You have some pretty specific needs, Guy.
My point was, if you're going to rent it numerous times, those rental fees add up. Why not buy it, especially at a discounted price like through Greentoe.com or used, and avoid those rental fees as well as the planning involved by having it always at your disposal. Then, when a better option comes along, sell it at minimal loss, or depending on how much you used it, for a financial gain.
Of course, this only makes sense if you're talking 4-5 rentals of a week or so in duration, or more. A one week rental is $135, times 4 would be $540. A new copy at retail price would be $2600. You could probably snag it from Greentoe.com for $2200-2300-ish, brand new. Then you could sell it for $2000.
At that point, you've broken even (with 4 one-week rentals) and the lens has been in your possession making it available to use whenever you want.
It makes financial sense as well as practical sense.
Again, this is only if you rent it 4 times. Your post made me think you've rented it several times with the likelihood of needing it again in the future, but I could be misinterpreting what you wrote/meant.
Just trying to help :-)