fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...

arbitrage
Offline

p.1 #1AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
So yesterday I went for a hike to see the eagle nest. I brought along my 600II and 5D4 and 1DX2. My goal was to see if the 5D4 was performing okay on the 600 and the 600 with the TCs. I usually don't do AFMA but I do do it at the eagle nest as I use a tripod and a fixed distance.

I started the test with the 5D4 and bare 600. Results were a blurry mess. This was odd and first thing I think of is atmosphere conditions and cold weather...shooting across a valley to the nest and it being -21C outside. So my next shot is always with LV to see if it is atmosphere....if LV is good then it isn't atmosphere directly and if LV is just as blurry then it is atmosphere.

2nd shot below is LV....looks damn good. Oh, oh....this is not right....the bare 600 has never required AFMA on any of my other bodies...only once adding the 2xTC have I seen a big enough change to warrant AFMA. So now I try the extremes of the AFMA range and start at +20.....tack sharp....Oh, oh....that isn't good at all!!

I next try -10 and that is worse than 0 so we know we have something seriously wrong with the AF in these conditions.

+20 was best and closest to the LV shot. And nice and sharp.

I then went and did some testing on 840mm and 1200mm....1200mm was a bit of a mess no matter what...LV...any AFMA so that did tell me the atmosphere was doing something. 840 was great at 0 AFMA...go figure.

So then 45mins later I tried the bare 600mm again. Shot 5 is LV....shot 6 is 0 and shot 7 is 20. Now the 0 and 20 are very close to LV but I can see the focus plane being moved back and forth but the eagle maintained good sharpness. As another 15-20mins past the ideal AFMA was between 0 and +10 but it was so close that in a burst of shots there were some that were best at 0 and others at +10. This is more normal for me in that the normal AF variations do more than a 10 point difference on an AFMA scale.

In the end the 5D4 and 600 started performing normal again and required little to no AFMA.

My subjective conclusion: There was atmosphere and cold temps involved and I think in this case the atmosphere wasn't totally ruining shots with turbulent air but was affecting the normal AF. As the atmosphere settled over the next hour, the AF started working normally again....if I'd left AFMA at +20 it would have been out by the time things settled. Remember, I went to the nest just at sunrise so the air/ground temp mix was changing as I was there. The fact that 1200mm never gave good results showed me that atmosphere was affecting things with higher focal lengths. This was true on the 1DX2 and the EOS M5 all in LV also.

Final thoughts....AFMA is best less to real field conditions where you can re-evaluate it over time and you need a fixed tripod and fixed distance to subject to even have a chance of working it out. For the first hour I would have used +20 or LV to get good shots. An hour later I was at 0-10 with little difference to get the best shots. +20 was starting to soften and push the DOF way behind the eagle with the eagle just maintaining good sharpness but not as good as 0-10.





0...and this was the best of many....most were worse than this







LV







+20







-10







LV about 45mins later



Edited on Feb 06, 2017 at 10:43 AM · View previous versions
Feb 06, 2017 at 09:16 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #2AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
The last images....





AFMA 0







+20







+10

Feb 06, 2017 at 09:17 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.1 #3AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Perhaps your lens and camera just needed to reach a constant stable temperature before the AF was consistent?
Feb 06, 2017 at 09:23 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #4AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
molson wrote:
Perhaps your lens and camera just needed to reach a constant stable temperature before the AF was consistent?


Yes it could have been the internals also. But I did do some tests with Servo vs One Shot and the One Shot ones tested better....so I think AF was being affected but that still could be from lens/body temps or from air quality.

I had to hike 20mins to get to the nest and the temps never rose during my time there but the sun came out and started to add some changes to the ground temps I would assume.

Also the fact that 1200mm couldn't produce a useable shot even in LV and even 45mins later told me that something was still funky in the air. I have tack sharp shots at 1200mm from that same location with a bunch of bodies but those were in May-Sept....not at =20C.
Feb 06, 2017 at 09:37 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.1 #5AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
arbitrage wrote:
molson wrotePerhaps your lens and camera just needed to reach a constant stable temperature before the AF was consistent?
Yes it could have been the internals also. But I did do some tests with Servo vs One Shot and the One Shot ones tested better....so I think AF was being affected but that still could be from lens/body temps or from air quality.

I had to hike 20mins to get to the nest and the temps never rose during my time there but the sun came out and started to add some changes to the ground temps I would assume.

Also the fact that 1200mm couldn't produce a useable shot even in LV and even 45mins later told me that something
...Show more →

I image even a tiny bit of condensation of the AF sensor would also create problems, that would gradually go away as the temperature stabilized, and would also not affect LV focusing. For example, if you mounted the lens on the camera at home, or in a warm car, and trapped some warm humid air inside the camera.
Feb 06, 2017 at 09:45 AM
therealthings
Offline
Details
p.1 #6AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
That is why on static shots like this i only use LV and 10x zoom to be sure i have critical focus. BTW, all the 1dxII copies i had so far (4x) required a -2 MFA on all lenses. And my 70-200 required a -7 on 3 exept 1 copy. All done in controlled environment.
Feb 06, 2017 at 10:17 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.1 #7AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Ironically Canon has a patent related to using contrast-detect AF to automatically perform AFMA of its PDAF system. The patent is similar to what Nikon implemented on the D5/D500 but Canon's implementation has the potential to be much better due to their dual-pixel AF system, which would allow them to do it faster and even continuously if they wanted. I suppose the entire thing will be moot once Canon switches to full-time dual-pixel AF on all their bodies.
Feb 06, 2017 at 10:25 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.1 #8AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
arbitrage wrote:
-20 was best and closest to the LV shot. And nice and sharp.



Might want to correct that line. I was scratching my head on that one until I realized it was just a typo.

Of the final shots, other than the LV shot I see very little difference between the +10 & +20 but the 0 shot looks a little soft.

I'm curious as to what was the real cause of this was. Temp (internal & external) is the most likely culprit, but it would be interesting to know for certain. Hope you find out.

Dave
Feb 06, 2017 at 10:26 AM
OntheRez
Offline
Details
p.1 #9AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
I've never shot in the extremes of cold you were working with, but have noticed somewhat similar - though not as extreme - with high heat: running from 80 to 105 as one example. Clearly the air is changing thus it is effecting how light is being refracted. As you've noted, I'd never attempt to micro-focus in the field. One simply has to shoot thru the temp changes picking whatever works best.

Also many may not be aware, but in the desert the reverse also happens. I've seen a 30° temp drop in 45 minutes as sundown approaches. Contrary to popular opinion it does get cold in the desert - at least relative to it's highest temps.

Robert
Feb 06, 2017 at 10:36 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #10AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
lighthound wrote:
arbitrage wrote-20 was best and closest to the LV shot. And nice and sharp.
Might want to correct that line. I was scratching my head on that one until I realized it was just a typo.

Of the final shots, other than the LV shot I see very little difference between the +10 & +20 but the 0 shot looks a little soft.

I'm curious as to what was the real cause of this was. Temp (internal & external) is the most likely culprit, but it would be interesting to know for certain. Hope you find out.

Dave


Thanks corrected...yest that did confuse things a lot!!

I left it at +10 for now but will re-evaluate in warmer climate if that every occurs
Feb 06, 2017 at 10:44 AM
Umeflippen
Offline
Details
p.1 #11AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
I can confirm that my 300 f/2.8 is II behaves the same way in -20 °C or below.
Feb 06, 2017 at 02:42 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #12AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Umeflippen wrote:
I can confirm that my 300 f/2.8 is II behaves the same way in -20 °C or below.


Thanks, good to know. I've had issues earlier this year with 1DX2 and the 600II in about -20C where I had to get really close to my subject before AF would work properly. But that time seemed like a distance thing...probably shooting through the cold air at too far a distance throws the AF off. Maybe it is something in the lens or camera also.
Feb 06, 2017 at 03:00 PM
schlotz
Offline
Details
p.1 #13AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Hmm... 20 min hike-in at -20ºC with serious gear/weight and attempting AFMA appears to be extremely challenging if not almost impossible given the changes described. I admire your determination Geoff. Doing it in warmer weather at least sounds more comfortable but at 1200mm across a valley, won't similar conditions still affect things?

Of course warm to you folks up there is anything north of +5ºC

Matt
Feb 07, 2017 at 08:37 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.1 #14AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
+5 is shorts, beer and BBQ weather for us.
Feb 07, 2017 at 08:49 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #15AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
schlotz wrote:
Hmm... 20 min hike-in at -20ºC with serious gear/weight and attempting AFMA appears to be extremely challenging if not almost impossible given the changes described. I admire your determination Geoff. Doing it in warmer weather at least sounds more comfortable but at 1200mm across a valley, won't similar conditions still affect things?

Of course warm to you folks up there is anything north of +5ºC

Matt


If I don't get outside I go crazy so I manage!! I already go crazy waking up at 6AM and having to wait till 10AM to have the sun get above the mountains. Oh well in a few months the sun won't even set!!

Even in warmer temps depending on air/ground differences I can get atmospheric issues on any day of any season. But at least at the nest I have my tripod (probably the only place I ever use a tripod) and can take a few minutes to dial in big lenses. When the conditions are right 1200mm is effective....see below









Feb 07, 2017 at 08:53 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #16AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Compare the above to the best the 1200mm could manage on Sunday and this was LV taking all the AF out of it....




Feb 07, 2017 at 08:57 AM
schlotz
Offline
Details
p.1 #17AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Stunning
Feb 07, 2017 at 09:01 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.1 #18AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
arbitrage wrote:
Compare the above to the best the 1200mm could manage on Sunday and this was LV taking all the AF out of it....




This would be driving me nuts if I were in your shoes. That 5DSR shot is crazy nice. It looks like you had slightly stronger light than you have in your 5DIV shots but I wouldn't think that would be enough to cause this and your ISO isn't that far off from the 5DSR shot.

Have you had success like that with your 5DIV with the same lens or has it been too cold since you got it to verify?

I don't understand how or why cold temps could effect focus while using LV.
You had IS turned off right? My thinking there was maybe the viscosity of the lubricant for the IS might be thickened by the cold temps. I know nothing about how the internals actually work so I'm just spit balling here.

If it were condensation on the sensor, would using the hand warmer trick eliminate that from happening?

Dave

Feb 07, 2017 at 12:06 PM
Ruffo
Offline
Details
p.1 #19AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Was it windy or calm? Judging from the photos, it looked calm at your subject but if you were shooting across a gap, sometimes there is an updraft from the cooler shaded floor up to the sunlit higher elevation that can be as bad as a heat mirage. (Superior Mirage or inversion)

I hope you are able to pinpoint whether this effect was environmental or if it was a product of the newer version lens or camera bodies. Perhaps manual focus under live view would reveal if the AF is being tricked or if the mechanics are being influenced by temperature.

For reference, I have spent quite a lot of time photographing in -20°F to -40°F with the 500f/4 IS, 600f/4 IS, 1.4x II, 1D2, 1D3, 1D4 and have never seen this effect on AF. If anything, the colder temperatures seemed to produce images that were more crisp do to the absence of heat mirage.


Feb 07, 2017 at 12:09 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #20AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
lighthound wrote:
arbitrage wroteCompare the above to the best the 1200mm could manage on Sunday and this was LV taking all the AF out of it....
This would be driving me nuts if I were in your shoes. That 5DSR shot is crazy nice. It looks like you had slightly stronger light than you have in your 5DIV shots but I wouldn't think that would be enough to cause this and your ISO isn't that far off from the 5DSR shot.

Have you had success like that with your 5DIV with the same lens or has it been too cold since you got it to verify?

I don't understand how or why cold temps could effect focus while using LV.
You had IS turned off right? My
...Show more →

It is most likely atmosphere temp difference between the nest in sun and the valley in shade. The sun had just risen and was on the nest. The valley I shoot across....not a huge valley, actually just down a hillside as the nest tree is halfway down the embankment but it is shaded most of the time from southern trees.

Sometimes "dirty" air causes LV to not even get a sharp shot if the air is really turbulent. In this case it seemed that LV was fine at 600 and 840 but at 1200 there was too much "dirty" air compressed in front of the lens (if that makes any sense?) and it gave a softer image even in LV. I tried with 5D4, 1DX2 and M5 all in LV and all had trouble with 1200mm but the 1DX2 did best.

I was using IS as my tripod head isn't tight when I shoot here. I took multiple frames at each MFA value and used long lens technique which I'm good at. I handhold 1200mm all the time with sharp results. Canon MkII lenses only need IS off at low SS on a locked down tripod head with remote trigger....even then they are supposed to detect that scenario and compensate. For this type of situation IS only helps as I never lock down a supertele as it still vibrates even using timers (you can see this in LV at 10x mag very easily).
Feb 07, 2017 at 01:22 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell

You are not logged inLog inRegister