fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Batis 135, is it a keeper?

  
 
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.7 #1Batis 135, is it a keeper?
GabrielPhoto wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
ecarlino wroteI've heard 4 arguments against this lens:

1. price is too high, especially for "only" f/2.8
2. the OOF rendering is a bit nervous
3. f/2.8 doesn't provide shallow enough DoF
4. f/2.8 isn't fast enough for dark places

I respect everyone's personal budgets and $2000 is definitely not cheap for a prime lens, but the whole "especially for an f/2.8" part is a bit weak b/c it ignores what this lens is all about.

The OOF rendering was my biggest concern (especially since the B85 was too much for my tastes). After having evaluated the B135 in the harshest of conditions (foliage) and being honest about how frequently I'd find myself in those conditions, I decided I could live with the worst case given the low percentage of shots i'd find myself in those situations - and it wasn't nearly as bad, IMO, as the b85.

Shallow DoF and subject-separation were never concerns for me. I've never been interested in portraits where ONLY the eyeballs are in focus but not the nose nor ears - at typical portrait distances, 135mm @ f/2.8 for me is perfectly fine (if perhaps a bit too shallow even). I also personally find @ 135mm that compression is what i really enjoy and NOT obliterating backgrounds is more frequently my goal, even if i still want there to be some 3D effect. There have been a few occasions with mid-distance subjects and relatively close backgrounds where a bit more separation would have been preferred, but it's not that big of a deal and doesn't happen for me often enough to really make it a deal-breaker (e.g. not that it's an interesting shot, but fire hydrant on previous page would have been nicer if the fence was a bit more blurred - although a bit of processing to pop the hydrant may have helped if it was a shot i cared about).

As far as 'dark places' - that's simply not something i'd ever need 135mm for, but that seems like a very specialized use-case and for those people, then this lens simply won't do (although the a7r2 does some pretty amazing things in the dark, but i understand that in some cases, especially with moving subjects, every stop counts).

My point in these comments is that when this lens was announced, the criticisms were all of the nature that the B135, given it was only f/2.8 was a very 'specialized' lens of limited use. My experience has been completely the opposite - given its light weight, small size and absolutely perfect IQ from wide-open, it is really a work horse of a lens that gets a lot of use in almost every situation. And for all of the whole "f/2.8" nonsense, i'd simply point out that walking around with a f/1.8 is a non-starter for me and I would think that such a large size (e.g. a fast 135 or f/2.8 70-200 zoom - of similar IQ) would make those lenses more of a 'special use' lens than the b135. Certainly there may be pros and hobbyists who don't mind that their "gear IS the point" or at least don't mind that the gear is obviously around their neck or hanging off their shoulder - but for me the whole point of the sony bodies is to enjoy my life again and not have the photography get in the way and i never thought i'd be walking around with something longer than 85mm b/c the size of a high IQ lens would simply be too much for me to enjoy - but the B135 ticks all the boxes for me and it's been a lot of fun.
The very good news is ...as far as 135mm primes goes there is something for everyone as well as for those of us that need more than one 135mm prime :-)

1. Sigma 135/1.8 ( Pretty much stole the show this year ) I WILL try this lens at some point
2. Samyang 135/2 (Native MF, very good IQ for only $400-$500 )
3. Canon 135 ( Small and still loved by many)
4. Batis 135/2.8 ( Native, lot of goodness packed in this lens)
5. Carl Zeiss Classic or Milvus 135/2 ( The 135mm Otus)
Indeed! 135mm lovers *(like someone I know..cough cough ) are in Paradise right now with all the options.


I think you have me confused with someone else. Who in their right mind would own more than one 135 prime lens? I think I may need an intervention....
Sep 14, 2017 at 11:28 AM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.7 #2Batis 135, is it a keeper?
LBJ2 wrote:
GabrielPhoto wrote
LBJ2 wrote
ecarlino wroteI've heard 4 arguments against this lens:

1. price is too high, especially for "only" f/2.8
2. the OOF rendering is a bit nervous
3. f/2.8 doesn't provide shallow enough DoF
4. f/2.8 isn't fast enough for dark places

I respect everyone's personal budgets and $2000 is definitely not cheap for a prime lens, but the whole "especially for an f/2.8" part is a bit weak b/c it ignores what this lens is all about.

The OOF rendering was my biggest concern (especially since the B85 was too much for my tastes). After having evaluated the B135 in the harshest of conditions (foliage) and being honest about how frequently I'd find myself in those conditions, I decided I could live with the worst case given the low percentage of shots i'd find myself in those situations - and it wasn't nearly as bad, IMO, as the b85.

Shallow DoF and subject-separation were never concerns for me. I've never been interested in portraits where ONLY the eyeballs are in focus but not the nose nor ears - at typical portrait distances, 135mm @ f/2.8 for me is perfectly fine (if perhaps a bit too shallow even). I also personally find @ 135mm that compression is what i really enjoy and NOT obliterating backgrounds is more frequently my goal, even if i still want there to be some 3D effect. There have been a few occasions with mid-distance subjects and relatively close backgrounds where a bit more separation would have been preferred, but it's not that big of a deal and doesn't happen for me often enough to really make it a deal-breaker (e.g. not that it's an interesting shot, but fire hydrant on previous page would have been nicer if the fence was a bit more blurred - although a bit of processing to pop the hydrant may have helped if it was a shot i cared about).

As far as 'dark places' - that's simply not something i'd ever need 135mm for, but that seems like a very specialized use-case and for those people, then this lens simply won't do (although the a7r2 does some pretty amazing things in the dark, but i understand that in some cases, especially with moving subjects, every stop counts).

My point in these comments is that when this lens was announced, the criticisms were all of the nature that the B135, given it was only f/2.8 was a very 'specialized' lens of limited use. My experience has been completely the opposite - given its light weight, small size and absolutely perfect IQ from wide-open, it is really a work horse of a lens that gets a lot of use in almost every situation. And for all of the whole "f/2.8" nonsense, i'd simply point out that walking around with a f/1.8 is a non-starter for me and I would think that such a large size (e.g. a fast 135 or f/2.8 70-200 zoom - of similar IQ) would make those lenses more of a 'special use' lens than the b135. Certainly there may be pros and hobbyists who don't mind that their "gear IS the point" or at least don't mind that the gear is obviously around their neck or hanging off their shoulder - but for me the whole point of the sony bodies is to enjoy my life again and not have the photography get in the way and i never thought i'd be walking around with something longer than 85mm b/c the size of a high IQ lens would simply be too much for me to enjoy - but the B135 ticks all the boxes for me and it's been a lot of fun.
The very good news is ...as far as 135mm primes goes there is something for everyone as well as for those of us that need more than one 135mm prime :-)

1. Sigma 135/1.8 ( Pretty much stole the show this year ) I WILL try this lens at some point
2. Samyang 135/2 (Native MF, very good IQ for only $400-$500 )
3. Canon 135 ( Small and still loved by many)
4. Batis 135/2.8 ( Native, lot of goodness packed in this lens)
5. Carl Zeiss Classic or Milvus 135/2 ( The 135mm Otus)
Indeed! 135mm lovers *(like someone I know..cough cough ) are in Paradise right now with all the options.
I think you have me confused with someone else. Who in their right mind would own more than one 135 prime lens? I think I may need an intervention....

You think??
Sep 14, 2017 at 11:51 AM
oddjobprime
Offline
Details
p.7 #3Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Fred Miranda wrote:
BTW: B&H and Adorama are both selling the Batis 135/2.8 APO for $1,899. (You must add it to Cart to see the new price)
Full Zeiss warranty. (They are authorized resellers)

B&H Photo | Adorama


Good catch. I noticed that yesterday and now I have one in the mail
Getting it through B&H with this deal saves me $450 CAN compared to buying within Canada.
Sep 14, 2017 at 11:53 AM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.7 #4Batis 135, is it a keeper?
oddjobprime wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteBTW: B&H and Adorama are both selling the Batis 135/2.8 APO for $1,899. (You must add it to Cart to see the new price)
Full Zeiss warranty. (They are authorized resellers)

B&H Photo | Adorama
Good catch. I noticed that yesterday and now I have one in the mail
Getting it through B&H with this deal saves me $450 CAN compared to buying within Canada.


Good deal on a great lens!
FYI, or maybe you know this already, make sure to register your Batis 135 on-line to qualify for the Zeiss extended warranty. "From the purchase date you have a four-week window to register your ZEISS photographic product online. You will then receive the ZEISS Extended Warranty which is valid for three years."

https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/service/product-registration/photo-lenses/americas/canada.html
Sep 14, 2017 at 01:27 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #5Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Couple corporate shots today. Clean and crisp. Just renders so nice in this area


Thats just money in the bank.














Sep 14, 2017 at 01:37 PM
Jonathan Brady
Offline
Details
p.7 #6Batis 135, is it a keeper?


LBJ2 wrote:

FYI, or maybe you know this already, make sure to register your Batis 135 on-line to qualify for the Zeiss extended warranty. "From the purchase date you have a four-week window to register your ZEISS photographic product online. You will then receive the ZEISS Extended Warranty which is valid for three years."

https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/service/product-registration/photo-lenses/americas/canada.html


I had no idea. Perfect timing, for me! Thanks!
Sep 14, 2017 at 02:03 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #7Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Can I get a 100 dollar kickback. Lol
Sep 14, 2017 at 02:04 PM
oddjobprime
Offline
Details
p.7 #8Batis 135, is it a keeper?
LBJ2 wrote:
oddjobprime wrote
Fred Miranda wroteBTW: B&H and Adorama are both selling the Batis 135/2.8 APO for $1,899. (You must add it to Cart to see the new price)
Full Zeiss warranty. (They are authorized resellers)

B&H Photo | Adorama
Good catch. I noticed that yesterday and now I have one in the mail
Getting it through B&H with this deal saves me $450 CAN compared to buying within Canada.
Good deal on a great lens!
FYI, or maybe you know this already, make sure to register your Batis 135 on-line to qualify for the Zeiss extended warranty. "From the purchase date you have a four-week window to register your ZEISS photographic product online. You will then receive the ZEISS Extended Warranty which is valid for three years."

https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/service/product-registration/photo-lenses/americas/canada.html

Thanks! I was aware but I appreciate your input nonetheless. Sadly, I forgot to do it with my Batis 25 - I'll try not to drop the ball this time!

Sep 14, 2017 at 02:16 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #9Batis 135, is it a keeper?
GMPhotography wrote:
Couple corporate shots today. Clean and crisp. Just renders so nice in this area

Thats just money in the bank.


Very nice!
Just for curiosity. Do you need to stop down to f/7.1 for your lighting or you really want more depth of field?
Sep 14, 2017 at 02:54 PM
anthonyket
Offline
Details
p.7 #10Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Can anyone talk to the B135 lowlight performance indoors at 2.8? I have only seen well lit acceptable shutter speed outdoor shots . Currently my 135L at f/2 is ideal for my lowlight events where I need reach.
Dec 03, 2017 at 07:01 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.7 #11Batis 135, is it a keeper?
anthonyket wrote:
Can anyone talk to the B135 lowlight performance indoors at 2.8? I have only seen well lit acceptable shutter speed outdoor shots . Currently my 135L at f/2 is ideal for my lowlight events where I need reach.


If you mean is the lens awesomely sharp etc, at f2.8 yes it is. It's essentially indistinguishable from the 2/135 Apo Sonnar ZF2 stopped down to f2.8. And it's noticeably better than the 135L (which I had at one point) when its stopped down.

As far as the lens is concerned the shutter speed and lighting levels are irrelevant.

If you mean is f2.8 fast enough in low light events etc for your usage that depends on your camera and other factors. Since you have the 135L why not just try it out set to f2.8 on an adapter. The only difference using the Batis will be that it's sharper and has less CA so it'll be a fine test of whether you can get the shutter speeds you need with the noise you can tolerate.
Dec 03, 2017 at 07:10 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.7 #12Batis 135, is it a keeper?

LBJ2 wrote:
oddjobprime wrote
Fred Miranda wroteBTW: B&H and Adorama are both selling the Batis 135/2.8 APO for $1,899. (You must add it to Cart to see the new price)
Full Zeiss warranty. (They are authorized resellers)

B&H Photo | Adorama
Good catch. I noticed that yesterday and now I have one in the mail
Getting it through B&H with this deal saves me $450 CAN compared to buying within Canada.
Good deal on a great lens!
FYI, or maybe you know this already, make sure to register your Batis 135 on-line to qualify for the Zeiss extended warranty. "From the purchase date you have a four-week window to register your ZEISS photographic product online. You will then receive the ZEISS Extended Warranty which is valid for three years."

https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/service/product-registration/photo-lenses/americas/canada.html


I bought the 135/2.8 Batis in Tokyo as new and registered it online right away about 2 weeks ago, but haven't heard anything from Zeiss (no e-mail response or anything). How do they usually let the owner know that the registration was successful and the warranty got extended?

Earlier on this registration process was excluding Japan so I couldn't do it with my earlier Batis lenses. This was the first time to try.

I'm very happy with the lens. Also still have the Batis 25mm. I used to own the 85mm and 18mm too but I sold them as I got the new Sony WA zooms this year and since I also have the 85GM and Sony 85/1.8.
Dec 03, 2017 at 07:15 PM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.7 #13Batis 135, is it a keeper?
It is a good question (love o hear Guy’s take on this). I think it is the studio lighting that necessitates stopping dow to get the whole face in focus.

In a natural (diffused lighting) one could get away with a wider aperture.

Fred Miranda wrote:
GMPhotography wroteCouple corporate shots today. Clean and crisp. Just renders so nice in this area

Thats just money in the bank.
Very nice!
Just for curiosity. Do you need to stop down to f/7.1 for your lighting or you really want more depth of field?


Dec 03, 2017 at 08:26 PM
MrTMan
Offline
Details
p.7 #14Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I bought the 135/2.8 Batis in Tokyo as new and registered it online right away about 2 weeks ago, but haven't heard anything from Zeiss (no e-mail response or anything). How do they usually let the owner know that the registration was successful and the warranty got extended?

Earlier on this registration process was excluding Japan so I couldn't do it with my earlier Batis lenses. This was the first time to try.



I've had the same thing happen. I've registered a half dozen Zeiss lenses, and it seems like half the time I've gotten an email to confirm that the lens was registered, and that I have an extra year of warranty -- and half the time I've gotten no response at all. I have no idea whether or not this means that a lack of email confirmation = no extended warranty.
Dec 03, 2017 at 10:52 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.7 #15Batis 135, is it a keeper?
MrTMan wrote:
Juha Kannisto wroteI bought the 135/2.8 Batis in Tokyo as new and registered it online right away about 2 weeks ago, but haven't heard anything from Zeiss (no e-mail response or anything). How do they usually let the owner know that the registration was successful and the warranty got extended?

Earlier on this registration process was excluding Japan so I couldn't do it with my earlier Batis lenses. This was the first time to try.
I've had the same thing happen. I've registered a half dozen Zeiss lenses, and it seems like half the time I've gotten an email to confirm that the lens was registered, and that I have an extra year of warranty -- and half the time I've gotten no response at all. I have no idea whether or not this means that a lack of email confirmation = no extended warranty.


Thanks for the information! At least that gives me confidence that it wasn't any unusual problem. I remember seeing some notice text on the web page at the end of the registration procedure saying that I should be hearing from Zeiss in a few days so I have been waiting some kind of confirmation e-mail at least.

I'm still in the initial 4 week window so I could try to do the registration on their website one more time and see what
happens...
Dec 03, 2017 at 11:53 PM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.7 #16Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Juha Kannisto wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
oddjobprime wrote
Fred Miranda wroteBTW: B&H and Adorama are both selling the Batis 135/2.8 APO for $1,899. (You must add it to Cart to see the new price)
Full Zeiss warranty. (They are authorized resellers)

B&H Photo | Adorama
Good catch. I noticed that yesterday and now I have one in the mail
Getting it through B&H with this deal saves me $450 CAN compared to buying within Canada.
Good deal on a great lens!
FYI, or maybe you know this already, make sure to register your Batis 135 on-line to qualify for the Zeiss extended warranty. "From the purchase date you have a four-week window to register your ZEISS photographic product online. You will then receive the ZEISS Extended Warranty which is valid for three years."

https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/service/product-registration/photo-lenses/americas/canada.html
I bought the 135/2.8 Batis in Tokyo as new and registered it online right away about 2 weeks ago, but haven't heard anything from Zeiss (no e-mail response or anything). How do they usually let the owner know that the registration was successful and the warranty got extended?

Earlier on this registration process was excluding Japan so I couldn't do it with my earlier Batis lenses. This was the first time to try.

I'm very happy with the lens. Also still have the Batis 25mm. I used to own the 85mm and 18mm too but I sold them as I got
...Show more →

Hello Juha: Check your SPAM folder just in case. I always receive a "ZEISS: Thank you for registering" email confirming my Zeiss lens registration, and extended warranty period along with a registration number. From the way the registration email reads, you will need the registration number, so you may want to contact them directly to follow up. Here is the contact info they sent to me:

"Should you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact us:

E-Mail: [email protected]
Phone: +49 7364 / 20-6175
Web: http://www.zeiss.com/photo"



Dec 04, 2017 at 10:28 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #17Batis 135, is it a keeper?
The Batis 135/2.8 is back to $2,000 after the holiday sales.
Dec 04, 2017 at 10:35 AM
rico
Offline
Details
p.7 #18Batis 135, is it a keeper?
Fred Miranda wrote:
Just for curiosity. Do you need to stop down to f/7.1 for your lighting or you really want more depth of field?

Guy is probably pretty busy right now. I'll answer for him since we conversed on this topic recently, and shoot portraits the same way. He likes to have the entire face in focus, including the nose and ears. Back of the head and trailing shoulders can fall off. Especially for corporate, one eye in focus and a blurry blob for a nose doesn't work. For myself, portraiture at f/1 is simply ridiculous! For head-and-shoulders or tighter, I'm set on FF 135mm or longer, and acceptable aperture is f/8. The b/g will be nicely blurred, but not melted into a puddle, and sharpness is maintained if the subject shifts thanks to the working DOF.

In related news, I ordered a Sigma MC-11 and Canon 135/4L TS-E from B&H, so expect some, ahh, intriguing studio portraits soon. I might even open up to f/5.8!
Dec 05, 2017 at 02:57 AM
philip_pj
Online
Details
p.7 #19Batis 135, is it a keeper?
'I might even open up to f/5.8!'

Don't get carried away, now. All things in moderation ;-)
Dec 05, 2017 at 04:32 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #20Batis 135, is it a keeper?
rico wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteJust for curiosity. Do you need to stop down to f/7.1 for your lighting or you really want more depth of field?
Guy is probably pretty busy right now. I'll answer for him since we conversed on this topic recently, and shoot portraits the same way. He likes to have the entire face in focus, including the nose and ears. Back of the head and trailing shoulders can fall off. Especially for corporate, one eye in focus and a blurry blob for a nose doesn't work. For myself, portraiture at f/1 is simply ridiculous! For head-and-shoulders or tighter, I'm set on FF 135mm or longer, and acceptable aperture is f/8. The b/g will be nicely blurred, but not melted into a
...Show more →

Thanks for responding and your right doing corporate work you cannot have a eye out of focus , even the entire face can be a issue. F7.1 works real well with full chest up. Plus you have to give yourself some room for either a 5x7 or 8x10 ratio. Just never sure what a client will do cropping wise. Yes this is playing it safe but that’s what your getting paid for. We as photographers have to ride that fence between playing it safe and getting great shots. You want to be called back. I have had corporate clients for years because I’m dependable and that’s very important for your business. Hell I may not be great but I get the shot and that’s the key. I love this focal length and this lens in particular because at 2.8 wide open I can use it for podium type stuff and it’s sharp as a rack. That’s the big big plus for the Batis it’s just a laser at 2.8 so it’s very diverse in its use. Also going to be a perfect pixel stitch lens. Can’t wait to try that
Dec 05, 2017 at 04:46 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister