fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018The Alt Monthly Competition #70

  
 
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.2 #1The Alt Monthly Competition #70
retrofocus wrote:
Even I am using myself a Sony MLC for digital, I think the definition of what was formerly considered Alt in this competition needs to be clarified and revised: when this is cross-posted to the Sony forum, is a Sony camera with Sony lens still considered Alt even it is now one of the major camera brands? Or is posting only allowed for example with Sony camera and Alt lens as it was permitted with Canon/Nikon all the time when these cameras were used with an Alt lens?


The rules will remain the same. Sony+Sony has always been considered alt for the purposes of this competition, and it will continue to do so. If we limit this to only non system lenses, we will literally see fewer than 5 entries per month (this month has 4 entries that would qualify), which while perhaps in the original spirit when the competition was conceived 6 years ago, is kind of pointless. For the last 3-4 years at least, despite the name, this competition has been, defacto, the Alt and Mirrorless Monthly competition, and perhaps we should rename it as such.
May 01, 2018 at 12:30 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.2 #2The Alt Monthly Competition #70
Jman13 wrote:
retrofocus wroteEven I am using myself a Sony MLC for digital, I think the definition of what was formerly considered Alt in this competition needs to be clarified and revised: when this is cross-posted to the Sony forum, is a Sony camera with Sony lens still considered Alt even it is now one of the major camera brands? Or is posting only allowed for example with Sony camera and Alt lens as it was permitted with Canon/Nikon all the time when these cameras were used with an Alt lens?
The rules will remain the same. Sony+Sony has always been considered alt for the purposes of this competition, and it will continue to do so. If we limit this to only non system lenses, we will literally see fewer than 5 entries per month (this month has 4 entries that would qualify), which while perhaps in the original spirit when the competition was conceived 6 years ago, is kind of pointless. For the last 3-4 years at least, despite the name, this competition has been, defacto, the Alt and Mirrorless Monthly competition, and perhaps we should rename it as such.
...Show more →

Okay - this is clearly a change in paradigm which I did not perceive as such. I simply saw the Sony camera - Sony lens allowance rooted in the history of the Alt forum when Sony was still (small) part of it and not separate. I am not against to have brands in separate forums but IMO Sony is now exactly like Canon or Nikon in size and usage and should be treated as such which would no longer be Alt. We can stick to the historical way and keep allowing Sony+Sony as it always was but then I agree, it should be renamed as you suggested. The other Alt gear will only be a small part of the competition if any I am afraid. Consequently, it should also be cross-posted into the Fuji and micro 4/3rd boards, too.
May 01, 2018 at 12:49 PM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.2 #3The Alt Monthly Competition #70
retrofocus wrote:
Jman13 wrote
retrofocus wroteEven I am using myself a Sony MLC for digital, I think the definition of what was formerly considered Alt in this competition needs to be clarified and revised: when this is cross-posted to the Sony forum, is a Sony camera with Sony lens still considered Alt even it is now one of the major camera brands? Or is posting only allowed for example with Sony camera and Alt lens as it was permitted with Canon/Nikon all the time when these cameras were used with an Alt lens?
The rules will remain the same. Sony+Sony has always been considered alt for the purposes of this competition, and it will continue to do so. If we limit this to only non system lenses, we will literally see fewer than 5 entries per month (this month has 4 entries that would qualify), which while perhaps in the original spirit when the competition was conceived 6 years ago, is kind of pointless. For the last 3-4 years at least, despite the name, this competition has been, defacto, the Alt and Mirrorless Monthly competition, and perhaps we should rename it as such.
Okay - this is clearly a change in paradigm which I did not perceive as such. I simply saw the Sony camera - Sony lens allowance rooted in the history of the Alt forum when Sony was still (small) part of it and not separate. I am not against to have brands in separate forums but IMO Sony is now exactly like Canon or Nikon in size and usage and should be treated as such which would no longer be Alt. We can stick to the historical way and keep allowing Sony+Sony as it always was but then I agree,
...Show more →

I agree that it should be cross-posted in all mirrorless forums, but the problem is that the way the site is set up, it only allows cross posting in 2 boards. I wonder if Fred would allow a post in the other forums directing them to the main thread. You may view it as a change, but honestly at this point disallowing mirrorless systems with their native lenses would be the big change...I'm not going to modify that.

Edit: Fred gave a go ahead on the other post in the other forums to direct them to the competition.
May 01, 2018 at 01:45 PM
Ming-Tzu
Offline
Details
p.2 #4The Alt Monthly Competition #70
Wrong thread. Deleted.

Edited on May 04, 2018 at 07:22 PM · View previous versions
May 04, 2018 at 05:16 PM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.2 #5The Alt Monthly Competition #70
Ming, you’re on the wrong competition, check a few post down for Alt and Mirrorless#71.

Ming-Tzu wrote:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Camera body: Fuji X-T2
Lens: Fuji 10-24
Aperture: f/16
Filters: None
Short note on PP: exposure, color and other sliders adjusted in LR
Top vote (3p) + reason: johnahill + love the cloud formations and how the shape of it leads the eye to the city in the center of the frame. Incredible photo.
Runner-up vote (2p): Mathieu18
Last vote (1p): TNCasual
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

May 04, 2018 at 06:01 PM
Ming-Tzu
Offline
Details
p.2 #6The Alt Monthly Competition #70
Mathieu18 wrote:
Ming, you’re on the wrong competition, check a few post down for Alt and Mirrorless#71.

Ming-Tzu wrote------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Camera body: Fuji X-T2
Lens: Fuji 10-24
Aperture: f/16
Filters: None
Short note on PP: exposure, color and other sliders adjusted in LR
Top vote (3p) + reason: johnahill + love the cloud formations and how the shape of it leads the eye to the city in the center of the frame. Incredible photo.
Runner-up vote (2p): Mathieu18
Last vote (1p): TNCasual
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Thanks!
May 04, 2018 at 07:23 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister