p.3 #1Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Just wanted to add that everything looks great on my screen and I'm using a MBPr. I'm surprised at all the complaining. I could dig into that further, but it isn't worth the arguing. Apparently some people just need things to complain about...
Thanks again for sharing and I'm even more impressed to read that those were all handheld!
p.3 #2Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Not that this has anything to do with the quality of the written content or the quality of the images (thank you by the way)...but I would have to agree that this was rather frustrating to get through. And I would also state that I do not feel like it is the norm to have these high resolution monitors. Many people have them but there are still a large quantity of people using 1080p monitors. Not to mention there are probably lots of people not even sitting at the computer in which they edit photos (work, phone, tablet etc).
And most importantly, I feel, the content of your writing meant volumes more than your images to me. Your opinion of how the lens performs compared to the 14-24 and the 16-35 is much more easily expressed in words than images. Especially when all (3) of those lenses are good performing lenses.
p.3 #4Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
I wonder why some have issues seeing the images and the writing but others do not, even if they have similar lower res screens? Anyway, in future, I may try to put the writing and the sample images in different posts, as Lynne has suggested to me in a PM.
Thank you everyone for your lovely comments and suggestions. Much appreciated!
p.3 #6Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Vcize wrote:
Great review, and amazing job getting those shots that sharp handheld at those shutter speeds. Thanks for posting.
How did you get the images that large here on FM? The file size limit here is very small.
Thank you very much.
I link my photos to my photo hosting site rather than upload them here. So, what you are seeing is a linked photo, not an uploaded photo. Use the link:
[ img ]....[ /img ] Remove spaces between [ ] and img /img. and insert photo address with /jpg at the end. So, the address would look like:
p.3 #7Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
This lens on its own has been making me want to go full frame. I am actually hoping sigma comes out with a wide zoom in its art series soon, wider than the 18-35. Supposedly they are launching some new lenses soon. I personally really want to stay on a crop sensor but lenses like this tamron make it tough.
p.3 #8Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Lance, old topic by now but have you considered filter system? I have same lens
I bought the Haida and it is very very nice quality. I hear that the Nisi filter holder should really be avoided....but their glass 10 stop filter is great.
I will go with Lee Big Stopper when I get more money, but Haida brand -- at least in this filter system holder -- is close to the Lee SW150 in my opinion. Well worth $100 total, shipped.
p.3 #9Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
lsutigerfan wrote:
Lance, old topic by now but have you considered filter system? I have same lens
I bought the Haida and it is very very nice quality. I hear that the Nisi filter holder should really be avoided....but their glass 10 stop filter is great.
I will go with Lee Big Stopper when I get more money, but Haida brand -- at least in this filter system holder -- is close to the Lee SW150 in my opinion. Well worth $100 total, shipped.
p.3 #11Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Lance B wrote: pwschladen wroteGreat review! Thanks Lance!
Of course it is clear that you get the best out of any lens you use - results most of us can only aspire to.
Regarding the VR - which of the slower shutter speed shots were handheld?
PatrickThank you, Patrick,
They were all handheld.
I hope it's OK to dig up this old thread. Given that you took all those wonderful images handheld, I'd be curious if you, or anyone else, have tips on how to focus this lens for edge to edge sharpness, especially at infinity. Using live view autofocus in the center on a distant subject, I find I get a "runway" of sharpness where the center is sharp, and the ground running all the way to the foreground at the bottom edge is sharp, but the left/right edges are blurry. My guess is that this is due to the field curvature of the lens, but I am willing to be enlightened.
p.3 #12Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
infimum wrote:
I hope it's OK to dig up this old thread. Given that you took all those wonderful images handheld, I'd be curious if you, or anyone else, have tips on how to focus this lens for edge to edge sharpness, especially at infinity. Using live view autofocus in the center on a distant subject, I find I get a "runway" of sharpness where the center is sharp, and the ground running all the way to the foreground at the bottom edge is sharp, but the left/right edges are blurry. My guess is that this is due to the field curvature of the lens, but I am willing to be enlightened.
Yes, field curvature would be causing what you are seeing. Not a lot you can do except work with it as it is generally more of a help than a hinderance, IMO. The issue is, if you didn't have it, then the ground close in would be horribly OOF but the sides might be ok. In your sample photo at DPR, the foliage in the front would be way OOF and would really ruin the photo as it is right there staring at you OOF, like it is in the f2.8 image. Your sample photo at f11 doesn't look objectionable, but is probably as good as you're going to get with such an extreme wide angle lens.
Just don't think that this lens is perfect for every situation, no lens is, just some are better than others and when I say some are better than others, they will be better at a specific task/distance/focal length/aperture or whatever and another lens at other specific tasks. The thing is, under about 24mm it is really tough to design a lens that can do everything perfectly, especially when talking about a zoom amd at the lens's extreme ends like at 15mm with the Tamron or 16mm for the Nikon 16-45 or 14mm for the Nikon 14-24. To be honest, I'd be happy with your f11 result as I think it's about as good as you're going to get. I think you're asking too much of an extreme wide angle lens.
as a guide, I generally focus further into the photo allowing for the inherent DOF of such a wide angle lens to help with keeping the foreground subject matter in focus which will also help with the edges as you are pushing focus back into the photo. I do not use live view.
p.3 #13Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
One of the strengths of the 14-24 is that it uses the same SWM as the 24-70 allowing it to focus super fast. The 14-24 is the fastest focusing Ultra wide by any manufacturer by a long margin.
p.3 #14Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
RSHPhotography wrote:
One of the strengths of the 14-24 is that it uses the same SWM as the 24-70 allowing it to focus super fast. The 14-24 is the fastest focusing Ultra wide by any manufacturer by a long margin.
How is the Tamron's for us speed?
I've never noticed that it is slow, seems to focus fast enough for any slow moving buildings or landscapes that might try and get away at a moments notice. Lets put it this way, I own the Nikon 14-24, the Nikon 16-35 and the Tamron but haven't noticed any real AF speed differences between any of them.
p.3 #16Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
Lance B wrote:
Yes, field curvature would be causing what you are seeing. Not a lot you can do except work with it as it is generally more of a help than a hinderance, IMO. The issue is, if you didn't have it, then the ground close in would be horribly OOF but the sides might be ok. In your sample photo at DPR, the foliage in the front would be way OOF and would really ruin the photo as it is right there staring at you OOF, like it is in the f2.8 image. Your sample photo at f11 doesn't look objectionable, but is probably as good as you're going to get with such an extreme wide angle lens. ...Show more →
Thanks for the detailed reply, Lance. It's helpful for calibrating my expectations. As a followup, I checked over the images I took with the rental copy as well as my purchased copy. While both displayed the field curvature we're discussing here, the left/right edges on the rental at 15mm sharpened up much more nicely than the purchased copy. The dpreview images were from the rental, so I guess that's about what I should expect from a good copy.
On the flip side, the rental copy seemed to display left/right tilt at 30mm (visible with flat subjects closer up), while the purchased copy occasionally showed a left/right tilt at random -- maybe about a few percent chance of getting a noticeably tilted image, but not noticeable the rest of the time. If I hadn't been shooting a bunch of identical shots from a tripod, I could easily have dismissed it as user error.
I suppose the complexities of manufacturing UWA zooms mean that every copy will have its individual quirks, but I didn't like the random chance of tilt or the bad edges on my copy. So it's off to the exchange lottery...
p.3 #17Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
RSHPhotography wrote:
One of the strengths of the 14-24 is that it uses the same SWM as the 24-70 allowing it to focus super fast. The 14-24 is the fastest focusing Ultra wide by any manufacturer by a long margin.
How is the Tamron's for us speed?
I have no complaints at all, however I do wonder why fast focus would even be required for a WA lens ? Most of the time it's on a tripod and manually focused anyway but when handheld WA lenses tend to focus fast anyway considering how much of the frame is going to be in focus !
p.3 #18Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
infimum wrote: Lance B wroteYes, field curvature would be causing what you are seeing. Not a lot you can do except work with it as it is generally more of a help than a hinderance, IMO. The issue is, if you didn't have it, then the ground close in would be horribly OOF but the sides might be ok. In your sample photo at DPR, the foliage in the front would be way OOF and would really ruin the photo as it is right there staring at you OOF, like it is in the f2.8 image. Your sample photo at f11 doesn't look objectionable, but is probably as good as you're going to get with such an extreme wide angle lens.Thanks for the detailed reply, Lance. It's helpful for calibrating my expectations. As a followup, I checked over the images I took with the rental copy as well as my purchased copy. While both displayed the field curvature we're discussing here, the left/right edges on the rental at 15mm sharpened up much more nicely than the purchased copy. The dpreview images were from the rental, so I guess that's about what I should expect from a good copy.
On the flip side, the rental copy seemed to display left/right tilt at 30mm (visible with flat subjects closer up), while the purchased copy occasionally showed a left/right tilt at random -- maybe about a few percent chance of getting a noticeably tilted image, but not noticeable the rest of the time. If I hadn't been shooting a bunch of identical shots from a tripod, I could easily have dismissed it as user error.
I suppose the complexities of manufacturing UWA zooms mean that every copy will have its individual quirks, but I didn't like the random chance of tilt or the bad edges on my copy. So it's off to the exchange lottery... ...Show more →
The unfortunate result of these complex lens designs.
p.3 #19Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
I don't know...did I get a "flawless copy" ?? See pics..just kidding BTW
Story here is this: cleaned D800 earlier the same day and bumped it to SPOT metering. Daylight was fading and all my shots were nearly too dark to see after I checked them at home. I didn't even peek at LCD and never knew I had royally screwed up. The incredible sensor that D800 carries helped me recover shadows and scene.
Does my copy appear to have uniform sharpness, guys? Again, just kidding. You can't tell from these 3 shots anyhow, but I'm happy with it
p.3 #20Thoughts on Tamron 15-30 f2.8 VC after two weeks travel photos
JimFox wrote:
These photos are just way too big. I don't think we need to pixel peep? It's taking forever to load the photos, and the worst thing is the text now doesn't word wrap to fit the screen, each line goes out as far as your photos do, which means to read what you wrote I would have to keep sliding the bottom scroll bar back and forth and back and forth.
Needless to say I didn't read what you wrote as it was too hard to read. It would have been interesting I am sure, but when things are just too much trouble to access or read, a lot of us just won't do it.
BTW, for those that want or feel the need to pixel peep, then post these on Pbase or some other site dedicated to photo hosting, and people can go there to look at them. Or just post them here at a lower resolution and then post a few 100% crops?