Greggf wrote:
The bokeh of the c/y 50 planar is pretty busy wide open. As for the Lux, I think the pre-asph versions(a la Mandler design) are much closer to the C-Sonnar look, IMO. I've used them all, and I think the C Sonnar has the best people look, then the Lux pre, then whatever else you want to throw in the mix.
A fair assessment. I never used the CZ CS50 or C/V 50/1.5 Asph but remember when they were released, with most of those early images being shot on film (RFF). CS50 focus shift was a major topic, but is virtually irrelevant on MILC. As for CZ P50/1.4 C/Y and the Summilux-M 50, I have and enjoy both of them but the 'lux has far smoother bokeh, and that eternal Mandler look. The Planar is as sharp as anything you will find when stopped down, although not exactly endearing in rendition. I'm smitten by the Zony 50/1.4, but the sheer mass is daunting.