fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?

  
 
krautland
Offline

p.1 #1Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
When shooting with a 400mm f2.8 LII + 2x TC III on a 1DX2 I sometimes get extremely soft images. This problem comes and goes and I am struggling to find out what causes it. A soft sample image is here: http://imgur.com/a/khYDJ Anyone have guesses for what might cause this? This was shot at 1/1250th @800mm.

Thing I've tried:

- disconnecting everything, reconnecting. This fixes the issue but it will come back at some point.

- refocussing, i.e. because I may have focussed on wires. no help when issue is present.

- 400 without the 2xTC works fine all the time.

Is this a known issue? (The 1DX2 is on the latest firmware.)

http://i.imgur.com/nW4rMUa.jpg

Edited on Mar 05, 2017 at 09:09 AM · View previous versions
Mar 05, 2017 at 01:05 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
Looks weird. Maybe you have "focus search" turned off (lens drive when AF impossible), and it's giving up because it's taking "too long" to lock into focus. Just a guess. My 1DX + 500/4L IS + 2xIII had dependable AF for static subjects.
Mar 05, 2017 at 05:30 AM
LuckyStrike
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
Interesting ... Though I have no answers for you, I must admit to experiencing some similar problems occcasionally while using the 1DX2 with my 300 f/2.8 + 2X ... I have had a number of occasions where the rig just did not focus static images in reasonable light. I generally write it off to atmospheric conditions, but (however, unless super low light I find focus is fast and reliable)

LuckyT

Mar 05, 2017 at 10:46 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
That example is most likely atmospherics. Recently I showed a thread where cold temps and atmosphere disturbances between warming land and cold air made my MFA go to needing +20 where under regular conditions was +5 to +10.

On my 7D2 there were issues with focus not working if I didn't attach the TC to the lens first and then to the camera and then power on the camera. Different sequences of that often resulted in total AF fail confirmed even indoors testing MFA with FoCal program. None of my other bodies are that picky but that is Canon's recommended sequence of attaching a TC. To be honest I never do it that way, usually camera is ON and it is random if I attach TC to body or lens first.
Mar 05, 2017 at 10:54 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
Based on the photo above, I would suspect North Korean hackers have infiltrated your camera's firmware...
Mar 05, 2017 at 12:13 PM
technic
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
arbitrage wrote:
That example is most likely atmospherics. Recently I showed a thread where cold temps and atmosphere disturbances between warming land and cold air made my MFA go to needing +20 where under regular conditions was +5 to +10.

On my 7D2 there were issues with focus not working if I didn't attach the TC to the lens first and then to the camera and then power on the camera. Different sequences of that often resulted in total AF fail confirmed even indoors testing MFA with FoCal program. None of my other bodies are that picky but that is Canon's recommended
...Show more →

Agree about atmospheric conditions being a likely factor. I did some testing with my 80D, new 100-400II and TC over the last two weeks and found that PDAF for long distance shots (over 100m or so) was unreliable.Taking shots with PDAF it shows as occasional (very) soft focus, while clearly lens quality or camera shake were not a factor. When using Liveview with 10x magnify the source of the problem became obvious: the sharpness 'ripples' in and out from time to time. The result of this was also that even Liveview focus was often not exact, probably because there is a delay between judging focus and taking the picture.

Now my situation is probably worse than average as I live next to a canal and the countryside here is often relatively wet as well. Good conditions for long distance tele shots do occur, but they are probably rare ...

I now also understand why I did get some weird, locally very unsharp, shots with my 4/300mm last summer: those shots were taken using Liveview (AI servo), with the camera and lens just above the water in sunny conditions. For close up shots this works well, but for longer distance it adds an 'variable air lens' to the optical system ;-)

BTW, testing indoors at 10m distance or so, I also have occasional wrongly focused images using PDAF and a very easy AF target, where the camera confirms focus. I can even see in the viewfinder that the focus isn't perfect. Not sure yet where that is coming from :-(
Mar 05, 2017 at 12:41 PM
AJSJones
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
I saw the title and noticed the snow in the (huge!) picture and immediately thought of some similar experiences in Churchill with the polar bears, using my 5DsR and the 1-400 v2 and 1.4xIII - some were fine but some inexplicably soft - not just focused in the wrong plane as if AF had got it wrong but no real plane was in focus. The sharpest plane was soft compared to others from the same gear at similar distances on other occasions. I wondered about atmospheric issues - cold haze rather than heat haze - and the distances were long enough for refractive effects to contribute. Glad to hear others think that might be a reasonable explanation - I've not seen it since. Otherwise it's like the rattle in your car that doesn't show up when you take to the repair shop and returns when you drive home
Mar 05, 2017 at 01:47 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
I just wonder how disconnecting and reconnecting the lens fixes atmospheric conditions...
Mar 05, 2017 at 02:45 PM
technic
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
alundeb wrote:
I just wonder how disconnecting and reconnecting the lens fixes atmospheric conditions...


