fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...

  
 
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #1AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Ruffo wrote:
Was it windy or calm? Judging from the photos, it looked calm at your subject but if you were shooting across a gap, sometimes there is an updraft from the cooler shaded floor up to the sunlit higher elevation that can be as bad as a heat mirage. (Superior Mirage or inversion)

I hope you are able to pinpoint whether this effect was environmental or if it was a product of the newer version lens or camera bodies. Perhaps manual focus under live view would reveal if the AF is being tricked or if the mechanics are being influenced by temperature.

For
...Show more →

No wind at all and the nest is sheltered from our usually South wind as the embankment wraps around to the south of the nest. Still that day was calm....thank goodness as it was already -20 or worse without wind. As I noted in my above reply, the nest was in sun and valley/embankment in shade...likely different air temps.

I have a lot of freezing cold shots also. Usually all is fine. Twice this year I've had these issues. Once shooting Hawk Owls with 1DX2 and 600/1.4 at 840. But same place on another day was fine with same equipment. That time I had to get really close to the owl and then AF worked for a sharp shot.

In the end I'm not worried, will all work out when air/ground temps are more even. Likely that same day in the afternoon would have been fine as it was already getting way better after the first hour. 1200mm was the only remaining issue. This was the first time I had 600 on 5D4 but 1DX2 wasn't much better and I've shot that a bunch at 1200mm
Feb 07, 2017 at 01:27 PM
tiggy
Offline
Details
p.2 #2AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Question, Arbitrage: did you try the 1dx2 at the same time. Did it suffer no effects in the same conditions? You mentioned that you brought both cameras, but I didn't see that you checked the alternate body.
Feb 07, 2017 at 01:53 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #3AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
tiggy wrote:
Question, Arbitrage: did you try the 1dx2 at the same time. Did it suffer no effects in the same conditions? You mentioned that you brought both cameras, but I didn't see that you checked the alternate body.


The 1DX2 was a little better with not needing any extreme AFMA but it still couldn't get me a sharp shot with the 1200mm lens on.

I should add to all of this that I also tested a target up on the hill so not shooting across any valley and not as far away. There the cameras did fine, even at 1200mm. The 5D4 was good with 600mm without any AFMA when not shooting across the valley minutes after it was needing +20 across the valley to the nest. It took a good 45mins till it was better across the valley again and then it still was better at +10 as seen in the OP but it was doing fairly good at 0. Just depends where you wanted the DOF to be...the eagle was sharp for the most part from 0 to +20.

This all comes back to comments I've made recently telling people to stop wasting time with AFMA for every new lens body they get. If you can demonstrate a consistent focus plane issue which is always in the same direction than try AFMA. But for long lens wildlife shooters there are way too many other variables including the basic AF system that will cause variance in focus shifts to more of a degree than AFMA can adjust for. Just like above when things settled down, 0 through +20 all gave an acceptable shot.

And even if +10 was the best when I left the area, I would bet that next time 0 will be all I need. We shall see. But for when I go out next somewhere else I will reset 5D4/600 back to 0 as that will be hand-holding where I find AFMA makes no difference because of all the other variable going on.

This is just how I view AFMA, I stopped doing it routinely (I used to use Focal for every new gear) about 1.5 years ago and have had no issues with not doing it. The only time I still do it is at the eagle nest because I can really control it.

AFMA is said to change with distance to subject, temperature and time (with the lens being knocked about with use). With all those things affecting it and changing day to day it is usually a huge waste of time to even do it.
Feb 07, 2017 at 02:04 PM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.2 #4AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
I have never been a big fan of MFA, I'm defiantly in the minority on that one and I often paid for saying it. My first body that had it was the 50D. That was better than sliced bread. We all started to download angled paper targets. Now the distance issue came in. What is the optimal distance?

Chuck Westfall said in one article to MFA at 50X but if you can do better. If I can do better? I'm not the engineer that designed this. You put MFA into the camera you tell me the best procedure. We all know or should know the manual says for best results MFA at location. We all say read the manual but ignore the warnings about MFA which include it is not normally necessary and my prevent accurate AF from being achieved.

I bookmarked Canon articles and procedures and some say at location and some say 50X. Then Lens Align came out and it recommended 25X. Another different suggested difference.

So over time this all started to turn me off. I knew I was not going to MFA at location. I found that most of my Canon bodies and lenses were very close and I understand about variation in manufacturing and a spec range. Rudy Winston said in another article you may not see a drastic change within -5 to +5.

Funny that -5 +5 was sort of my personal limit for Canon gear. All my gear was usually less and on the plus side. It was out it was really out and then it went to Canon. One example was my 70-200 2.8 II which needed +15 at 200mm. Turned out a broad was mis-calibrated.

Just to point out two Canon techs told me on two separate occasions that MFA was for emergencies only. I'm not going to send my lens in of it needs +4 but not going to correct for Canon's gross mis-calibration. I know others are perfectly fine with making that type of correction and I respect that. Personally I'll never accept that from Canon.

So this was just a progression over time and I shot 5 years with my 7D classic and 300L F4 IS with no MFA and can produce thousands of tack sharp images. My 5D's were fine as well.

I finally had to do it because of my 1.4 III. My 7D2 and 5D4 are about +2 to +4 between 100mm and 400mm for my 100-400 II but when the TC goes on then it needs +13 at 560mm. Since the cam and lens are OK I really have no choice. Although TC's work with zooms Roger Cicala from lens rentals says TC's are actually tuned for long primes. Maybe that is why it needs so much. A a small deviation in the lens that is still within spec may really exaggerate when you magnify it.

Dot Tune confirmed that it was out but could repeat it. My fault as I did it outdoors and some days were windy. I already had FoCal V1 which I used to confirm my 70-200 was out to lunch but never used it since. I upgraded to V2 to fine tune that combo. I'm still from the camp where I don't want to think. I want something to tell me what the final value is.

Just to show how consistent Canon is these days FoCal does not play nice with Mac Sierra and Canon. They are waiting for Canon to release the updated software libraries which is hopefully soon. In the meantime I entered my 5D3/7D2 values of +13 for the 100-400 II and 1.4 III for my 5D4 and it is tack sharp.

So that was my experience with MFA. When it first came out I loved it, then I really disliked it and then I had no choice but to use it. Currently I just make sure I at least use Focal's minimum suggested distance and I try to judge the distance I shoot on average which each lens and cam combo and MFA there.

I also purchased the hard target and two daylight balanced studio CFL's. The target is in a bright porch with the CFL's to give the target enough light.
Feb 08, 2017 at 08:55 AM
dgdg
Offline
Details
p.2 #5AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Thanks for the tips on atmospheric effects.
My bare 600mm and 100-400mm need no MFA.
However both my teleconverters cause a significant and noticeable shift in the depth of field. I've MFA'd several bodies, including a couple rentals over the years.
A simple MFA at the end of my driveway to the mailbox across the street works like a charm with much improved real world results. I have not noticed any focus plane issues with relatively longer distances.
Feb 08, 2017 at 09:20 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #6AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
dgdg wrote:
Thanks for the tips on atmospheric effects.
My bare 600mm and 100-400mm need no MFA.
However both my teleconverters cause a significant and noticeable shift in the depth of field. I've MFA'd several bodies, including a couple rentals over the years.
A simple MFA at the end of my driveway to the mailbox across the street works like a charm with much improved real world results. I have not noticed any focus plane issues with relatively longer distances.


When I was into doing MFA all the time, I found my big primes needed next to nothing until you started adding TCs and then I would get more into the +/- 10 area at most. Often 1.4TC needed next to nothing. If I do test and get +/-5 range I leave it at zero. If I get +/-10 I will retest on a few different occasions and if it is consistent then I will set the MFA to the value. But as I said before for the past 1.5 years or so I've just never bothered with AFMA. Last May during the first week the eagles were hatched I got the 5DSR in the mail. Went to the nest, mounted 1200mm on it and shot away....didn't even look at MFA and came home with tickity tack shots. Maybe I was lucky, maybe the distance to the nest gives me enough DOF in good atmospheric conditions anyways even with the reduced DOF of 1200mm.

The issue with MFA is it also changes with distance so it really is a lot of guess work and estimates. Also with Focal not being able to automate the process on newer Canon bodies I also believe there to be too much disruption to the images when you have to touch the camera for every MFA change....this is my same issue with DOT tune technique....that one is even worse....and I've proven that I can do Dottune 5 times in a row and get widely different values. Focal is more consistent but I wish it would be fully automated so you didn't disturb the camera at all during the testing.
Feb 08, 2017 at 09:45 AM
PV Hiker
Offline
Details
p.2 #7AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
-21c is 5 degrees f so not extremely cold. I question how the camera and lens was packed and carried from house to car to location. If the camera was at house room temp and packed well to maintain that temp and at location was then mounted on lens that had been exposed to cold temp?

Where I'm going with this is at location you mount the camera, the mirror is exposed to the cold, could be moist air when you mount the camera to lens. Same with the lens , you expose the filter element to the air. The camera could have been still heat soaked and exposing it to the air could have fogged up the mirror or could have changed the mounting distance tolerances to the sensor plane.

The auto focus uses the mirror to look through and sounds like something was going on with the clarity because you said in live view the image was sharp. Live view does not use the mirror to focus. It will take a long time for camera to equalize to the surrounding temp and the mirror is inside and is slow to change.

Maybe if you would have un-mounted the camera and had a look at the mirror condition it would have confirmed at the time. But it is all a guess after the fact.

Consider the different temp between camera, lens, extenders to outside air. there is slight changes to the stacked tolerances meeting at the film plane. It all takes time for the equipment to get soaked to the ambient temperature.

Just some other random thoughts....
Feb 08, 2017 at 10:07 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #8AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Gear was put in my Ajna backpack. No car involved. Hiked for 20mins to the nest.

The reason I think it was more likely atmosphere is that I first took a few shots handheld from an angle that would have been less over the valley before getting to my regular angle. Those shots with bare 600 on 5D4 were sharp. Only when I got to the other position did the issues start. I've shot in -36C this year starting within minutes of getting out of the car and had no issues but that was a different day and different location.

I will go out again today at -26C and see what happens.

PV Hiker wrote:
-21c is 5 degrees f so not extremely cold. I question how the camera and lens was packed and carried from house to car to location. If the camera was at house room temp and packed well to maintain that temp and at location was then mounted on lens that had been exposed to cold temp?

Where I'm going with this is at location you mount the camera, the mirror is exposed to the cold, could be moist air when you mount the camera to lens. Same with the lens , you expose the filter element to the air. The
...Show more →
Feb 08, 2017 at 10:21 AM
PV Hiker
Offline
Details
p.2 #9AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
Thanks for the follow up. It is just amazing just how many factors that are involved just in one capatured image.
Feb 08, 2017 at 10:47 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.2 #10AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
PV Hiker wrote:
Thanks for the follow up. It is just amazing just how many factors that are involved just in one capatured image.



Yes... and sometimes people are a little too quick to blame the equipment when there is a glitch in capturing the image.
Feb 08, 2017 at 11:43 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #11AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
UPDATE: Went back to the nest on Wednesday in very similar conditions...maybe 2-3 degrees C cooler but otherwise the same and same time of day.

Same behavior reared its head with lenses needing +10 to +20. This was more consistent with the 600, 600/1.4 and 600/2.0 all needing high positive AFMA shooting across to the nest. And it was similar on the 1DX that I brought along also this time. But the 1DX was better.

When I went down the hill, much closer to the nest the AFMA shifted back to 0 to +10 range at most and made little difference...this was at 600mm only that I tested but as I got closer the DOF would have decreased so one would expect AFMA to become more important but it acutally became less important. There are issues shooting across the larger distance (80-100ft) to the nest in these conditions.

Thankfully we are in for a warming trend up to -5C this weekend with clouds and maybe snow. I hope on Saturday to try the same in these different conditions and see what the results are.

Stay tuned!!
Feb 10, 2017 at 10:10 AM
canon.eos30d
Offline
Details
p.2 #12AFMA...field adjustments and a cautionary tale...
arbitrage wrote:
UPDATE: Went back to the nest on Wednesday in very similar conditions...maybe 2-3 degrees C cooler but otherwise the same and same time of day.

Same behavior reared its head with lenses needing +10 to +20. This was more consistent with the 600, 600/1.4 and 600/2.0 all needing high positive AFMA shooting across to the nest. And it was similar on the 1DX that I brought along also this time. But the 1DX was better.

When I went down the hill, much closer to the nest the AFMA shifted back to 0 to +10 range at most and made little difference...this was
...Show more →

Thanks for a detail write up, Geoff. I really appreciate your effort and love reading stuff like this.

-Tam

Feb 10, 2017 at 11:13 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister