I thought we had a thread on this already but I do not see it. If so maybe Fred can move them. Anyway this is a fun lens and I'm still testing it as this morning i noticed the extreme corners don't get really that sharp but given its a 12mm maybe the just don't anyway. Something I am not worried about. But i MUST give you all a VERY STERN warning using this lens. DO NOT GO PHOTOGRAPH WILD ANIMALS WITH THIS LENS. YOU WILL GET EATEN ALIVE. lol
Seriously you are on top of everything with this lens.
How do the corners compare to your VC15? Given that the VC12 is significantly wider I would expect that a good copy of the 15 would have better corners. Are they significantly different?
I've seen good copies of the CV 15/4.5III and tested two copies of both CV 12mm and CV 10mm lenses.
At infiinity, the 15mm is superior towards the edges and the 12 is not far behind. Both have more resolution and contrast when compared to the 10mm.
Guy,
I just checked your RAW files your copy peaks at f/8-9 for the extreme edges which is similar to what I saw with my two copies. It's hard for me to know if your copy is better or worse than mine but they do peak at similar aperture openings.
Thanks Fred. I would say the 15 is a little better in the extreme corners but we are talking a very extreme wide here so I really don't expect miracles in the extreme corners . I think that's a fair assessment for a lens like this. It's very sharp lens so far pretty happy with it. My test wall changed they put new wood in it so it's harder to see . I sent Fred my Raws just to see if his copy is similar to his. Sounds like it is. Really fun lens
Anyone familiar with how this CV 12mm compares to the Canon 11-24 at 12mm? Seems the Canon got outstanding reviews for sharpness, but never seen it directly compared against the CV 10-12-15.
I am noticing one thing as it seems things closer in the extreme corners look better than far away. Something to watch as you shoot as most images the bottom of the frame looks better in the corners.
Well my 12mm is officially mine forever. A very rare moment for me but I have a Gordy wrist strap and it failed today pulling camera I put strap around my wrist lifted out of bag and was left with wrist on my arm. Camera and 12mm hit the deck in a rocky flower bed and caught the top petal and bent it and scratched the hood. Gordy strap is being burned. I did get a immediate camera fail and turned off and than on and still fail. Than pulled battery and it's working again. I'll inspect it further in a few minutes but shit happens. I have seen this stuff happen way too often on workshops with other folks. Guess it was my turn this time. But I seriously consider myself lucky after millions of frames over the years I have done well here.
p.1 #11Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III Images and Tests
Yea I know, glad I was keeping it anyway. Everything seems okay and I bent the ding back to shape. I could dremel it off and still use the lens hood. About 1/4 inch
p.1 #13Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III Images and Tests
GMPhotography wrote:
Yea I know, glad I was keeping it anyway. Everything seems okay and I bent the ding back to shape. I could dremel it off and still use the lens hood. About 1/4 inch
Guy, I was confused by your your earlier post. I thought there must be some mistake as I did not know any Voigtlander hood to survive long in the company of you and your Dremel.....
Sorry about the mishap. I can relate in that I once had a Canon 5D M2 with a Zeiss ZE 50/2 take a drink in the river when I was photographing a waterfall. Was glad I had inland marine coverage.
p.1 #14Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III Images and Tests
Nice, Guy!
I'm still mulling over whether I want to switch from the 10 to the 12; the 12 seems a bit better. But I think when I want extreme I want EXTREME, and can put up with a slight contrast/sharpness drop to pay for that. A 14/15 is more a general purpose ultra wide for me, and having sold my most recent Samyang (history: Good copy, bad copy, terrible copy, OK copy) I'm evaluating my options: Laowa, AF Samyang, Irix, Beast Samyang, CV, or wait. I'd really like a superb 14/15, and maybe one day there'll be a Loxia. The SLR Zeiss is nice, but too big and expensive (I'd forgive big OR expensive, but not both..)
p.1 #15Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III Images and Tests
Vcize wrote:
You don't have insurance?
I would not use insurance for a single 1k lens . For me I use that for a total loss of a system. Besides that lens works fine just a dinged hood. I don't care too much about looks just how they perform.
p.1 #16Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III Images and Tests
DavidBM wrote:
Nice, Guy!
I'm still mulling over whether I want to switch from the 10 to the 12; the 12 seems a bit better. But I think when I want extreme I want EXTREME, and can put up with a slight contrast/sharpness drop to pay for that. A 14/15 is more a general purpose ultra wide for me, and having sold my most recent Samyang (history: Good copy, bad copy, terrible copy, OK copy) I'm evaluating my options: Laowa, AF Samyang, Irix, Beast Samyang, CV, or wait. I'd really like a superb 14/15, and maybe one day there'll be a Loxia. The SLR Zeiss is nice, but too big and expensive (I'd forgive big OR expensive, but not both..)...Show more →
It's a tough call. I like the 12mm as I like the look of the images, there are a lot of lenses coming to market so just seeing if I need something between 12 and 21. I don't think I do but will see.
p.1 #18Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III Images and Tests
Guy, very sorry to hear that, that is a real bummer as Mike said earlier (burn that strap well and put it behind you)
I'm glad you are still keeping the 12mm though, as it's a fun lens for sure
The 16-35mm FE is a very good one lens solution for filling in some of the FL gaps between the 12mm - 21mm as well as 21mm - 25mm where it performs at it's best, as you already know and have demonstrated previously, it's not so great at the 35mm end and certainly it's no replacement for your 21mm Loxia.
Please continue with this thread if possible, as I expect it will be very useful for many here who are considering getting this lens
p.1 #19Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III Images and Tests
Yes the good news is it's a nice copy so I did not have to return it anyway. Which is the saving grace. It took a hard fall and survived so glad about that. And yes keep this thread going.
p.1 #20Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III Images and Tests
leicamera wrote:
Guy, very sorry to hear that, that is a real bummer as Mike said earlier (burn that strap well and put it behind you)
I'm glad you are still keeping the 12mm though, as it's a fun lens for sure
The 16-35mm FE is a very good one lens solution for filling in some of the FL gaps between the 12mm - 21mm as well as 21mm - 25mm where it performs at it's best, as you already know and have demonstrated previously, it's not so great at the 35mm end and certainly it's no replacement for your 21mm Loxia.
Please continue with this thread if possible, as I expect it will be very useful for many here who are considering getting this lens
If they came out with a GM 16-35 now that maybe worth it as well in that area. Not sure I would use both GMs at the same time though. But if the 16-35 turned out better than the 24-70 we'll that adds a decision to make.