fredmiranda.com Login

Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar

  
 
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.19 #1Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Since I messed up the exposure on the first one (same shutter speed for both GM at F2.5 and Loxia 85 at F 2.4 (which meant the Loxia was slightly over exposed) I figure I should reveal the answers.

Kudos to Fred Miranda who got them all right (only one, I think as not everyone guessed all 5 pics):

First test:
1 GM (No one missed this one that guessed!)
2 CV,
3 Loxia 85

Second Test:
1 CV
2 Loxia 50

Aug 27, 2017 at 10:26 AM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.19 #2Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Nice! At least I got the second set "right".

Anyway, impressive set of lenses, all around, IMO.
Aug 27, 2017 at 10:47 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #3Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Missed one , not bad for IPhone viewing

Biggest problem is there all three great lenses so it makes it tough.

Luvwine wrote:
Since I messed up the exposure on the first one (same shutter speed for both GM at F2.5 and Loxia 85 at F 2.4 (which meant the Loxia was slightly over exposed) I figure I should reveal the answers.

Kudos to Fred Miranda who got them all right (only one, I think as not everyone guessed all 5 pics):

First test:
1 GM (No one missed this one that guessed!)
2 CV,
3 Loxia 85

Second Test:
1 CV
2 Loxia 50


Aug 27, 2017 at 01:37 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.19 #4Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
I hope you guys are happy with all the teasing! I just ordered one.
I will compare it to my Loxia 50/2 and Zeiss 85/4 ZM. If it comes close, I will probably sell them for it...
Aug 27, 2017 at 01:43 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #5Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Right behind yea next week I'm ordering mine.

Fred Miranda wrote:
I hope you guys are happy with all the teasing! I just ordered one.
I will compare it to my Loxia 50/2 and Zeiss 85/4 ZM. If it comes close, I will probably sell them for it...

Aug 27, 2017 at 01:45 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.19 #6Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Fred Miranda wrote:
I hope you guys are happy with all the teasing! I just ordered one.
I will compare it to my Loxia 50/2 and Zeiss 85/4 ZM. If it comes close, I will probably sell them for it...


I will be interested to see if you like the rendering for landscape. I find the Voigtlander to be the most neutral/natural lens I have for color along with the other virtues we have been talking about. However, the Loxia and ZM lenses have terrific landscape rendering and whether this could replace them for you for that purpose will be interesting to see. The loxia lenses on vegetation in particular are quite "3d" and on some shots, I see less of that with the Voigtlander. If you like the lens half as much as I do, however, you will be well pleased.
Aug 27, 2017 at 03:18 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #7Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
It could be just a little clarity/ contrast boast needed. I'll see what it is once I test it against the Batis 135

Luvwine wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteI hope you guys are happy with all the teasing! I just ordered one.
I will compare it to my Loxia 50/2 and Zeiss 85/4 ZM. If it comes close, I will probably sell them for it...
I will be interested to see if you like the rendering for landscape. I find the Voigtlander to be the most neutral/natural lens I have for color along with the other virtues we have been talking about. However, the Loxia and ZM lenses have terrific landscape rendering and whether this could replace them for you for that purpose will be interesting to see. The loxia lenses on vegetation in particular are quite "3d" and on some shots, I see less of that with the Voigtlander. If you like the lens half as much as I do, however, you will be
...Show more →


Edited on Aug 27, 2017 at 04:03 PM · View previous versions
Aug 27, 2017 at 03:21 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.19 #8Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Luvwine wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteI hope you guys are happy with all the teasing! I just ordered one.
I will compare it to my Loxia 50/2 and Zeiss 85/4 ZM. If it comes close, I will probably sell them for it...
I will be interested to see if you like the rendering for landscape. I find the Voigtlander to be the most neutral/natural lens I have for color along with the other virtues we have been talking about. However, the Loxia and ZM lenses have terrific landscape rendering and whether this could replace them for you for that purpose will be interesting to see. The loxia lenses on vegetation in particular are quite "3d" and on some shots, I see less of that with the Voigtlander. If you like the lens half as much as I do, however, you will be
...Show more →

I should have it on Tuesday and I'm curious to shoot with it.
Aug 27, 2017 at 03:24 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.19 #9Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Few quick snaps from today with the CV 65/2 apo:

F2:


F2:


F4:


F2 (with tubes I think):
Aug 27, 2017 at 05:34 PM
DannyBurkPhoto
Offline
Details
p.19 #10Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
The f/2 flowers are very Otus-like
Aug 27, 2017 at 06:05 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Jannik Peters
Offline
Details
p.19 #11Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
My Loxia 85 is up for sale as well.. CV65 and GM85 are definitely different enough.
Aug 27, 2017 at 06:28 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.19 #12Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Well, at least we can all recognize the results of having the largest front and rear elements of the test subjects.
Aug 27, 2017 at 06:39 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.19 #13Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Jochenb wrote:
When I compare RAW files of both the Voigtlander 65 and Loxia 50 I just see a little more "presence" in the Loxia files. At least on the A7RII. I felt the same way when comparing the FE55 with the Loxia or Canon L lenses with the Zeiss ZE/ZF lenses a few years ago.
It has nothing to do with LR vs C1 (have both). I always make my own profiles, because I think the standard profiles for Sony are horrible.
Still, this Voigtlander clearly has great qualities and I'm certainly interested in it. It seems to be much more
...Show more →

Between the Canon L (do you mean the 50 1.2L?) and the Zeiss ZE/ZF, which was it that you thought had more "presence"? I'm not sure from the phrasing.

Thanks!
Aug 27, 2017 at 08:50 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.19 #14Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Jannik Peters wrote:
Okay folks.. I have made a small but interesting comparison between my Loxia 85 and my CV65.

- Lenses were electronically decoupled.. So it is just the glass that you see here
- CV is cropped to the size of the Loxia
- both lenses wide open
- same position
- same time
- same light
- the brightness level of the toy is exactely the same (CV -0,25 exposure, Loxia +-0)
- no sharpening applied
- White balance sliders exactely the same

So which one is which?


I think the bottom is the CV65--it looks just a touch more compressed and a tiny tad sharper on the little white dots on the toy, as a macro should. But I prefer the look of the top picture.
Aug 27, 2017 at 09:10 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.19 #15Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
chiron wrote:
Jannik Peters wroteOkay folks.. I have made a small but interesting comparison between my Loxia 85 and my CV65.

- Lenses were electronically decoupled.. So it is just the glass that you see here
- CV is cropped to the size of the Loxia
- both lenses wide open
- same position
- same time
- same light
- the brightness level of the toy is exactely the same (CV -0,25 exposure, Loxia +-0)
- no sharpening applied
- White balance sliders exactely the same

So which one is which?
I think the bottom is the CV65--it looks just a touch more compressed and a tiny tad sharper on the little white dots on the toy, as a macro should. But I prefer the look of the top picture.


Ha! I got it wrong, but I was thinking the Loxia was a 50mm, not the 85mm. Gotta learn to pay attention when I read.
Aug 27, 2017 at 09:15 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.19 #16Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
If we are getting tricked by these samples, to me, it just means that all these lenses are marvels and the differential is something other than IQ.
Aug 27, 2017 at 09:53 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.19 #17Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Fred Miranda wrote:
If we are getting tricked by these samples, to me, it just means that all these lenses are marvels and the differential is something other than IQ.


Yes; for years people have been saying "modern lenses are so good that IQ is not a factor in choice".
But it was never true, especially as camera resolution improved.

But now I think it is more or less true for the best lenses. Otuses, L85, B135, CV65, Sigma 135: all lenses where IQ is just not a factor any more. And even if we get 200mp sensors, and will see issues at 1:1, IQ will still not be a factor unless printing to the side of a house and inspecting closely (200mp will be great for doing away with moire though)

At the wide end it's a bit harder, but even there we are getting close to the "IQ not a basis for choice" levels with the best lenses.

I'll almost miss the discussions of lens IQ...
Aug 27, 2017 at 10:21 PM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.19 #18Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Phillip Reeve wroteTo each his own but the CV is far from a low contrast lens and I bet that few people would be able to pick it out against a Loxia 50 if they have a dozen or so images. Even less so if images are processed.
Phillip,
I just read your entire review. Nicely done as always!

On bokeh rendering, I see you rated it above average.
Did you test it against the Loxia 50/2 at mid distances?

Thanks

Yes, I think overall bokeh is above average but one good or bad rating doesn't really do it justice. I think closeup bokeh is very smooth, at portrait distances it is still fine but at longer distances it does indeed become a bit harsh. The rather strong cat-eyes and straight aperture blades can also cause issues. Bastian is sending his FE55 over so that I compare both lenses a bit closer in the coming days, bokeh is one of the things I will have a close look.
Aug 28, 2017 at 12:36 AM
pdmphoto
Offline
Details
p.19 #19Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
The F2 close-up shots remind me of the Olympus 90 F2 macro, but I think that lens has better bokeh. Maybe just the longer focal length?
Aug 28, 2017 at 12:50 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #20Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
As far as bokeh a lot of these tests are against a longer lens to start with so a 85 regardless of lens will be slightly better. I think during a 55 1.8 might give us better insight to this since it's only 10 mm longer than the 85 which is 20 mm longer. I think it's worth a test just to get a idea of the other way. Not many 65 to compare too
Aug 28, 2017 at 09:41 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister