I've heard 4 arguments against this lens:
1. price is too high, especially for "only" f/2.8
2. the OOF rendering is a bit nervous
3. f/2.8 doesn't provide shallow enough DoF
4. f/2.8 isn't fast enough for dark places
I respect everyone's personal budgets and $2000 is definitely not cheap for a prime lens, but the whole "especially for an f/2.8" part is a bit weak b/c it ignores what this lens is all about.
The OOF rendering was my biggest concern (especially since the B85 was too much for my tastes). After having evaluated the B135 in the harshest of conditions (foliage) and being honest about how frequently I'd find myself in those conditions, I decided I could live with the worst case given the low percentage of shots i'd find myself in those situations - and it wasn't nearly as bad, IMO, as the b85.
Shallow DoF and subject-separation were never concerns for me. I've never been interested in portraits where ONLY the eyeballs are in focus but not the nose nor ears - at typical portrait distances, 135mm @ f/2.8 for me is perfectly fine (if perhaps a bit too shallow even). I also personally find @ 135mm that compression is what i really enjoy and NOT obliterating backgrounds is more frequently my goal, even if i still want there to be some 3D effect. There have been a few occasions with mid-distance subjects and relatively close backgrounds where a bit more separation would have been preferred, but it's not that big of a deal and doesn't happen for me often enough to really make it a deal-breaker (e.g. not that it's an interesting shot, but fire hydrant on previous page would have been nicer if the fence was a bit more blurred - although a bit of processing to pop the hydrant may have helped if it was a shot i cared about).
As far as 'dark places' - that's simply not something i'd ever need 135mm for, but that seems like a very specialized use-case and for those people, then this lens simply won't do (although the a7r2 does some pretty amazing things in the dark, but i understand that in some cases, especially with moving subjects, every stop counts).
My point in these comments is that when this lens was announced, the criticisms were all of the nature that the B135, given it was only f/2.8 was a very 'specialized' lens of limited use. My experience has been completely the opposite - given its light weight, small size and absolutely perfect IQ from wide-open, it is really a work horse of a lens that gets a lot of use in almost every situation. And for all of the whole "f/2.8" nonsense, i'd simply point out that walking around with a f/1.8 is a non-starter for me and I would think that such a large size (e.g. a fast 135 or f/2.8 70-200 zoom - of similar IQ) would make those lenses more of a 'special use' lens than the b135. Certainly there may be pros and hobbyists who don't mind that their "gear IS the point" or at least don't mind that the gear is obviously around their neck or hanging off their shoulder - but for me the whole point of the sony bodies is to enjoy my life again and not have the photography get in the way and i never thought i'd be walking around with something longer than 85mm b/c the size of a high IQ lens would simply be too much for me to enjoy - but the B135 ticks all the boxes for me and it's been a lot of fun.