Good point, but I wonder if this observation from the OP was reproducible (instead of just blind chance).

Atmospheric disturbance can be very erratic, maybe the problem temporarily disappears after disconnecting and reconnecting ...
Mar 05, 2017 at 03:03 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
Of course if it is atmospheric disconnection and reconnecting won't do anything. But I just wonder as technic mentioned how reliable that is working for the OP. Has reconnecting fixed it every time? Could it be a mix of issues? Different days, different problems? Somedays my 7D2 had issues due to air turbulence other days it was a connection issue that I solved just like the OP describes.

There could also be the situation where the disconnect/reconnect isn't actually solving it but the air turbulence is changing. Even when their is air turbulence, it goes in and out and you can have perfect focus and terrible focus all within a 1 second burst.

Anyways all we can do is wait for the OP to return and add maybe a bit more info about shooting conditions and how reliable the fix was.

All I can say is this is not a known issue with the 400/2x
Mar 05, 2017 at 04:57 PM
BPDsas67
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
This couldn't be more timely!.. I was going to post a similar question regarding the 2xTCiii paired with 500mmii and the 5dmkiv. I recently purchased the 2xTC a couple of months ago and was pleasantly surprised how well it performed with minimal fall off in sharpness. I was loving this combo up until yesterday and this morning while attempting to shoot Hooded Mergansers at a local pond. Last week I used this combo and almost every shot was on the money... yesterday morning and this morning it is the opposite. Almost every shot is way soft. I tested this combo in backyard this afternoon and checked MA (+2) . Everything looked great. The only difference between using this combo up until the last couple days is that it is significantly colder... great light... but COLD! I was also thinking maybe the highly reflective whites on the Mergs was throwing it off... but had similar results with a GBH and Hawk that showed up at the pond this morning. Sounds like some of the responses to the post could be the issue.. although I have never had any issue with 1.4tc that lives on the 500mm. Any comments - help would be appreciated.
Mar 05, 2017 at 05:32 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
BPDsas67 wrote:
This couldn't be more timely!.. I was going to post a similar question regarding the 2xTCiii paired with 500mmii and the 5dmkiv. I recently purchased the 2xTC a couple of months ago and was pleasantly surprised how well it performed with minimal fall off in sharpness. I was loving this combo up until yesterday and this morning while attempting to shoot Hooded Mergansers at a local pond. Last week I used this combo and almost every shot was on the money... yesterday morning and this morning it is the opposite. Almost every shot is way soft. I tested this combo
...Show more →

Cold air and warming water will give air turbulence. I know I and others often jump on this for the reason very quickly but it is because I have a lot of experience with it in not only warm environments but cold environments also (a lot of times this winter). All you need is a difference in water/ground and air right above it. Assuming you were shooting fairly low over the water at the ducks and the air was colder than normal it could easily have been this type of issue. If you've had good results before and it was okay back home then I'd be very confident that it was an atmospheric issue. These type of issues are magnified with longer lenses compressing more air and the fact you are often trying to shoot over longer distances and there is more air in the way. If you are out and see this again on the rear LCD try shooting a few in LV...if those are off also then it is atmosphere. Also LV zoomed into 10x will often show the turbulence and you can watch focus go in and out on the subject.

Also see my recent thread where atmosphere or cold temps or both were throwing my focus way off where I needed +20 AFMA in the early hours and that went back to +5 to +10 later in the day as temps changed. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1474075/0?keyword=afma#13909638
Mar 05, 2017 at 05:44 PM
krautland
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
First of all thank you very much to everyone for the replies. It's great to wake up in the morning and find so much useful information. A lot of questions have been asked and I will try to answer what I can. If I miss anything please let me know.

jcolwell wrote:
Maybe you have "focus search" turned off (lens drive when AF impossible)


Hm. I must check that. I generally operate on Mode 1 AF with either Single Shot or Servo. I realize the 400 has a PF mode but I don't use that since when I shoot motion I usually manually focus. I personally find the manual for the 400 to be near useless and not much more than a leaflet. How did you cope?

arbitrage wrote:
That example is most likely atmospherics.


I think you are on the money, now that I think of it after reading this whole thread. This particular image was taken from one side of a river across the water to the other side of the river. It was around -5C but the river was only half frozen and I could see the moving water being at higher temperatures. The train was off and not idling but I could still see it also being at a different temperature.

However: I am familiar with the usually strong atmospheric disturbances seen at airports around jet turbines, especially at this focal length. I can observe those easily on scene and I was unable to see any such things there. This was a crystal clear, quiet, sunny day.

molson wrote:
Based on the photo above, I would suspect North Korean hackers have infiltrated your camera's firmware...


Ha! There are some that would call me the infiltrator. I shoot a lot in North Korea. (This was taken from China though. No way to get that lens into NK.)

AJSJones wrote:
I saw the title and noticed the snow in the (huge!) picture and immediately thought of some similar experiences in Churchill with the polar bears, using my 5DsR and the 1-400 v2 and 1.4xIII - some were fine but some inexplicably soft - not just focused in the wrong plane as if AF had got it wrong but no real plane was in focus. The sharpest plane was soft compared to others from the same gear at similar distances on other occasions. I wondered about atmospheric issues - cold haze rather than heat haze - and the distances were
...Show more →

Yeah, I didn't want to make it even smaller because I feared you guys wouldn't be able to see what I meant. My impression is that you, too are on the money with haze and atmospherics and that we are experiencing the same issue.

technic wrote:
I wonder if this observation from the OP was reproducible (instead of just blind chance).


arbitrage wrote:
I just wonder as technic mentioned how reliable that is working for the OP. Has reconnecting fixed it every time? Could it be a mix of issues? Different days, different problems? Somedays my 7D2 had issues due to air turbulence other days it was a connection issue that I solved just like the OP describes.


Totally blind chance. I feel completely unsure if disconnecting and reconnecting made a difference, it's just something I did a few times. It worked enough to make me think this could be it. This whole problem doesn't appear a lot. I did read another comment here saying the 7D in particular was finicky when it comes to the connection sequence, which I also read in my manual I believe, and I must admit I have been less than disciplined in how I would connect and disconnect camera, TC and lens. I operate this combo in very fast-paced environments with constant interruptions from police, border guards and soldiers, both Chinese and North Korean, so often proper procedure goes out of the window in favor of getting the shot before the chance is irrevocably gone. People can be very touchy in this area when it comes to photography.

One thing that I can say for certain is that I never have issues using the 400 with the 1DX2 without the TC.
Mar 05, 2017 at 09:30 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
As per the air turbulence, in my experience in cold weather is you can't see it with the naked eye like you can heat shimmer over hot pavement or your example at the airport. If you zoom in with LV then you may see some of it but it will look like focus is drifting in and out.

Try testing the 400/2x combo in a more controlled environment, maybe inside or just out in a park mid-day. For sure give it some more tries before writing it off totally.

As I mentioned before, with my 1DX and 1DX2 and my 5 series cameras I've never paid attention to how I connect lens or TC first and usually I leave the camera on all the time. Only on my 7D2 did I find issue and others reported issues on that camera. So I think it is unlikely that it is the sequence of TC attachment that is the issue in this case.
Mar 05, 2017 at 09:37 PM
krautland
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
arbitrage wrote:
Try testing the 400/2x combo in a more controlled environment, maybe inside or just out in a park mid-day. For sure give it some more tries before writing it off totally.


Yes, I will do that. I also just read your AFMA post and will try that out. Some of your test shots look familiar to me in terms of focussing issues. I always chalked that up to subjects moving, wires or similar details and got quite good at checking and adapting where I focus at extreme distances but I always thought it was me who just didn't get it right the first time, not something external. It's really quite a relief to read your post outlining similar issues, makes me feel like I am closer to where I should be.
Mar 05, 2017 at 09:43 PM
technic
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Intermittent Soft focus issue with 2x III converter?
arbitrage wrote:
As per the air turbulence, in my experience in cold weather is you can't see it with the naked eye like you can heat shimmer over hot pavement or your example at the airport. If you zoom in with LV then you may see some of it but it will look like focus is drifting in and out.


Yes, that's what I am seeing as well. I can only see it in the viewfinder when heat shimmer is involved, like shooting into the setting sun or something similar. In that case, straight lines in the subject will often become 'wavy', in my area even a 200mm shot will sometimes show this effect in such conditions. In colder conditions it is more like focus drifting in and out and the 'distortions' in the subject are much smaller; I had not noticed it before with my 200mm but with the 400 it is very obvious especially with 10x Liveview.

I see a related effect when shooting the sun behind a church tower close to my home, similar to the shot below (don't have the recent shot online). I use MF for these shots, prefocusing in Liveview while the sun is hidden. When the sun appears through small openings in the tower or on the sides, the areas in the image that are close to the sun sometimes get very soft with distortions that look a bit like CA, as if focus was wrong. But the rest of the building (bottom and top) in the image remains perfectly sharp. Probably also some kind of 'air lens' effect.

2016_IMG_5630 by Niek Haak, on Flickr
Mar 06, 2017 at 02:52 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister