fredmiranda.com Login

Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar

  
 
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.33 #1Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
LightShow wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteI've never looked into this. Is the Otus 28/1.4 APO, the only wide angle apochromatic lens out there?
I've already been looking for an APO wide, all I've found is the Otus 28, and this: http://www.slrmagic.info/product/APO+HyperPrime+CINE+APO25PL
I contacted them to see if they had any plans to house it in a normal lens body, and their reply was not at this time...
Also this: Schneider 24mm f/5.6 Apo-Digitar XL, and, Rodenstock 35mm f/4.5 Apo-Grandagon
I'm looking forward to a CV 65/2 Macro APO vs Leica R 60/2.8 Macro comparison.


The Schneider 24 needs exactly 12mm between the rear surface and the sensor for infinity. You might be able to sync it into the mount 6mm to accomplish that, but you'll want to do a bag-bellows test before committing to a remount. I'm betting the corners will be trouble no matter how far you stop down. The Grandagon requires a little less than 18mm and there's no way you're getting that huge rear element in a Sony. it's the APO-Sironar-Digital HR or Digaron HR 35/4 that can work. I'd planned to convert mine for use on a GFX (along with a 60/4 and 100/4) before I went the DB route, but I've still got it in it's temporary E-mount I used for proof-of-concept. Great lens, but given the size, weight, and typical price (good deals happen if you're patient) you're better off the 35LII which, by f/4, is as well-corrected and higher resolution across the frame.
Sep 06, 2017 at 08:35 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.33 #2Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
GMPhotography wrote:
It's funny I read a lot of negatives on this VC65 n other sites, glad I don't pay attention to any of them but if the whiners actually shot the damn thing maybe they would get it. For us pixel peeping souls this thing has a place in your kit. Get over it's a 65mm it's actually a lovely focal length


Interesting: where have read the whining? The only semi negative stuff I've read is from complete bulls**t sites.

I mean, even Llloyd Chambers loves the CV65, and it's not even made by Zeiss!
Sep 06, 2017 at 08:40 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.33 #3Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Try SAR the comments it's pretty funny actually.

DavidBM wrote:
GMPhotography wroteIt's funny I read a lot of negatives on this VC65 n other sites, glad I don't pay attention to any of them but if the whiners actually shot the damn thing maybe they would get it. For us pixel peeping souls this thing has a place in your kit. Get over it's a 65mm it's actually a lovely focal length
Interesting: where have read the whining? The only semi negative stuff I've read is from complete bulls**t sites.

I mean, even Llloyd Chambers loves the CV65, and it's not even made by Zeiss!

Sep 06, 2017 at 08:46 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.33 #4Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
GMPhotography wrote:
Try SAR the comments it's pretty funny actually.

DavidBM wrote
GMPhotography wroteIt's funny I read a lot of negatives on this VC65 n other sites, glad I don't pay attention to any of them but if the whiners actually shot the damn thing maybe they would get it. For us pixel peeping souls this thing has a place in your kit. Get over it's a 65mm it's actually a lovely focal length
Interesting: where have read the whining? The only semi negative stuff I've read is from complete bulls**t sites.

I mean, even Llloyd Chambers loves the CV65, and it's not even made by Zeiss!


I'd have to really feel the need to punish myself to read the comments page on SAR!!
Sep 06, 2017 at 08:58 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.33 #5Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
DavidBM wrote:
GMPhotography wroteIt's funny I read a lot of negatives on this VC65 n other sites, glad I don't pay attention to any of them but if the whiners actually shot the damn thing maybe they would get it. For us pixel peeping souls this thing has a place in your kit. Get over it's a 65mm it's actually a lovely focal length
Interesting: where have read the whining? The only semi negative stuff I've read is from complete bulls**t sites.

I mean, even Llloyd Chambers loves the CV65, and it's not even made by Zeiss!


I've read comments like, "why would anyone buy this lens when there is a Sony 90/2.8 1:1 macro" or "manual focus lens, no thank you!..." or "weird focal length" or "too heavy", "too expensive"...etc... Some say the rendering can be harsh but I found that at close and mid-distances it's comparable with the 55/1.8 ZA's which everyone seems to really like...
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1451413/26#14168206

So I guess, some folks don't like manual focus lenses, or don't care about the level of CA correction and have different priorities.
Sep 06, 2017 at 08:58 PM
davewolfs
Offline
Details
p.33 #6Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Any advantage over Loxia 50 or Zony 50 1.4 other than Macro capability?
Sep 06, 2017 at 08:59 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.33 #7Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
kaioyang wrote:
genji wrote
Fred Miranda wroteIt's time for someone to make a 28/2.4 APO E-mount.
This might sound like heresy but I have mixed feelings about a 28/2.4 APO E-mount. This thread is making it increasingly clear that the Macro Apo-Lanthar 65/2 is a gateway drug to further APO ownership. I know I couldn't resist a 28mm APO E-mount but then I'd be unhappy that I didn't have 50mm and 90mm APO lenses to match it.
You can always get the CV APO Lanthar 90/3.5. 👍


Or the Leica 50 or 90 apo, but I doubt that the will match the new CV 65 in that Dept.
Sep 06, 2017 at 09:01 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.33 #8Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
davewolfs wrote:
Any advantage over Loxia 50 or Zony 50 1.4 other than Macro capability?


Dave, I tested against a good copy of the Loxia 50 at infinity here:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1451413/28#14168904

The 50/1.4 ZA is tougher competitor. Both have great CA correction although 65 APO is better with pretty much no CA. Both have high resolution close and at infinity and both are flat-field. Aside from weight differences, the 50/1.4 ZA's only major disadvantage is a noticeably mid-zone resolution dip in comparison.
Sep 06, 2017 at 09:03 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.33 #9Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
davewolfs wrote:
Any advantage over Loxia 50 or Zony 50 1.4 other than Macro capability?


Read back a few pages. It is getter corrected for CA and is sharper across the frame than the Loxia at least at larger apertures. There is no contest till F5.6 or smaller where the differences diminish, but don't disappear entirely.
Sep 06, 2017 at 09:06 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.33 #10Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
GMPhotography wroteIt's funny I read a lot of negatives on this VC65 n other sites, glad I don't pay attention to any of them but if the whiners actually shot the damn thing maybe they would get it. For us pixel peeping souls this thing has a place in your kit. Get over it's a 65mm it's actually a lovely focal length
Interesting: where have read the whining? The only semi negative stuff I've read is from complete bulls**t sites.

I mean, even Llloyd Chambers loves the CV65, and it's not even made by Zeiss!
I've read comments like, "why would anyone buy this lens when there is a Sony 90/2.8 1:1 macro" or "manual focus lens, no thank you!..." or "weird focal length" or "too heavy", "too expensive"...etc... Some say the rendering can be harsh but I found that at close and mid-distances it's comparable with the 55/1.8 ZA's which everyone seems to really like...
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1451413/26#14168206

So I guess, some folks don't like manual focus lenses, or don't care about the level of CA correction and have different priorities.


Oh sure, that's the usual stuff, and of course some people don't want MF or 65mm or a big heavy normal lens (actually I have some sympathy for the last - that's part of why I managed to hold out for a few days). I guess I thought Guy had read negative stuff about its optical qualities. Whether those great qualities are worth the trade off with MF, size, weight, aperture, magnification etc etc is another matter and we'll all decide differently.

And if I were sensible enough to have a pared down system with one key lens at each FL, rather than having different lenses for different use cases with different tradeoffs, I'm not sure that the CV would be in that pared down system because of the bulk and weight. But luckily I'm not that sensible...

Gotta say, I am amazed by the quality. I'd love to see a comparison with Otus 55 from f2 onwards...
Sep 06, 2017 at 09:08 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.33 #11Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
I read it for a good laugh. Lol

DavidBM wrote:
GMPhotography wroteTry SAR the comments it's pretty funny actually.

DavidBM wrote
GMPhotography wroteIt's funny I read a lot of negatives on this VC65 n other sites, glad I don't pay attention to any of them but if the whiners actually shot the damn thing maybe they would get it. For us pixel peeping souls this thing has a place in your kit. Get over it's a 65mm it's actually a lovely focal length
Interesting: where have read the whining? The only semi negative stuff I've read is from complete bulls**t sites.

I mean, even Llloyd Chambers loves the CV65, and it's not even made by Zeiss!
I'd have to really feel the need to punish myself to read the comments page on SAR!!

Sep 06, 2017 at 09:12 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.33 #12Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
DavidBM wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
DavidBM wrote
kaioyang wroteI wonder what the new CV40/1.2 will be, will it be APO too?
It won't be APO

(1) It's just too small to be apochromatically corrected at an f1.2 aperture
(2) They don't have APO in the name, and if the axial CA correction was great, you can bet they would have.

I'm also expecting that it'll be pretty unsharp off axis at wide apertures; again because of the size, even taking into account the mirrorless advantage (compare it with the ZA 1.4/35; and before anyone says that is just a DSLR design it really isn't: look at the placement of the elements)

None of that is to say it might not be a great lens. If it sharp *on* axis and in a decent usable sweet spot over a fair bit of the frame at wider apertures, and if it's sharp across the field stopped down, and the if LoCA is not too bad, it could be a sweet lens. We'll see.
I'm still betting that, if you love the 35/1.2II, you're going to love the 40/1.2.
Agree completely with that; in fact I'm expecting the 40 to perform rather better than 1.2/35, quite good though that was.


It's possible. Newer design, maybe newer materials available. I wasn't all that fond of the 35 (much prefer the ZM Distagon) so I think there's room for improvement.

If I ran Cosina, my next plan for the E-mount would be a three lens landscaper kit that didn't try to be anything but a landscaper kit. Fully manual. no FLEs, limited MFD's, nothing faster than f/4, but designed for high resolution, flare resistance, and color correction, at focal lengths of 24, 40, and 100. Give them locks so you can set them to the hyper-focal distance at your shooting aperture, filter-friendly hoods, and two sets of aperture blades, ten rounded and nine straight, with controls for one toward the front of the lens and the other behind the focusing ring with a clutch between them to keep you from trying to close one if the other is set for something other than wide open.
Sep 06, 2017 at 09:14 PM
kaioyang
Offline
Details
p.33 #13Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
genji wrote:
kaioyang wrote
genji wroteThis might sound like heresy but I have mixed feelings about a 28/2.4 APO E-mount. This thread is making it increasingly clear that the Macro Apo-Lanthar 65/2 is a gateway drug to further APO ownership. I know I couldn't resist a 28mm APO E-mount but then I'd be unhappy that I didn't have 50mm and 90mm APO lenses to match it.
You can always get the CV APO Lanthar 90/3.5. 👍
Too slow!


Then APO Lanthar 125/2.5 - that's fast enough. Unfortunately it's like $2k, too much for me...
Sep 06, 2017 at 09:20 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.33 #14Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
You know not sure it would be as good as the Batis 135 to be honest. The Batis really is a laser

kaioyang wrote:
genji wrote
kaioyang wrote
genji wroteThis might sound like heresy but I have mixed feelings about a 28/2.4 APO E-mount. This thread is making it increasingly clear that the Macro Apo-Lanthar 65/2 is a gateway drug to further APO ownership. I know I couldn't resist a 28mm APO E-mount but then I'd be unhappy that I didn't have 50mm and 90mm APO lenses to match it.
You can always get the CV APO Lanthar 90/3.5. 👍
Too slow!
Then APO Lanthar 125/2.5 - that's fast enough. Unfortunately it's like $2k, too much for me...

Sep 06, 2017 at 09:23 PM
kaioyang
Offline
Details
p.33 #15Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
GMPhotography wrote:
You know not sure it would be as good as the Batis 135 to be honest. The Batis really is a laser



Well, I look forward to seeing comparison between Batis 135, Zeiss APO 2/135 ZF.2 and Voigtlander APO Lanthar 125/2.5 :-)
Sep 06, 2017 at 09:25 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.33 #16Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Wish I had all three of those lenses to test out. Be fun

kaioyang wrote:
GMPhotography wroteYou know not sure it would be as good as the Batis 135 to be honest. The Batis really is a laser
Well, I look forward to seeing comparison between Batis 135, Zeiss APO 2/135 ZF.2 and Voigtlander APO Lanthar 125/2.5 :-)

Sep 06, 2017 at 09:32 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.33 #17Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
kaioyang wrote:
GMPhotography wroteYou know not sure it would be as good as the Batis 135 to be honest. The Batis really is a laser
Well, I look forward to seeing comparison between Batis 135, Zeiss APO 2/135 ZF.2 and Voigtlander APO Lanthar 125/2.5 :-)


There's a limited comparison between the f2ZF2 Apo Sonnar and the Batis in my review of the Batis on Phillip Reeve's site.

It's confined to wide open bokeh; but I can tell you that these two lenses, at shared apertures, look remarkably similar, though the Batis has even better APO correction!

I've still got them both, because while I'll never travel with the ZF2 Apo Sonnar, I quite often use it wide open for portraits or botanical images (sometimes blending in an f3.5 image of the detailed parts of the image to get the best of both worlds)

Sep 06, 2017 at 09:37 PM
davewolfs
Offline
Details
p.33 #18Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Interesting. Maybe I'll pick one up.

Fred and others how do you like the Loxia 35 to the 50 at larger apertures.

Usually the 50/21 combo serves me well for not so serious stuff.
Sep 06, 2017 at 09:43 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.33 #19Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Interesting in crop mode it's a 97.5mm focal length. In a pinch a viable option
Sep 06, 2017 at 09:52 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.33 #20Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
davewolfs wrote:
Interesting. Maybe I'll pick one up.

Fred and others how do you like the Loxia 35 to the 50 at larger apertures.

Usually the 50/21 combo serves me well for not so serious stuff.


The L35 has a mug of SA haze wide open, which you will either think is atmospheric and great, or hate. It clears up one stop down. The L50 is free of that.

The L50 is then a bit better in the periphery in terms of sharpness from f2 to f4; the gap is closing by f5.6. They are both superb at stopped down landscape apertures, with slight nod to the 50 in the corners as you'd expect with 50 vs 35.
Sep 06, 2017 at 10:01 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister