fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos

Lance B
Offline

p.1 #1Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Just spent two weeks in Japan and Singapore with the Tamron 15-30 f2.8 Di VC. I purchased it the week before I left and thus had little time to evaluate it other than a few quick shots around Sydney before I left to "get to know the lens" a little.

As some of you may know, I have the Nikon 16-35 f4 VR and also the Nikon 14-24 f2.8G and also the 24 f1.4G, which is a gem. One may wonder as to why I would get the Tammy when I have the extreme wide end well covered, but my thinking is that the Tammy has had such great reviews that I could actually sell both the 16-35 and the 14-24 and just use the one extreme wide angle zoom as it should be able to cover all bases.

As some of you may know, I am quite a fan of the Nikon 16-35 and the reasons for the 16-35 f4 VR is that it has a reasonable zoom range and has VR. Overall IQ and sharpness is very good to excellent depending on where you are in the zoom range. From 20mm to 28mm, the 16-35 is sharp and as sharp as mosty primes, this is its sweet spot in the zoom range. From 16-20 it is still very good to excellent if you stop down and also if know where to focus to get the best from the corners. CA is quite OK and can be fixed PP and distortion is also quite fixable PP - I've never had an image ruined due to distortion that couldn't be fixed PP. Over abut 28-30mm, the sharpness does drop off a tad and is the weakest point of this lens. VR is very useful inside places where it is dark and you can't use a tripod or don't have a tripod - like when travelling. I think of the Nikon 16-35 more as a travel lens mainly due to it's VR, zoom range and its very good to excellent IQ, more of an all purpose lens.

The reason for a 14-24 is obviously it's legendary IQ and sharpness right across its (limited) zoom range and also it's f2.8 ability. However, it's drawbacks can be that huge front element, flare at times, relatively limited zoom range, and when you want to use filters. It is also heavy in comparison to the 16-35. I think of the 14-24 as more of a specialty lens for use at home when I can control when and where I can/want to use it as you need to have a huge filter system and possibly a tripod.

So, in comes the Tammy. It seems to marry most of the benefits of the 16-35 with most of the benefits of the 14-24 and does it brilliantly. Overall, it seems to me as sharp as the 14-24 across the whole zoom range and across the frame and has excellent overall IQ. It is as sharp and sharper than the 16-35 depending on where you are in the zoom range with both lenses and corner performance of the Tammy is better than the 16-35 for sure. The Tammy seems easier to work with with regards to getting the edges and corners sharp as the field curvature of the Tammy works for you in most situations very well.

Distortion at the extreme wide end is much less than the 16-35 at the wide end and thus you lose less when correcting it in PP. It seems to be similar distortion to that of the 14-24 at the wide end, ie reasonably low for an extreme wide angle lens. CA is also very well controlled and very easily fixed in PP.

The Tammy obviously has a longer zoom range than the 14-24 going to 30mm, but 5mm shorter zoom range than the 16-35. The Tammy is much sharper at 30mm than the 16-35. I didn't find the shorter zoom range than the 16-35 an issue on my travels as I do take my 24-70 f2.8 as well and that makes the crossover between 24mm and 30mm rather than specifically at 24mm if you have the 14-24. Having a crossover range is definitely a bonus rather than a hard and fast 24mm.

The drawbacks of the Tammy are that it is quite heavy, 100gms heavier than the 14-24 and 400gms heavier than the 16-35. It also has a huge front element similar to the 14-24 and thus you need to be careful when walking around with it at your side, and for better protection, I generally zoomed it back to 30mm as this keeps it further into the lens hood. It also does not have a filter thread which may be of importance, but I didn't find the need for my travels photography as the D810 has such great DR. Flare only affected one image. Size and weight and the front element wasn't really an issue on my travels, but I would say that the 16-35 is a better choice in that regard. However, given my time again, I woul still choose the Tammy over the 16-35 for my travel photography.

So, summing up, I am extremely happy with the results and use of the Tammy for my travel photography and I am actually thinking of selling off my 14-24 and I may even sell off my 16-35.

If these images do not fit onto your screen, use "CTRL" plus the wheel on your mouse to "zoom out" to a smaller image. I do not know what function this is on an Apple computer.

D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 15mm, 1/15sec, f8, ISO720



D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 15mm, 1/10sec, f8, ISO1600



D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 30mm, 1/10sec, f8, ISO6400



D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 15mm, 1/250sec, f8, ISO64



D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 15mm, 1/40sec, f8, ISO560



D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 19mm, 1/40sec, f8, ISO1250



D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 15mm, 1/500sec, f9, ISO160



D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 15mm, 1/250sec, f8, ISO64



D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 21mm, 1/200sec, f8, ISO64



D810 + 15-30 f2.8 VC @ 15mm, 1/625sec, f10, ISO180



Edited on Sep 15, 2016 at 12:00 AM · View previous versions
Feb 18, 2016 at 02:06 AM
Mark K
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Thank you for your review. Currently have 16 35 vr at hand but thinking about bith the 14 24, and Tammy
Feb 18, 2016 at 07:26 AM
Lynn Ross
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
I don't understand why this has to be that big, trying to read what you said and opening my browser to full still can't read the darn thing with out having to scroll across the screen back and forth ... sorry for complaining .... I can't say its a good review since I quit reading because of the scrolling.
Feb 18, 2016 at 08:16 AM
Danner
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
They look GREAT on my 27" iMac.

Another great post by LanceB.

The Tammy is doing a fine job indeed.

- Dan
Feb 18, 2016 at 08:30 AM
Steve Perry
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Thanks for the review Lance! You almost (almost) have me thinking of selling my 14-24 to get that extra 6mm on the long end. Although, in order to attempt the switch I'd need to do the same as you and have both for a bit. (In the ned though, I'll probably stick with my 14- 24 )
Feb 18, 2016 at 08:34 AM
Donzo98
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
I sold my 14-24 right after the Tammy reviews came out.... and bought the Tammy.

Awesome lens...
Feb 18, 2016 at 08:57 AM
Andrew Pece Photography
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Thanks for the words and the photos.

Do you have an opinion of the rundown on sharpness at f8 between the three lenses you discussed? From what you said, maybe comparable, yet the 16 35 may fall a bit behind on the long end?
Feb 18, 2016 at 10:21 AM
cohenfive
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Thanks for the review, and great images as well. I have the nikon, and it sounds like the tammy is equivalent performance for less money. Doesn't sound like it outperforms in any way, and you lose just a tad on the extreme wide end, but it is a great value lens for sure. I bought one for a buddy of mine and she is very happy with it.
Feb 18, 2016 at 12:16 PM
SSISteve
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Lynn Ross wrote:
I don't understand why this has to be that big, trying to read what you said and opening my browser to full still can't read the darn thing with out having to scroll across the screen back and forth ... sorry for complaining .... I can't say its a good review since I quit reading because of the scrolling.


Pics look fine to me.


Feb 18, 2016 at 12:45 PM
Leo_N
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Thank you Lance! A valuable review from an ouner of both Nikon alternatives
Could you adress the issue of the actual widest focal length of the Tamron?
DPreview claim its is more of a 16mm
When compared with nikon at 15mm
Feb 18, 2016 at 01:17 PM
DownToThis
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Great review and amazing pictures!
Feb 18, 2016 at 01:42 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Lynn Ross wrote:
I don't understand why this has to be that big, trying to read what you said and opening my browser to full still can't read the darn thing with out having to scroll across the screen back and forth ... sorry for complaining .... I can't say its a good review since I quit reading because of the scrolling.


Looks great to me.

I for one appreciate large pics, they look better, load instantly, and display beautifully on almost every monitor without scrolling unless you're living in the stone age. They can also give somewhat of an indication of expected lens performance.
Feb 18, 2016 at 02:33 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Lynn Ross wrote:
I don't understand why this has to be that big, trying to read what you said and opening my browser to full still can't read the darn thing with out having to scroll across the screen back and forth ... sorry for complaining .... I can't say its a good review since I quit reading because of the scrolling.


As I stated in my original post, just above the photos. If the photos appear too large, press the "CTRL" button on your computer along and use the scroll wheel of your mouse to zoom out or in as desired. The reason for the large images is that many people now have HD screens with 2560 x 1440 pixels, or Ultra HD screens with 3840 x 2160 pixels and small images lose impact on those large screens. In fact they look like postage stamps and you can't judge sharpness or IQ. If I use small images and get the people with large screens to use the "CTRL" + scroll wheel on the mouse to enlarge them, the images lose resolution when enlarged. In other words, it's better to get people with small screens to reduce the image size than it is to get people with large screens to enlarge the images. I use the zoom method regularly as writing can be quite small on these new high res screens, no big deal.

