molson wrote: ffstory wroteI am surprised that the 105mm 2.8G made it to the list.
This is rather old lens that is no match to more recent macro lenses like 60mm 2.8G or Tamron 90mm VC.
Three copies of this lens I used were mediocre even on my D800 and the lens really struggles on D500.Roger's test at LensRentals wasn't too flattering for the old 105mm f2.8G VR...
Well, not so fast. Here's the conclusion from the test Roger did: "The 105 VR, which tested only slightly above average at longer shooting distances, is truly spectacular at macro distances." I did not buy the lens to use it mainly as a telephoto. While I do use it that way when needed, Roger still called it "slightly above average." I wouldn't call that "mediocre." I bought the lens for its macro capability, as that's what I most often use it for. (If I wanted a standard 105mm, I would have bought the 105mm f1.4E.) I take it along on hikes and shoot bugs, flowers, and "miniature landscapes." That's why I was surprised I didn't see it on Thom's list. I'm not aware of any ~100mm macro that is better than the Nikon. A 60mm is way, way too short for insects and general outdoor macro use.
The issue I have with 105mm VR at macro distances is a ton of LoCA which makes it harder to use it for certain subjects. Perhaps bugs/flowers are fine.
molson wrote: Two23 wroteI'm not aware of any ~100mm macro that is better than the Nikon.Both the Canon 100mm f2.8L and the Sony FE 90mm f2.8 G are noticeably better. So is the Zeiss 100mm f2.8 Makro-Planar, but it only goes to 1:2.
Won't argue about the Canon & Sony because I'm not familiar with them. I see them as superfluous though since they won't mount on my Nikon. DxO shows the Zeiss resolves at 23 lines and the Nikon 21, which is pretty close. I went with the Nikon for the 1:1, and sometimes the AF is nice to have.
Two23 wrote: molson wroteTwo23 wroteI'm not aware of any ~100mm macro that is better than the Nikon.Both the Canon 100mm f2.8L and the Sony FE 90mm f2.8 G are noticeably better. So is the Zeiss 100mm f2.8 Makro-Planar, but it only goes to 1:2.Won't argue about the Canon & Sony because I'm not familiar with them. I see them as superfluous though since they won't mount on my Nikon. DxO shows the Zeiss resolves at 23 lines and the Nikon 21, which is pretty close. I went with the Nikon for the 1:1, and sometimes the AF is nice to have.
Kent in SD
When I had the 105VR, it was used mostly for portrait work on 24mp DX bodies and FX bodies, was pretty damn good for sharpness--almost too good.
FWIW, I thought that the 105VR was on the official Nikon list.
Gary Irwin wrote: Two23 wroteThe lens omission I'm most curious about is the Nikon 70-200mm f4 VR. All the reviews I've seen rated this lens highly.Over on NR, Thom clarified that *his* copy of the 70-200/4 performed well on his D810, but didn't do so well on higher resolution cameras (DX bodies I would assume). But he indicated he was going to try a few other copies before deciding whether to include it or not. As you indicated, Thom ALWAYS has his reasons. Personally I've been following and corresponding with him from time to time over the years and although I've questioned his thinking on occasion I always seem to end up agreeing with him.
I never listen to people like that anymore in an absolute sense. If I did, I would not be using gorgeous and classic looking lenses like my 28/2 AIS, 105 2.5AIS on my D810 to the delight of my clients. With the exception of only a few like the 24-120, 16 2.8D all my glass looks a lot better on my 810 than it does on my 750 or did on my D3 and 700 when I had those. I get absolute sharpness, my 851.8G and very much likely the new 105 1.4 I get tomorrow will do the best on the 850 as will my favorite lens, the 50mm F2 Zeiss Milvus.
But it is all about getting a creative and well seen shot to me, always has been and I think too much tech-centric crap gets in the way of that for a lot of people these days.
Dj R wrote:
Some say the Tokina at-x pro 100mm 2.8 outperforms the nikon
Though I have not used this lens, I would not doubt what they say..
I have been so impressed with my Tokina 11-16 Pro DX 2.8. Very sharp and so solidly built.
Many years ago I had the 105 2.8 micro and the 55 2.8 micro (both MF). The latter was one of the sharpest lenses I have owned, and sharper than the 105.
PIXPHATIC wrote: RKnecht wroteFWIW, he doesn't list the 200-500 as D800/D810 worthy and I know when I use those 2 together, the results are amazing.Cannot agree more.... the 200-500 had just got better with the D500 attached to it.....and if I am not mistaken, D850 will take it's performance to another level. Right from 200mm (in FX mode) to 750mm ( in 1.5 DX mode), it is expected that the lens will perform brilliantly. The AF will be faster than with D800/810/750 and the focusing better.
Cannot wait to see some user images with this new combo.
P.S. - Looking forward to see an updated review of the 200-500 by him, with the D500 and D850.
He does give a brief explanation as to why he didn't list the 200-500...
"Why no 200-500mm f/5.6? Because of the 400-500mm range, particular as you move from the central area. This lens holds up well with DX at these pixel densities, but not FX. But wait a second, you say, can't I just crop my D850 to DX and then the lens should be recommended? Well, true. But if you're buying a 45.4mp camera for 45.4mp my exclusion stands. You might as well save your money and buy a D500 if long telephoto is your focus. So let's be clear: my lens recommendations above are for the full FX frame, the full 45.4mp."
I think these lists are a lot less useless than some of you think.
Sure, these lists fail to make it clear enough that they're saying "these are the lenses that will most take advantage of the additional resolution" rather than "lenses absent from this list will look worse with additional resolution."
Nonetheless, that's useful information. If you've got lenses which struggle to resolve your D810, and you don't have enough money to buy a D850 *and* upgrade your lenses, and the resolution bump is the reason you want a D850, you're about to make a mistake.
Lee Saxon wrote:
I think these lists are a lot less useless than some of you think.
If you've got lenses which struggle to resolve your D810, and you don't have enough money to buy a D850 *and* upgrade your lenses, and the resolution bump is the reason you want a D850, you're about to make a mistake.
That is actually not really the case. Any lens, no matter what it is, will be the same or better on a D850 than it was a D810. Adding resolution 'upgrades' all your lenses at once. It cannot go the other way. Worst case scenario it stays the same, and you still have all the other benefits of the D850 over the D810 which are quite significant, plus the ability to downsample further. No matter what lens you put on a D850, you're still getting a 46MP file from it to print or manipulate.
The other misleading part of those lists is that using the best glass for the best IQ holds true for every camera, not just the high resolution ones. There is no lens that looks great on the D810 that will not look as good or better on a D850, all else being equal. Getting the most out of any camera requires the best glass and good technique. There is never a reason not to want more resolution from an IQ perspective, all else being equal.
Further adding to confusion, Nikon themselves have been telling people that "anything with a gold ring" is what you want to use on the D850. That classification excludes some excellent lenses and includes some very average ones. Still, none will ever perform worse on the D850 than any other camera.
CanadaMark wrote:
That is actually not really the case. Any lens, no matter what it is, will be the same or better on a D850 than it was a D810...It cannot go the other way. Worst case scenario it stays the same...
That's what I'm saying: that while it's true these lists don't do a good enough job making the above clear, it is still the case that some lenses are going to have more "headroom" to improve than others, and whether one owns such lenses is useful information for at least some use cases.
I mean, I know if I owned mediocre old lenses that were already pretty maxed out by the D750, and the amount of real detail they could resolve was going to jump from "24mp" (I know the real number is lower when you do the math on debayering) to, say, "29mp," I'd have a harder time ordering a D850 instead of a used D810. Even if there are a lot of other improvements between the two.
Lee Saxon wrote: CanadaMark wroteThat is actually not really the case. Any lens, no matter what it is, will be the same or better on a D850 than it was a D810...It cannot go the other way. Worst case scenario it stays the same...That's what I'm saying: that while it's true these lists don't do a good enough job making the above clear, it is still the case that some lenses are going to have more "headroom" to improve than others, and whether one owns such lenses is useful information for at least some use cases.
I mean, I know if I owned mediocre old lenses that were already pretty maxed out by the D750, and the amount of real detail they could resolve was going to jump from "24mp" (I know the real number is lower when you do the math on debayering) to, say, "29mp," I'd have a harder time ordering a D850 instead of a used D810. Even if there are a lot of other improvements between the two.
The thing is though you could be taking that same lens, putting it on a D850, down sampling to the 24MP of the D750, and getting a better image with a higher perceived sharpness, less noise and more processing leeway. Those gains would be proportionately larger than doing the same from a D810. As soon as you make a comparison, you're always better off with higher resolution. When isolated, yes the best glass is required to get the most out of the D850 at the pixel level but that is true of any camera at any resolution. From an image quality perspective, there is no disadvantage whatsoever of having more resolution, all else being equal. When you compare it to lower resolution cameras, you will still end up with a better image when equalized, or in the most extreme scenarios it will never be worse.
Yes you will want the best glass you can afford for the D850, but that is universal. Also from an image quality perspective you are always better off with more resolution assuming other areas of the sensor performance are similar (ISO, DR, etc.) which they are, if not even better in the case of the D850. If I had a bunch of mediorcre lenses, the D850 would be just as attractive to me as if I had a collection of the very best lenses because I am still better off in either scenario with the extra resolution. People with the best lenses will get the most out of the D850, but no matter what lenses you have you are better off.
Well, the only "lens list" that would likely have any meaning would be one from Nikon since only Nikon has the full design detail of the lens and can determine things such as diffraction limits. Photography enthusiasts like Tom Hogan can only post opinions which may or may not be correct.
Photozone.de has a few reviews on lenses on the Canon 5DsR at 50mp with resolution comparisons to tests on a 24mp Canon body. One is the Sigma 20 1.4, I believe. You can see how the lenses benefit from the increased MP, particularly in the centers, and how the more borderline areas of performance show modest gains at best. Bottom line, yes, all lenses will benefit to some extent, and the best lenses will show amazing performance across the board. So to "fully exploit" the resolution increase across the frame (a la Thom Hogan) you need lenses that are corner to corner sharp by f/4-5.6. Other lenses will benefit, they just might not max out the sensor performance like a Sigma 135 1.8.
D850 will be with my d500 in the very near future. Lenses need to be small and light, otherwise they will not qualify. Simple reason: I will not carry them around.
70-200 f4 not f2.8. I have the amazing 300 f4 PF +tcs. Am thinking about doing away with 200-500. To big, to heavy.