Two23 wrote:
The lens omission I'm most curious about is the Nikon 70-200mm f4 VR. All the reviews I've seen rated this lens highly.
Over on NR, Thom clarified that *his* copy of the 70-200/4 performed well on his D810, but didn't do so well on higher resolution cameras (DX bodies I would assume). But he indicated he was going to try a few other copies before deciding whether to include it or not. As you indicated, Thom ALWAYS has his reasons. Personally I've been following and corresponding with him from time to time over the years and although I've questioned his thinking on occasion I always seem to end up agreeing with him.
Gary Irwin wrote:
Over on NR, Thom clarified that *his* copy of the 70-200/4 performed well on his D810, but didn't do so well on higher resolution cameras (DX bodies I would assume).
.
Another lens I'm surprised wasn't mentioned is the Nikon 105mm f2.8 VR Micro. I have that lens and it is as sharp as anything else I have (except the two Sigmas.) Maybe it's an easy lens to overlook.
My core lens line up is Nikon 24mm PC-E, Sigma 35mm f1.4A, Sigma 50mm f1.4A, Nikon 105mm f2.8 Micro. All of those should be an easy transition to a D850 when I finally get around to buying a pair in a couple of years. That's why I've been paying close attention to lenses. I also use a 20mm f1.8G for special tasks, which also made the cut. My other lenses, less used, lenses are Nikon 70-200mm f2.8 VR which I'll eventually sell, and a Nikon 80-400mm AFS which I intend to replace with a Nikon 300mm f4 PE + TC14 (when I find a well priced used one.) I'm mostly getting rid of that last one to get something more compact for mountain hiking.
That's in the range of $12,000 - $15,000. I'm thinking my wife would say no (especially since we just spent that much to replace our failed HVAC system - not to mention we are still recovering from what we paid for our wedding andhoneymoon earlier this year, and trips for recent family illnesses.)
I'm not considering the 200 f/2 or 400 f/2.8E (regardless how much I would love them) because I don't have them now and they would add another $18,000 to the tab.
Some of my glass could use an upgrade for sure - like my 70-200 f/2.8 (version 1) but I somehow manage to get acceptable photos using the glass I have anyways. It was mentioned in another thread that the glass will last a good 20 years or more, but we want to upgrade when a new body comes out. I guess that works for Nikon and those with deep pockets, but not for me!...Show more →
Including the 24-70 f2.8E on the "approved" list is somewhat debatable, depending on which lens test you look at... and there don't seem to be any macro lenses that make the cut, other than the AF-S 60mm f2.8G
Gary Irwin wrote: Two23 wroteThe lens omission I'm most curious about is the Nikon 70-200mm f4 VR. All the reviews I've seen rated this lens highly.Over on NR, Thom clarified that *his* copy of the 70-200/4 performed well on his D810, but didn't do so well on higher resolution cameras (DX bodies I would assume). But he indicated he was going to try a few other copies before deciding whether to include it or not. As you indicated, Thom ALWAYS has his reasons. Personally I've been following and corresponding with him from time to time over the years and although I've questioned his thinking on occasion I always seem to end up agreeing with him.
FWIW.
Thom lost a lot of credibility in my books when he insisted that the D800E left-AF issue was a figment of my imagination.
Fortunately, Nikon agreed with me and all the other D800/E owners who had the same issue, and fixed the problem...
RKnecht wrote:
FWIW, he doesn't list the 200-500 as D800/D810 worthy and I know when I use those 2 together, the results are amazing.
Cannot agree more.... the 200-500 had just got better with the D500 attached to it.....and if I am not mistaken, D850 will take it's performance to another level. Right from 200mm (in FX mode) to 750mm ( in 1.5 DX mode), it is expected that the lens will perform brilliantly. The AF will be faster than with D800/810/750 and the focusing better.
Cannot wait to see some user images with this new combo.
P.S. - Looking forward to see an updated review of the 200-500 by him, with the D500 and D850.
Ug.
If someone is getting a D850 then they ought to already know about what lenses are sharp or not and if it matters at all for them for what they shoot. If not, then they likely are getting a camera that they can't get the most out of anyways.
But I decided D810/200-500 files look better than D500/200-500 files. That's the reason for my interest in the D850.
Don't believe any D850 lens list. Mark characterizes it just right. I have the old 18-200 DX lying around here somewhere. And I will use it on the D850. I will not buy any new lens for this D850. Money for this camera is enough of mine going to Nikon for a few years. That said, next on any list for me will be that 70-200 FL.
AFERMARKET GRIPS, CHARGERS, BATTERIES
In another thread, someone raised the unfounded fear that using aftermarket accessories might void the warranty. That's BS.
These cameras are very well built. The body warranty lasts but a year and that year goes by petty fast. So any maintenance I have will come out of my pocket. This DSLR will likely be worth maintaining for a long time. I expect to pay for that.
So depending on what is offered, I see myself buying aftermarket offerings for the grip, EN-EL18 charger and batteries.
Another way to look at this whole thing is that moving to a D850 will upgrade all of your lenses at once, regardless of what they are. From that point of view it is a bargain.
molson wrote:
Including the 24-70 f2.8E on the "approved" list is somewhat debatable, depending on which lens test you look at... and there don't seem to be any macro lenses that make the cut, other than the AF-S 60mm f2.8G
Hey - that is one lenses I already have! At least I could shoot some macro!
Seriously, my post was (mostly) tongue in cheek, as I figured most of this thread was. When I buy a body, I'm not likely to be replacing all my lenses at the same time. They are obtained over years and have to last me a long time.
As for not getting everything out of a camera body that I could, I doubt I accomplished that with the D100, let alone be able to do that with a D850! However, I never let that get in the way of a body upgrade if I can otherwise justify it.
Then again, I'm not sure I could justify the purchase of a D850 when I have a low shutter count on my current D810.
Honestly - it is nice being just a hobby photographer. Cheaper too!
If someone is getting a D850 then they ought to already know about what lenses are sharp or not and if it matters at all for them for what they shoot.
It does help to know if one's current lenses will be a limiting factor or not - if they are, there's not a lot to be gained from increasing the megapixel count with a D850.
molson wrote: jhinkey wroteIf someone is getting a D850 then they ought to already know about what lenses are sharp or not and if it matters at all for them for what they shoot.It does help to know if one's current lenses will be a limiting factor or not - if they are, there's not a lot to be gained from increasing the megapixel count with a D850.
Coming from a D810, megapixel count would not be my reason for wanting a D850 - it just isn't what I would consider a big change over what I already have. The speed, auto-focus, and other enhancements are a bigger draw for me.
Still, many of my lenses were obtained when I was shooting an F100 and D100, so a lens upgrade would probably be beneficial even for my main cameras I'm currently using. The problem for me is that Nikon has been upgrading them faster than I can get around to buying them!
I guess it all comes down to priorities. If it hadn't been for the theft of my F100, F5, and 600 f/4 AF-S (1st version) a few years back, I would more than likely still be shooting the D300/D700 combo. I wasn't any more ready then to buy a $3300 body than I am now.
When may D800 arrived, used it with, my 80-200 F2.8 one touch (around a 15-year-old lens) at my son’s wedding, wow, with film (the lens started life out as part of my F3 kit), it was good, with my D7000, nice, but on the D800 it was a wow.
I would not worry about glass right now, you might be surprised, use what you have, then slowly buy new lenses as you feel the need