Compared to the 1.8G, (which I owned awhile ago), I don't think the AF is quite as fast. I don't find it slow though at all, though I have only shot it in single shot. As far as sharpness at similar apertures, they are both are very sharp in the center. The 1.8G seems sharper away from the center and probably just touch sharper in the center. If you're looking for sharpness across the frame the 1.8G is going to be better, but I think you get the 1.4D for the rendering vs absolute sharpness. I like them both, the 1.8G is a great used pick up right now.