Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wrotesebbe wroteelimoss wroteIf we are talking strictly about axial CA correction -- I could be wrong, but -- I don't think the inbuilt lens profiles, even sneaky ones, correct axial CA to any significant extent. Lateral CA, certainly.I don't expect to see much difference to what Fred posted here. But as he also did his default sharpening it's difficult to judge if there is something. I'm thinking to replace the Sony FE 90/2.8 and if the lens really shows no CA this may be a good reason. The 90 shows the same bokeh balls when you stop it down and it seems to perform similar at 1:1.The 90, in most situations I've use it in, has much rounder balls at f6.3 than this.
The axial CA of 90 is a touch worse, but still plenty low enough not to bother me.
The FBW is excellent on the 90, but I'd still prefer the real helicoid.
OTOH I like that the 90 doesn't extend.
The 90 is a touch worse at infinity.
At macro distances the 90 is about as good and contrasty as I think I can detect even life size, so I'll call that a draw with the CV based on the samples I've seen.
Of course the 90 means you don't need to pack an AF portrait lens with you on macro trip. (not I think that I've ever used it that way except as a test)The FE 90/2.8 Macro is "internal focus" and therefore focal length will be much reduced at MFD. Have you calculated the real FL at 1:1 magnification? It's different with the 110/2.5 APO as it extends to reach its maximum magnification.
What is the working distance with the FE 90? With the CV 110 at 1:1 macro, it's 7 inches. (without the hood)The FL if the 90 is about 70mm at LifeSize. Don’t recall working distance off hand, I haven’t found it restrictive.
My test copy of 110 still hasn’t arrived, but I’m told its effective FL of the 110 is 90mm at 1:1 despite the extension (maybe die to complex element movements).
Still that’s longer than the 90; I certainly think effective FL and working distance, along with haptics and the last touch of chromatic correction, will be advantages for the 110.Yes, I think @bjornthun@'s calculations are correct here: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1574251/2#14689560
Basically the 110/2.5 has 7-inch working distance and the 90/2.8 G has ~ 5.5 inches. (Both without hoods)
Of course how much working distance matters is subject dependent. I basically do botanical stuff with macro lenses (and often for reasons of perspective am using 35mm macros (pentax APS macro adapted to full frame - surprisingly good), ultra wides and so on as well as longer ones. So I'm used to short working distance - even to the point of almost touching the front element! So 12cm is luxury, enough for any lighting plan I am likely to use. But someone chasing bugs will care a lot more!
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wrotesebbe wroteI don't expect to see much difference to what Fred posted here. But as he also did his default sharpening it's difficult to judge if there is something. I'm thinking to replace the Sony FE 90/2.8 and if the lens really shows no CA this may be a good reason. The 90 shows the same bokeh balls when you stop it down and it seems to perform similar at 1:1.The 90, in most situations I've use it in, has much rounder balls at f6.3 than this.
The axial CA of 90 is a touch worse, but still plenty low enough not to bother me.
The FBW is excellent on the 90, but I'd still prefer the real helicoid.
OTOH I like that the 90 doesn't extend.
The 90 is a touch worse at infinity.
At macro distances the 90 is about as good and contrasty as I think I can detect even life size, so I'll call that a draw with the CV based on the samples I've seen.
Of course the 90 means you don't need to pack an AF portrait lens with you on macro trip. (not I think that I've ever used it that way except as a test)The FE 90/2.8 Macro is "internal focus" and therefore focal length will be much reduced at MFD. Have you calculated the real FL at 1:1 magnification? It's different with the 110/2.5 APO as it extends to reach its maximum magnification.
What is the working distance with the FE 90? With the CV 110 at 1:1 macro, it's 7 inches. (without the hood)The FL if the 90 is about 70mm at LifeSize. Don’t recall working distance off hand, I haven’t found it restrictive.
My test copy of 110 still hasn’t arrived, but I’m told its effective FL of the 110 is 90mm at 1:1 despite the extension (maybe die to complex element movements).
Still that’s longer than the 90; I certainly think effective FL and working distance, along with haptics and the last touch of chromatic correction, will be advantages for the 110.Yes, I think @bjornthun@@'s calculations are correct here: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1574251/2#14689560
Basically the 110/2.5 has 7-inch working distance and the 90/2.8 G has ~ 5.5 inches. (Both without hoods)Of course how much working distance matters is subject dependent. I basically do botanical stuff with macro lenses (and often for reasons of perspective am using 35mm macros (pentax APS macro adapted to full frame - surprisingly good), ultra wides and so on as well as longer ones. So I'm used to short working distance - even to the point of almost touching the front element! So 12cm is luxury, enough for any lighting plan I am likely to use. But someone chasing bugs will care a lot more!
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteThe 90, in most situations I've use it in, has much rounder balls at f6.3 than this.
The axial CA of 90 is a touch worse, but still plenty low enough not to bother me.
The FBW is excellent on the 90, but I'd still prefer the real helicoid.
OTOH I like that the 90 doesn't extend.
The 90 is a touch worse at infinity.
At macro distances the 90 is about as good and contrasty as I think I can detect even life size, so I'll call that a draw with the CV based on the samples I've seen.
Of course the 90 means you don't need to pack an AF portrait lens with you on macro trip. (not I think that I've ever used it that way except as a test)The FE 90/2.8 Macro is "internal focus" and therefore focal length will be much reduced at MFD. Have you calculated the real FL at 1:1 magnification? It's different with the 110/2.5 APO as it extends to reach its maximum magnification.
What is the working distance with the FE 90? With the CV 110 at 1:1 macro, it's 7 inches. (without the hood)The FL if the 90 is about 70mm at LifeSize. Don’t recall working distance off hand, I haven’t found it restrictive.
My test copy of 110 still hasn’t arrived, but I’m told its effective FL of the 110 is 90mm at 1:1 despite the extension (maybe die to complex element movements).
Still that’s longer than the 90; I certainly think effective FL and working distance, along with haptics and the last touch of chromatic correction, will be advantages for the 110.Yes, I think @bjornthun@@@'s calculations are correct here: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1574251/2#14689560
Basically the 110/2.5 has 7-inch working distance and the 90/2.8 G has ~ 5.5 inches. (Both without hoods)Of course how much working distance matters is subject dependent. I basically do botanical stuff with macro lenses (and often for reasons of perspective am using 35mm macros (pentax APS macro adapted to full frame - surprisingly good), ultra wides and so on as well as longer ones. So I'm used to short working distance - even to the point of almost touching the front element! So 12cm is luxury, enough for any lighting plan I am likely to use. But someone chasing bugs will care a lot more!Do you shoot 1:2 more than 1:1?
Probably pretty even between 1:1 and 1:3. (and sometimes closer).
I know when I take a 1:2 like the CV or back in the day my old makro planar Or OM into the field I’m often frustrated - occasionally because I want 1:1 but more often 1:1.5 or so seems to be the sweet spot for what I do. Australian wildflowers are often tiny!
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteThe FE 90/2.8 Macro is "internal focus" and therefore focal length will be much reduced at MFD. Have you calculated the real FL at 1:1 magnification? It's different with the 110/2.5 APO as it extends to reach its maximum magnification.
What is the working distance with the FE 90? With the CV 110 at 1:1 macro, it's 7 inches. (without the hood)The FL if the 90 is about 70mm at LifeSize. Don’t recall working distance off hand, I haven’t found it restrictive.
My test copy of 110 still hasn’t arrived, but I’m told its effective FL of the 110 is 90mm at 1:1 despite the extension (maybe die to complex element movements).
Still that’s longer than the 90; I certainly think effective FL and working distance, along with haptics and the last touch of chromatic correction, will be advantages for the 110.Yes, I think @bjornthun@@@@'s calculations are correct here: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1574251/2#14689560
Basically the 110/2.5 has 7-inch working distance and the 90/2.8 G has ~ 5.5 inches. (Both without hoods)Of course how much working distance matters is subject dependent. I basically do botanical stuff with macro lenses (and often for reasons of perspective am using 35mm macros (pentax APS macro adapted to full frame - surprisingly good), ultra wides and so on as well as longer ones. So I'm used to short working distance - even to the point of almost touching the front element! So 12cm is luxury, enough for any lighting plan I am likely to use. But someone chasing bugs will care a lot more!Do you shoot 1:2 more than 1:1?Probably pretty even between 1:1 and 1:3. (and sometimes closer).
I know when I take a 1:2 like the CV or back in the day my old makro planar Or OM into the field I’m often frustrated - occasionally because I want 1:1 but more often 1:1.5 or so seems to be the sweet spot for what I do. Australian wildflowers are often tiny!
You have so many great lenses like the FE 90/2.8G and CV 65/2 but based on what you like to shoot, I have the feeling you will appreciate the 110/2.5's IQ and precision.
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteThe FL if the 90 is about 70mm at LifeSize. Don’t recall working distance off hand, I haven’t found it restrictive.
My test copy of 110 still hasn’t arrived, but I’m told its effective FL of the 110 is 90mm at 1:1 despite the extension (maybe die to complex element movements).
Still that’s longer than the 90; I certainly think effective FL and working distance, along with haptics and the last touch of chromatic correction, will be advantages for the 110.Yes, I think @bjornthun@@@@@'s calculations are correct here: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1574251/2#14689560
Basically the 110/2.5 has 7-inch working distance and the 90/2.8 G has ~ 5.5 inches. (Both without hoods)Of course how much working distance matters is subject dependent. I basically do botanical stuff with macro lenses (and often for reasons of perspective am using 35mm macros (pentax APS macro adapted to full frame - surprisingly good), ultra wides and so on as well as longer ones. So I'm used to short working distance - even to the point of almost touching the front element! So 12cm is luxury, enough for any lighting plan I am likely to use. But someone chasing bugs will care a lot more!Do you shoot 1:2 more than 1:1?Probably pretty even between 1:1 and 1:3. (and sometimes closer).
I know when I take a 1:2 like the CV or back in the day my old makro planar Or OM into the field I’m often frustrated - occasionally because I want 1:1 but more often 1:1.5 or so seems to be the sweet spot for what I do. Australian wildflowers are often tiny!You have so many great lenses like the FE 90/2.8G and CV 65/2 but based on what you like to shoot, I have the feeling you will appreciate the 110/2.5's IQ and precision.
That’s my fear too. And it’s so easy not to return review copies.....almost makes buying it the default
RobertHolloway wrote:
Nooo, Fred please say it's useless in some sort of way
I can feel my fingers twitching as it's now available.
I hate this forum.
Rob
For me personally the only negative is the 763 grams but hey it's less than the official weight.
bjornthun wrote: Fred Miranda wroteWith the CV 110/2.5, I've not seen any trace of color aberration. Truly amazing level of correction.I think it beats the old 125/2.5. No question.
At least my 125/2.5 copy is a Nikon mount for my Z7 so that $1000 isn’t burning a hole in my pocket... yet.
LBJ2 wrote: Fred Miranda wroteWith the CV 110/2.5, I've not seen any trace of color aberration. Truly amazing level of correction.Fred, how would you compare APO performance to the Zeiss Batis 135 ?
Regarding LoCA correction, the Batis 135/2.8 is very similar in performance to the Voigtlander and noticeably better than the Zeiss 135/2 APO.
I will try post some samples later.
Thanks for your kind words. I like it very much, Fred. Only issue is one I expected. That is, the focal length does not get as much use as wider lenses —especially in the winter where there is a dearth of flowers or other likely subjects for a macro lens. I suppose I could pick a nit with the cat eyes in the corners of the bokeh, but the lovely sun stars make up for it. I will need to wait till spring to really give it a flower workout. Now, if I were at Yosemite or something, then longer focal lengths come into play a lot more than for the NC mountains and waterfalls I am mostly shooting right now.
I fear it will not be a big seller as many have already bought the Sony 90 macro and are happy with their 70-200 or 100-400 for general use. It is supremely well corrected and as sharp as any other lens in the stable, but these merits may not be enough to sell a medium fast manual focus medium telephoto prime lens in large numbers.
I also just bought the Sony GM 100-400 so it is competing a bit with that lens for my attention at the moment, but I will try to post some more pics here as I take them.
Edit: Here is a less than wonderful images from just after sunrise when the sun hid behind the clouds--just to prove that it is not just sitting on a shelf!
G'day. Got mine on Monday and took it out for a spin in Melbourne yesterday.
So far I'm very impressed with its resolution, yet found the focus ring very sensitive near infinity, more so than the 65.
I saw its a similar design to the ol' Tamron Adaptall 90mm f2.5 SP macro - which used to be a favorite of mine. The front extends quite far out, which makes macro focusing very easy, but means a VERY short throw from 3m to infinity. Tricky, but doable, especially with focus magnify.
Beautiful shots, by the way.
kaioyang wrote:
G'day. Got mine on Monday and took it out for a spin in Melbourne yesterday.
So far I'm very impressed with its resolution, yet found the focus ring very sensitive near infinity, more so than the 65.