fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)

  
 
Juha Kannisto
Online

p.1 #1Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
1 week ago I got this relatively rare lens (Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2) from Yahoo Japan Auctions and Ron (rscheffler) suggested I'd post my impressions about it in a separate thread, so here they are.

Cosina released this lens only as bundled with "250 Jahre" Voigtländer 250th Anniversary limited edition Bessa R3M and R2M film cameras back in 2006 and later a different (limited edition nickel rigid) version was released in 2010 with same optics. Availability in 2nd hand market is quite limited nowadays and affects the pricing. There were 1700 black and 800 silver lenses released in 2006 and later 600 of the nickel limited edition with same optics. I had been interested in the lens for a while already but couldn't ever find one at a price I was willing to pay until now.

Reference information about the lens:
https://cameraquest.com/voigtlen.htm (scroll to: Voigtlander 50mm f/2 Heliar Leica M mount 250th Anniversary lens)
https://cameraquest.com/voigt_250.htm
https://cameraquest.com/voigt_502n.htm
http://www.cosina.co.jp/seihin/voigtlander/archives/Limited.pdf (page 6, in Japanese)

Some basic specs info:
- Mount: VM (M-mount) for the 2006 version, LTM (Leica Thread Mount) for the 2010 version
- Optical design is basically based on original Heliar from 1900, 5 lenses in 3 groups (rather similar to Voigtländer 50/3.5)
- Aperture clicks at half stops from f2 to f8, then only full stops at f11 and f16
- Minimum focus distance: 1m (somewhat limiting)
- 11 aperture blades (resulting in 22 point sunstars)
- Collapsible (safe to collapse into Sony cameras too), but doesn't become a whole lot shorter when collapsed
- Stated weight is 260g (without hood), I measured mine at 256g without caps and hood, 268g with original hood
- 39mm filter thread (same as the new CV 35/2 VM)
- The later nickel edition is lighter at 191g

Some photos showing the lens next to the new CV Ultron 35/2 VM (which is pretty similar in size when 50/2 is collapsed). In addition to its original bundled hood, the 50/2 can also use the same hoods and caps as the 35/2 VM (LH-12, LH-4N).


























View previous versions
Feb 17, 2019 at 03:23 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.1 #2Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Some photos showing the lens on my A9 in collapsed and extended states, with and without hood:


























Feb 17, 2019 at 03:26 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.1 #3Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Lots of samples (all are fine jpegs straight out of camera) from my 1st week of shooting with the lens around several locations in Tokyo in cloudy and sunny weather conditions:

https://photos.app.goo.gl/LDV8yvtSjBhc68XA7

Most of the photos are either close-ups at f2 (wide open) or long distance city shots at f5.6, where I think the lens reaches best corner-to-corner results on my A9. There are also just a few at other apertures like f4 and f2.8. I didn't see any use to stop down further than f5.6.

Exif doesn't include the aperture info since it's a manual adapted lens. I used my Rayqual LM-SαE (v2) adapter.
Feb 17, 2019 at 03:31 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.1 #4Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Impressions after 1st week of use:

I'm really enjoying the lens. It seems like a very nice pair for the new CV Ultron 35/2 since they look and feel quite similar (especially when 50/2 is in collapsed state), and share the same f2 aperture, 39mm filter thread, and can share same hoods (though I think the bundled hood for 50/2 is too narrow for use on 35mm). The focusing rings and aperture rings on both are quite similar too and focusing has a similar feel between both lenses. Wide open rendering of both lenses share some similar classic traits as well.

This 50/2 Heliar doesn't have any of the handling issues that e.g. 50/3.5 IV has (i.e. here the aperture is not clickless, the whole front of the lens doesn't rotate when focusing, aperture is not connected to focusing etc.).

I find the lens to be reasonably sharp at f2 but not razor-like, with nice rendering and background blur. The wide open rendering feels "classic" but is not as funky as e.g. with the 35/1.4 Nokton classic. For infinity shots, corner-to-corner sharpness gets excellent at f5.6 and I don't find much difference at all between optimal focus for center, midfield and corners from f5.6 so the lens is easy to focus. I found the results at f5.6 to be so good that there is no need to use the smaller apertures for me.

With my adapter and camera, the best infinity focus is typically a hair before hard infinity, e.g. in the middle of the first loop in infinity symbol.

There are 11 aperture blades unlike with most other VM lenses, so sunstars will be 22-pointed. I prefer the usual 10-pointed starts, but the extra blade could probably benefit some other types of shooting.

The negatives for me so far include the 1m minimum focus distance which is a bit limiting and I think flare resistance when shooting against the sun is not as good as with some of the most recent Voigtländer lenses. The lens is a bit heavier (at ~260g) than e.g. 35/2 VM and even the 50/1.5 Nokton VM (black version is 220g), but it's built really well. I have sometimes been impressed by the 3D-like depth rendering of 50/3.5 Heliar and so far I'm not sure if the 50/2 can produce a similar effect.

Overall I think I will enjoy this lens a lot and plan to use it together with the CV 35/2 for my general walk-around shooting, when not preferring to go with the native e-mount options. I like the smallish size and look & feel of these 2 lenses a lot.
Feb 17, 2019 at 04:02 AM
hanay78
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Thank you for sharing this post. It is an interesting lens I was not aware of!
Are you still using it?
Feb 09, 2022 at 05:07 PM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.1 #6Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
hanay78 wrote:
Thank you for sharing this post. It is an interesting lens I was not aware of!
Are you still using it?


Thanks! I still have it and I plan to keep it but I haven't used it so often recently since I have a lot of different 50mm lenses and I've been using the new CV 50/1.5 Heliar classic a lot instead since that one was released. The main downside of the older 50/2 Heliar classic for me is the 1m close focus distance whereas the new CV 50/1.5 Heliar classic can focus to 0.5m. Anyhow, it's a nice one to keep in the collection.
Feb 09, 2022 at 08:30 PM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.1 #7Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Here are some more photos I've taken with this lens on 3 of my cameras. I've primarily used it at f5.6 and f2 (wide open) and not much in-between.

Sigma fp:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/RtQg2H8gJNgam1sf9
https://photos.app.goo.gl/CogRk1gdjBpaXXi89

Sony A9:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/xndC29d55hHG2CLP8
https://photos.app.goo.gl/AaFpUcBRyFVDUuKU6

Sony A7C:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/gvtgA6n981crfCac6
Similar shots taken on 50/1.5 Heliar classic at equal apertures on Sigma fp: https://photos.app.goo.gl/ejxpq1wyAHiGozBt6
Feb 10, 2022 at 06:08 AM
Bertrick
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
This same model of this lens was my workhorse lens on my M8.2. I eventually sold my 50mm Summicron and kept this Heliar because when I compared them in identical situations, I either could not distinguish one image from the other, or I preferred the Heliar image. I still have it because, well, it is a Classic Heliar.

I have considered getting the new f/1.5 Heliar. Other than minimum focus distance how do you describe the difference in images from the new 1.5 vs the older 2.0 at apertures in the range from 2.0 to 4.0? I assume that from about F/5.6 onward they are very similar.
Feb 10, 2022 at 06:33 AM
hanay78
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
I have gone through some of your pictures. Thank you very much for sharing them. Bokeh is quite busy, quite circular. The lens seems tiny, which is fantastic IMHO.


Juha Kannisto wrote:
Here are some more photos I've taken with this lens on 3 of my cameras. I've primarily used it at f5.6 and f2 (wide open) and not much in-between.

Sigma fp:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/RtQg2H8gJNgam1sf9
https://photos.app.goo.gl/CogRk1gdjBpaXXi89

Sony A9:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/xndC29d55hHG2CLP8
https://photos.app.goo.gl/AaFpUcBRyFVDUuKU6

Sony A7C:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/gvtgA6n981crfCac6
Similar shots taken on 50/1.5 Heliar classic at equal apertures on Sigma fp: https://photos.app.goo.gl/ejxpq1wyAHiGozBt6


Feb 10, 2022 at 06:49 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.1 #10Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Bertrick wrote:
This same model of this lens was my workhorse lens on my M8.2. I eventually sold my 50mm Summicron and kept this Heliar because when I compared them in identical situations, I either could not distinguish one image from the other, or I preferred the Heliar image. I still have it because, well, it is a Classic Heliar.

I have considered getting the new f/1.5 Heliar. Other than minimum focus distance how do you describe the difference in images from the new 1.5 vs the older 2.0 at apertures in the range from 2.0 to 4.0? I assume that from
...Show more →

I've usually used the older 50/2 wide open and at f5.6 and the new 50/1.5 wide open and at f5.6 and much less at the in-between apertures. I did one comparison shoot with both where I took many shots at f2.0 at 1m or further distances and they were surprisingly similar that time. Generally I think the older 50/2 is probably better corrected once stopped down a bit and the 50/1.5 has more aberrations overall and may have more field curvature on Sony E-mount cameras. 50/1.5 is quite unique wide open and I especially like its wide open rendering at closer to mid-distances. Difficult to say much more about their differences at f2.0 to 4.0 as I haven't done so much side-by-side comparison.
Feb 11, 2022 at 06:17 AM
Bertrick
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
"surprisingly similar" at f/2.0 for 1m and further is very interesting to me and very useful. This increases my interest in the 1.5 Heliar. THANKS!!
Feb 11, 2022 at 08:26 AM
hanay78
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
I am very interested in this heliar 50/2. Actually, I also discovered the Leica elmar-m 50/2.8 which looks very similar externally. Does anybody made a comparison among both? Leica is slower but lighter 167g!
Feb 12, 2022 at 12:57 PM
Sonnar-7
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
I quite like the rendering, feels characterful but more subtle than the 1.5, more swirl and maybe rounder, smaller bokeh balls, less glow but at f2 the 1.5 loses it also.
How do you feel is the central sharpness compared to the 1.5? At f2, I think it might catch-up. Did you witness some flaring artefacts with this one? The 1.5 produces all kind of those, every shape and every colors, I find it to be a great feature as they are warm, contrasty and it’s like having a menu to choose from.
Intriguing lens despite the 1.5 existing now.
Apr 19, 2024 at 01:19 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.1 #14Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Sonnar-7 wrote:
I quite like the rendering, feels characterful but more subtle than the 1.5, more swirl and maybe rounder, smaller bokeh balls, less glow but at f2 the 1.5 loses it also.
How do you feel is the central sharpness compared to the 1.5? At f2, I think it might catch-up. Did you witness some flaring artefacts with this one? The 1.5 produces all kind of those, every shape and every colors, I find it to be a great feature as they are warm, contrasty and it’s like having a menu to choose from.
Intriguing lens despite the 1.5 existing now.


It's been a long while since I used my 50/2 Heliar classic, I need to give it a fresh run to refresh my memories on how it works I think central sharpness at f2 is similar to Heliar classic 50/1.5 at f2, or perhaps a bit sharper. I haven't seen very exotic flaring with the 50/2 but there were cases where it lost a lot of contrast overall when shooting against the sun (more than modern CV lenses). I'll give it a fresh run this weekend to refresh my memories and will share some new samples too

I noticed that currently Map Camera has quite many 2nd hand copies of 50/2 Heliar classic, including the same version as I have in black and also in silver and also some Nickel versions, + a couple that are sold with the originally paired Bessa cameras (those full sets are always quite expensive).
https://www.mapcamera.com/search?keyword=Voigtlander%20Heliar%2050mm%20f2&igngkeyword=1

Looks like the current day prices at Map for the 2nd hand copies of the lens in good condition are between 150K to 160K yen. I got mine at a really good price (67K yen) back in 2019 from Yahoo Japan Auctions (in great condition too). It was a really good deal at that price. At 150K I think it's getting a bit pricey while 50/1.5 Heliar classic also exists and could be bought for half the price.
Apr 19, 2024 at 02:48 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.1 #15Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
@Sonnar-7@ It took a while but this weekend I managed to take my Heliar classic 50/2 out for a long walk while the weather was great and I took a lot of new samples using it with my A7CII.

I used CV VM-E close focus adapter II to get it to focus closer than 1m but I didn't use the close focusing option that much. I think it is quite well behaved already from wide open and not as quirky as Heliar classic 50/1.5. It's fairly sharp already wide open too. I think it doesn't produce much flares when shooting against bright lights but it will lose global contrast quite a bit when shooting against the sun. I enjoyed shooting with it and I think it performed nicely, but if one wants really classic rendering with more aberrations then the Heliar classic 50/1.5 would be a better choice.

For corner-to-corner sharpness at stopped down apertures I think it's better than 50/1.5 at least when adapted to Sony, with less noticeable field curvature.

Lots of samples taken at f2 and f5.6: https://photos.app.goo.gl/LanR7zAmWRNyP4fs9

I applied my favorite filmic preset on them and exported from Raw with C1 Pro.
May 06, 2024 at 07:14 AM
Sonnar-7
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Juha Kannisto wrote:
@Sonnar-7@@ It took a while but this weekend I managed to take my Heliar classic 50/2 out for a long walk while the weather was great and I took a lot of new samples using it with my A7CII.

I used CV VM-E close focus adapter II to get it to focus closer than 1m but I didn't use the close focusing option that much. I think it is quite well behaved already from wide open and not as quirky as Heliar classic 50/1.5. It's fairly sharp already wide open too. I think it doesn't produce much flares when shooting
...Show more →

Haha, thank you for all these samples! That lens did intrigue me, it’s quite an interesting one. It looks like it swirls far more than the Heliar 1.5 that swirls not as much as one would think at looking at the samples Cosina had at the release of the lens(those still bug me since my Heliar doesn’t render much like those).
The bokeh bubbles are smaller but change form quite quickly off center due to the swirl.
The glow is nice at f2, it’s something I discovered lately with the Light Lens Lab Panchro, I used to be put off by a character lens that doesn’t open more than f2, but with the Panchro I learned to appreciate to have the quirks at f2 since I have more definition in the center and still keep the glow and artefacts and the character of the lens, a lens like the Heliar 1.5 will loose most of what makes it interesting in that regard if you push for more definition at f2.
I did not experiment enough with the MS-Optics Sonnetar 50mm 1.3 to see when it looses its character if ever and which parts.
The Heliar f2 seems to complement well the 1.5 by offering character and sharpness in the center the 1.5 lacks a bit.
It looks like it’s far more flare resistant I would have liked.
Nice results and nice photos! Thanks @Juha Kannisto@!

May 06, 2024 at 08:35 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.1 #17Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Bertrick wrote:
"surprisingly similar" at f/2.0 for 1m and further is very interesting to me and very useful. This increases my interest in the 1.5 Heliar. THANKS!!


I would love to see a comparison showing this. The CV 50/1.5 Heliar at f/2 is almost like a different lens compared to when it's wide open. From the images posted and my own experience with the CV 50/1.5 Heliar, it seems that their rendering is similar when both are wide open. However, the f/1.5 version is quite soft wide open, especially for subjects focused at mid-distance.

I wish the tiny CV 40/2.8 Heliar rendered more like the 50/2 Heliar, but I find the former's rendering smoother.
Jun 22, 2024 at 10:18 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.1 #18Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Fred Miranda wrote:
Bertrick wrote"surprisingly similar" at f/2.0 for 1m and further is very interesting to me and very useful. This increases my interest in the 1.5 Heliar. THANKS!!
I would love to see a comparison showing this. The CV 50/1.5 Heliar at f/2 is almost like a different lens compared to when it's wide open. From the images posted and my own experience with the CV 50/1.5 Heliar, it seems that their rendering is similar when both are wide open. However, the f/1.5 version is quite soft wide open, especially for subjects focused at mid-distance.

I wish the tiny CV 40/2.8 Heliar rendered more like the 50/2 Heliar, but I find the former's rendering smoother.


Hi Fred,

I think the "surprisingly similar" at f2.0 was from my earlier comment that Bertrick was referencing. My comment was after I had done this shoot where I had the Heliar classic 50/2 on my A7C and Heliar classic 50/1.5 on my Sigma fp and tried to take similar shots at shared apertures on both back to back. The framing was not a perfect match though...

Sony A7C:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/gvtgA6n981crfCac6
Similar shots taken on 50/1.5 Heliar classic at equal apertures on Sigma fp: https://photos.app.goo.gl/ejxpq1wyAHiGozBt6

Each shot in the album shot with A7C + 50/2 has a counterpart shot in the other album shot with Sigma fp + 50/1.5 at same apertures and the shots are in the same order.
Jun 23, 2024 at 03:44 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.1 #19Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Bertrick wrote"surprisingly similar" at f/2.0 for 1m and further is very interesting to me and very useful. This increases my interest in the 1.5 Heliar. THANKS!!
I would love to see a comparison showing this. The CV 50/1.5 Heliar at f/2 is almost like a different lens compared to when it's wide open. From the images posted and my own experience with the CV 50/1.5 Heliar, it seems that their rendering is similar when both are wide open. However, the f/1.5 version is quite soft wide open, especially for subjects focused at mid-distance.

I wish the tiny CV 40/2.8 Heliar rendered more like the 50/2 Heliar, but I find the former's rendering smoother.
Hi Fred,

I think the "surprisingly similar" at f2.0 was from my earlier comment that Bertrick was referencing. My comment was after I had done this shoot where I had the Heliar classic 50/2 on my A7C and Heliar classic 50/1.5 on my Sigma fp and tried to take similar shots at shared apertures on both back to back. The framing was not a perfect match though...

Sony A7C:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/gvtgA6n981crfCac6
Similar shots taken on 50/1.5 Heliar classic at equal apertures on Sigma fp: https://photos.app.goo.gl/ejxpq1wyAHiGozBt6

Each shot in the album shot with A7C + 50/2 has a counterpart shot in the other album shot with
...Show more →

That's a great comparison. I take it back and agree that their rendering structure is quite similar at f/2!

Personally, I tend to shoot the CV 50/1.5 Heliar at f/1.7 (which is between f/1.5 and f/2 but not clearly marked on the lens). I think that at f/1.7, the 50/1.5 Heliar also matches the slightly lower contrast of the 50/2 Heliar. Honestly the CV 50/1.5 Heliar is on the greatest classic (re)creations from Cosina.
Jun 23, 2024 at 09:10 AM
_jim_
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Voigtländer Heliar classic 50/2 impressions (on Sony A9)
I have the looks-like-a-collapsible-but-is-actually-non-collapsible nickel version of this lens. The build quality is superb and the rendering is very pleasant. Compared to my other low-element count 50/2 lens, the LLL 'Elcan,' the Heliar has more SA and is weaker across the frame at full aperture, but contrast and flare resistance are higher. I prefer the look to out-of-focus draw on the Voigtlader vs. the LLL.

Jenny by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Resplendor Vineyard by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Dad by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Dad by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Leica M7, Voigtlander Heliar 50/2 Nickel, Eastman-5222, Xtol 1:1
Jun 23, 2024 at 09:58 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister