fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?

  
 
airfrogusmc
Offline
Details
p.10 #1D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Learning to use DoF scales takes time and it does work but if you can't master it then use something that you can. Manual focus on anything moving even with peak focusing you have exactly the same issue. I find it a lot easier to focus with the ORF when things are moving than with peak focusing.

What you like and dislike and the way something feels to you is subjective but the fact still remains that Leica M lenses preform better on Leica M cameras. That is not not subjective. If you want and need bells and whistles then maybe a Leica M rangefinder might not be for you. I, by far prefer, it.
Aug 29, 2017 at 09:25 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.10 #2D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
airfrogusmc wrote:
Learning to use DoF scales takes time and it does work but if you can't master it then use something that you can. Manual focus on anything moving even with peak focusing you have exactly the same issue. I find it a lot easier to focus with the ORF when things are moving than with peak focusing.

What you like and dislike and the way something feels to you is subjective but the fact still remains that Leica M lenses preform better on Leica M cameras. That is not not subjective. If you want and need bells and whistles then
...Show more →

What do you mean better, if you have to stop down ( your words ) in order to guarantee you can focus on a moving subject? Would you say something like an A9 with Tap that allows autofocus of the M lenses...thus using whatever aperture you require to get the most out of an image would produce an overall better result than needing to stop down for focus?
Aug 29, 2017 at 10:19 AM
airfrogusmc
Offline
Details
p.10 #3D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Yeah, I hear that is not real reliable and that sony again doesn't always play well with Leica wide glass and if you haven't mastered skills of shooting with DoF scales and rangefinder when shooting wide open then these manual focus lenses are probably not the tool for the job anyway, right? Lots of really good choices in auto focus lenses for other than M bodies but to say that focus peaking with Leica glass wide open is a a lot better than focusing with the rangefinder wide open isn't true and Leica glass does perform better on Leica M bodies period.
Aug 29, 2017 at 11:20 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.10 #4D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
airfrogusmc wrote:
Yeah, I hear that is not real reliable and that sony again doesn't always play well with Leica wide glass and if you haven't mastered skills of shooting with DoF scales and rangefinder when shooting wide open then these manual focus lenses are probably not the tool for the job anyway, right? Lots of really good choices in auto focus lenses for other than M bodies but to say that focus peaking with Leica glass wide open is a a lot better than focusing with the rangefinder wide open isn't true and Leica glass does perform better on Leica M
...Show more →

No dispute here...but do the bodies with the glass result in better images...especially non static moving subjects. I really don't care if lenses on a Leica M body result in the utmost quality if I have to compromise my shooting ( stopping down to ensure focus is right ) to achieve this quality.
Aug 29, 2017 at 11:42 AM
airfrogusmc
Offline
Details
p.10 #5D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
If I were shooting things where I needed insanely shallow DoF and were moving insanely fast I would have kept my 200 2L and I would have a 1DX whatever body or pick up this Nikon camera and maybe a Nikon 200 2 or the 105 1.4 but I tend to use DoF instead of letting use me. If you are a slave to shooting wide open all the time isn't that like being a one trick pony? And after 40 + years of shooting using DoF scales and manual focus I can hit a lot of times using DoF scales and focus with the rangefinder wide open on fast moving subjects. I think there are a lot of photographers that actually did a pretty good job with it before auto focus.
Aug 29, 2017 at 11:52 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.10 #6D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
There were a few info from a Chinese interview with Nikon during introduction maybe useful for anyone interested in this camera.

1. The shutter is redesigned for 9 frame/s and also for higher pixel density. So you will expect about the SAME performance as D810 performance on pixel level. I wouldn't say this is not a achievement but I was expecting it is better than D810. Given speed and quietness, I will choose latter myself.

2. Sensor is a Nikon Design. (I don't really know what it means by that. All the info still very implicit to me) Backlight is not aim for high ISO low noise but more mainly for the speed of transfer data required for 9 frame/s with high pixels or LV/video feed.

Here is a little bit interesting info indicate that it might no longer be a Sony sensor.(I would expect better high ISO performance) I don't see this is a good news actually. It sending a strong signal that Sony no longer provide best sensor to competitor, at least no longer in advance provide that. And that is very important giving design cycle of this kind of product. It will handicap competitor's product design cycle. (Now Nikon, Pentax etc on FF future could be Fuji, Pentax or Hasselblad on MF) I was waiting for D850 final spec to confirm my guess.

By inspect Bill Claff's preliminary DR results, it shows D850 has about the same DR as D810, and very slightly better high ISO performance after ISO400. and if you insert A7RII in below graph, you will see Sony A7RII is better than both of them for about 1 stop at high ISO. (I think this is pixel level performance, so more pixel the better if scale down, but still) I would think Sony's best sensor should do better than what D850 can do at this time.

https://nikonrumors.com/2017/08/24/photons-to-photos-published-first-nikon-d850-dynamic-range-chart.aspx/
edit: picture is too big, insert link here.

I was not following all the sensor technology so please pardon me if my guess is too wild. I hope this is the trade off nikon decide to take that sacrifice high ISO performance for reading speed and noise? (so not 12 bit limitation for silent shooting or for long exposure more than 30s etc...?)

This is not big deal for me that sensor DR is almost out of my consideration in upgrading, I would prefer they put some of effort in color fidelity etc...

Apparently, Brand fan boy will feel exciting that I win, you lose if this is true. Actually it is not the case. I wish Canon or Sony can produce better product surpass Nikon or vise versa that only customer can be real winner.

Dominance only means customer will be the losers. Any brand selling more camera, make more profits is none of my business, but dominance is usually means poorer product asking for higher price.

For D850, Nikon user should thanks for Canon or Sony's competition and their better products yesterday, (Don't we see how Nikon hide feature, reduce build quality after D3/D700 success?) and today's D850 also means better future products for Canon or Sony users.
Aug 29, 2017 at 01:26 PM
Arka
Offline
Details
p.10 #7D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
airfrogusmc wrote:
Yeah, I hear that is not real reliable and that sony again doesn't always play well with Leica wide glass and if you haven't mastered skills of shooting with DoF scales and rangefinder when shooting wide open then these manual focus lenses are probably not the tool for the job anyway, right? Lots of really good choices in auto focus lenses for other than M bodies but to say that focus peaking with Leica glass wide open is a a lot better than focusing with the rangefinder wide open isn't true and Leica glass does perform better on Leica M
...Show more →

If you haven't used the systems you're talking about, it's kind of hard for you to authoritatively comment on what's better or worse. I appreciate that the Leica M system is a great one for you, but many of your comments suggest that people who opt out the Leica universe don't know how to use DoF scales on an RF. You also seem to suggest that anyone not using those scales, or using the lenses with an AF adapter, are clearly not using the "right tool for the job" - thereby implying that there's only one such tool for a "job" as diverse as photography.

I used a Leica M for 5 years (less than your 4 decades, but still long enough to generate tens of thousands of in-focus images), and learned how to use DoF scales pretty well for street and other types of photography. But that approach is of limited usefulness when shooting wide open, where certain Leica lenses are capable of very shallow DoF. When shooting wide open, I agree with you that RF is a better focus modality for moving objects than peaking (provided you have good vision, which I don't). But it's not better than AF, and the TAP adapter confers AF capability for Leica lenses that, depending on the lens and camera you're using, is pretty reliable. I speak from personal experience... I've used both systems (not just "heard" about them). Is it perfect? No. But what is?

I'm not trying to sell you on anything, but your insistence on the "right tool" having to be a "dedicated tool," (be it a video camera or AF lenses) feels shortsighted to me. You suggest that an AF lens is a "better tool for the job" than an MF lens originally designed for an RF camera, but ignore the fact that there is no AF lens out there today that can provide the speed, image quality, and small size of a Leica M lens. Sony and Zeiss equivalents of the 50mm f/1.4 and 35mm f/1.4 are behemoths compared to Summiluxes offering the comparable capabilities via the TAP adapter. Sure, the Sony versions will AF more reliably, but I won't want to take them anywhere because they're huge. Similarly, an M camera (my experience is with the M240) may offer some image quality advantage versus the Sony A9 (though most reviews on the web discussing this topic suggest that this advantage is vanishingly small for any lens 35mm or longer), but I can shoot more of what I want, and get it in focus, using a Sony + TAP adapter than I did with my Leica M240. To me, that compromise position is "the right tool for the job" - small, light, flexible, with exceptional image quality.

Edited on Aug 29, 2017 at 02:39 PM · View previous versions
Aug 29, 2017 at 02:30 PM
Arka
Offline
Details
p.10 #8D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
airfrogusmc wrote:
If I were shooting things where I needed insanely shallow DoF and were moving insanely fast I would have kept my 200 2L and I would have a 1DX whatever body or pick up this Nikon camera and maybe a Nikon 200 2 or the 105 1.4 but I tend to use DoF instead of letting use me. If you are a slave to shooting wide open all the time isn't that like being a one trick pony? And after 40 + years of shooting using DoF scales and manual focus I can hit a lot of times using DoF
...Show more →

Oh good grief.

I'm glad we do have choices, and I'm really glad product manufacturers don't share your narrow view of "right tool." Basically, your perspective reads as: "Anyone who wants to shoot shallow DoF is a 'slave' to DoF, a 'one-trick pony,' and therefore should suffer having to carry 12lbs of stuff around." Do you seriously think that most people who engage in the act of photography are that monolithic in their view of what and how to shoot?
Aug 29, 2017 at 02:38 PM
airfrogusmc
Offline
Details
p.10 #9D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Speaking of good grief. DoF is a tool. Sometimes shallow is the right choice sometimes not. I always question anyone that thinks any technique is right all the time. Just because you can do something like shoot at .95 doesn't mean it is the right choice all the time. If you shoot wide open all the time then maybe it is a one trick pony don't you think? I know hard it is for some that are chasing a one size fits all, jack of all trades kind of camera but that camera doesn't exist and probably never will. Some cameras are clearly better at some things than others and knowing that and using what is appropriate for job is key in my opinion. And I'm glad that some do share my views and keep making tools that for the way I see and work. Like a Monochrome digital only camera or the new M 10 which is quite a departure from the what everyone else is producing.

BTW there is not to many formats or cameras over the years that I have not shot with both professionally and for more personal work and that includes digital to so before you make assumptions well you get the drift.

If my business and or my personal work included sports then I would have a camera and glass that did that really well. If I were a doing video I would have the best in that regard. Right tool and all. I have the best for what I shoot both personally and professionally and the good thing is my work pays for it all.


BTW you read a lot of stuff that just is not there. I never said if you get out of Leica it's because you can't do a or b. I never said that. Shoot with whatever you want to shot with. I was just correcting some things that you said about that are not accurate. Leica M is not a camera for everyone or probably even most. I have never said anything different.

So does this mean your going to pick up a Nikon 850? Or no?
Aug 29, 2017 at 03:24 PM
Arka
Offline
Details
p.10 #10D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
The only assumptions I make are based on what you write, and one of the things you wrote (40 years of shooting experience) suggests to me that you've tried a bunch of stuff and found something you liked. That much is obvious, and Leica is a great system to like. I also assume you haven't tried an A9 with a TAP adapter because you said you'd "heard" about its apparent unreliability. Let me know if those are bad assumptions.

As to other forms of assumption, why do you suggest that someone enjoying the shallow DoF effect only shoots that way (thereby fulfilling your one trick pony mold?)? For me at least, it happens to be one approach I enjoy, but not nearly enough to buy a massive 200mm f/2 (one rental of that monstrosity was enough to persuade me I'd be never use it). Rather, I enjoy every aspect of my fast and small M lenses - shallow DoF, low light capability, and outstanding imaging properties. And while it may be true that no "one-size-fits all" camera exists, some are certainly more flexible than others. I'm willing to trade the vanishingly small decline in image quality (one that few have been able to absolutely quantify) for the tremendous added flexibility.

You won't get any disagreement from me that Leica's pursuit of more specialized cameras is laudable - I spent many years and thousands of dollars on Leica equipment, most of which I still own and love. But I'm also very happy that there are solutions available that are more open and still offer excellent quality and capability.

Oh, and yes. I'll be getting a D850 to replace my D800. For sure!

airfrogusmc wrote:
Speaking of good grief. DoF is a tool. Sometimes shallow is the right choice sometimes not. I always question anyone that thinks any technique is right all the time. Just because you can do something like shoot at .95 doesn't mean it is the right choice all the time. If you shoot wide open all the time then maybe it is a one trick pony don't you think? I know hard it is for some that are chasing a one size fits all, jack of all trades kind of camera but that camera doesn't exist and probably never will. Some
...Show more →
Aug 29, 2017 at 03:51 PM
airfrogusmc
Offline
Details
p.10 #11D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
I've have a friend that has both so no assumption..

When the shots on the line for a client I need to know. I need to have the confidence of being able to get the shot. I trust my abilities over automation every time.

If I were in the market for a DSLR like i said earlier I would be giving it a hard look.
Aug 29, 2017 at 03:56 PM
Alexluu627
Offline
Details
p.10 #12D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
I think when they say Nikon designed the sensor, probably they meant Sony modified the sensor to what they wanted. It's most likely still a Sony sensor.

sony has the resources to make better sensors, so I wouldn't be surprised if Sony doesn't care to much about the d850.
They probably already built a couple of sensors and is just waiting for the right time to release them.


zhangyue wrote:
There were a few info from a Chinese interview with Nikon during introduction maybe useful for anyone interested in this camera.

1. The shutter is redesigned for 9 frame/s and also for higher pixel density. So you will expect about the SAME performance as D810 performance on pixel level. I wouldn't say this is not a achievement but I was expecting it is better than D810. Given speed and quietness, I will choose latter myself.

2. Sensor is a Nikon Design. (I don't really know what it means by that. All the info still very implicit to me) Backlight is
...Show more →
Aug 29, 2017 at 04:34 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.10 #13D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
I will bite here but this is Nikon D850 thread and will try keep this brief I did have the M9/M240's/MM for about 6 years and moved to Sony A7 series and kept my Leica M lenses, WATE, 21 SEM, 24 Lux, 28 Cron, 35 Cron Asph, 35 Lux FLE, 50 Cron IV, 50 Cron Asph , 50 Lux Asph, 50 Noct f/1.0, 75 Cron, 75 Lux, 90 Cron Pre Asph and 90 Cron Asph. At the time the understanding there was little downside in adapting Leica M lenses to the A7r but I spent 2 years with adapting these lenses including several Kolari modifications trying to maximize the performance of the M lenses. I had a huge investment in lenses that were performing less than on my M9/M240. At this point I decided to sell all my Leica M lenses unless I was willing to re invest in a M body again. Of course you can adapt the M mount lenses and there are several lenses that do work well, like the WATE, 24 Lux, 35 FLE, 50 Cron IV, 75 Cron and 90 Cron but I now keep with native mounts.
Aug 29, 2017 at 05:11 PM
Arka
Offline
Details
p.10 #14D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
charles.K wrote:
I will bite here but this is Nikon D850 thread and will try keep this brief I did have the M9/M240's/MM for about 6 years and moved to Sony A7 series and kept my Leica M lenses, WATE, 21 SEM, 24 Lux, 28 Cron, 35 Cron Asph, 35 Lux FLE, 50 Cron IV, 50 Cron Asph , 50 Lux Asph, 50 Noct f/1.0, 75 Cron, 75 Lux, 90 Cron Pre Asph and 90 Cron Asph. At the time the understanding there was little downside in adapting Leica M lenses to the A7r but I spent 2 years with adapting
...Show more →

I'm using a 50 Lux and 35 FLE Lux, and really like what I see so far on the A9. My CV 21m Ultron also looks pretty good at f/5.6... haven't tried it faster speeds, but I probably should. How was the Noct?

I'm selling my 90mm f/2 (pre-Asph), as it performs worse than the native Sony 85mm f/1.8, which is also lighter than the Leica 90.
Aug 29, 2017 at 05:17 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.10 #15D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Arka wrote:
charles.K wroteI will bite here but this is Nikon D850 thread and will try keep this brief I did have the M9/M240's/MM for about 6 years and moved to Sony A7 series and kept my Leica M lenses, WATE, 21 SEM, 24 Lux, 28 Cron, 35 Cron Asph, 35 Lux FLE, 50 Cron IV, 50 Cron Asph , 50 Lux Asph, 50 Noct f/1.0, 75 Cron, 75 Lux, 90 Cron Pre Asph and 90 Cron Asph. At the time the understanding there was little downside in adapting Leica M lenses to the A7r but I spent 2 years with adapting these lenses including several Kolari modifications trying to maximize the performance of the M lenses. I had a huge investment in lenses that were performing less than on my M9/M240. At this point I decided to sell all my Leica M lenses unless I was willing to re invest in a M body again. Of course you can adapt the M mount lenses and there are several lenses that do work well, like the WATE, 24 Lux, 35 FLE, 50 Cron IV, 75 Cron and 90 Cron but I now keep with native mounts.
I'm using a 50 Lux and 35 FLE Lux, and really like what I see so far on the A9. My CV 21m Ultron also looks pretty good at f/5.6... haven't tried it faster speeds, but I probably should. How was the Noct?

I'm selling my 90mm f/2 (pre-Asph), as it performs worse than the native Sony 85mm f/1.8, which is also lighter than the Leica 90.


I made a choice as I was frustrated by the process of adapting. There are some very good lenses and can be adapted, just that I did not wish to keep expensive M glass in preference to native lenses then. I opted for the Loxia 21 over the WATE as there were few choices then. I did try the 50 Lux Asph on the A7r/A7r Mod/A7s/A7II but I did not like look or rendering compared to my M240/50 Lux combo. The 35 FLE combined with the VM-E adapter worked quite well. If you already M glass with no need to move it on, of course adapting makes great sense.
Aug 29, 2017 at 06:55 PM
Arka
Offline
Details
p.10 #16D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
That's exactly my situation. I have the M glass but wasn't happy with current Leica camera options, so I decided to try the Sony. So far so good on the two summiluxes and the ultron. The 90 Cron isn't working out so well though. Fortunately there's a good native lens alternative. What I can't stand about the native lens alternatives for the luxes, however, is how massive they are. This is also the reason I never seriously considered the SL.

charles.K wrote:
Arka wrote
charles.K wroteI will bite here but this is Nikon D850 thread and will try keep this brief I did have the M9/M240's/MM for about 6 years and moved to Sony A7 series and kept my Leica M lenses, WATE, 21 SEM, 24 Lux, 28 Cron, 35 Cron Asph, 35 Lux FLE, 50 Cron IV, 50 Cron Asph , 50 Lux Asph, 50 Noct f/1.0, 75 Cron, 75 Lux, 90 Cron Pre Asph and 90 Cron Asph. At the time the understanding there was little downside in adapting Leica M lenses to the A7r but I spent 2 years with adapting these lenses including several Kolari modifications trying to maximize the performance of the M lenses. I had a huge investment in lenses that were performing less than on my M9/M240. At this point I decided to sell all my Leica M lenses unless I was willing to re invest in a M body again. Of course you can adapt the M mount lenses and there are several lenses that do work well, like the WATE, 24 Lux, 35 FLE, 50 Cron IV, 75 Cron and 90 Cron but I now keep with native mounts.
I'm using a 50 Lux and 35 FLE Lux, and really like what I see so far on the A9. My CV 21m Ultron also looks pretty good at f/5.6... haven't tried it faster speeds, but I probably should. How was the Noct?

I'm selling my 90mm f/2 (pre-Asph), as it performs worse than the native Sony 85mm f/1.8, which is also lighter than the Leica 90.
I made a choice as I was frustrated by the process of adapting. There are some very good lenses and can be adapted, just that I did not wish to keep expensive M glass in preference to native lenses then. I opted for the Loxia 21 over the WATE as there were few choices then. I did try the 50 Lux Asph on the A7r/A7r Mod/A7s/A7II but I did not like look or rendering compared to my M240/50 Lux combo. The 35 FLE combined with the VM-E adapter worked quite well. If you already M glass with no need to
...Show more →
Aug 29, 2017 at 07:27 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.10 #17D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
That's the problem once you add AF drive, electronic aperture control, etc. The lenses balloon. Plus I think with the drive for optical perfection and a degree of future proofing for really high MP sensors, the trend is to use large lens elements and lots of them. This is contradictory to Leica's M lens philosophy of the least number of possible elements to achieve the objective.
Aug 29, 2017 at 10:17 PM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.10 #18D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
A side topic, the more I look D850, the more I feel it seems can only get money from its own users than draw other camp either Canon or Sony.

For satisfied Sony user, it doesn't offer size, sensor performance, eye AF, video, EVF etc. For canon, yeh it indeed have better spec and sensor performance, but I see no reason pro will give up 30M(might be a plus than minus) 5div for this, serious amateur will not just change from 5dsr chasing for 9frame/sec and regular people won't need this kind of thing too. 5Div's sensor is really good enough to the point not an issue anymore. And today, Canon just announce another set of glass includ 85L IS and a set of TS. This is huge for studio/product photographer than DR I'd say. I could imagine that those set of lens might draw more people from Nikon than D850 draw people from Canon. You have to say Canon is the company made some good decision to steady improve their sensor than out source as Nikon, now almost feel handicapped by its competitor for product cycle. Canon has a clear picture what future product sensor will have, pixel, features etc....and Canon is the one keep improve their lens line up that keep their customer loyal even with "hate"

Nikon users still miss good latest WA zoom from Nikon, 16-35 f4 is so so lens, 14-24 is ten year old desperately need update E version and very important lens 16-35 f2.8 just missing for almost 20 years? And Nikon only have TS 19mm introduced last year, rest of them either too old or not good. I will not take credit for 70-200E and 28E and 105E. (I do have reservation about 58G, though the render is good but the SA of the lens make AF unreliable worse than sigma) Nikon's behavior of last few years deserve their struggle now I think includ QC and arrogant to customer service and customer request for true D700 successor. And their lenses are extreme expensive. After using sigma's ART, I can almost feel the arrogant of Nikon's offer: insist expensive without noticeable high quality.

Nikon's management deserve the punishment they are facing now. Until D850, offered at $3300 with spec sheet show some sincerity to its loyal customers. (I'd say D810 is pretty good too, but it happen only because Nikon need it desperately than they offer it to customers with pride) but I could not help feeling it is a little bit late to the game.
Aug 29, 2017 at 11:07 PM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.10 #19D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
And don't make me mention that DF again was ruined by cost and marketing people. I think the designer have the passison to bring a product like this but finally get handicap by management again to castrate feature and maximize profit make that huge campaign looks like a joke in the end.
To be fair, it is a good body with nice sensor. But I couldn't help thinking Nikon was messing up so many things like this because of stupid management decision.

Edited on Aug 29, 2017 at 11:32 PM · View previous versions
Aug 29, 2017 at 11:17 PM
Arka
Offline
Details
p.10 #20D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
rscheffler wrote:
That's the problem once you add AF drive, electronic aperture control, etc. The lenses balloon. Plus I think with the drive for optical perfection and a degree of future proofing for really high MP sensors, the trend is to use large lens elements and lots of them. This is contradictory to Leica's M lens philosophy of the least number of possible elements to achieve the objective.


Yeah, and that's a problem that infects Leica now too, at least for the SL. Recent M-system lenses have been large but still quite manageable in size. Not so for its SL system lenses. They rival the size of S system lenses, and do so for I am sure many of the same reason you mention here - AF motors, aperture control motors, and the use of whatever optical tricks are necessary to maximize resolution so pixel peepers won't deign to write a negative review.

Aug 29, 2017 at 11:29 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister