
The Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 Heliar is a very versatile lens. Wide open, it offers a unique look, achieving high resolution at close distances with a lot of character in its rendering. Juha's comparison at f/2 shows that its rendering is similar to the CV 50/2 Heliar.
Also, it resembles another lens I love, the Leica 50/2 Rigid. The Leica lens is more contrasty and capable of higher off-axis resolution, but the rendering structure is quite similar as well.
p.2 #3Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
I have a silver version of the 50 2.0 Collapsable Heliar that was from the 250th Anniversary set. I bought it from a member of another forum late in 2018 as a lens for my then new to me M4. I posted about it on this forum because it is more of an oddity than a collectors piece and no one seems to know what it’s worth. It’s a nice lens and I switch between it and a 50 Summicron V5 on the M4. I dug it out yesterday since it’s been a while since it has been used. I may have posted this example before.
M4, Voigtlander 50 2.0 Collapsable Heliar, 5222, HC-110 Dilution B:
And a please-ignore-the-faux-keh-shot. I think it looks very handsome on a black chrome body. One 'advantage' that the nickel version has over the collapsible version is an infinity lock to grab on to vs the the thin focus ring.