Jonathan F wrote:
NateWeatherly wrote
ken.vs.ryu wrote
is TAP better/faster with the a7iii vs a7r2 ? I have both the A7RII and A7 III and have used the TAP a lot with both of them. Haven't done any scientific comparisons, but here's a summary of my anecdotal impressions:
Compared to A7RII + TAP firmware 5.0, the A7III + TAP firmware 6.0:
- has Eye AF! (works, but not as well as native glass)
- is more consistently able to achieve focus stopped down or in low light, using AF points outside the center of the frame, using the single point focus area (“flexible spot small”), and on small or low contrast details due to A7III’s improved AF sensors, BUT...
- has overall slightly slower AF aquisition AND...
- has slightly less dependable AF *accuracy*, especially when stopped down and/or when using lenses with spherochromatic aberrations or smearing issues caused by the sensor coverglass (My M-Rokkor 40mm f/2 is a prime example of this type of lens).
This seems to be mostly due to adjustments in firmware 6.0 to use a slower or more gradual/tapered lead up to “in-focus” in order to avoid the spasmodic “jitter” problems caused (ironically) by the new camera's faster AF. Where on the A7RII it could go slightly past focus and then quickly back up, on the A7III it will sometimes be fooled by the depth of field, color fringing, and/or astigmatism into stopping just short of ideal focus, seemingly to avoid overshooting focus and triggering the back and forth jitter caused by the A7III taking AF readings faster than the TAP motor can respond.
So, overall, I've found the A7III + TAP 6.0 to be very usable and often much better than the A7RII + TAP 5.0, but, sadly, also less *dependable* and therefore less well suited to professional work, weddings, etc. I find myself having to use focus magnification to confirm accurate af much more often than I ever did on the A7RII.
Right now I'm thinking that I'm going to get my A7RII modded with the Kolari UT and primarily dedicate that camera to using the TAP and the A7III to native lenses where it excels. Glad to know I'm not the only one with the same observation! I have the A7III and A7II and notice the exact same issue. Strangely enough, I also notice my A7II + TAP w/firmware 5.0 does better in low light (less jitter) than my A7III + TAP w/firmware 6.0. I notice a tad better performance with the A7III + TAP/fw6.0 if you turn the live view effects setting -off-.
I'm a little bummed the A7III isn't has stable with the TAP as the previous generation though.
I used to have an A7II and I think that the TAP actually worked better on that in low light than it did on my A7RII, so I wouldn’t be surprised if the A7II is close to or a little better in low light than the A7III.
And yeah, I always notice better AF performance with Live View Setting Effect “off”. Also, I think that using PP10 (Hybrid log gamma) helps in low light too. Mess around with the “detail” settings until you find the best settings.
I will say though that I really don’t get any jitter on my A7III since updating to 6.0. Maybe make sure your A7III has the latest Sony firmware?