fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?

  
 
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.11 #1D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
zhangyue wrote:
A side topic, the more I look D850, the more I feel it seems can only get money from its own users than draw other camp either Canon or Sony.

For satisfied Sony user, it doesn't offer size, sensor performance, eye AF, video, EVF etc. For canon, yeh it indeed have better spec and sensor performance, but I see no reason pro will give up 30M(might be a plus than minus) 5div for this, serious amateur will not just change from 5dsr chasing for 9frame/sec and regular people won't need this kind of thing too. 5Div's sensor is really good
...Show more →

Michael, I don't agree with you here. It is not that Nikon is taking away from Sony or Canon, but people are just ordering the D850 and there is a very large back log of orders which is very good for Nikon. In my discussions it is a broad spectrum of people ordering from wedding photographers, fashion, nature/landscape and just keen advanced amateurs. I don't think it is an either/or thinking but many photographers still love a DSLR alongside their Sony/Fuji/Leica/Canon for specialist needs. Each system has it strengths.

Some brief words from DP Review summarizing 10 things he learned which were not in the manual.

"..........................
I touched one! My local dealer, Service Photo, had a hands on opportunity tonight. I learned a few things that were not clear to me from the material the Nikon advertising machine has put out. Marketing terms are fine, but what do they really mean?

1) The silent mode really is silent. It is an electronic 1st curtain and an electronic 2nd curtain. No moving parts!
2) The Bluetooth is basically there to keep the WiFi engaged without annoying re-connections.
3) You can shoot raw only and the camera will make a JPEG on the fly and send it to your smart phone/tablet/whatever.
4) You can review the images in the camera even when it is turned off using the WiFi link.
5) You can send raw images to your smart device but it will be slow. A 2 MB JPEG is fast, but I couldn't get them to quantify it. Probably on the order of a second.
6) You can trigger the camera from your smart device.
7) The camera data displayed at the bottom of the OVF is readable to a person with glasses. No other camera has been able to do that for my particular situation. (About a 3 diopter correction.)
8) The OVF image is bright!!
9) The touch screen features on the flip out screen are very fast ... faster than my iPad Pro. Hold to focus and release to take the picture. Two finger gestures to zoom in or out. Maybn more.
10) I really do want one! ................."

I have spoken to others who have had hands on with the D850 and they just love the camera. Yes it is a DSLR but it may be one of the last but it is really good. As Ron mentioned the D850 is likely to be the hybrid of DSLR qualities that narrow the gap with mirrorless bodies.

Personally I am in no rush as the D810/D750 is still a superb combo with my select lenses but I will be in for the second wave of orders in November unless there is stock left over

There is still quite some time and I keen to see some RAW files post processed via updated Lr/PS to really get a feel for the files. We can read all the DR specs and it is fine for some initial comparisons but depending on how we expose images and then process the RAW's will make a huge difference. The D810 RAW files at 64 ISO always amaze me from ETTR and low key images protecting the highlights. I just hope the D850 RAW files are similar and not affected by the new sensor.

The reason why I love the concept of the D850 is that while I love the D810, I was aspiring to the Fuji GFX 50s as my FF/miniMF substitute since the body size/weight were similar. With the D850 the entry cost is relatively low and it achieves more than what I need without having to invest in another series of lenses and system.


Aug 30, 2017 at 12:57 AM
Arka
Offline
Details
p.11 #2D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
zhangyue wrote:
A side topic, the more I look D850, the more I feel it seems can only get money from its own users than draw other camp either Canon or Sony.

For satisfied Sony user, it doesn't offer size, sensor performance, eye AF, video, EVF etc. For canon, yeh it indeed have better spec and sensor performance, but I see no reason pro will give up 30M(might be a plus than minus) 5div for this, serious amateur will not just change from 5dsr chasing for 9frame/sec and regular people won't need this kind of thing too. 5Div's sensor is really good
...Show more →

I don't agree at all. Nikon will sell a ton of these, and thereby keep their system viable for their next big thing (whatever that may be). I will definitely buy one... it's the first dSLR from any company that has excited me since the D800 came out in 2012.

As for the comments on lenses... I and the landscape photographers I shoot with must not be all that picky, as none of us are clamoring for updates to the 14-24 or 16-35. The 14-24 is still superb and widely used by landscape photographers on Nikon and non-Nikon bodies. On a recent trip to Patagonia, I saw a lot of those lenses with Fotodiox filter adapters on them. The 16-35 is very well suited for its target audience, and delivers perfectly good images - I've shot several that I've expanded to 40x60 and larger, and have been very very pleased. And the 105mm f/1.4 - that one is a sublime lens - there's really nothing else out there like it on any system. And, as you mentioned, there are great Sigma options out there that will likely shine on Nikon's new sensor and AF system (once firmware is updated). If there are any business consequences to Nikon at all, it might be that there will be little to no reason to upgrade to the D900 when that comes out... this D850 looks like a solid camera that will last for years to come. I'm not sure what Nikon could've done that would've caused an exodus from Canon-land or Sony-land at this point.

Canon's lens announcements were yawners to me. A slate of TS/Es and an 85 that's slower than its predecessors... whoop-de-do. I'm certainly not switching to Canon over any of those (though I might consider adapting them to my A9 if I ever had a need for such capabilities).
Aug 30, 2017 at 02:32 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.11 #3D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
zhangyue wrote:
A side topic, the more I look D850, the more I feel it seems can only get money from its own users than draw other camp either Canon or Sony.

For satisfied Sony user, it doesn't offer size, sensor performance, eye AF, video, EVF etc. For canon, yeh it indeed have better spec and sensor performance, but I see no reason pro will give up 30M(might be a plus than minus) 5div for this, serious amateur will not just change from 5dsr chasing for 9frame/sec and regular people won't need this kind of thing too. 5Div's sensor is really good
...Show more →

Michael,

I agree with part of this. Although I think the Nikon 850 is a great camera, I don't think it will draw many Canon or Sony shooters. If people shoot Sony now as their primary system, then they are probably committed to mirrorless and only a mirrorless FF 35mm camera from Nikon or Canon will likely draw them away from Sony. And if Canon shooters haven't switched yet, then the better sensor in this camera over the 5D IV (which does a lot better than previous Canon sensors) is not likely to draw people.
Still, for Nikon shooters this is a great development as Charles says and I am not nearly so pessimistic about Nikon's lens offerings. Nikon has hit some home runs in lens development recently. I think the 105 f/1.4 was a bold idea and a brilliant implementation. I think the 19 TSE actually is a bit better in a number or respects than the excellent Canon 17 and 24 TSEs. Those were definitely recent home runs in my book. Yeah, they have a couple of lenses in their line up that would not have been my choices to make and are perhaps not ideal, but so does everyone else. They also have some holes to fill (e.g., a good 135), but so does everyone else and in the case of Nikon it is hard to think of a hole that isn't filled by a good third party lens (e.g., the Sigma Art 135 f/1.8). I find it hard to be too critical of their lens lineup. Quality control is something that everyone has also got to improve as we have moved to high resolution sensors. We just notice weak quality control a lot easier. So, there too I think they are keeping up with the competition and it is an industry problem and not a Nikon problem. I say all this even though I am not a Nikon shooter and although I have a lot of lenses I don't own a single Nikon lens or camera (I do have a number of Nikon mount Milvus and ZF.2 lenses but I use them on other cameras). I won't be getting the D850 either, but I will be recommending it to my friends who shoot Nikon and I think as Charles says it will extend the life of Nikon as a company for at least the cycle of this camera. Long term Nikon is going to have to figure out the mirrorless world--as I see that as the way of the future--but even on that front this camera seems to be the first step of Nikon doing that. It may be a halting jerky step, but they are at least moving in the right direction, IMO.

Edited on Aug 30, 2017 at 07:49 AM · View previous versions
Aug 30, 2017 at 07:46 AM
Gary Clennan
Offline
Details
p.11 #4D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Arka wrote:
The 14-24 is still superb and widely used by landscape photographers on Nikon and non-Nikon bodies. On a recent trip to Patagonia, I saw a lot of those lenses with Fotodiox filter adapters on them.


I agree that the 14-24mm f/2.8 Nikkor is amazing. It has been my main UWA lens for A7RII for the past two years. Until I dropped it on the rocks a few weeks ago..... However, now that I have the 16-35mm GM, I don't miss the 14-24mm at all. The performance on the high MP A7RII is simply amazing. I would prefer if it did go as wide as 14mm but I will probably supplement with a wide prime like the CV12. Or I could go for the "divorce option" (as Fred put it so eloquently) and buy the 12-24mm as well.
Aug 30, 2017 at 07:47 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.11 #5D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
While there are measurable differences between equivalent lenses across brands, are there any truly terrible ones now, at least at the higher end of the market?

