p.6 #1Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
I wasn't saying it was a definitive source, nor was I trying to say it's a clone. Actually doesn't look far off when you see the lens mounted, looks bigger than in the stand alone lens shots.
As to what product they were referencing, they talk about the 35/1.4 being a re-housing as well on a seperate slide, they were definitely referencing the 40 here.
I know at least one poster here was going to be at CP+, maybe they can inquire and give us (me?) some closure. All that aside the one RAW I've seen draws an awfully lot like the 35/1.2, regardless the lens design.
Makten wrote: Mathieu18 wrotePer DPReveiw's hands on (I'm assuming they talked to Cosina reps): "The fastest 40mm ever made for full frame (in case you've been waiting for one) the 40mm Nokton is based on an older VM (Leica M) mount lens, but has been 'optimized' for Sony E mount."Most likely a typo and they meant that the 35 Nokton is based on an older VM lens.
Edit: Or it's the 35/1.2, but it doesn't make sense since the 40 is shorter.
p.6 #2Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
Mathieu18 wrote:
I wasn't saying it was a definitive source, nor was I trying to say it's a clone. Actually doesn't look far off when you see the lens mounted, looks bigger than in the stand alone lens shots.
As to what product they were referencing, they talk about the 35/1.4 being a re-housing as well on a seperate slide, they were definitely referencing the 40 here.
I know at least one poster here was going to be at CP+, maybe they can inquire and give us (me?) some closure. All that aside the one RAW I've seen draws an awfully lot like the 35/1.2, regardless the lens design. ...Show more →
Yes, but it could also be the 35/1.2 that is "tweaked" so much that it's not really the same lens anymore, even if the basic design is very similar. I think I remember the 35 to be a bit narrower than many other 35:s, so it's not impossible that even the FL is the same.
And you might be right about the length and size as well. The lens is obviously larger than it looks on its own.
However, with such a large exit pupil, the bokeh could be affected by the sensor stack, so it's possible that it will draw differently on the Sony cameras even if they just changed minor things to adapt it better to the new environment.
I guess there will be plenty of sample images soon, and then we'll find out.
p.6 #3Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
I asked Barney about that and he said it was only from the super bad translation of the press release (the one we have all seen) and that he's not at all sure it's right. And my reading of the press release is tha the 35 only is a mod of a previous design for FE.
Anyhow, we'll likely know for sure before handing over our money!
Mathieu18 wrote:
Per DPReveiw's hands on (I'm assuming they talked to Cosina reps): "The fastest 40mm ever made for full frame (in case you've been waiting for one) the 40mm Nokton is based on an older VM (Leica M) mount lens, but has been 'optimized' for Sony E mount."
DavidBM wroteartur5 wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteazenis wroteI just wish them to make them in M mount. After getting used to TAP, there's no going back. In the case of the CV 10/5.6 and 12/5.6 III E-mount lenses, there were options for the M-mount as well. It's not unreasonable to think that Voigtlander would be consistent here.Maybe, Fred, but with slower lenses like those wides I'd guess it would easier to design a 'compromise' that works ok on both filter stacks, but with these fast lenses they would really need to make some optical changes between the two versions.Possibly you’re right, but I have my doubts. I think that a fast 35 or 40mm lens is still a bit friendlier to different sensor stacks than those ultrawides, which are quite challenging because of the steep ray angles, even if they’re slow and more retrofocus than classical RF designs. Therefore, I wouldn’t be surprised at all if Cosina designed the new lenses optimized for a sensor stack in-between Sony and Leica thickness and release E and M versions which share the same optics, as they seem to have done with the latest Heliar 15/4.5.
I’d like to be wrong because a lens designed to be compatible for Leica and Sony sensors at the same time will be always a compromise. Let’s wait and see.I agree it's wait and see; and I too hope that these models aren't compromises. Ultrawides are indeed more sensitive; but so are faster lenses. The 40 is *very* fast, and the wides were *very* slow, which is why I thought speed might trump AOV on balance in these cases. One other piece of evidence: the way CV talk about the 35 suggests it really is reformulated specifically for Sony compared with the M version. If that's right, it might be that the 40 is truly optimized rather than a compromise.
p.6 #6Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
Makten wrote: Mathieu18 wrotePer DPReveiw's hands on (I'm assuming they talked to Cosina reps): "The fastest 40mm ever made for full frame (in case you've been waiting for one) the 40mm Nokton is based on an older VM (Leica M) mount lens, but has been 'optimized' for Sony E mount."Edit: Or it's the 35/1.2, but it doesn't make sense since the 40 is shorter.
My guess, based on the bokeh in the wide open sample, is that it is based on the 35/1.2.
I've got a Voigtlander 40/1.4 and the 35/1.2. The 35/1.4 is a modified 40/1.4, and if you look around the web you'll see that it has similar bright edges to the bokeh balls, while the 35/1.2 has onion ring bokeh. The 35/1.2 has pretty good wide open sharpness, but suffers from onion ring bokeh - which seems to match what we're seeing and being promised.
p.6 #7Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
Mathieu18 wrote:
I wasn't saying it was a definitive source, nor was I trying to say it's a clone. Actually doesn't look far off when you see the lens mounted, looks bigger than in the stand alone lens shots.
As to what product they were referencing, they talk about the 35/1.4 being a re-housing as well on a seperate slide, they were definitely referencing the 40 here.
I know at least one poster here was going to be at CP+, maybe they can inquire and give us (me?) some closure. All that aside the one RAW I've seen draws an awfully lot like the 35/1.2, regardless the lens design.
...Show more →Makten wroteMathieu18 wrotePer DPReveiw's hands on (I'm assuming they talked to Cosina reps): "The fastest 40mm ever made for full frame (in case you've been waiting for one) the 40mm Nokton is based on an older VM (Leica M) mount lens, but has been 'optimized' for Sony E mount."Most likely a typo and they meant that the 35 Nokton is based on an older VM lens.
Edit: Or it's the 35/1.2, but it doesn't make sense since the 40 is shorter.
I'm heading to CP+ from now, will chat with Cosina staff there and ask whether the 40/1.2 is an entirely new design or based on 35/1.2 Nokton. Hopefully those demo units are also available for hands on trials... It may be pretty crowded there today.
p.6 #8Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
sychan wrote: Makten wroteMathieu18 wrotePer DPReveiw's hands on (I'm assuming they talked to Cosina reps): "The fastest 40mm ever made for full frame (in case you've been waiting for one) the 40mm Nokton is based on an older VM (Leica M) mount lens, but has been 'optimized' for Sony E mount."Edit: Or it's the 35/1.2, but it doesn't make sense since the 40 is shorter.My guess, based on the bokeh in the wide open sample, is that it is based on the 35/1.2.
I've got a Voigtlander 40/1.4 and the 35/1.2. The 35/1.4 is a modified 40/1.4, and if you look around the web you'll see that it has similar bright edges to the bokeh balls, while the 35/1.2 has onion ring bokeh. The 35/1.2 has pretty good wide open sharpness, but suffers from onion ring bokeh - which seems to match what we're seeing and being promised.
Onion ring bokeh can be expected just from the fact that it's an aspherical design - which we know from the name. It's unclear if Cosina has access to the super smooth aspherical mouldings (Sony) or polishing ((Panny) that mitigate the onion rings.
p.6 #9Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
Spoke with 2 Cosina guys at the Voigtländer counter at CP+ and they said the 40/1.2 has no relation at all to the 35/1.2 M design and that it's a completely new design. It's not really smaller than 35/1.2 (could be slightly shorter but its' diameter is larger), but at least the demo version is considerably lighter. We compared the weights side by side (to 35/1.2 v2 without any adapters) and the 40/1.2 demo version felt about 100g lighter. They couldn't say anything about the official weight or release date or price. I managed to take some trial shots with both the 40mm and 65mm at the counter, not much targets to shoot there though... Still at CP+.
p.6 #10Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Spoke with 2 Cosina guys at the Voigtländer counter at CP+ and they said the 40/1.2 has no relation at all to the 35/1.2 M design and that it's a completely new design. It's not really smaller than 35/1.2 (could be slightly shorter but its' diameter is larger), but at least the demo version is considerably lighter. We compared the weights side by side (to 35/1.2 v2 without any adapters) and the 40/1.2 demo version felt about 100g lighter. They couldn't say anything about the official weight or release date or price. I managed to take some trial shots with both the 40mm and 65mm at the counter, not much targets to shoot there though... Still at CP+....Show more →
Good news Juha!
Gosh at 100g lighter than the old 1.2/35 and my favourite normal fl, if it's a new design as good as the 1,7/35 stopped down and usable wide open it could be my new favourite standard. My only fear is that it's a bit too small to be great for an f1.2!
p.6 #11Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
D.C. Watch Impress, one of the premier Japanese photo news sites, had a hands on with the new CV lenses. The APO Lanthar and 1.2/40 are close to ready and will sell in Japan for under about US 1300 each. The 1.4/35 classic is further away, but will be quite a bit cheaper. Here's a google translation of what they say about the 40
"Large aperture lens excellent in portability, based on the concept of "compact and high performance". We also adopt aspheric lenses, aiming at modern high performance lenses. As well as Macro Apolanter 65 mm, we aim to sell this year under 150,000 yen"
9099 f1.2 very close
9105 f1.2 close
9110 f1.2 very close
9111 f2.8 very close
9985 f1.2 close
9989 f1.2 close
9994 f1.2 close
0009 f4 infinity
0013 f8 infinity
0018 f2.8 infinity
0022 f4 infinity
0026 f2 close
0028 f1.2 close
0030 f1.4 close
0031 f2 close
0036 f2 close
0046 f1.2 close
I really liked the lens based on this demo, very nice size & weight, great handling, infinity was spot on on this demo lens (I like it when hard infinity gives the best sharpness at "infinity" and there's no need to pull back). Great sunstars as usual with Voigtländer. I also think it's plenty sharp from wide open at the focused point. I also think there's not much field curvature, at least much less than with Ultron 35/1.7. I'm certainly going to buy this 40mm when they release it.
p.6 #15Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
GMPhotography wrote:
Curious about the 65 if you tried it at the show
I tried it only rather briefly, and not so seriously as I was much more keen on 40mm since it would work nicely for me as a daily walkaround lens and I have less personal need for the 65mm macro (I already have the FE 90/2.8 macro and I don't shoot macro that much). In any case the 65mm seemed also like a fine lens with great build and handling and IQ seemed to be excellent based on very brief sampling. It extends quite a lot when focusing close. I was thinking about it also for general use (especially before the 40mm got announced) but if they are both going to be somewhere around 125 to 150K yen, I'll most likely just get the 40mm as it fits my needs much better.
I have a few demo counter snapshots taken with it also, will put them in Google Drive on Sunday morning Japan time as it's running late here now...
p.6 #17Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I really liked the lens based on this demo, very nice size & weight, great handling, infinity was spot on on this demo lens (I like it when hard infinity gives the best sharpness at "infinity" and there's no need to pull back). Great sunstars as usual with Voigtländer. I also think it's plenty sharp from wide open at the focused point. I also think there's not much field curvature, at least much less than with Ultron 35/1.7. I'm certainly going to buy this 40mm when they release it.
p.6 #19Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
I copied some samples taken at the Cosina Voigtländer CP+ counter area with my A7II + 65mm here, original RAW + JPEG. All were at f2 except 9127 that was at F5.6.
p.6 #20Voigtlander E-mount 35mm 1.4, 40mm 1.2, 65mm f2 in Development
Hey Juha - Thank you for all the 40/1.2 images!
Exif, distance reporting and such is nice to have. The image quality, judging by the samples is pretty good. Good enough? Maybe. In my opinion they should have made the lens a little slower focusing more on micro-contrast and chromatic aberrations than on speed. Perhaps the f/1.2 is about bragging rights and a high price tag?