p.1 #1Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
Well I've just done something impulsive.
I'm off tomorrow for ten days in the wilderness in Fijordland, New Zealand, and I had packed my gear before coming into the city ready to fly out. I decided to take Batis 18, Sony 28 and ZM 85. Just wanted to go with a different kit from last wilderness backpacking trip (Lox 21, c/y 35-70 and FE 2.8/35 for a lenscap to keep on camera while actually hiking, the other lenses to use in a considered way with tripod before and after hiking in the good light.)
But having packed and left home I read that it was peak wildflower season, and I had not packed one of my macros or even tubes! But I have been intrigued by the little FE. It's only 230g which is very hiking friendly. Philip Reece says it's at least as good as my old Zuiko 3.5/50 at1:10 (which is the sweet spot of that lens) and better at all other magnifications.
So seeing on in a brick and morter shop for less than I can get anywhere in the world online, I went for it.
Seems optically good, and nice and light. Pity about the 7 aperture blades, but could be worse.
AF seems pretty useless for macro, but the MF implementation seems adequate, and the AF works fine at portrait distances and beyond. I'd be happy to pay a bit more for a more refined less noisy experience, but that might weigh more and lots of folk need a more affordable decent macro.
SO: I'll be back in ten days, after which I'll post some images from NZs alpine herb fields. But I expect to find this thread populated with other people's experience of this lens!
p.1 #3Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
I've been really impressed with the optical performance of this lens. Despite being cheap I'd rate it right up there with the best lenses I've used. It's much better than the copy of the Sony 90 macro I had but returned. My first copy of the 50 was a bit disappointing, with a noticeable left-right difference in sharpness, but my second copy is pretty even and sharp over the whole frame.
p.1 #4Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
justruss wrote:
Your impulse buy is our benefit: Really looking forward to your images and experience, David.
If you don't mind trying to get a sense of the AF and IQ for portraits/portrait distance images, it would be much appreciated.
But, of course, the most important thing is: Enjoy your trip!
OK a few comments before I head off on trip, but I'm away from a real computer so no samples etc until I get back close to e end of the month.
I spent yesterday getting a feel for the lens so that there wouldn't be surprises when I'm on the wilderness hike.
I confirmed that AF is fine at portrait to infinity distance. You have to make sure that the limiter is set to 30cm to infinity, which actually allows a lot of close focus. But then it works well. Not as fast as many lenses, but reliably accurately and fast enough. And eye AF works really well, and will track a moving eye around the frame. Since I
am carrying food and shelter for ten days I am not taking another 50, so this will have to do for landscape and people pics on the trip (though macro is what I want it for). The IQ at portrait and infinity seems impressive, informally almost up there with the Loxia, maybe as good in some ways. Stopped down the bokeh balls are a bit more angular than I like, but no worse than any other 50 macro I know. Centre and large area around great wide open, the rest following quickly and great across the frame at f5.6.
The macro resolution and contrast is really impressive, much better than my old Zuiko. I think about as good as my FE 90 which is amazing really. The bokeh balls aren't as nice though.
AF really is useless for macro, even when the limiter is set for macro only, but I don't care. It has a proper MF switch, and the MF implementation is linear, so it's easy to use and to preset for your desired magnification, and the you can fine tune with the ring or moving the camera. It has a VERY long throw which some might find annoying, But which I much prefer in a macro. It has a focus hold button which can be usefully reprogrammed.
All in all I'm hoping it will prove a great purchase. I sometimes like a macro on wilderness trips and I would never take my 90 or even heavier ones. In the past I've taken helicoid adapters or tubes with other lenses to avoid weight of a short tele macro, but the IQ is not the same. And this doubles as an excellent modern 50 for other purposes. At 230g it's about the weight difference between ZM 85 which I'm taking, and Loxia 85!
p.1 #6Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
stevei wrote:
So what do you think of the lens after your trip, David?
I like it a lot; and wish it had a few small upgrades even at more cost.
First its resolution and microcontrast are great. Really great. Like you wouldn't complain if it was four times the price. I doubt there's a better short macro in terms of resolution and contrast for any money; I think it's sharper and snappier than the makro planar I once had, and every bit as sharp and contrasty as the FE 90. Runs rings around my OM 3.5/50 which was one of the very best classic short macros. I think for landscape use it's on par with my Loxia 50; and contrastier than the FE 55. It's super sharp wide open centrally, which makes it a useful portrait 50 even though slow (and strangely eye AF seems to work quite fast). The makro bokeh is great, but the portrait distance bokeh is so-so: a tad nervous.
That's the good news. But why did they give it so few aperture blades? OOF highlights have a very angular shape. And while flare control is superb, you don't get much of a sunstar.
If you depend on AF this lens may not be for you. The motor is moving the whole optical unit, so it's slow, incredibly so in the macro range. Not so bad at longer distances, if you have the limiter engaged. The MF is also slow but in a god way: the FBW is linear and very long throw, so you have great control. When shooting macro the best bet is to set the lens to the rough magnification you want before raising it to your eye or looking at the screen. Then use the MF or move the camera to fine tune (actually AF in macro works ok if you have pre focused)
So what do I think? Well for multi day hiking where every gram is counted, it's a no brainer. You get your fifty and your macro in a 230g package, and its optically great. That was my rationale and I'm confident now it was right.
If you aren't doing that? Well there's a nearby lens - the same one with a nicer iris and better AF - that would be wonderful to own. If you don't want a 50 macro in particular you wold likely be served better by the fifties of your choice and the FE90. If, like me, you like to have a shorter perspective macro as well as a tele macro it's probably the one to get. Makro planar is nicer in some ways, but not sharper, and not 1:1. The new voigtlander APO lanthar will be interesting to watch, but it's quite long - it's effective focal length at close focus may be not much shorter than many 90s if it keeps fl at close focus, which is likely in a mechanical design. And this little light lens outclasses the legacy 50 macros I know.
p.1 #7Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote:
I like it a lot; and wish it had a few small upgrades even at more cost.
First its resolution and microcontrast are great. Really great. Like you wouldn't complain if it was four times the price. I doubt there's a better short macro in terms of resolution and contrast for any money; I think it's sharper and snappier than the makro planar I once had, and every bit as sharp and contrasty as the FE 90. Runs rings around my OM 3.5/50 which was one of the very best classic short macros. I think for landscape use it's on par with my Loxia 50; and contrastier than the FE 55. It's super sharp wide open centrally, which makes it a useful portrait 50 even though slow (and strangely eye AF seems to work quite fast). The makro bokeh is great, but the portrait distance bokeh is so-so: a tad nervous.
That's the good news. But why did they give it so few aperture blades? OOF highlights have a very angular shape. And while flare control is superb, you don't get much of a sunstar.
If you depend on AF this lens may not be for you. The motor is moving the whole optical unit, so it's slow, incredibly so in the macro range. Not so bad at longer distances, if you have the limiter engaged. The MF is also slow but in a god way: the FBW is linear and very long throw, so you have great control. When shooting macro the best bet is to set the lens to the rough magnification you want before raising it to your eye or looking at the screen. Then use the MF or move the camera to fine tune (actually AF in macro works ok if you have pre focused)
So what do I think? Well for multi day hiking where every gram is counted, it's a no brainer. You get your fifty and your macro in a 230g package, and its optically great. That was my rationale and I'm confident now it was right.
If you aren't doing that? Well there's a nearby lens - the same one with a nicer iris and better AF - that would be wonderful to own. If you don't want a 50 macro in particular you wold likely be served better by the fifties of your choice and the FE90. If, like me, you like to have a shorter perspective macro as well as a tele macro it's probably the one to get. Makro planar is nicer in some ways, but not sharper, and not 1:1. The new voigtlander APO lanthar will be interesting to watch, but it's quite long - it's effective focal length at close focus may be not much shorter than many 90s if it keeps fl at close focus, which is likely in a mechanical design. And this little light lens outclasses the legacy 50 macros I know....Show more →
This and your previous post have provided an excellent summary of the strengths and weakness of the 50mm FE Macro. I wouldn't use a short macro enough to warranty purchasing one but, if I was in the market, I'd give it serious consideration based on your experience.
[Edited] Though now you have me wondering about getting a set of extension tubes to use with my Loxia 50mm and 85mm lenses.
p.1 #8Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote: stevei wroteSo what do you think of the lens after your trip, David?I like it a lot; and wish it had a few small upgrades even at more cost.
First its resolution and microcontrast are great. Really great. Like you wouldn't complain if it was four times the price. I doubt there's a better short macro in terms of resolution and contrast for any money; I think it's sharper and snappier than the makro planar I once had, and every bit as sharp and contrasty as the FE 90. Runs rings around my OM 3.5/50 which was one of the very best classic short macros. I think for landscape use it's on par with my Loxia 50; and contrastier than the FE 55. It's super sharp wide open centrally, which makes it a useful portrait 50 even though slow (and strangely eye AF seems to work quite fast). The makro bokeh is great, but the portrait distance bokeh is so-so: a tad nervous.
That's the good news. But why did they give it so few aperture blades? OOF highlights have a very angular shape. And while flare control is superb, you don't get much of a sunstar.
If you depend on AF this lens may not be for you. The motor is moving the whole optical unit, so it's slow, incredibly so in the macro range. Not so bad at longer distances, if you have the limiter engaged. The MF is also slow but in a god way: the FBW is linear and very long throw, so you have great control. When shooting macro the best bet is to set the lens to the rough magnification you want before raising it to your eye or looking at the screen. Then use the MF or move the camera to fine tune (actually AF in macro works ok if you have pre focused)
So what do I think? Well for multi day hiking where every gram is counted, it's a no brainer. You get your fifty and your macro in a 230g package, and its optically great. That was my rationale and I'm confident now it was right.
If you aren't doing that? Well there's a nearby lens - the same one with a nicer iris and better AF - that would be wonderful to own. If you don't want a 50 macro in particular you wold likely be served better by the fifties of your choice and the FE90. If, like me, you like to have a shorter perspective macro as well as a tele macro it's probably the one to get. Makro planar is nicer in some ways, but not sharper, and not 1:1. The new voigtlander APO lanthar will be interesting to watch, but it's quite long - it's effective focal length at close focus may be not much shorter than many 90s if it keeps fl at close focus, which is likely in a mechanical design. And this little light lens outclasses the legacy 50 macros I know....Show more →
Great write-up David! I don't have any macro lenses currently and the FE 50/macro sounds like a winner for the size, weight and price.
p.1 #9Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wrotestevei wroteSo what do you think of the lens after your trip, David?I like it a lot; and wish it had a few small upgrades even at more cost.
First its resolution and microcontrast are great. Really great. Like you wouldn't complain if it was four times the price. I doubt there's a better short macro in terms of resolution and contrast for any money; I think it's sharper and snappier than the makro planar I once had, and every bit as sharp and contrasty as the FE 90. Runs rings around my OM 3.5/50 which was one of the very best classic short macros. I think for landscape use it's on par with my Loxia 50; and contrastier than the FE 55. It's super sharp wide open centrally, which makes it a useful portrait 50 even though slow (and strangely eye AF seems to work quite fast). The makro bokeh is great, but the portrait distance bokeh is so-so: a tad nervous.
That's the good news. But why did they give it so few aperture blades? OOF highlights have a very angular shape. And while flare control is superb, you don't get much of a sunstar.
If you depend on AF this lens may not be for you. The motor is moving the whole optical unit, so it's slow, incredibly so in the macro range. Not so bad at longer distances, if you have the limiter engaged. The MF is also slow but in a god way: the FBW is linear and very long throw, so you have great control. When shooting macro the best bet is to set the lens to the rough magnification you want before raising it to your eye or looking at the screen. Then use the MF or move the camera to fine tune (actually AF in macro works ok if you have pre focused)
So what do I think? Well for multi day hiking where every gram is counted, it's a no brainer. You get your fifty and your macro in a 230g package, and its optically great. That was my rationale and I'm confident now it was right.
If you aren't doing that? Well there's a nearby lens - the same one with a nicer iris and better AF - that would be wonderful to own. If you don't want a 50 macro in particular you wold likely be served better by the fifties of your choice and the FE90. If, like me, you like to have a shorter perspective macro as well as a tele macro it's probably the one to get. Makro planar is nicer in some ways, but not sharper, and not 1:1. The new voigtlander APO lanthar will be interesting to watch, but it's quite long - it's effective focal length at close focus may be not much shorter than many 90s if it keeps fl at close focus, which is likely in a mechanical design. And this little light lens outclasses the legacy 50 macros I know.Great write-up David! I don't have any macro lenses currently and the FE 50/macro sounds like a winner for the size, weight and price.
Here's a comparison of the top left corners of the Lox and the FE macro at f8 and infinity; on a par. Other corners are similar except the Lox is just noticeably ahead in the bottom right. Centring on the Lox perfect, centring on the FE maybe just a touch out but not enough to to make my try to change it in Oz where that's a lot harder than in the US. And also, it's pretty well centred, and getting better on a plain Sony might be hard. Differences go away at 1:2
Pretty impressive for infinity on a macro (and the overall contrast is really great - so at the image level it's more impressive than if you peek). And it only gets better the closer you focus.
The Sony has a slightly shorter focal length at infinity than the Lox.
EDIT Oh and here's the bottom right. As you can see, the Lox is better by only a tiny margin.
p.1 #10Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
genji wrote:
[Edited] Though now you have me wondering about getting a set of extension tubes to use with my Loxia 50mm and 85mm lenses.
Seeing that the Loxia 50 looked great at close range, I compared at actual MFD to the MP 50. I thought I might be able to get away with using the Loxia as a semi-macro. Disappointing results....the MP50 is much sharper in that range. I haven't yet tried close range with the 85.
p.1 #11Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
Here's an obligatory pet picture taken of our Doodle Annie taken with the FE 2.8/50 wide open; it proves nothing of course (other than perhaps the richness of the colour at default saturation) but obligations are obligations....
p.1 #12Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote:
Pretty impressive for infinity on a macro (and the overall contrast is really great - so at the image level it's more impressive than if you peek). And it only gets better the closer you focus.
This is the aspect which impressed me the most: it is very good at any distance. Classic 50mm Macros in comparison are very good at about 1:10 and significantly worse at larger or smaller magnifications.
p.1 #13Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DannyBurkPhoto wrote: genji wrote[Edited] Though now you have me wondering about getting a set of extension tubes to use with my Loxia 50mm and 85mm lenses.Seeing that the Loxia 50 looked great at close range, I compared at actual MFD to the MP 50. I thought I might be able to get away with using the Loxia as a semi-macro. Disappointing results....the MP50 is much sharper in that range. I haven't yet tried close range with the 85.
This is useful information. According to the Zeiss website, the field of view at close range is similar for both lenses: 255.1mm x 168.3mm for the Loxia 50 and 257.9mm x 172.6mm for the Loxia 85. Even if the L50 is disappointing, the L85 could possibly be acceptable or better. Only one way to find out though...
p.1 #14Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
genji wrote: DannyBurkPhoto wrotegenji wrote[Edited] Though now you have me wondering about getting a set of extension tubes to use with my Loxia 50mm and 85mm lenses.Seeing that the Loxia 50 looked great at close range, I compared at actual MFD to the MP 50. I thought I might be able to get away with using the Loxia as a semi-macro. Disappointing results....the MP50 is much sharper in that range. I haven't yet tried close range with the 85.This is useful information. According to the Zeiss website, the field of view at close range is similar for both lenses: 255.1mm x 168.3mm for the Loxia 50 and 257.9mm x 172.6mm for the Loxia 85. Even if the L50 is disappointing, the L85 could possibly be acceptable or better. Only one way to find out though...
Wow that's massive focus breathing on the L85! Not good if you want face filling images with a compressed perspective. Is the L85 internal focus?
p.1 #15Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote:
Wow that's massive focus breathing on the L85! Not good if you want face filling images with a compressed perspective. Is the L85 internal focus?
Neither the L50 nor the L85 are internal focus. But the CFD of the L50 is 45cm while that of the L85 is a fraction under 80cm; so the similar field of view values were pretty much what I expected. Or am I missing something?
I tried a couple of different online field of view calculators and they came up with different values than the Zeiss numbers I quoted: 324mm x 216mm for the Loxia 50 and 330.4mm x 220.2mm for the Loxia 85mm. But both online calculators yielded exactly the same values.
p.1 #16Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
genji wrote: DavidBM wroteWow that's massive focus breathing on the L85! Not good if you want face filling images with a compressed perspective. Is the L85 internal focus?Neither the L50 nor the L85 are internal focus. But the CFD of the L50 is 45cm while that of the L85 is a fraction under 80cm; so the similar field of view values were pretty much what I expected. Or am I missing something?
I tried a couple of different online field of view calculators and they came up with different values than the Zeiss numbers I quoted: 324mm x 216mm for the Loxia 50 and 330.4mm x 220.2mm for the Loxia 85mm. But both online calculators yielded exactly the same values.
Ah you are missing nothing; for some stupid reason I thought you were comparing the fields of view of lenses at the same close focusing distance, but of course you said MFD and the MFDs are very different!
p.1 #17Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wroteDavidBM wrotestevei wroteSo what do you think of the lens after your trip, David?I like it a lot; and wish it had a few small upgrades even at more cost.
First its resolution and microcontrast are great. Really great. Like you wouldn't complain if it was four times the price. I doubt there's a better short macro in terms of resolution and contrast for any money; I think it's sharper and snappier than the makro planar I once had, and every bit as sharp and contrasty as the FE 90. Runs rings around my OM 3.5/50 which was one of the very best classic short macros. I think for landscape use it's on par with my Loxia 50; and contrastier than the FE 55. It's super sharp wide open centrally, which makes it a useful portrait 50 even though slow (and strangely eye AF seems to work quite fast). The makro bokeh is great, but the portrait distance bokeh is so-so: a tad nervous.
That's the good news. But why did they give it so few aperture blades? OOF highlights have a very angular shape. And while flare control is superb, you don't get much of a sunstar.
If you depend on AF this lens may not be for you. The motor is moving the whole optical unit, so it's slow, incredibly so in the macro range. Not so bad at longer distances, if you have the limiter engaged. The MF is also slow but in a god way: the FBW is linear and very long throw, so you have great control. When shooting macro the best bet is to set the lens to the rough magnification you want before raising it to your eye or looking at the screen. Then use the MF or move the camera to fine tune (actually AF in macro works ok if you have pre focused)
So what do I think? Well for multi day hiking where every gram is counted, it's a no brainer. You get your fifty and your macro in a 230g package, and its optically great. That was my rationale and I'm confident now it was right.
If you aren't doing that? Well there's a nearby lens - the same one with a nicer iris and better AF - that would be wonderful to own. If you don't want a 50 macro in particular you wold likely be served better by the fifties of your choice and the FE90. If, like me, you like to have a shorter perspective macro as well as a tele macro it's probably the one to get. Makro planar is nicer in some ways, but not sharper, and not 1:1. The new voigtlander APO lanthar will be interesting to watch, but it's quite long - it's effective focal length at close focus may be not much shorter than many 90s if it keeps fl at close focus, which is likely in a mechanical design. And this little light lens outclasses the legacy 50 macros I know.Great write-up David! I don't have any macro lenses currently and the FE 50/macro sounds like a winner for the size, weight and price.Here's a comparison of the top left corners of the Lox and the FE macro at f8 and infinity; on a par. Other corners are similar except the Lox is just noticeably ahead in the bottom right. Centring on the Lox perfect, centring on the FE maybe just a touch out but not enough to to make my try to change it in Oz where that's a lot harder than in the US. And also, it's pretty well centred, and getting better on a plain Sony might be hard. Differences go away at 1:2
Pretty impressive for infinity on a macro (and the overall contrast is really great - so at the image level it's more impressive than if you peek). And it only gets better the closer you focus.
The Sony has a slightly shorter focal length at infinity than the Lox.
EDIT Oh and here's the bottom right. As you can see, the Lox is better by only a tiny margin....Show more →
Looks very impressive as you described David. The Loxia 50 is outstanding at f/8 (infinity) so this new macro is indeed great considering it's optimized for closer distances.
p.1 #18Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
According to DxO, the Sony FE 50mm f2.8 macro is the third-sharpest lens they've tested on the A7R II to date - slightly sharper than the Loxia 50mm f2.
p.1 #19Sony FE 50mm macro: impulse purchase and future image thread
I promised some images; here's one.
I love this lens. It's surprising how for a lot of macro stuff where you aren't limited my working distance, the ergonomics of this little lens are so much better than the lovely 2.8/90, even when you are at home on a tripod and aren't carting it around. And I've come to really like it's MF for macro. The ring turns smoothly without jarring your setup, and the linear but very long throw makes focus stacking and careful focus much more precise (at the cost of time consuming big focus racks, but well worth it)