jamato8 wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wrotejamato8 wroteThe first is f2 200 iso100. Mounted on a tripod and a timer used. Contrasty natural light so in this you can't see so much of the contrast loss. The second f4 50 iso100. IS off. Even on the EVF wide open you can see the difference. 3rd image uncropped of the f2 shot. Second full sized f4.
On my computer screen and even viewing the image once taken on the EVF the difference is more obvious.
So I wonder, since I have read a number of times that wide open the lens is excellent, does anyone see much difference when stopping down to f4 or 5.6.
Just looked under light through the lens. Surprised, there is dust on the inside element. Really surprised by this.From my perspective this is still fine performance wide open at 1:2. I don't doubt these is a slight drop in resolution, but what is more noticeable here is a razor thin depth of field that makes judging sharpness very difficult. DOF is so thin it is easy to judge aspects of the images that are not in the best plane of focus. I love shallow DOF close ups/macro, but on this shot I think the DOF is just too shallow in the wide open shot and that is in my view the primary reason the stopped down shot looks better.I agree that DOF plays a role on jamato's example, giving the f/4 crop the impression of more sharpness.
As with any lens, there is always a bump in contrast/resolution from wide open (This is the case with outstanding lenses like the ZF 135/2 APO)...so we can't expect the CV 65/2 to be any different. However, with this lens, I think the difference is very tiny and f/2.8 is already as sharp as it can be at center even at infinity distance.
Here is an example with a somewhat flat subject. It shows a dog's can food with very small lettering and as you can see, the focus area does not change much in terms of contrast/resolution from wide open to f/4 but it greatly varies as the can starts to curve (DOF). Look at the logo and then the word "Manufactured". The word starts very similar between the two apertures but at f/4 is much sharper at the end of it as the can curves very slightly.
@jamato8@@, if you can't duplicate the below with your lens, I would try a different copy.I have sent back the 1st 65 and got the second today.
Immediately through the EVF I can see the difference. More contrast wide open and just sharper. With images taken, there is little difference in sharpness from wide open with f4 just slightly better. This is more like what I was seeing on here and thank you Fred for posting the images of print as that really helped to define what I was and wasn't seeing with the first copy. This second one has what you are getting on the images you posted.
jamato8 wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wrotejamato8 wroteThe first is f2 200 iso100. Mounted on a tripod and a timer used. Contrasty natural light so in this you can't see so much of the contrast loss. The second f4 50 iso100. IS off. Even on the EVF wide open you can see the difference. 3rd image uncropped of the f2 shot. Second full sized f4.
On my computer screen and even viewing the image once taken on the EVF the difference is more obvious.
So I wonder, since I have read a number of times that wide open the lens is excellent, does anyone see much difference when stopping down to f4 or 5.6.
Just looked under light through the lens. Surprised, there is dust on the inside element. Really surprised by this.From my perspective this is still fine performance wide open at 1:2. I don't doubt these is a slight drop in resolution, but what is more noticeable here is a razor thin depth of field that makes judging sharpness very difficult. DOF is so thin it is easy to judge aspects of the images that are not in the best plane of focus. I love shallow DOF close ups/macro, but on this shot I think the DOF is just too shallow in the wide open shot and that is in my view the primary reason the stopped down shot looks better.I agree that DOF plays a role on jamato's example, giving the f/4 crop the impression of more sharpness.
As with any lens, there is always a bump in contrast/resolution from wide open (This is the case with outstanding lenses like the ZF 135/2 APO)...so we can't expect the CV 65/2 to be any different. However, with this lens, I think the difference is very tiny and f/2.8 is already as sharp as it can be at center even at infinity distance.
Here is an example with a somewhat flat subject. It shows a dog's can food with very small lettering and as you can see, the focus area does not change much in terms of contrast/resolution from wide open to f/4 but it greatly varies as the can starts to curve (DOF). Look at the logo and then the word "Manufactured". The word starts very similar between the two apertures but at f/4 is much sharper at the end of it as the can curves very slightly.
@jamato8@@, if you can't duplicate the below with your lens, I would try a different copy.I have sent back the 1st 65 and got the second today.
Immediately through the EVF I can see the difference. More contrast wide open and just sharper. With images taken, there is little difference in sharpness from wide open with f4 just slightly better. This is more like what I was seeing on here and thank you Fred for posting the images of print as that really helped to define what I was and wasn't seeing with the first copy. This second one has what you are getting on the images you posted.
You’re gonna love this lens! Persistence pays off. Congrats!
Did some field documentation today, which is one of the main reasons I got the 65. Edge to edge totally sharp with the right amount of contrast. Shooting directly into the setting sun I did pick up some flare but was able to edit it out. It will flare though. The quality of the images, the intense sharpness makes up for this.
It focuses really close and can accept tubes making it even closer. Probably one of the best lenses I've ever owned. Saw one in the B/S too if you're looking.
How would you rate this vs the Planar T* 50mm 1.4 ZA? I'm thinking about returning mine to swap for this lens. I just got the Distagon 35 ZA and the Planar T 50 and I'm thinking CV 40 1.2 and CV 65 APO may be the better rendering lenses.
I did a brief comparison with the Voigt 65 to Otus 55 - some, including myself, have commented that the 65's rendering is quite Otus-like, so I was curious to see how they actually compare one to one. Nothing scientific here, just a setup on a bookcase around 3 ft from the camera. I'll try some outdoor comparisons at greater distance when the weather improves.
I'm surprised to see that they are actually this close to one another. Disregarding the difference in focal length, the rendering is VERY similar, including bokeh and other factors. In fact, the 65 seems a touch sharper on the text. Here are a few test shots - just for fun, if nothing more.
First pair: Voigt 65 wide open from A7R3. Processed in ACR with default sharpening (25/1.0/25); no further sharpening on the jpgs. Full frame for reference, then a clip at actual res; focus point on the book spine text reading "by Les Line".