p.2 #1Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
johnahill wrote:
Nice
I was looking at the 50 macro but then landed a Leica 100 Apo-Macro for a few hundred more
Everyone needs a short tele macro as well! And if only one macro, then probably a short tele version. I use the G 2.8/90 but the if you got a 100 Apo-Macro for that little it's a sizzling deal. Actually super-sizzling! I've never seen one go for under three to four times the price of the 2.8/50 FE, and sometimes six times!
p.2 #2Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote:
I promised some images; here's one.
I love this lens. It's surprising how for a lot of macro stuff where you aren't limited my working distance, the ergonomics of this little lens are so much better than the lovely 2.8/90, even when you are at home on a tripod and aren't carting it around. And I've come to really like it's MF for macro. The ring turns smoothly without jarring your setup, and the linear but very long throw makes focus stacking and careful focus much more precise (at the cost of time consuming big focus racks, but well worth it)
The Hydrangea shot is gorgeous. Even though I don't need a 50mm macro lens, this one is extremely appealing. But the lowest price I can find locally online is ~AUD750. I think I might have to stick with my Makro-Elmarit-R 60/2.8.
p.2 #3Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
genji wrote: DavidBM wroteI promised some images; here's one.
I love this lens. It's surprising how for a lot of macro stuff where you aren't limited my working distance, the ergonomics of this little lens are so much better than the lovely 2.8/90, even when you are at home on a tripod and aren't carting it around. And I've come to really like it's MF for macro. The ring turns smoothly without jarring your setup, and the linear but very long throw makes focus stacking and careful focus much more precise (at the cost of time consuming big focus racks, but well worth it)The Hydrangea shot is gorgeous. Even though I don't need a 50mm macro lens, this one is extremely appealing. But the lowest price I can find locally online is ~AUD750. I think I might have to stick with my Makro-Elmarit-R 60/2.8.
I'm sure the Makro-Elmarit-R has and will do you proud! The real appeal of the FE (aside from being optically terrific) is the lightness when doing double duty as landscape 50 and macro when hiking. But if I wasn't doing that I'd prefer the haptics of the Makro-Elmarit (or a Milvus). I do love my old Zuiko 3.5/50; but the newer lens outperforms it (which in turn outperformed most classic macros in its day) at every distance except close to the 1:10 that the Zuiko, like most camera makers macros of the time, was optimised for.
I got it at a George's 20% off sale, and timed it before going overseas to get the GST back, so it was somewhere in the high six hundreds of AUD
p.2 #4Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote: genji wroteThe Hydrangea shot is gorgeous. Even though I don't need a 50mm macro lens, this one is extremely appealing. But the lowest price I can find locally online is ~AUD750. I think I might have to stick with my Makro-Elmarit-R 60/2.8.I'm sure the Makro-Elmarit-R has and will do you proud! The real appeal of the FE (aside from being optically terrific) is the lightness when doing double duty as landscape 50 and macro when hiking. But if I wasn't doing that I'd prefer the haptics of the Makro-Elmarit (or a Milvus). I do love my old Zuiko 3.5/50; but the newer lens outperforms it (which in turn outperformed most classic macros in its day) at every distance except close to the 1:10 that the Zuiko, like most camera makers macros of the time, was optimised for.
I got it at a George's 20% off sale, and timed it before going overseas to get the GST back, so it was somewhere in the high six hundreds of AUD...Show more →
I didn't realise that George's had 20% off sales, I'll have to keep my eye out in the future. I purchased my Loxia 85 from George's and, not only were they $400 cheaper than DigiDirect, but they were pleasant and professional as well.
p.2 #5Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
genji wrote: DavidBM wrotegenji wroteThe Hydrangea shot is gorgeous. Even though I don't need a 50mm macro lens, this one is extremely appealing. But the lowest price I can find locally online is ~AUD750. I think I might have to stick with my Makro-Elmarit-R 60/2.8.I'm sure the Makro-Elmarit-R has and will do you proud! The real appeal of the FE (aside from being optically terrific) is the lightness when doing double duty as landscape 50 and macro when hiking. But if I wasn't doing that I'd prefer the haptics of the Makro-Elmarit (or a Milvus). I do love my old Zuiko 3.5/50; but the newer lens outperforms it (which in turn outperformed most classic macros in its day) at every distance except close to the 1:10 that the Zuiko, like most camera makers macros of the time, was optimised for.
I got it at a George's 20% off sale, and timed it before going overseas to get the GST back, so it was somewhere in the high six hundreds of AUDI didn't realise that George's had 20% off sales, I'll have to keep my eye out in the future. I purchased my Loxia 85 from George's and, not only were they $400 cheaper than DigiDirect, but they were pleasant and professional as well.
They had the 20% off on in stock items around Boxing Day! Yes they are much more pleasant to deal with than Kent St Digidirect, who are either gruff or sleazy depending who you get. I hear tell BJ Digidirect might give you the time of day...
p.2 #6Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote:
They had the 20% off on in stock items around Boxing Day! Yes they are much more pleasant to deal with than Kent St Digidirect, who are either gruff or sleazy depending who you get. I hear tell BJ Digidirect might give you the time of day...
What struck me about Kent St Digidirect is the pervasive attitude that they are doing you a massive favour by allowing you to give them money in exchange for photo gear.
p.2 #7Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
genji wrote: DavidBM wroteThey had the 20% off on in stock items around Boxing Day! Yes they are much more pleasant to deal with than Kent St Digidirect, who are either gruff or sleazy depending who you get. I hear tell BJ Digidirect might give you the time of day...What struck me about Kent St Digidirect is the pervasive attitude that they are doing you a massive favour by allowing you to give them money in exchange for photo gear.
Indeed. And it's quite a LOT of money. Hell my local cafe can be pleasant and helpful for a three dollar cafe. And my local bookstore acts like I've saved them from bankruptcy if I buy a $20 book.
p.2 #8Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote: genji wroteDavidBM wroteI promised some images; here's one.
I love this lens. It's surprising how for a lot of macro stuff where you aren't limited my working distance, the ergonomics of this little lens are so much better than the lovely 2.8/90, even when you are at home on a tripod and aren't carting it around. And I've come to really like it's MF for macro. The ring turns smoothly without jarring your setup, and the linear but very long throw makes focus stacking and careful focus much more precise (at the cost of time consuming big focus racks, but well worth it)The Hydrangea shot is gorgeous. Even though I don't need a 50mm macro lens, this one is extremely appealing. But the lowest price I can find locally online is ~AUD750. I think I might have to stick with my Makro-Elmarit-R 60/2.8.I'm sure the Makro-Elmarit-R has and will do you proud! The real appeal of the FE (aside from being optically terrific) is the lightness when doing double duty as landscape 50 and macro when hiking. But if I wasn't doing that I'd prefer the haptics of the Makro-Elmarit (or a Milvus). I do love my old Zuiko 3.5/50; but the newer lens outperforms it (which in turn outperformed most classic macros in its day) at every distance except close to the 1:10 that the Zuiko, like most camera makers macros of the time, was optimised for.
I got it at a George's 20% off sale, and timed it before going overseas to get the GST back, so it was somewhere in the high six hundreds of AUD...Show more →
I'm thinking exactly that, the 50 macro would be handy to have to cover macro in such a small package but also doubles as a decent normal 50
p.2 #9Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
johnahill wrote:
I'm thinking exactly that, the 50 macro would be handy to have to cover macro in such a small package but also doubles as a decent normal 50
David's comparison with the Loxia 50 earlier in this thread certainly confirms your suggestion that the 50 macro is a decent normal 50 as well as yielding excellent macro images.
p.2 #10Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
Hi all, wanted to piggyback off this thread and ask about the Zeiss 55/1.8 vs the 50 2.8 macro. I am looking for a Sony native 50 and was initially going to pick up a used Zeiss 55/1.8. But now that I see the 50 macro I was thinking if it could serve triple duty as macro/landscape/portrait then I may go for it. I was hoping for some thoughts between these two, especially as the macro is lighter, cheaper, and has the macro functionality.
p.2 #11Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
znikon5 wrote:
Hi all, wanted to piggyback off this thread and ask about the Zeiss 55/1.8 vs the 50 2.8 macro. I am looking for a Sony native 50 and was initially going to pick up a used Zeiss 55/1.8. But now that I see the 50 macro I was thinking if it could serve triple duty as macro/landscape/portrait then I may go for it. I was hoping for some thoughts between these two, especially as the macro is lighter, cheaper, and has the macro functionality.
Golly that's a hard choice; it's all down to what you want to use it for.
Obviously if you want f1.8-2.5 then you want the 1.8/55. And if informal portraiture is your big thing you might want that. Especially as the AF on the 55 is faster and quieter. On the other hand, eyeAF on the macro works better than ordinary AF it almost seems, and f2.8 is not too bad for portraits. Make sure to use the focus limiter. The bokeh at f2.8 on the macro is not as nice as on the 55, though. So I'd say the macro can do good occasional duty as a people lens, but if it's your main thing I'd go with the 55 $$ permitting.
But if what you want is primarily a macro lens and a stopped down landscape lens, then I think you can't go wrong with the 2.8/50. It's about as sharp stopped down (possibly the 55 is a touch sharper) but also I think the macro has nicer contrast than the 55. What's impressive about this affordable little lens is that it is so good at landscape distance; usually with a short macro we'd be saying "excellent for macro, very sharp at portrait distances but not fast enough for some tastes at portrait, and good but not the lens of choice for infinity"
p.2 #12Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote: znikon5 wroteHi all, wanted to piggyback off this thread and ask about the Zeiss 55/1.8 vs the 50 2.8 macro. I am looking for a Sony native 50 and was initially going to pick up a used Zeiss 55/1.8. But now that I see the 50 macro I was thinking if it could serve triple duty as macro/landscape/portrait then I may go for it. I was hoping for some thoughts between these two, especially as the macro is lighter, cheaper, and has the macro functionality.Golly that's a hard choice; it's all down to what you want to use it for.
Obviously if you want f1.8-2.5 then you want the 1.8/55. And if informal portraiture is your big thing you might want that. Especially as the AF on the 55 is faster and quieter. On the other hand, eyeAF on the macro works better than ordinary AF it almost seems, and f2.8 is not too bad for portraits. Make sure to use the focus limiter. The bokeh at f2.8 on the macro is not as nice as on the 55, though. So I'd say the macro can do good occasional duty as a people lens, but if it's your main thing I'd go with the 55 $$ permitting.
But if what you want is primarily a macro lens and a stopped down landscape lens, then I think you can't go wrong with the 2.8/50. It's about as sharp stopped down (possibly the 55 is a touch sharper) but also I think the macro has nicer contrast than the 55. What's impressive about this affordable little lens is that it is so good at landscape distance; usually with a short macro we'd be saying "excellent for macro, very sharp at portrait distances but not fast enough for some tastes at portrait, and good but not the lens of choice for infinity"...Show more →
thanks for the reply. i think i am looking for more of the latter - namely, good stopped down landscape and macro capability; informal portraiture is not my thing but it'd be nice to have the capability to do people shots. i think i may forego the zeiss (which i've rented and really liked) and go with the cheaper alternative. one thing i noticed on dxo mark is while the 50 is really sharp on a7r2, it goes down out of proportion on the a7r (which is what i have) so not sure if that's going to be a factor...
p.2 #13Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
znikon5 wrote: DavidBM wroteznikon5 wroteHi all, wanted to piggyback off this thread and ask about the Zeiss 55/1.8 vs the 50 2.8 macro. I am looking for a Sony native 50 and was initially going to pick up a used Zeiss 55/1.8. But now that I see the 50 macro I was thinking if it could serve triple duty as macro/landscape/portrait then I may go for it. I was hoping for some thoughts between these two, especially as the macro is lighter, cheaper, and has the macro functionality.Golly that's a hard choice; it's all down to what you want to use it for.
Obviously if you want f1.8-2.5 then you want the 1.8/55. And if informal portraiture is your big thing you might want that. Especially as the AF on the 55 is faster and quieter. On the other hand, eyeAF on the macro works better than ordinary AF it almost seems, and f2.8 is not too bad for portraits. Make sure to use the focus limiter. The bokeh at f2.8 on the macro is not as nice as on the 55, though. So I'd say the macro can do good occasional duty as a people lens, but if it's your main thing I'd go with the 55 $$ permitting.
But if what you want is primarily a macro lens and a stopped down landscape lens, then I think you can't go wrong with the 2.8/50. It's about as sharp stopped down (possibly the 55 is a touch sharper) but also I think the macro has nicer contrast than the 55. What's impressive about this affordable little lens is that it is so good at landscape distance; usually with a short macro we'd be saying "excellent for macro, very sharp at portrait distances but not fast enough for some tastes at portrait, and good but not the lens of choice for infinity"thanks for the reply. i think i am looking for more of the latter - namely, good stopped down landscape and macro capability; informal portraiture is not my thing but it'd be nice to have the capability to do people shots. i think i may forego the zeiss (which i've rented and really liked) and go with the cheaper alternative. one thing i noticed on dxo mark is while the 50 is really sharp on a7r2, it goes down out of proportion on the a7r (which is what i have) so not sure if that's going to be a factor...
Everything goes down out of proportion to the modest mpix differnece on the A7r compared to rii on DXO. There has been lots of speculation as to why: dxo error, some special feature of the rII sensor which makes it sharper, or subtle shutter shock on the A7r (Jim Kasson's tests showed in some scenarios the effective resolution of the A7r was about 24MP - so an effect not enough to make one think one's R is unsharp, but enough to explain those numbers.)
But of course the r is lovely, and the important thing for you is that I don't think there's any special drop for that lens...
p.2 #14Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote: znikon5 wroteDavidBM wroteznikon5 wroteHi all, wanted to piggyback off this thread and ask about the Zeiss 55/1.8 vs the 50 2.8 macro. I am looking for a Sony native 50 and was initially going to pick up a used Zeiss 55/1.8. But now that I see the 50 macro I was thinking if it could serve triple duty as macro/landscape/portrait then I may go for it. I was hoping for some thoughts between these two, especially as the macro is lighter, cheaper, and has the macro functionality.Golly that's a hard choice; it's all down to what you want to use it for.
Obviously if you want f1.8-2.5 then you want the 1.8/55. And if informal portraiture is your big thing you might want that. Especially as the AF on the 55 is faster and quieter. On the other hand, eyeAF on the macro works better than ordinary AF it almost seems, and f2.8 is not too bad for portraits. Make sure to use the focus limiter. The bokeh at f2.8 on the macro is not as nice as on the 55, though. So I'd say the macro can do good occasional duty as a people lens, but if it's your main thing I'd go with the 55 $$ permitting.
But if what you want is primarily a macro lens and a stopped down landscape lens, then I think you can't go wrong with the 2.8/50. It's about as sharp stopped down (possibly the 55 is a touch sharper) but also I think the macro has nicer contrast than the 55. What's impressive about this affordable little lens is that it is so good at landscape distance; usually with a short macro we'd be saying "excellent for macro, very sharp at portrait distances but not fast enough for some tastes at portrait, and good but not the lens of choice for infinity"thanks for the reply. i think i am looking for more of the latter - namely, good stopped down landscape and macro capability; informal portraiture is not my thing but it'd be nice to have the capability to do people shots. i think i may forego the zeiss (which i've rented and really liked) and go with the cheaper alternative. one thing i noticed on dxo mark is while the 50 is really sharp on a7r2, it goes down out of proportion on the a7r (which is what i have) so not sure if that's going to be a factor...Everything goes down out of proportion to the modest mpix differnece on the A7r compared to rii on DXO. There has been lots of speculation as to why: dxo error, some special feature of the rII sensor which makes it sharper, or subtle shutter shock on the A7r (Jim Kasson's tests showed in some scenarios the effective resolution of the A7r was about 24MP - so an effect not enough to make one think one's R is unsharp, but enough to explain those numbers.)
But of course the r is lovely, and the important thing for you is that I don't think there's any special drop for that lens...
interesting hypotheses...hadn't really given them much thought until i saw those dxo score comparisons between the 2 cameras with the same lens. yeah, i'm enjoying the r right now and hope to upgrade at some point in the future. appreciate the advice.