p.1 #1Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Hello together,
I am currently debating whether I should add the Loxia 25mm to my kit. In the past, I had great fun with the Batis 25mm, but I hated the manual focus experience. But most of my shots with it were taken with manual focus at f8, so I did not see the value it and sold it. What I liked about the Batis 25mm was the OLED display, because a (rough) approximation of the hyperfocal distance was very easy and it also was easy to set the manual focus to either 6m or 20m, depending on where most of the "action" happened in my landscapes.
I read Phillip Reeve's review about the Loxia 25mm and noticed that he (or actually Bastian) said that "precise focusing at infinity [is] a little harder with this lens". Furthermore, I also noticed that the lens does not feature markings for depth of field at f8 (contrary to the Loxia 21mm) and that the focusing distance is not communicated to the camera, so it cannot be seen in the viewfinder. Moreover, the infinity hard stop seems to be past true infinity, so the rather short travel between "2m" and "(true) infinity" is even shorter.
I am very intrigued by the Loxia 25mm because of its manual focusing, sun stares and overall image quality, but I am unsure about the manual focusing experience when maximizing depth of field at f8 (I would like to avoid f11 because image quality suffers, at least in Phillip Reeve's test).
So my question to the (few) Loxia 25mm owners out there: How tricky is it to focus the lens at hyperfocal distance at f8? And generally, how tricky is it to focus the lens at some distance between 2m and (true) infinity?
By tricky I mean that even with the slightest twist of the focus ring, I could change the focus from around hyperfocal distance to infinity.
p.1 #2Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Don't have the 25, but the lenses I have with distance markings all seem to still be using sharpness standards for film and 8x10 prints. In practice, the DoF is maybe half what the lens says and less useful for it.
p.1 #3Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Julian, I have shoot manual focus since 2008 and I have hard time understanding your question. I do not understand why in earth someone would like to focus @ f/8? Even with lenses having focus shift that would be extreme super hyper stupid. With lenses not having focus shift it's 5x more stupid. There is no way to focus accurately any wide angle using f/8. Handhold macros I could consider focus and shoot @ f/8 - in any other usage I could never consider focusing @ f/8.
Even DOF covers large area, contrast is higher in center of DOF, and I would never compromise my photos by focusing "blind" using f/8. Due to large tolerances in lensmount to sensor distance I would not trust any infinity stop or markings in lens or led display, that is just wasting your potential you can get out from digital camera. Also using 20Mpix camera and hyperfocal distance sounds 100% ridiculous to me.
Alternative answer to your question: Loxia is really easy to focus at any distance wide open, even very large distances. After focusing it's easy to close down to shooting aperture using aperture ring (nothing like Batis, which doesn't have aperture ring).
p.1 #4Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Thanks for the advice, Samuli!
I take most of my pictures when I travel with my friends & girlfriend - unfortunately they are not as much into photography as me. We have an agreement that I can take as many pictures as I want, but they don't wait and I have to catch up with them. Consequently, I very rarely use a tripod or any filters, but I prefer to get the maximum quality by minimizing the time I need to spend per photo
With the Batis I found it time-consuming to first focus at f2, then stop down, then recheck whether the background is actually in focus & re-focus if necessary. Consequently, I tended to set the lens at f8 and while switching the camera on already setting the focus to 6m or around >20m in case that the main highlight is in the distance - in both cases I can be certain that the background is in-focus and that the main subject has very high contrast. I agree that this might not result in the very best quality, but it yields a high quality picture while taking only a few seconds.
But I appreciate your advice and will try to incorporate it when I have more time.
Anyways, even with f2.4 the distance between the 2m and the infinity mark seems to be very short and could be a bit tricky to dial in...?
p.1 #5Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Julian, within limitations given I would not even bring camera... good for you if you still want to try under such awful conditions, which do everything else than make your creativity flow. If I would force myself to shoot under such situation, I would prefer setup every noob had; AF-zoom (I don't own one, but if I would be forced to this kind of awful scenario I would buy 24-105 f/4, which otherwise sounds so awful idea that I would not touch it, but might be good for this kind of point-and-shoot stuff).
One hint for faster manual focusing; set the JPG sharpening to maximum and many times you can see, already without magnification, where focus plane is in image. This will naturally not effect your actual image as you can sharpen the RAW-file in converter any way you like.
For Loxia 25 focus throw; as lens is new I was still last time with the lens shooting few "test images". One of the tests was scene where I focused to 8-10m distance, and I shot this to see how much CA on background trees which were ~30m distance in f/2.4-4 aperture range. While shooting this test scene I focused to my "target" and few images also I focused the far away trees and I did not have any problem doing either one. Compared to many other lenses Loxia 25's "2m to infinity" is more degrees than majority of makro-lenses, which I find challenging to focus on long distances.
p.1 #6Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
I just got my Loxia 25, so I won't say anything too definitive, but I don't think in use it really is any different from the Loxia 21. What one needs to do in situations such as yours, IMO, is do enough testing on a tripod so that you know exactly where infinity an say 20 ft and 40 ft are on the focus scale. Then set the distance you want the lens to focus based on your knowledge of where on the focus scale you need toter the ring. I don't find this hard at all. If infinity focus is just before the centre of the infinity symbol--as it is on my Loxia 25--then I just turn the focus ring there and shoot. If I want 20m and it is at the start of the infinity symbol then I turn the focus ring there and shoot. You could even make little marks with a paint brush and a bit of white paint if you wanted, but I find I don't need to. The point is you should figure out the exact focussing on the focus scale with the aperture wide open (I haven't detected any focus shift on the Loxia 25) and then use that knowledge to let you focus quickly without even having to bring the camera to your eye. I hope this helps.
p.1 #7Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Dof markings are really a formality even on manual focus lenses these days. Pixel densities are such that I use the f/4 markings to indicate f/8 dof. My 21mm Loxia performs as expected if I do that but then my infinity is at the marker.
You could potentially send the lens to Zeiss and ask them to precisely calibrate infinity to the marking. The FE mount seems to have very sloppy flange distance tolerances so you may need your body calibrated/shimmed as well.
p.1 #8Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Steve Spencer wrote:
I just got my Loxia 25, so I won't say anything too definitive, but I don't think in use it really is any different from the Loxia 21. What one needs to do in situations such as yours, IMO, is do enough testing on a tripod so that you know exactly where infinity an say 20 ft and 40 ft are on the focus scale. Then set the distance you want the lens to focus based on your knowledge of where on the focus scale you need toter the ring. I don't find this hard at all. If infinity focus is just before the centre of the infinity symbol--as it is on my Loxia 25--then I just turn the focus ring there and shoot. If I want 20m and it is at the start of the infinity symbol then I turn the focus ring there and shoot. You could even make little marks with a paint brush and a bit of white paint if you wanted, but I find I don't need to. The point is you should figure out the exact focussing on the focus scale with the aperture wide open (I haven't detected any focus shift on the Loxia 25) and then use that knowledge to let you focus quickly without even having to bring the camera to your eye. I hope this helps....Show more →
Wouldn't the accuracy of theses markings change with the ambient temperature? I thought the variation that comes with changes in ambient temperature is a reason why infinity is usually not at a hard stop on lenses.
p.1 #9Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Samuli Vahonen wrote:
Julian, I have shoot manual focus since 2008 and I have hard time understanding your question. I do not understand why in earth someone would like to focus @ f/8? Even with lenses having focus shift that would be extreme super hyper stupid. With lenses not having focus shift it's 5x more stupid. There is no way to focus accurately any wide angle using f/8. Handhold macros I could consider focus and shoot @ f/8 - in any other usage I could never consider focusing @ f/8.
Even DOF covers large area, contrast is higher in center of DOF, and I would never compromise my photos by focusing "blind" using f/8. Due to large tolerances in lensmount to sensor distance I would not trust any infinity stop or markings in lens or led display, that is just wasting your potential you can get out from digital camera. Also using 20Mpix camera and hyperfocal distance sounds 100% ridiculous to me.
Alternative answer to your question: Loxia is really easy to focus at any distance wide open, even very large distances. After focusing it's easy to close down to shooting aperture using aperture ring (nothing like Batis, which doesn't have aperture ring).
From my current lenses, only the CV 40/1.2 shows noticeable focus shift and that's pretty common with ultra fast lenses. When shooting at smaller apertures, I like focusing this lens at f/4.
With the Loxia 21 or 25, I find focusing so easy and accurate. At infinity, both are perfectly focused a small tad before the lens' hard stop. However, the very corners are focused at the hard stop since there is FC to consider. I don't detect noticeable focus shift with this Loxia, so I will probably be focusing it at f/2.8 for all shooting apertures.
p.1 #10Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
chiron wrote: Steve Spencer wroteI just got my Loxia 25, so I won't say anything too definitive, but I don't think in use it really is any different from the Loxia 21. What one needs to do in situations such as yours, IMO, is do enough testing on a tripod so that you know exactly where infinity an say 20 ft and 40 ft are on the focus scale. Then set the distance you want the lens to focus based on your knowledge of where on the focus scale you need toter the ring. I don't find this hard at all. If infinity focus is just before the centre of the infinity symbol--as it is on my Loxia 25--then I just turn the focus ring there and shoot. If I want 20m and it is at the start of the infinity symbol then I turn the focus ring there and shoot. You could even make little marks with a paint brush and a bit of white paint if you wanted, but I find I don't need to. The point is you should figure out the exact focussing on the focus scale with the aperture wide open (I haven't detected any focus shift on the Loxia 25) and then use that knowledge to let you focus quickly without even having to bring the camera to your eye. I hope this helps.Wouldn't the accuracy of theses markings change with the ambient temperature? I thought the variation that comes with changes in ambient temperature is a reason why infinity is usually not at a hard stop on lenses.
Not with such a short focal length in my experience. Another important reason infinity is not a hard stop is that if a lens mount was ever just a bit too thick/too far from the sensor then the lens wouldn't reach infinity on that camera. By making the hard stop just a bit beyond infinity the lens makers can assure that the lens will focus to infinity even if the camera mount isn't precisely right. Temperature is a big deal with longer lenses and that is another reason on those lenses that it is important that the lens focuses a bit beyond infinity to allow for those thermal changes as well.
p.1 #11Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Case in point the Loxia 25 I got from Fred the infinity point is slightly different on my body. On my body it’s almost dead middle of the symbol. Actually a touch before it. I think Fred said on his body it was past my mark.
p.1 #12Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Samuli Vahonen wrote:
I do not understand why in earth someone would like to focus @ f/8? Even with lenses having focus shift that would be extreme super hyper stupid. With lenses not having focus shift it's 5x more stupid. There is no way to focus accurately any wide angle using f/8.
Samuli, while I appreciate the humor in this, it's probably poor advice to the uninitiated. Particularly when the objective is to have large DOF, stopped down focusing is much more reliable than just guessing what will and won't be in focus on the basis of wide open focusing. When focus stacking, for example, only stopped down focus can show you where you need to focus next. Field curvature can also fool you as it varies when you are not at shooting aperture. Unless you are in low light, today's sensors combined with high magnification EVF views makes it pretty easy to see what is in focus. Also, if you are stopped down to working aperture and actually look at your image, you can forget all about the super-hyper-stupid markings on your lens.
p.1 #13Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
rvh23 wrote:
Samuli, while I appreciate the humor in this, it's probably poor advice to the uninitiated. Particularly when the objective is to have large DOF, stopped down focusing is much more reliable than just guessing what will and won't be in focus on the basis of wide open focusing. When focus stacking, for example, only stopped down focus can show you where you need to focus next. Field curvature can also fool you as it varies when you are not at shooting aperture. Unless you are in low light, today's sensors combined with high magnification EVF views makes it pretty easy to see what is in focus. Also, if you are stopped down to working aperture and actually look at your image, you can forget all about the super-hyper-stupid markings on your lens....Show more →
Sorry no humor - I was stunned by idea of focusing @ f/8. Notice that this question was for Loxia 25. Why this matters? Well, Loxia 25 has very different rendering style than most of the modern lenses; it has really nice subject separation for 25mm lens, and this is because contrast difference between center of DOF vs boke is large for modern lens. I would prefer to place this highest contrast area to subject where it matters the most and not just randomly choose some plane to have better contrast. And I hope while reading you understand the difference between sharpness and contrast.
If we talk generally then it's different topic. With modern poor rendering style (subjective opinion) lenses with their high contrast boke it's enough to place sufficient sharpness to subject and it really doesn't matter where you focus.
One of the lenses I love the most (definitely top 3) of hundreds of lenses I have shoot is Zeiss ZE/ZF series Planar 1.4/50. It has focus shift and requires focusing at shooting aperture until f/2.5-2.8 (depending on shooting distance) after which it can be focused f/2.8 - but again I would not focus f/8 shot @ f/8, unless shooting flowers or some other close-up kind of work. My worst nightmare would be very slow lens (e.g. f/4) which has focus shift, that would be really frustrating and totally useless for me (I think some of the Sony zooms is like this, can't remember which one as I'm not great fan of slow zooms anyways).
p.1 #14Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Isn't the question about hyperfocus? ie. DOF covering the whole scene?
In other words unrelated to Samuli's whole point?
If it were me I would spend some time with the lens, familiarise yourself with where the markings correspond to in a scene (reminds me of calibrating my hpf rings with a Leica disto) and learn what you should use when the pressure is on.
There is no secret other than practice with the lens on your camera with the kind of scenes you like to compose.
p.1 #15Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Many thanks for the helpful answers!
It is true that the best way is to try it out myself and I will certainly do so. I just don’t like ordering lenses just for testing purposes (in „Does the lens work for me?“; testing for decentering is of course another issue) and then sending them back to the retailer. So if all you professionals had trouble with the Loxia 25mm, I would have not even bothered with trying it But your answers and also the pictures in the Loxia 25 threads have convinced me that I should at least give it a try!
I’ll probably wait until my local dealer has some in stock and then ask politely to try it for 1h or so.
EDIT: Actually, I have the 24-105 Zoom. But I don’t particularly like the shooting experience. I find it easier to compose in my mind with some specific focal length (typically 24mm or 55mm) and then take the respective lens. While with the zoom I tend to shoot a lot of pictures just because I can zoom to various focal lengths, but this is reflected in the „quality“ of the composition and thus the picture etc...
p.1 #16Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
I hear you Julian, no one wants to make a mistake if they can avoid it.
By the same token I can remember many times I gelled with a lens despite so many people saying it wasn't worth it because product B was better for whatever reason.
p.1 #17Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
JulianD wrote:
EDIT: Actually, I have the 24-105 Zoom. But I don’t particularly like the shooting experience. I find it easier to compose in my mind with some specific focal length (typically 24mm or 55mm) and then take the respective lens. While with the zoom I tend to shoot a lot of pictures just because I can zoom to various focal lengths, but this is reflected in the „quality“ of the composition and thus the picture etc...
+1 - shooting experience with zooms is awful also in my opinion, don't like it when shooting as hobby, but mandatory tools for most pro-work (maybe one more reason why I'm so happy I don't have to do it anymore).
thrice wrote:
By the same token I can remember many times I gelled with a lens despite so many people saying it wasn't worth it because product B was better for whatever reason.
+1 - two lenses I like most, what comes to rendering style are lenses, are hated by >50% of community and are pain in the #ss to shoot with: Zeiss ZE/ZF Planar 1.4/50 (focus shift, crappy wide open or at least "weird boke") and Zeiss ZM Biogon 2/35 (requires this filter mod + front lens to work and even then it's really hard to shoot as crappy boke easily comes out from the lens). If I would listen others opinions I would not have neither. Therefore I trust more image samples than opinions about lenses.
p.1 #18Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
A zoom is a neccasary evil for me but I only use it on PR type and event work and it’s in my AF kit for that work. For my work or more commercial type shooting I grab my manual focus kit which the 25 is part of.
One thing to be aware of on this forum is you have a lot of older shooters that grew up with manual focus lenses so we are just more experienced with them but this just takes some time to get used too and get the best out of them.
p.1 #19Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
Samuli,
Isn’t the Loxia 35/2 biogon the exact same lens as the ZM 35/2, except that it’s optimized for the Sony sensor stack thickness?
Samuli Vahonen wrote: JulianD wroteEDIT: Actually, I have the 24-105 Zoom. But I don’t particularly like the shooting experience. I find it easier to compose in my mind with some specific focal length (typically 24mm or 55mm) and then take the respective lens. While with the zoom I tend to shoot a lot of pictures just because I can zoom to various focal lengths, but this is reflected in the „quality“ of the composition and thus the picture etc...+1 - shooting experience with zooms is awful also in my opinion, don't like it when shooting as hobby, but mandatory tools for most pro-work (maybe one more reason why I'm so happy I don't have to do it anymore).
thrice wroteBy the same token I can remember many times I gelled with a lens despite so many people saying it wasn't worth it because product B was better for whatever reason.+1 - two lenses I like most, what comes to rendering style are lenses, are hated by >50% of community and are pain in the #ss to shoot with: Zeiss ZE/ZF Planar 1.4/50 (focus shift, crappy wide open or at least "weird boke") and Zeiss ZM Biogon 2/35 (requires this filter mod + front lens to work and even then it's really hard to shoot as crappy boke easily comes out from the lens). If I would listen others opinions I would not have neither. Therefore I trust more image samples than opinions about lenses.
p.1 #20Loxia 25mm - Tricky to focus at infinity/hyperfocal?
GMPhotography wrote:
One thing to be aware of on this forum is you have a lot of older shooters that grew up with manual focus lenses so we are just more experienced with them but this just takes some time to get used too and get the best out of them.
Good point Guy. While reading this I realized that I have most of time photographed with manual focus, not just post "Canon AF-period". Before digital I was shooting with Pentax ME and some other Pentax body, which had AF, but I did not have any AF lenses . Then short period with Canon AF-glass from 2002 when first digital consumer body (D30 or 30D, the model which came out in 2001) came available secondhand with affordable price until 5Dmk1/1Dsmk2/1Dmk3 - tried all L-lenses, never happy with them and finally sold majority of my Canon lenses in 2008 when 5DmkII (=fullframe live view below 8kEUR, price of 1Dsmk3) become available. Since then been 99% manual focus, little bit AF with Sony lenses, but for real shooting I prefer manual focusing even with the AF-lenses.
I have never been thinking about it, but it must be very different for folks who have started their photography with autofocus (and zoom lenses). They must see us here as crazy idiots or annoying snobs