Mark, excellent photograph, by the way. Both in the initial composition and the post processing execution.
As an old fart raised on film and wet darkrooms, I may well not have gone this far with the image had I the opportunity. But, I like seeing what you, the Ryan Dyars and Marc Adumus' are doing. Given the flexibility and range of digital versus what we had with film and wet darkrooms, it is good some are willing to explore how far they can push the processes and still bring home an image which resonates for people, especially for people who have been in similar places and situations and have seen the possibilities, and who are constantly exposed to the images we are now seeing day in, day out on TV and movies.
With film, doing something like this was simply not possible, or if possible, not practical given time and financial constraints. Multiple exposures, through registered masks, an hour to see the result of an action at the cost of many dollars when you weren't making many, made doing something like this nearly impossible and impractical. And then, after a couple of days of work, if you did finally get it right, try replicate it.
Now people, who have excellent Photoshop skills, can fulfill their vision more readily. Good. Let them go for it. If it does not appeal to you, fine. There is a lot of room in photography to make your own way. If you wish to comment, it is helpful to explain why something does not work for you. Maybe both you and the original artist will learn something from the dialogue. An old fart like me, I'll just muddle along learning from what they are doing and, hopefully, improving my own vision and photographs and maybe joining the 20th century before it comes to an end. Uhhh. What. Wait. Huhh?
And to Jim Fox, if I seemed a bit harsh, I meant to be, but just a bit. It was not out of animosity. I want to see where highly competent people are trying to go with photography. Mark Metternich is one of those people. I want him to continue posting, and the same with Ryan Dyar and Marc Adamus. Now, what you did with your current Second Beach photo is more in my style. And having spent time at Second Beach back in the days of film, no time and no money, I very much appreciate the image and know you had to be cooking it a bit, too. And you cooked it very well. Thanks for presenting it, as with Mark and his photograph. I learn from both.