p.23 #1The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Wow you guys go whole hog testing lenses don't ya.
I don't write reviews (thank god), and I understand you need to be meticulous in your analysis.
I'm a passionate amateur photographer (do occasional paid work), and try to keep things as simple as possible when I shoot. With Sony's focus magnification and peaking, they make it just so easy with manual lenses. I just point my a7rii (with the Voigtlander attached), choose my aperture (wide for subject isolation, f8 for landscape), twist the focus ring until my target's in focus, then press the shutter.
Excuse my ignorance, but I just don't understand why lenses come under more scrutiny than handling (size, weight, controls), sharpness, chromatic aberration, vignetting, distortion, bokeh, then a conclusion expressing the reviewers opinion.
I tested this lens, and knew within a couple of hours whether it was a keeper or not.
It seems like instead of reviewing what's right with the Voigtlander, people are looking hard to find what's wrong with it, creating confusion for prospective buyers. I just don't get the philosophy behind it?
J
p.23 #2The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
jaybr wrote:
Wow you guys go whole hog testing lenses don't ya.
I don't write reviews (thank god), and I understand you need to be meticulous in your analysis.
I'm a passionate amateur photographer (do occasional paid work), and try to keep things as simple as possible when I shoot. With Sony's focus magnification and peaking, they make it just so easy with manual lenses. I just point my a7rii (with the Voigtlander attached), choose my aperture (wide for subject isolation, f8 for landscape), twist the focus ring until my target's in focus, then press the shutter.
Excuse my ignorance, but I just don't understand why lenses come under more scrutiny than handling (size, weight, controls), sharpness, chromatic aberration, vignetting, distortion, bokeh, then a conclusion expressing the reviewers opinion.
I tested this lens, and knew within a couple of hours whether it was a keeper or not.
It seems like instead of reviewing what's right with the Voigtlander, people are looking hard to find what's wrong with it. I just don't get the philosophy behind it?
J...Show more →
I don't normally do much formal testing of my lenses I just provided initial sample shots since I got the lens so early and as I was curious to find out how the lens behaves at infinity, e.g. how much it needs to be stopped down for best corner-to-corner.
Then I tested some more since there were requests for certain types of shots, and then I did even more testing since David's review had some different findings than mine, wanted to show that the problem of field curvature is not necessarily so pronounced with all copies. Way more formal testing than I would normally do, and I don't need it to satisfy my own curiosity about the lens, I'm already very satisfied with it. None of this has changed my opinion of the lens, I'm entirely happy with it for my intended purposes. I also didn't do any of the testing to show the lens in bad light, although e.g. the requested de-focused light point shots can be used as a negative point if one is allergic to mild onion rings... (I'm not).
Anyway, it's also nice to know all the behavioral details so one can avoid any potential pitfalls in daily usage...
I also decided that it was a keeper after first shots on the day I got it. But anyway, I also would prefer to start shooting the lens for enjoyment from now rather than for any further testing so I think I'll go for that from tomorrow
p.23 #3The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
👍
It's just a lot of those "behavioural details" are subjective.
I had to laugh earlier when I read that someone wasn't gonna buy the Voigtlander because the review wasn't to his liking. He was gonna go with his "Milvus"
This Voigtlander can fit in your pocket, and shoots fine at f1.2
I'd like to see him do that with his Milvus 😉
J
p.23 #4The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
jaybr wrote:
👍
It's just a lot of those "behavioural details" are subjective.
I had to laugh earlier when I read that someone wasn't gonna buy the Voigtlander because the review wasn't to his liking. He was gonna go with his "Milvus"
This Voigtlander can fit in your pocket, and shoots fine at f1.2
I'd like to see him do that with his Milvus 😉
J
Yes, the behavioural details can be very subjective. I'm also finding the 40/1.2 with this size, weight and IQ to be closest to my ideal lens from anything out there so far (of course not for every purpose but for generic daily use which is my most important use case), but those who seek Otus / APO-like behavior for landscape use on tripod and don't care about size & weight much at all might prefer some other options.
It's kind of annoying that when we put out some samples it can immediately turn off people who see one aspect they don't like (whereas it might be a very small part of the whole story) when we hope to present the lens in good light and hope the lens would sell so well that Cosina will make a lot more for e-mount But I still believe in objective reporting/evaluation and there will be a lot of opinions and stories out there...
p.23 #5The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
jaybr wrote:
👍
It's just a lot of those "behavioural details" are subjective.
I had to laugh earlier when I read that someone wasn't gonna buy the Voigtlander because the review wasn't to his liking. He was gonna go with his "Milvus"
This Voigtlander can fit in your pocket, and shoots fine at f1.2
I'd like to see him do that with his Milvus 😉
J
I understand your point but I don't think that everything is so clear. What one is pleased with is subjective. Somebody can sacrifice a little bit of image quality for a more compact lens. Somebody else prefers to carry the perfect lens even if it is big and expensive.
What we have tried to clarify here is which are the strong and the weak points of this lens. Copy variation, field curvature and other parameters are not easy to analyse, unless we do thorough tests and also have plenty of copies available to test, which is not the case so far (hopefully it will be soon). So it is not a matter of people who are pixel-peeping and trying to find weaknesses.
Initial David's test showed that the lens is really soft outside the centre in wide apertures. Further tests showed that this is probably attributed to field curvature of this specific copy and the "problem" can potentially not be a problem with more careful focusing. Juha's tests show probably a better behaviour in terms of field curvature. I think that the centre and corner performance in the crops he posted in a 36mp body is more than satisfactory for such a lens.
Personally I have field curvature issues with my 24-70 GM between 30 and 40mm, causing soft borders/corners until f5.6. Things improve substantially by focusing in the borders of the frame, which become sharp even at f2.8. After I found out how my copy "works" I was happy to keep it and now I know the way to get the most from it. So a little bit of testing is not a bad thing at all and sometimes it helps you find tricks to optimise the performance of your lens.
For all these reasons I find these tests really useful.
p.23 #6The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
I understand what you're saying.
My point is that you can find fault with every lens, even the famed Zeiss Otus (bloody big, heavy, ugly, expensive, and no FE mount ) 😉
The Voigtlander FE 40mm f1.2 has its compromises to keep it relatively compact and light.
Others see these compromises as flawes.
J
p.23 #7The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
I think everything looks really good for what the lens is. I mean, field curvature at infinity and f/1.2 is not gonna be a problem for real world shooting, except for under circumstances where you'll be happy to get a usable image.
What I'm really interested in (as usual) is bokeh at a few meters distance. I suspect it will look awful, since most lenses with smooth bokeh at MFD are the opposite when focusing further away.
p.23 #8The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
jaybr wrote:
I tested this lens, and knew within a couple of hours whether it was a keeper or not.
It seems like instead of reviewing what's right with the Voigtlander, people are looking hard to find what's wrong with it, creating confusion for prospective buyers. I just don't get the philosophy behind it?
J
I appreciate this approach, actually. It's a $1000+ lens in a focal length near a lens I'm already very happy with (the CV 35 1.7). I need to be talked down off the ledge, and really scrutinize whether I'd be happier with it than the lens I already have, love, and have a vision synched to. I really appreciate all the honest reviews.
On the other hand I can sort of see the problem with this fault-finding approach. When we first started using the CV 65 recently, there was a fair bit of picking apart the bokeh. There must be something wrong with it! But the funny thing is that actually influenced my perception of what I was getting from the lens. I had some predisposition to find fault with the bokeh of the CV65 based on what I was reading, not actually what I was seeing.
(One quote I like from Charles Darwin, I heard from a Buddhist teacher: "When there is a difference between the book and the bird, trust the bird.")
Now with the CV 65 I like the bokeh a whole lot more than when I first got it.
p.23 #9The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Makten wrote:
I think everything looks really good for what the lens is. I mean, field curvature at infinity and f/1.2 is not gonna be a problem for real world shooting, except for under circumstances where you'll be happy to get a usable image.
What I'm really interested in (as usual) is bokeh at a few meters distance. I suspect it will look awful, since most lenses with smooth bokeh at MFD are the opposite when focusing further away.
this is what i'm interested in finding out about now too. otherwise the lens looks pretty great to me.
p.23 #10The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Makten wrote:
What I'm really interested in (as usual) is bokeh at a few meters distance. I suspect it will look awful, since most lenses with smooth bokeh at MFD are the opposite when focusing further away.
sebboh wrote:
this is what i'm interested in finding out about now too. otherwise the lens looks pretty great to me.
Yup, that's pretty much what remains, bokeh and LoCA when focused a couple of meters away and something about flare. If not outright bad results I think I'll to look for a S/H A7R mkII.
For landscapes and such there are plenty of other good enough lenses available.
p.23 #12The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
davewolfs wrote:
Can we get some samples posted 😁
Exactely my thought.. I am also still curious about the lens and about its rendering. Seems like a demanding but rewarding lens and it also seems like its possible to work around some of its quirks. Bokeh at mid-distances is also one of my main concerns, please don't forget to turn EFSC off
Great work by Juha and David so far, we got to know the lens a lot better because of their work
p.23 #13The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Just when I talked myself out of it, I was thinking I could carry the Contax 35-70 f3.4 for landscapes (it's actually better than my CV 35 1.7 without the PCX (which I still haven't gotten working), corner to corner at f8) and the 40 1.2, depending on rendering, as a bokeh lens maybe better than the CV35 for that.
I think someone should lend one of these to sebboh so he can post his findings.
p.23 #14The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
jaybr wrote:
👍
It's just a lot of those "behavioural details" are subjective.
I had to laugh earlier when I read that someone wasn't gonna buy the Voigtlander because the review wasn't to his liking. He was gonna go with his "Milvus"
This Voigtlander can fit in your pocket, and shoots fine at f1.2
I'd like to see him do that with his Milvus 😉
J
I am glad to be a source of amusement for you (and others maybe). Let me provide you with more opportunity to laugh at my expense.
I knew from the start that expecting a flawless f:1.2 lens of this size, weight and cost was completely unreasonable. The question, for me, was: can I live with the flaws that CV have chosen to not avoid?
The answer, for me, my taste and my anticipated use, is "no". FWIIW, someone else commented that expecting this lens to be as "clean" as the CV 65 f:2.0 was again not reasonable. So I am not alone is finding this lens "less-than-perfect".
But, if your priorities include above all else to carry the lens in your pocket and shoot it primarily at f:1.2, it is probably the best in the world. Just, I claim my right to set my own priorities, and they are, as you can guess, different.
p.23 #15The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Review updated with bokeh at 3 metres; an aperture series from f1.2-f8
I gave it a total torture test.
subject at 3m is the zone of doom for most lenses: the subject is far enough away for the background to get distracting and close enough so bokeh is still an issue.
The balcony frame giving on to the garden is at 3m; there are then flowers, stems and foliage from just a few cm behind the plane of focus, back in every position to infinity.
Most lenses produce a kaleidoscopic whirl of sick in this situation, especially wide and semi wide ones. For all the odd bit of structure (especially in the transition zone about 10-20cm behind the subject-frame) and occasional chromatic issue, I'm pretty impressed with the cv here. Many lenses, especially fast ones, would have produced an even wilder look. The chromatic issues have cleaned up here at f1.6 considerably compared to wide open..
p.23 #17The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
It's pretty nice weather in Tokyo today so I'm enjoying the day (a national holiday here) and shooting a lot with my Nokton and A7r until its batteries run out (will switch to A9 later), did a bit more formal testing this morning with a tripod too and now it's finished so I can start shooting for fun (definitely leaving the tripod home for that). Will share something this evening
p.23 #18The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
philber wrote: jaybr wrote👍
It's just a lot of those "behavioural details" are subjective.
I had to laugh earlier when I read that someone wasn't gonna buy the Voigtlander because the review wasn't to his liking. He was gonna go with his "Milvus"
This Voigtlander can fit in your pocket, and shoots fine at f1.2
I'd like to see him do that with his Milvus 😉
JI am glad to be a source of amusement for you (and others maybe). Let me provide you with more opportunity to laugh at my expense.
I knew from the start that expecting a flawless f:1.2 lens of this size, weight and cost was completely unreasonable. The question, for me, was: can I live with the flaws that CV have chosen to not avoid?
The answer, for me, my taste and my anticipated use, is "no". FWIIW, someone else commented that expecting this lens to be as "clean" as the CV 65 f:2.0 was again not reasonable. So I am not alone is finding this lens "less-than-perfect".
But, if your priorities include above all else to carry the lens in your pocket and shoot it primarily at f:1.2, it is probably the best in the world. Just, I claim my right to set my own priorities, and they are, as you can guess, different.
There's a tendency, not to much in evidence among FM members but which occasionally appears to think that there are two kinds of lenses AWESOME and SH*T; where AWESOME means you want it and SH*T means you don't.
Whereas the reality is that we all have constraints: habit, money, time, taste - that variously affect what kind of lens works for u.
I'm super impressed by the Milvus 35 from it's MTF and samples. The MTF looks like a super tele by f4. That could only be if it was largely free of LoCA and astigmatism and SA. It's optically great.
But I know me. I'm not going to carry it in the kind of situations that I'd wan't a fast moderate wide in.
But if I was the kind of person who would carry a kilo of Milvus around, I'd save my pennies and buy it in a heartbeat.
Still the fact that I wouldn't do that doesn't mean that (as some folk on other forums might do) I'm going to say it's SH*T because you would be INSANE to carry that around. All power to someone with the commitment to do so!
And of course, the CV 40 is less than perfect. But could it be any better in colour correction, speed, flatness of field, sharpness at wide apertures and peripherally, or weight and size and handling? Sure it could. But maybe couldn't be any better in any of those ways without giving up on one of the others (or costing way more).
It's a game of trade-offs: and if a really fast moderate wide normal that's portable and feels like a classic normal lens to use is what you want, this package of trade-offs is pretty attractive. But only to someone for whom that's the right package of tradeoffs. Someone else will happier with much slower and a similar size in exchange for optical benefits. Someone else will insist on the speed, and be prepared to go for more size and weight and cost to increase the quality even further. And which of those things is the right thing to do depends what you are doing.
p.23 #19The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
DavidBM wrote:
Review updated with bokeh at 3 metres; an aperture series from f1.2-f8
I gave it a total torture test.
Great sample, David!
Actually, it looks quite good, especially the background blur. Chromatic aberrations are also less pronounced than expected. The strong outlining towards the edges is a bit strange (right part of the image background).
The weak spot is the transition zone, that looks rather nervous. Nevertheless, most lenses are more than less problematic there.
p.23 #20The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Philber wrote:
"Well, with the latest pics and David's very telling review, I have decided to take this lens off my to-buy list. Not that it isn't eminently desirable, but I am looking for a one-lens star, or a one of a two-lens kit with the 65mm CV. I am afraid the 40 is not that sort of all-rounder, or rather that I couldn't get it to perform like an all-rounder.
This means I am back to the Milvus 35, twice the cost and weight..."
...
I simply responded to Philber's post above, where he implied that the Voigtlander FE 40mm wasn't a "one-lens star", preferring his twice as expensive and twice as heavy adapted Milvus 35mm. Horses for courses.
The best lens I have in my kit, is the one I have with me. The Voigtlander FE 40mm f1.2 is that lens for me because it's compact, light, and versatile, being fast glass with excellent optical quality. Looks like a great "all-rounder" to me.
J