Sorry for the inconvenience, but this is the way things are going as people are getting these larger more high res screens and they look amazing.
Feb 18, 2016 at 03:23 PM
hijazist
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Lynn Ross wrote:
I don't understand why this has to be that big, trying to read what you said and opening my browser to full still can't read the darn thing with out having to scroll across the screen back and forth ... sorry for complaining .... I can't say its a good review since I quit reading because of the scrolling.


Thanks for the review Lance!

IMHO most those interested in these lenses are looking for minute characteristics that are hard to judge with small JPEGs such as corner sharpness, distortion, etc... Large images give a better idea about the lens's performance, which is the whole point of a review
Feb 18, 2016 at 03:23 PM
Surfnsun
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Thanks for sharing! Definitely a fan!
Feb 18, 2016 at 03:31 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Andrew Pece Photography wrote:
Thanks for the words and the photos.

Do you have an opinion of the rundown on sharpness at f8 between the three lenses you discussed? From what you said, maybe comparable, yet the 16 35 may fall a bit behind on the long end?


No very wide angle to extreme wide angle zoom is perfect, thay all have their strengths and weaknesses depending on a number of factors. You have things like field curvature that can be a reasonably flat field curvature or a pronounced field curvature which may or may not work for you or against you at a particular scene. Not only that, but the field curvature may change significantly depending on focus distance and where it is in the zoom range. One scene may suit the 16-35 more and another scene may suit the 14-24 more and yet another suit the 15-30 more, all 3 lenses are different and none are perfect for every scene.

At f8, they are all very sharp and generally all very sharp right through the zoom range, the 16-35 losing a bit at about the 28-30mm mark. I would say that the Tamron and the 14-24 are very close across the zoom range and at all apertures, both extremely sharp in the centre and very good in the edges and corners a tad better overall than the 16-35. Corner sharpness is good with the 16-35 depending on focal length and where you focus and that is due to it's field curvature which seems to be different to the others. The differences are subtle and with careful focusing you can achieve excellent results from all of them. There is a very good review done by Mansurov at Photography Life and his conclusions seem to mirror mine and other's that I have read:
https://photographylife.com/reviews/tamron-15-30mm-f2-8

Feb 18, 2016 at 03:37 PM
creamfactor
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Leo_N wrote:
Thank you Lance! A valuable review from an ouner of both Nikon alternatives
Could you adress the issue of the actual widest focal length of the Tamron?
DPreview claim its is more of a 16mm
When compared with nikon at 15mm


I can chime in as an owner of this lens. There are claims that the FL is closer to 16mm, and that's true to an extent... due to significant focus breathing. You lose a bit on the wide lens the closer you focus towards infinity(which is where most of us are using this lens). It's 15 only at closer focusing distances.

I adore this lens, though, and the VC is actually become an incredible convenience and creative tool for hand held shooting.
Feb 18, 2016 at 03:42 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Leo_N wrote:
Thank you Lance! A valuable review from an ouner of both Nikon alternatives
Could you adress the issue of the actual widest focal length of the Tamron?
DPreview claim its is more of a 16mm
When compared with nikon at 15mm


Firstly, focal length is measured when a lens is set to infinity and some lenses can alter greatly when focused close or anywhere in between. However, I did a quick comparo in my small computer room when I first got the lens to check to see how wide all 3 were in an indoor scenario. If we accept that the 14-24 @ 14mm is 14mm and we accept that the 16-35 @ 16mm is actually 16mm, then the Tammy @ 15mm would be more like 15.5mm when focused at about the 3mt mark. However, due to the fact that the Tammy exhibits less distortion than the 16-35, once corrected for that distortion the 16-35 could be easily 17mm or even 18mm, the Tammy may end up being 16mm once corrected. The 14-24 may end up being 14.5 or 15mm once corrected. Unfortunately, I did not keep the shots. I have not checked the lenses at infinity.
Feb 18, 2016 at 03:49 PM
pwschladen
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Great review! Thanks Lance!
Of course it is clear that you get the best out of any lens you use - results most of us can only aspire to.

Regarding the VR - which of the slower shutter speed shots were handheld?

Patrick

Feb 18, 2016 at 04:34 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
pwschladen wrote:
Great review! Thanks Lance!
Of course it is clear that you get the best out of any lens you use - results most of us can only aspire to.

Regarding the VR - which of the slower shutter speed shots were handheld?

Patrick



Thank you, Patrick,

They were all handheld.
Feb 18, 2016 at 04:37 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell

You are not logged inLog inRegister