For example, I think I read that the new Sony FE 70-200/2.8 doesn't perform as well as the Canikon equivalents. But the real-world images I've made with it don't give me the impression of it lacking anything, at least on the 20MP a9. Images are sharp, AF works, rendering looks good...

Previously I've shot with the Sony FE 85/1.4 and thought it was very impressive. It's better than my Canon 85/1.2 in a number of ways. But despite the Canon's relative weaknesses, such as bokeh fringing and not as good off-center sharpness, it's still very good. Yes, I've ordered the new 85/1.4L IS. To me the difference between f/1.2 and f/1.4 is mostly irrelevant and I would not base a purchase decision on this factor alone. I would have actually preferred an 85/2L IS from Canon. My interest in the new 85 is its faster AF and IS, both of which I feel can be of benefit to the work I do. In this respect, I think Canon's choice of feature set was a good one. Reading the interviews with the designers and engineers responsible for the new 85, there was a lot of effort put into making it as small as possible (of course it's still large, but not Sigma Art large), which I appreciate. Size of the recent Art lenses (as well as questions about AF reliability/consistency) and Zeiss Otus/Milvus, too, are one of the primary reasons I have not bothered with those options.

I think the D850 will pull some from other brands, but it won't be a wholesale shift, as was once the case with cameras such as the D3 bringing over a lot of Canon shooters unhappy with the 1DIII (many of whom were previously long-time Nikon users). Those happy with Sony mirrorless will wait for the a7RIII or whatever other iteration of the a9 appears in the near future. It's bound to happen and I think any of us who have been doing this for some time realize it's just a matter of waiting for 'our' manufacturer to release a competitive product.

That said, if I was an enthusiast with the spare cash, I would probably get a D850 with 28/1.4, 58 and 105/1.4. I'm a proponent of the Canon 50L's rendering, so think I could live with the 58's SA induced AF quirks...
Aug 30, 2017 at 09:47 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.11 #6D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Charels, Arka, Steve and Gary, thanks for respond my whining. I was not deny the significance of D850. I love it as much as the time starting this thread. A side topic means discuss about how Nikon is/was doing, how could they gain market share etc which is not really my business

As for Lens selection: TS lens with High density sensor is a serious combination that Canon realize it is important feature can allow it compete with MiniMF and gain customers from traditional MF and LF customers. and it is a important lens selection for Studio, Product, Architecture even Landscape photographer. I will not ignore the significance of their introduction and applaud their continues efforts paying to LEns selection. The lens selection is ready for 5DSRII striking any time soon.

As for 14-24, I own that lens more than 9 years on and off. I don't have much complain general speaking, it brought most of my SWA keeper actually. It use to be the KING. However, It has its quack in field: Flare performance, Sun star can be inconsistent and hard to get super one (picky about light spot direction and size), field curvature(associate with copy variation actually) make focusing need be very careful to optimize cross frame sharpness.

It is all about relative. Nikon use to be WA leader in this field. Will you say the same thing here now? 5 years ago, this single lens can draw many customer to Nikon Camp. Now, 11-24, 16-35F4, 16-35f2.8III, (looks to me Canon slowly, steadily become the new leader in SWA ) Tamron 15-30. Sigma 12-24 14f1.8. Where is Nikon? You can't just ignore this range for 5 years with superb DR landscape camera. (Again, a wrong market decision IMO) Where is 16-35f2.8? one of most important WA I would say. (Gary, I see no reason you will miss 14-24 with 16-35GM for the performance size, weight and filter selection)

And now Sony has 12-24 seems the new KING and 16-35GM, it is pain me to stop my Sony system now because of I just can't full in with current Sony EVF and ergonomics but that 16-35 is so small with nice rendering and most important I don't need 150mm filter system A PITA in field IMO. Filter is a big consideration why I value 16-35 f2.8 so high. It can capture star during night, It can cover upto 35mm without changing lens during the day and take filter as easy as any lens. TBH, I seriously thought about get a Canon body with this lens actually half year ago. Sony realize the significance of this range for them that introduce 12-24, 16-36f2,8 almost at the same time with 16-35 Zeiss and 21 loxia, Voigtlander 10, 12, 15. If I am a landscape shooter, I am long gone now. What the hell is Nikon Management thinking? Once Sony figure out star eat, drop bit Long exposure, Why Nikon? Again, are Nikon prepared for that?

Steve, I forget that 19mm. It is the best now. The problem is it still require special filter and I believe asking price is close to $3000. I am willing to pay that amount for next great 14-28E (not a typo) , but pain for a prime.

70-200FE 105 and 28E are real winner. (I don't want spend time on 24-70E here) 58G has great concept, but will benefit from a little fine tune in E version IMO.

Edited on Aug 30, 2017 at 10:40 AM · View previous versions
Aug 30, 2017 at 10:11 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.11 #7D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
rscheffler wrote:
While there are measurable differences between equivalent lenses across brands, are there any truly terrible ones now, at least at the higher end of the market?

For example, I think I read that the new Sony FE 70-200/2.8 doesn't perform as well as the Canikon equivalents. But the real-world images I've made with it don't give me the impression of it lacking anything, at least on the 20MP a9. Images are sharp, AF works, rendering looks good...

Previously I've shot with the Sony FE 85/1.4 and thought it was very impressive. It's better than my Canon 85/1.2 in a number of
...Show more →

Ron, Grass is greener here Sony 85GM is the one I always want. Cash is ready but for portrait I decide stay with OVF at least one more round for the reason mentioned. I am very happy with Sigma now. (but I don't want make myself too controversy here ) Sigma lens have right manual focus direction with real focus ring for me, a quite big plus for my consideration. I hate focus by wire though for Sony lens.
Aug 30, 2017 at 10:15 AM
Lee Saxon
Offline
Details
p.11 #8D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Steve Spencer wrote:
And if Canon shooters haven't switched yet, then the better sensor in this camera over the 5D IV (which does a lot better than previous Canon sensors) is not likely to draw people.


If all you could say were "better sensor than the 5D IV" (which would've been, I guess, a D750 sensor in a pro body), I'd agree. I think "resolution of 5Ds and speed of 5D IV in one body *plus* better sensor" might be more of a pull though. I don't know how many committed Canon users are gonna sell their big lens collections over this, but the "brand agnostics" who go with whoever's better each generation are, I think, going to be sending their money Nikon's way for a little while.

Aug 30, 2017 at 12:40 PM
davewolfs
Offline
Details
p.11 #9D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Isn't the 58 a dud?

zhangyue wrote:
charles.K wroteI am glad I have moved my lens system to Nikon
You should, you should I have been watching your awesome images by using 105, 58 and 85. (Though I miss your images here. D810 is already quite nice but this D850 pull ahead in lots of areas.) I am just surprised you are the only few did it. I really wish we have more discuss on Canon, Nikon or pentax SLR gear here. They were treat like dying dinosaurs here now, are they?



Aug 30, 2017 at 02:47 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.11 #10D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Lee Saxon wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteAnd if Canon shooters haven't switched yet, then the better sensor in this camera over the 5D IV (which does a lot better than previous Canon sensors) is not likely to draw people.
If all you could say were "better sensor than the 5D IV" (which would've been, I guess, a D750 sensor in a pro body), I'd agree. I think "resolution of 5Ds and speed of 5D IV in one body *plus* better sensor" might be more of a pull though. I don't know how many committed Canon users are gonna sell their big lens collections over this, but the "brand agnostics" who go with whoever's better each generation are, I think, going to be sending their money Nikon's way for a little while.



I would think most of the brand agnostics would have already drifted to Nikon with the D810 or to Sony with the A7r II depending on their mix of types of shooting and preferences. Perhaps a few went back to Canon with the 5Ds if they were most concerned about resolution, but I can't see this camera pulling them back. I doubt hardly anyone came back to Canon for the 5D IV even though it did a nice job of getting Canon back closer to the competition. It seems to me most Canon shooters at this point are committed to Canon for the lenses and not for the cameras, and Sony shooters are committed to Sony for mirrorless, and brand agnostics will pick one of those two for the same reasons or they are already shooting Nikon. I think it is a great camera, but I don't think it will affect Nikon's user base much if at all.
Aug 30, 2017 at 02:59 PM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.11 #11D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
BTW, the new 85L is awesome. I usually rate 85 is more useful than 105 or 135. Not for the Blur but mainly about working distance, about right amount of flating on 3D subject.
You should be very happy with that lens.

rscheffler wrote:
While there are measurable differences between equivalent lenses across brands, are there any truly terrible ones now, at least at the higher end of the market?

For example, I think I read that the new Sony FE 70-200/2.8 doesn't perform as well as the Canikon equivalents. But the real-world images I've made with it don't give me the impression of it lacking anything, at least on the 20MP a9. Images are sharp, AF works, rendering looks good...

Previously I've shot with the Sony FE 85/1.4 and thought it was very impressive. It's better than my Canon 85/1.2 in a number of
...Show more →
Aug 30, 2017 at 04:02 PM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.11 #12D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
No, it is a good lens. It remind me a lot about 80lux. However, since it is a AF lens, my requirement is different. And since it is introduce 2015 instead of 1980, my expectation also different.

105E clearly show you can achieve sharpness and rendering at the same time, 58g did good on rendering portion but lacking in sharpness IMHO. And being a AF lens for pro. You have to put some perspective into reliable hit focusing, the lens I had is sharp enough for me but consistently back focus even with Perfect AF fine tune. They need do some homework make the lens right for copy variation, (widely reported, though I think mostly just from poor AF, with so few element and simple design, I would not expect it has so much variation as reported.) Reliable AF and good focus at all distance is important. And the lens should ask $1200 max than $1600 for the design complication and materials. Again, my therory: if you treat customer like fool you will be punished like a fool. (I know I looks weird spending $$$$$ for Leica stuff and complain Nikon's price, but here the perspective is totally different. I am trying to be sane here. )

And I don't want repeat how suck the Nikon AF lens for manual focusing, but that is niche need for someone like me.

davewolfs wrote:
Isn't the 58 a dud?

zhangyue wrote
charles.K wroteI am glad I have moved my lens system to Nikon
You should, you should I have been watching your awesome images by using 105, 58 and 85. (Though I miss your images here. D810 is already quite nice but this D850 pull ahead in lots of areas.) I am just surprised you are the only few did it. I really wish we have more discuss on Canon, Nikon or pentax SLR gear here. They were treat like dying dinosaurs here now, are they?



Edited on Aug 30, 2017 at 04:23 PM · View previous versions
Aug 30, 2017 at 04:12 PM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.11 #13D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?

I do find many canon user get D500 and 200-500 though, but looks none of them make commitment for Nikon. A reason worth Nikon management to think about why?

Steve Spencer wrote:
Lee Saxon wrote
Steve Spencer wroteAnd if Canon shooters haven't switched yet, then the better sensor in this camera over the 5D IV (which does a lot better than previous Canon sensors) is not likely to draw people.
If all you could say were "better sensor than the 5D IV" (which would've been, I guess, a D750 sensor in a pro body), I'd agree. I think "resolution of 5Ds and speed of 5D IV in one body *plus* better sensor" might be more of a pull though. I don't know how many committed Canon users are gonna sell their big lens collections over this, but the "brand agnostics" who go with whoever's better each generation are, I think, going to be sending their money Nikon's way for a little while.
I would think most of the brand agnostics would have already drifted to Nikon with the D810 or to Sony with the A7r II depending on their mix of types of shooting and preferences. Perhaps a few went back to Canon with the 5Ds if they were most concerned about resolution, but I can't see this camera pulling them back. I doubt hardly anyone came back to Canon for the 5D IV even though it did a nice job of getting Canon back closer to the competition. It seems to me most Canon shooters at this point are committed
...Show more →
Aug 30, 2017 at 04:17 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.11 #14D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
zhangyue wrote:
BTW, the new 85L is awesome. I usually rate 85 is more useful than 105 or 135. Not for the Blur but mainly about working distance, about right amount of flating on 3D subject.
You should be very happy with that lens.

rscheffler wroteWhile there are measurable differences between equivalent lenses across brands, are there any truly terrible ones now, at least at the higher end of the market?

For example, I think I read that the new Sony FE 70-200/2.8 doesn't perform as well as the Canikon equivalents. But the real-world images I've made with it don't give me the impression of it lacking anything, at least on the 20MP a9. Images are sharp, AF works, rendering looks good...

Previously I've shot with the Sony FE 85/1.4 and thought it was very impressive. It's better than my Canon 85/1.2 in a number of ways. But despite the Canon's relative weaknesses, such as bokeh fringing and not as good off-center sharpness, it's still very good. Yes, I've ordered the new 85/1.4L IS. To me the difference between f/1.2 and f/1.4 is mostly irrelevant and I would not base a purchase decision on this factor alone. I would have actually preferred an 85/2L IS from Canon. My interest in the new 85 is its faster AF and IS, both of which I feel can be of benefit to the work I do. In this respect, I think Canon's choice of feature set was a good one. Reading the interviews with the designers and engineers responsible for the new 85, there was a lot of effort put into making it as small as possible (of course it's still large, but not Sigma Art large), which I appreciate. Size of the recent Art lenses (as well as questions about AF reliability/consistency) and Zeiss Otus/Milvus, too, are one of the primary reasons I have not bothered with those options.

I think the D850 will pull some from other brands, but it won't be a wholesale shift, as was once the case with cameras such as the D3 bringing over a lot of Canon shooters unhappy with the 1DIII (many of whom were previously long-time Nikon users). Those happy with Sony mirrorless will wait for the a7RIII or whatever other iteration of the a9 appears in the near future. It's bound to happen and I think any of us who have been doing this for some time realize it's just a matter of waiting for 'our' manufacturer to release a competitive product.

That said, if I was an enthusiast with the spare cash, I would probably get a D850 with 28/1.4, 58 and 105/1.4. I'm a proponent of the Canon 50L's rendering, so think I could live with the 58's SA induced AF quirks...


Canon's 85L II has always been a favorite lens of mine and emulates very closely to the 75 Lux/50 Nocti f/1.0 rendering and look. That said the new 85L looks to be amazing!

The GM 85/1.4 was a superb lens, albeit slower on the A7rII and very large and heavy. In preference I would pick the 85L II over the GM 85 for the look and style but I kept the GM 85 as it was native and no real issues with focusing and accuracy.

That said the Nikon 85/1.4G are 85/1.8G are truly excellent, and side by side evaluation with the GM 85 and 85/1.4G are very similar in look and rendering except that the 85/1.4G is about half the size and weight. This alone is a huge benefit when you look at the system size and weight.

The 105E is in another league again. Nikon really got this lens right at least for portrait photographers. The 105mm FL as always been a favorite even with film I was using the Nikon 105/2.5. The reason I love the 105/1.4E is that achieves the look of the 85/1.2L II with the additional FL of 105mm

Nikon like Canon, Fuji, Leica have a huge amount of experience and have been sleeping for awhile. Of course the slow down in the market will not help and each camera manufacturer needs to re evaluate and re define their direction. The direction may not be what we want or hope for and I suspect new camera models will come but will be rationalized to a few select models and longer lead times. We can be overly critical but there are no "bad" camera systems just what we prefer. I feel we are reaching the cusp of technology and there will be minimal improvements in the next few years without resorting to very high entry costs.

The D850 with respect to paper specs is superb and particularly the price entry level is a smart marketing move. Had I still kept just my Canon lenses, I would probably opt for the 5DIV as this camera is also great.

Aug 30, 2017 at 04:51 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.11 #15D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
davewolfs wrote:
Isn't the 58 a dud?

zhangyue wrote
charles.K wroteI am glad I have moved my lens system to Nikon
You should, you should I have been watching your awesome images by using 105, 58 and 85. (Though I miss your images here. D810 is already quite nice but this D850 pull ahead in lots of areas.) I am just surprised you are the only few did it. I really wish we have more discuss on Canon, Nikon or pentax SLR gear here. They were treat like dying dinosaurs here now, are they?


The 58G is not a dud, just that many photographers now aspire to the look of the 50 Art lens. I have both and the 58G is very sharp lens when you marginally stop it down. Wide open it is superb for portraits which it was designed for but it requires careful calibration. Once calibrated the face/eye recognition in AF-C Auto selection works superbly even at f/1.4 nailing the focus on the eyes. I had discussed this in a number of threads. Stopped down to f/4 and f/8 the lens is very sharp. The 50 Art alongside is probably on the best modern 50mm lenses I have owned and the AF and accuracy is excellent on both the D810 and D750.
Aug 30, 2017 at 05:00 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.11 #16D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
zhangyue wrote:
I do find many canon user get D500 and 200-500 though, but looks none of them make commitment for Nikon. A reason worth Nikon management to think about why?


Those would be the birders.... From the discussions I've read, the thing holding many of them back from more Nikon purchases, such as super-teles, is that apparently the Nikon TCs are not as good on their super-teles as Canon's are on their own. Also I think those Nikon lenses might be more expensive?

Anyway, I agree with and was going to write in my longer post above 'grass is greener'. Some of the appeal might just be to switch systems and try something different/new.

As for the future of photography... I think the mass consumer market will go to small devices that use computational photography rather than hardware. Those of us who like equipment will still be around, but it will be like film now - a niche within a niche. Fewer manufacturers, fewer selection, higher prices. That said, as technology advances and currently complex electronics either become simpler or the cost of entry to produce such components drops, I imagine 'mom & pop' custom manufacturers may emerge to address the niche photographic hardware market. Isn't there already talk about decentralized manufacturing, where you buy a product license and 'build' it yourself at home with your 'replicator-like' device? No more waiting around for some big company to make what you want - buy the plans from someone, do it yourself and customize it to your needs. Someone will publish lens designs and formulas for all the 'classics' which we can then tweak ourselves. Want a bit more or less SA? Tweak the air spacing, shape, refractive index of an element, the coatings, or add an aspheric to change the characteristics even more. Your 'iLens' software will guide you through the steps.

In the meantime I think I will probably try to hang onto my range of M glass as long as possible... I still think a purely mechanical device has a very long service life.
Aug 30, 2017 at 05:38 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.11 #17D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
charles.K wrote:
zhangyue wroteBTW, the new 85L is awesome. I usually rate 85 is more useful than 105 or 135. Not for the Blur but mainly about working distance, about right amount of flating on 3D subject.
You should be very happy with that lens.

rscheffler wroteWhile there are measurable differences between equivalent lenses across brands, are there any truly terrible ones now, at least at the higher end of the market?

For example, I think I read that the new Sony FE 70-200/2.8 doesn't perform as well as the Canikon equivalents. But the real-world images I've made with it don't give me the impression of it lacking anything, at least on the 20MP a9. Images are sharp, AF works, rendering looks good...

Previously I've shot with the Sony FE 85/1.4 and thought it was very impressive. It's better than my Canon 85/1.2 in a number of ways. But despite the Canon's relative weaknesses, such as bokeh fringing and not as good off-center sharpness, it's still very good. Yes, I've ordered the new 85/1.4L IS. To me the difference between f/1.2 and f/1.4 is mostly irrelevant and I would not base a purchase decision on this factor alone. I would have actually preferred an 85/2L IS from Canon. My interest in the new 85 is its faster AF and IS, both of which I feel can be of benefit to the work I do. In this respect, I think Canon's choice of feature set was a good one. Reading the interviews with the designers and engineers responsible for the new 85, there was a lot of effort put into making it as small as possible (of course it's still large, but not Sigma Art large), which I appreciate. Size of the recent Art lenses (as well as questions about AF reliability/consistency) and Zeiss Otus/Milvus, too, are one of the primary reasons I have not bothered with those options.

I think the D850 will pull some from other brands, but it won't be a wholesale shift, as was once the case with cameras such as the D3 bringing over a lot of Canon shooters unhappy with the 1DIII (many of whom were previously long-time Nikon users). Those happy with Sony mirrorless will wait for the a7RIII or whatever other iteration of the a9 appears in the near future. It's bound to happen and I think any of us who have been doing this for some time realize it's just a matter of waiting for 'our' manufacturer to release a competitive product.

That said, if I was an enthusiast with the spare cash, I would probably get a D850 with 28/1.4, 58 and 105/1.4. I'm a proponent of the Canon 50L's rendering, so think I could live with the 58's SA induced AF quirks...
Canon's 85L II has always been a favorite lens of mine and emulates very closely to the 75 Lux/50 Nocti f/1.0 rendering and look. That said the new 85L looks to be amazing!

The GM 85/1.4 was a superb lens, albeit slower on the A7rII and very large and heavy. In preference I would pick the 85L II over the GM 85 for the look and style but I kept the GM 85 as it was native and no real issues with focusing and accuracy.

That said the Nikon 85/1.4G are 85/1.8G are truly excellent, and side by side evaluation
...Show more →

I agree with everything you have said except that there will be minimal improvement in the next few years. We have seen tons of improvements in the last three years and I expect more in the next three years and even more in the next six years. I think there are two areas in which big improvements are almost certain.

First, EVF/LCD screen improvements that are now available but haven't been widely put into cameras seem almost certain to make their way into cameras in the next three years. I expect an EVF with the size and resolution of the Leica SL, the zero black out and responsiveness of the Sony A9 and with improved dynamic range and colour fidelity to be standard in EVF based cameras. I expect LCDs to be retina screens with increased resolution, clarity, and visibility in strong light. They will also get a lot more touch features and be more highly integrated with cell phones--the D850 has already taken big steps in that direction.

Second, I see no slowing down of sensor development. I expect in 3 years that we will have high megapixel back side illuminated stacked sensors which are fast and have excellent DR and low light capabilities. These sensors will also allow a fully electronic shutter which is silent for all shooting and will allow shutter speeds up to 1/3200. The jump in the next six years will be smaller because the electronic shutter capabilities will already have been achieved but sensors will still gain resolution/DR/and high ISO capabilities.

I expect the typical FF 35mm camera in six years to shoot 60 mpix at at least 14 fps, to have a fully silent electronic shutter (with a sensor readout of 1/300th of a second and therefore flash sync up to 1/300 of a sec), and a zero black out EVF at least as big as the Leica SL with even better dynamic range and colour fidelity. There may be a place for OVF cameras with mechanical shutters in this universe, but it will be a niche. In the meantime, this Nikon D850 will be a highly competitive camera and give Nikon about 4 years to develop its own kick ass mirrorless camera with a silent fully electronic shutter and zero black out EVF. Nikon now has a chance to compete in the emerging market, but in my view if they think there will only be minimal improvements in the competition in the next few years, then they are doomed.
Aug 30, 2017 at 05:47 PM
davewolfs
Offline
Details
p.11 #18D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
Does anyone have any numbers on how much market share Sony, Fuji and Olympus have taken from Canon/Nikon?

There is a lot of talk on the forums about how EVFs are superior and will deprecate the OVF. The reality is that the majority of consumers might not know or care.
Aug 30, 2017 at 06:40 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.11 #19D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
davewolfs wrote:
Does anyone have any numbers on how much market share Sony, Fuji and Olympus have taken from Canon/Nikon?

There is a lot of talk on the forums about how EVFs are superior and will deprecate the OVF. The reality is that the majority of consumers might not know or care.


Well looking at CIPA numbers for the first 6 months of 2017 shows 36% of all ILC shipped were mirror less, which dig directly into the market share of DSLR systems. A more startling number is DSLR sales continue to slide this year whereas mirrorless sales have taken a huge jump forward.

It's all in the CIPA reports online.
Aug 30, 2017 at 07:11 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.11 #20D850, now confirmed spec, what you think?
davewolfs wrote:
Does anyone have any numbers on how much market share Sony, Fuji and Olympus have taken from Canon/Nikon?

There is a lot of talk on the forums about how EVFs are superior and will deprecate the OVF. The reality is that the majority of consumers might not know or care.


There are lots of numbers available. One excellent source is the CIPA (Camera & Image Products Association) of which all major manufacturers are a part. The biggest trend is that the number of point and shoot cameras sold have dropped almost completely off the charts. This market segment has been almost totally abandoned. When we look at interchangeable lens cameras, however, you see that the market has contracted but not nearly as much. In 2012, the CIPA separated DSLRs in their records from non SLR (basically mirrorless) cameras. At that point 83% of the market share for interchangeable lens cameras was DSLRs and 17% was mirrorless (this is by sales dollars, but the story is similar for cameras sold too). From that point year over year mirrorless has held steady with mostly small increases and DSLRs have dropped pretty significantly, that is until this year. For the first six months of 2017 there has been a rebound in the sale of interchangeable lens cameras, but that increase has been almost totally in mirrorless cameras. Here are the numbers:

2012 - market share 83% DSLRs 17% mirrorless
2013 - DSLRs decline 11%; mirrorless decline 3%; market share 82% DSLRs 18% mirrorless
2014 - DSLRs decline 16%; mirrorless increase 13%; market share 77% DSLRs 23% mirrorless
2015 - DSLRs decline 8%; mirrorless increase 2%; market share 73% DSLRs 27% mirrorless
2016 - DSLRs decline 14%; mirrorless hold steady; market share 71% DSLRs 29% mirrorless
2017 (first six months) - DSLRs hold steady; mirrorless increase 84%; market share 60% DSLRs 40% mirrorless

So, if I am Canon and Nikon I would definitely be worried by this trend. The first six months may not hold for the year, and the D850 will bring back DSLRs I think to at least some extent, but the trend is pretty obvious and it won't be too much longer and DSLRs will only have a minority of the market share. Perhaps Canon and Nikon have slowed the free fall in sales from the preceding 4 years this year, but it is still not a pretty picture. On the other hand mirrorless is showing not too bad growth with the possibility that this year will be a turning point.
Aug 30, 2017 at 07:48 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister