fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Batis 135, is it a keeper?

  
 
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #1Batis 135, is it a keeper?
rico wrote:
Fred Miranda wrotePost your thoughts on the TS-E 135. I am intrigued by this lens.
Lens arrived this frigid Chicago afternoon.
I ripped into the box, and spent the next half hour getting frostbite—this thing is a 1.1kg hunk of metal.
Even the control dials are metal.
I initially thought it was standard Utsunomiya product, but now realize it's made by another division: Canon Hydraulic and Iron Foundries. I had to wipe off a layer of coal dust before mounting the lens.

I looked hard at the Batis for its optical performance, but I need tilt/shift rather than fast f/2.8 apertures and AF. The MC-11 is well built, but the resulting front-heavy load is a test for the
...Show more →

Awesome summary. From your description, I can almost feel its build quality.
Dec 07, 2017 at 09:48 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.9 #2Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Sounds like it should have warning . Don’t jump in a lake with it around your neck.
Dec 07, 2017 at 09:50 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.9 #3Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Fred Miranda wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
SoundHound wrote135mm F2.8 is the same speed as the midrange of my 70-200 GM. I read somewhere that Zeiss can’t make a 135mm F2.0 cheap enough to sell. Even Canon charges $5600 for their 200 mm F2.0.

The best expedient seems to be the compact EF 135mm F2.0 which takes a 1.4x TC very well for a 189mm F2.8.
From my discussions with a couple of Zeiss reps, Zeiss had several internal discussions over F2.8 vs F2 for the Batis 135. F2 was indeed a serious consideration. The decision to go with F2.8 was further confirmed with early consumer tests where photographers were given a choice between Milvus 135/2 and Batis 135/2.8 and the majority chose the Batis 135 2.8. Ultimately sales will determine if F2.8 was the right decision or not.

Personally, I wanted F2. But once I started using the Batis F2.8, I forgot all about F2.
For marketing purposes, they should've compromised at f/2.4!


Next FL: 200mm

I have been using the 4/70-200 recently for dogs-in-action now that I have a body that actually tracks.
Works fine; but the sharpness at 200 is only OK and it's not fast enough.
I don't want to use a huge 2.8/70-200
I'd rather an immaculately grea and portablet 2.8/200 prime. There's a Tamron/Batis patent for such a thing (or was it 180?)
Bring it on....
Dec 07, 2017 at 09:59 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #4Batis 135, is it a keeper?
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
LBJ2 wrote
SoundHound wrote135mm F2.8 is the same speed as the midrange of my 70-200 GM. I read somewhere that Zeiss can’t make a 135mm F2.0 cheap enough to sell. Even Canon charges $5600 for their 200 mm F2.0.

The best expedient seems to be the compact EF 135mm F2.0 which takes a 1.4x TC very well for a 189mm F2.8.
From my discussions with a couple of Zeiss reps, Zeiss had several internal discussions over F2.8 vs F2 for the Batis 135. F2 was indeed a serious consideration. The decision to go with F2.8 was further confirmed with early consumer tests where photographers were given a choice between Milvus 135/2 and Batis 135/2.8 and the majority chose the Batis 135 2.8. Ultimately sales will determine if F2.8 was the right decision or not.

Personally, I wanted F2. But once I started using the Batis F2.8, I forgot all about F2.
For marketing purposes, they should've compromised at f/2.4!
Next FL: 200mm

I have been using the 4/70-200 recently for dogs-in-action now that I have a body that actually tracks.
Works fine; but the sharpness at 200 is only OK and it's not fast enough.
I don't want to use a huge 2.8/70-200
I'd rather an immaculately grea and portablet 2.8/200 prime. There's a Tamron/Batis patent for such a thing (or was it 180?)
Bring it on....


I don't think anyone will complain that f/2.8 is too slow for a 200mm lens.
Dec 07, 2017 at 10:04 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.9 #5Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
LBJ2 wrote
SoundHound wrote135mm F2.8 is the same speed as the midrange of my 70-200 GM. I read somewhere that Zeiss can’t make a 135mm F2.0 cheap enough to sell. Even Canon charges $5600 for their 200 mm F2.0.

The best expedient seems to be the compact EF 135mm F2.0 which takes a 1.4x TC very well for a 189mm F2.8.
From my discussions with a couple of Zeiss reps, Zeiss had several internal discussions over F2.8 vs F2 for the Batis 135. F2 was indeed a serious consideration. The decision to go with F2.8 was further confirmed with early consumer tests where photographers were given a choice between Milvus 135/2 and Batis 135/2.8 and the majority chose the Batis 135 2.8. Ultimately sales will determine if F2.8 was the right decision or not.

Personally, I wanted F2. But once I started using the Batis F2.8, I forgot all about F2.
For marketing purposes, they should've compromised at f/2.4!
Next FL: 200mm

I have been using the 4/70-200 recently for dogs-in-action now that I have a body that actually tracks.
Works fine; but the sharpness at 200 is only OK and it's not fast enough.
I don't want to use a huge 2.8/70-200
I'd rather an immaculately grea and portablet 2.8/200 prime. There's a Tamron/Batis patent for such a thing (or was it 180?)
Bring it on....
I don't think anyone will complain that f/2.8 is too slow for a 200mm lens.


Just you wait!

I could have an f2.8 zoom: what's the point?
F 2.8! f 1.4 and under a kilo or I'm not in!
I have a 50mm lens that is f1.2 and I paid only $500 for it. Why should I pay two grand for an f2.8?
This thing weighs 800g ! Heavier than my f 1.4 85! Outrage!

etc...
Dec 07, 2017 at 11:26 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #6Batis 135, is it a keeper?
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
LBJ2 wrote
SoundHound wrote135mm F2.8 is the same speed as the midrange of my 70-200 GM. I read somewhere that Zeiss can’t make a 135mm F2.0 cheap enough to sell. Even Canon charges $5600 for their 200 mm F2.0.

The best expedient seems to be the compact EF 135mm F2.0 which takes a 1.4x TC very well for a 189mm F2.8.
From my discussions with a couple of Zeiss reps, Zeiss had several internal discussions over F2.8 vs F2 for the Batis 135. F2 was indeed a serious consideration. The decision to go with F2.8 was further confirmed with early consumer tests where photographers were given a choice between Milvus 135/2 and Batis 135/2.8 and the majority chose the Batis 135 2.8. Ultimately sales will determine if F2.8 was the right decision or not.

Personally, I wanted F2. But once I started using the Batis F2.8, I forgot all about F2.
For marketing purposes, they should've compromised at f/2.4!
Next FL: 200mm

I have been using the 4/70-200 recently for dogs-in-action now that I have a body that actually tracks.
Works fine; but the sharpness at 200 is only OK and it's not fast enough.
I don't want to use a huge 2.8/70-200
I'd rather an immaculately grea and portablet 2.8/200 prime. There's a Tamron/Batis patent for such a thing (or was it 180?)
Bring it on....
I don't think anyone will complain that f/2.8 is too slow for a 200mm lens.
Just you wait!

I could have an f2.8 zoom: what's the point?
F 2.8! f 1.4 and under a kilo or I'm not in!
I have a 50mm lens that is f1.2 and I paid only $500 for it. Why should I pay two grand for an f2.8?
This thing weighs 800g ! Heavier than my f 1.4 85! Outrage!

etc...


It all depends on how well the Batis 135/2.8 sells. I would love to have a Batis 200/2.8 APO to complement it.
Dec 09, 2017 at 04:51 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.9 #7Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
LBJ2 wroteFrom my discussions with a couple of Zeiss reps, Zeiss had several internal discussions over F2.8 vs F2 for the Batis 135. F2 was indeed a serious consideration. The decision to go with F2.8 was further confirmed with early consumer tests where photographers were given a choice between Milvus 135/2 and Batis 135/2.8 and the majority chose the Batis 135 2.8. Ultimately sales will determine if F2.8 was the right decision or not.

Personally, I wanted F2. But once I started using the Batis F2.8, I forgot all about F2.
For marketing purposes, they should've compromised at f/2.4!
Next FL: 200mm

I have been using the 4/70-200 recently for dogs-in-action now that I have a body that actually tracks.
Works fine; but the sharpness at 200 is only OK and it's not fast enough.
I don't want to use a huge 2.8/70-200
I'd rather an immaculately grea and portablet 2.8/200 prime. There's a Tamron/Batis patent for such a thing (or was it 180?)
Bring it on....
I don't think anyone will complain that f/2.8 is too slow for a 200mm lens.
Just you wait!

I could have an f2.8 zoom: what's the point?
F 2.8! f 1.4 and under a kilo or I'm not in!
I have a 50mm lens that is f1.2 and I paid only $500 for it. Why should I pay two grand for an f2.8?
This thing weighs 800g ! Heavier than my f 1.4 85! Outrage!

etc...
It all depends on how well the Batis 135/2.8 sells. I would love to have a Batis 200/2.8 APO to complement it.


So would I! it’s probably the top of my current wishlist. Come on guys, snap up 135s!
Dec 09, 2017 at 06:34 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.9 #8Batis 135, is it a keeper?
If the Batis 135 seems too dainty, automated and affordable, you might be ready for the manly version. My review of the Canon 135 TS-E: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1521442
Dec 10, 2017 at 07:42 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.9 #9Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
LBJ2 wroteFrom my discussions with a couple of Zeiss reps, Zeiss had several internal discussions over F2.8 vs F2 for the Batis 135. F2 was indeed a serious consideration. The decision to go with F2.8 was further confirmed with early consumer tests where photographers were given a choice between Milvus 135/2 and Batis 135/2.8 and the majority chose the Batis 135 2.8. Ultimately sales will determine if F2.8 was the right decision or not.

Personally, I wanted F2. But once I started using the Batis F2.8, I forgot all about F2.
For marketing purposes, they should've compromised at f/2.4!
Next FL: 200mm

I have been using the 4/70-200 recently for dogs-in-action now that I have a body that actually tracks.
Works fine; but the sharpness at 200 is only OK and it's not fast enough.
I don't want to use a huge 2.8/70-200
I'd rather an immaculately grea and portablet 2.8/200 prime. There's a Tamron/Batis patent for such a thing (or was it 180?)
Bring it on....
I don't think anyone will complain that f/2.8 is too slow for a 200mm lens.
Just you wait!

I could have an f2.8 zoom: what's the point?
F 2.8! f 1.4 and under a kilo or I'm not in!
I have a 50mm lens that is f1.2 and I paid only $500 for it. Why should I pay two grand for an f2.8?
This thing weighs 800g ! Heavier than my f 1.4 85! Outrage!

etc...
It all depends on how well the Batis 135/2.8 sells. I would love to have a Batis 200/2.8 APO to complement it.


I’d kill for a 200 2.8 Batis. I could stop renting the GM zoom
Dec 10, 2017 at 08:20 AM
Faraday
Offline
Details
p.9 #10Batis 135, is it a keeper?
GMPhotography wrote:
[
It all depends on how well the Batis 135/2.8 sells. I would love to have a Batis 200/2.8 APO to complement it.


I’d kill for a 200 2.8 Batis. I could stop renting the GM zoom

Just buy the damn zoom already! Do I have to drag you to the store? hehehehehe......
Dec 10, 2017 at 01:10 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.9 #11Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Lol
Dec 10, 2017 at 01:16 PM
Jonathan Brady
Offline
Details
p.9 #12Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Yeah, I don't understand why someone would rent something multiple times. Just buy it :-)
Offer $2k on Greentoe.com and see what happens.
Dec 10, 2017 at 02:00 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.9 #13Batis 135, is it a keeper?
I'm keeping an eye on this lens for some of my indoor stuff, but I'd really rather have a 135/2 AF solution (and no the A-mount Sony won't cut it).

That being said, the bit of testing I did manage to do with the display copy in-store showed it to be fantastic wide open, which really sings to me. 70-200/2.8 zooms are just not going to be this good at f/2.8, especially off-center as Fred's tests have shown.
Dec 10, 2017 at 02:01 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.9 #14Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Jonathan Brady wrote:
Yeah, I don't understand why someone would rent something multiple times. Just buy it :-)
Offer $2k on Greentoe.com and see what happens.


Because it sucks. It can’t do 200mm worth a damn . I have to back off to about 193mm. It’s not a great lens I said it numerous times I have issues with it. I don’t have a better option. Now maybe just maybe the A7rIII is good enough to get continous focus with a Canon. I shoot 20k images on this lens. Would buy a lens that barely works. I’d be a idiot to do that. This is money on the line. Please you find something better doing runway than you let me know. I need a net 300mm and I I want to use crop mode because I don’t need 42mpx. 18 is perfect

But there has not been a reliable AF continous 200mm yet on these bodies I can count on. I’m using Eye AF on top of that.
Dec 10, 2017 at 02:09 PM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.9 #15Batis 135, is it a keeper?
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
LBJ2 wrote
SoundHound wrote135mm F2.8 is the same speed as the midrange of my 70-200 GM. I read somewhere that Zeiss can’t make a 135mm F2.0 cheap enough to sell. Even Canon charges $5600 for their 200 mm F2.0.

The best expedient seems to be the compact EF 135mm F2.0 which takes a 1.4x TC very well for a 189mm F2.8.
From my discussions with a couple of Zeiss reps, Zeiss had several internal discussions over F2.8 vs F2 for the Batis 135. F2 was indeed a serious consideration. The decision to go with F2.8 was further confirmed with early consumer tests where photographers were given a choice between Milvus 135/2 and Batis 135/2.8 and the majority chose the Batis 135 2.8. Ultimately sales will determine if F2.8 was the right decision or not.

Personally, I wanted F2. But once I started using the Batis F2.8, I forgot all about F2.
For marketing purposes, they should've compromised at f/2.4!
Next FL: 200mm

I have been using the 4/70-200 recently for dogs-in-action now that I have a body that actually tracks.
Works fine; but the sharpness at 200 is only OK and it's not fast enough.
I don't want to use a huge 2.8/70-200
I'd rather an immaculately grea and portablet 2.8/200 prime. There's a Tamron/Batis patent for such a thing (or was it 180?)
Bring it on....
I don't think anyone will complain that f/2.8 is too slow for a 200mm lens.
Just you wait!

I could have an f2.8 zoom: what's the point?
F 2.8! f 1.4 and under a kilo or I'm not in!
I have a 50mm lens that is f1.2 and I paid only $500 for it. Why should I pay two grand for an f2.8?
This thing weighs 800g ! Heavier than my f 1.4 85! Outrage!

etc...

We all have different needs. I am one that wouldnt go for a 200mm 2.8 personally. If its going to be 2.8 then I rather just get the zoom and have the added flexibility. To each its own..


Edited on Dec 10, 2017 at 04:10 PM · View previous versions
Dec 10, 2017 at 03:17 PM
stevesanacore
Offline
Details
p.9 #16Batis 135, is it a keeper?
70-200 2.8 zooms are generally very heavy. I need one for my work, so I have always had one, but would rather have a 135 and 200 2.8 for my personal work if they were small and lightweight.
Dec 10, 2017 at 03:50 PM
scrappydog
Offline
Details
p.9 #17Batis 135, is it a keeper?
peter1219 wrote:
I'm interested whether people who bought Batis 135 are keeping it. Despite the great reviews I seldomly see images taken with this lens.


I am keeping it. I love this lens. Really fast and silent AF, sharp edge-to-edge wide open, Eye-AF works well with it, color rendition is really special. Zero complaints. I use it mostly for landscapes, but I think it would excel as a portrait lens, albeit without paper-think DOF, which is my preference. Since it doesn't have a AF/MF switch on the lens, to shift to MF mode, you need to switch it in the menu.

I have a flickr page for the Batis 135, but it's mostly lens tests. Feel free to check it out. Note that the first image was shot with the A7R2 and is posted at 100%, so you can pixel peep.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/68498746@N08/albums/72157689659693166
Dec 10, 2017 at 06:57 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #18Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Love it for landscapes. You can shoot wide open and get the performance of f/4!




Dec 10, 2017 at 08:07 PM
Jonathan Brady
Offline
Details
p.9 #19Batis 135, is it a keeper?
You have some pretty specific needs, Guy.
My point was, if you're going to rent it numerous times, those rental fees add up. Why not buy it, especially at a discounted price like through Greentoe.com or used, and avoid those rental fees as well as the planning involved by having it always at your disposal. Then, when a better option comes along, sell it at minimal loss, or depending on how much you used it, for a financial gain.
Of course, this only makes sense if you're talking 4-5 rentals of a week or so in duration, or more. A one week rental is $135, times 4 would be $540. A new copy at retail price would be $2600. You could probably snag it from Greentoe.com for $2200-2300-ish, brand new. Then you could sell it for $2000.
At that point, you've broken even (with 4 one-week rentals) and the lens has been in your possession making it available to use whenever you want.
It makes financial sense as well as practical sense.
Again, this is only if you rent it 4 times. Your post made me think you've rented it several times with the likelihood of needing it again in the future, but I could be misinterpreting what you wrote/meant.
Just trying to help :-)
Dec 11, 2017 at 05:57 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.9 #20Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Twice a year for a week each. So really makes no sense buying. The Batis 135 I use daily
Dec 11, 2017 at 06:54 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister