fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...

  
 
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.27 #1Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...

JaKo wrote:
Again and again, why some Leica users really need to bring Sony into Leica thread discussion? No one cares about 0.1mm on under-resolutioned M8/M9/M24 MP [just check LUF images sized to camouflage] so skip the 'sony envy' please.


I'm having mixed feelings reading between the lines to determine whether I should feel slighted by your comments...

That 0.1mm seems to be relevant if it's the thickness difference between current M cameras and the SL and turns out to be the primary factor in why the newest M lens actually performs better on the SL.

As an M user who is interested in the 28 Lux, yes, I do consider this somewhat of a betrayal by Leica if it was indeed intentional. Maybe future M bodies will have thicker sensor glass, as speculated, and that future M glass will be designed to this specification is only logical, if unfortunate for those unwilling or unable to upgrade. Though of course the new glass will deliver very usable, if not optimum image quality, on past digital M bodies.

Anyway, I agree about looking forward to real world, real user results from the SL...
Nov 26, 2015 at 12:58 AM
Mitch Alland
Offline
Details
p.27 #2Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Steve Spencer wrote:
Well there was a rumour this week on Leica rumours posted earlier in the thread that Leica will be coming out with a new 28 cron. I think that is certainly a distinct possibility, but we will know more before long. The 28 cron is 15 years old and it was designed 5 years before the first Leica digital M, so I think it is safe to say it was designed to be used on film...


On the other hand, Leica may issue a "newish" Summicron-28 merely to replace the atrocious lens hood that the current one comes with. As for the advantages of lenses designed for digital, whatever that means, I find it hard to find a 50mm more to my liking than my 1959 DR-Summicron.

Edited on Nov 28, 2015 at 03:51 AM · View previous versions
Nov 26, 2015 at 02:16 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.27 #3Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
SL+Zoom in hand.. You're welcome to ask me whatever.
Nov 26, 2015 at 02:54 AM
Jon Tainton
Offline
Details
p.27 #4Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
uhoh7 wrote:
Jon Tainton wroteAh, this insightful user review http://www.photoclubalpha.com/2015/10/29/sony-a7r-ii-review-by-david-kilpatrick/ may shed some light on the sub par performance of lenses on the Sony A7 series

The E/FE lens-body system is built round a concept of achieving final accuracy in alignment and focus without needing precision in every component. The nominal 18mm mount to sensor register doesn’t have to be perfect (and seems to vary by at least ±0.1mm). All Sony E and FE mount lenses compensate for variations and use free-floating magnetic focus often combined with floating OSS – they don’t have fixed infinity stops. Just as the bodies don’t have to be all that precise, the lenses themselves don’t need to be. As long as both work with the sensor to AF perfectly, the overall system is self-correcting.'

'So, one overall issue is that despite the high cost, the Sony FE/A7 series range of bodies and lenses lacks the precision engineering of past systems and it’s designed that way. When you find one side of your pictures always seems soft with wide-angle, wide zoom or very fast lenses you have encountered the limitations of Sony precision and quality control.'
This guy is pretty savy, I have been a member on his forum for years, though I rarely post. He may be on to something.

He has been using the DSLR sonys for a long time, and those guys are usually clear eyed about the A7x.
.......
Steve Huff is now smitten:




If I understand David Kirkpatrick's comments correctly on the innovative design philosophy of a tolerance lottery, Zeiss will need to design their FE mount, manual focusing lenses with hard stops that focus past infinity and deploy the engineering euphemism of 'thermal expansion'. I'm guessing that Zeiss's marketing material for their FE mount lenses won't feature the catchphrase 'To infinity and beyond' as the connotations are too painful.

Ah, the Huff vid seemed to spend no little time explaining the SL engineering qualities and the prospect of a 5-10 year camera life of joyful photography, apparently alien concepts to his followers, who do appear to be getting somewhat 'chippy' in their comments.
Nov 26, 2015 at 03:51 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.27 #5Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
adamdewilde wrote:
SL+Zoom in hand.. You're welcome to ask me whatever.


Hi Adam,

Can you you move the magnification function from the bottom left to the top right or better yet the front button?
Nov 26, 2015 at 06:17 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.27 #6Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Steve Spencer wrote:
adamdewilde wroteSL+Zoom in hand.. You're welcome to ask me whatever.
Hi Adam,

Can you you move the magnification function from the bottom left to the top right or better yet the front button?



Hi Steve,

No you can't. But I don't see why it couldn't be built into a later version of the firmware.
Personally I don't think magnification is as necessary with the SL as it is with other EVF cameras.
Nov 26, 2015 at 09:09 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.27 #7Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
adamdewilde wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
adamdewilde wroteSL+Zoom in hand.. You're welcome to ask me whatever.
Hi Adam,

Can you you move the magnification function from the bottom left to the top right or better yet the front button?
Hi Steve,

No you can't. But I don't see why it couldn't be built into a later version of the firmware.
Personally I don't think magnification is as necessary with the SL as it is with other EVF cameras.


Hi Adam,

I don't know about that. I missed focus with the camera and my tripod mounted Leica R 280mm f4 Apo Telyt lens when we tried it at PhotoPlus on October 22.

Rich
Nov 26, 2015 at 09:20 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.27 #8Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...

Steve Spencer wrote:
uhoh7 wrote
Steve Spencer wroteCharlie, it is appearing--to me at least--that the division of what works on the SL is whether the lens was designed for film or digital. The 35 cron ASPH, the 28 Elmarit ASPH, and the 28 cron ASPH all show some pretty serious decrements in performance but were clearly designed for film. All the other lenses 50mm and wider that are currently available, were made since Leica switched to digital (i.e., 2006). It is looking like all of these lenses (and of course the one's longer than 50mm) will work fine with the SL. We also know that Leica made the 28 Lux ASPH so that it works better with the SL than the M, and there is rumor of a new 28 cron ASPH coming out before too long.

It sure looks to me like the new M will have the same glass as the SL (perhaps the M262 as well) and that this new cover glass will become the standard for Leica. If they replace the 28 cron ASPH and the 35 cron ASPH, (and perhaps a slower 28) then all their current M lenses will work just fine with the SL and the new M. The current M lenses will all be post digital (except for the 90 cron ASPH and 135 Elmar APO, which hardly matter although I wouldn't be shocked to see these updated too).

So, I think the thicker cover glass of the SL is the way of the future, but obviously for some who prefer the older glass either a modified Sony or an M9 or M240 might be a nice option.
Please bring me up to speed here:

So, we know the SL has a thicker cover.......how? We know the 28 Lux was designed for the SL, how? Not saying you are wrong on either point, but what is the source? As to Sean Reid, who I having nothing against at all, how does he know the cover thickness on the M240? It's too bad Leica does not just tell us these things. It's not like cover thickness is some secret formula for the atomic bomb.

As to designed for film or digital concept and various lenses. The 28 cron and 28 elmarit are totally different designs, and the cron is the stronger for digital cameras, is my impression. Nevertheless both are fine on the M9 and 240, in fact the cron is far beyond fine. It is great. Is it weak on the SL?

The 35/2 ASPH is also very good on M9 and 240, nevermind some grumbling posts here and there which really are about the render. At f/2 it's fantastic. And despite mid-zone dips, it shoots very good landscapes once you stop down aways, and such a small lens. Sean finds it weak on the SL, how so?

There "design for film/digtial" and there is just "design", both will vary film v digital, more or less.

There may be other filter issues, e.g. low pass, which have been tweaked on the SL to enhance video, and perhaps there are other anti-moire tweaks on the SL, which may have an effect.

anyway these are interesting issues about which I am very curious.

I don't expect copy and past from behind paywall's but some paraphrasing will only help Sean and/or LLoyd's reputation.
Here is what we know from various tests. The 28 elmarit ASPH shows worse corner performance on the SL than the M240. We know this from 3 sources. Jono Slack has posted images showing this on the Leica Forum. Another poster in the link that Hiep originally posted and I reposted found the same thing, and those who have seen it say Sean Reid has shown the same thing. We also know that the 35 cron ASPH has worse corner performance on the SL than the M240. We know this from the link I reposted earlier and from Sean
...Show more →

The 28 lux was released last year as part of a limited edition M set in May I believe. This year it was made available more widley apart from a set. Hard to say or speculate if the Lux's design was for the SL imo given it's original special edition M set release. In a way,that would seem odd.
Nov 26, 2015 at 10:08 AM
davewolfs
Offline
Details
p.27 #9Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Why is it so difficult for any camera maker using an EVF to show both a zoomed version and actual composition on same screen. Silly that Leica doesn't allow the zoom function to be moved from left side.

I'm not buying the zoom not necessary argument. At least for my eyes.
Nov 26, 2015 at 10:28 AM
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.27 #10Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
rscheffler wrote: I'm having mixed feelings reading between the lines to determine whether I should feel slighted by your comments...

You shouldn’t, unless you’re one of those who constantly claim that every Sony A7x model is flawed by design because it is not perfectly working with some Leica-M lenses, or one of those who attach names to Sony and its designers because they create sensor stacks that work best with Sony lenses instead of other brands.
Adopting alt lenses on x-platform camera bodies is our hobby and we can’t blame hardware manufacturers for our failed hopes. This has been written long time before the release of Sony mirrorless FF two years ago.

Now it seems that Leica SL takes the heat for its compatibility with older M glass. SL, just like the S was designed to work with its own line of lenses. Perhaps the M --> SL adapter gave wrong hopes, but the new Summilux-SL 50 should be a clue.
Bummer, as the SL would be a better option for me than Kolari-modifying each new Sony A7x model. Betrayal? Not really, but surely disappointing from alt POV.
Nov 26, 2015 at 11:00 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.27 #11Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
adamdewilde wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
adamdewilde wroteSL+Zoom in hand.. You're welcome to ask me whatever.
Hi Adam,

Can you you move the magnification function from the bottom left to the top right or better yet the front button?
Hi Steve,

No you can't. But I don't see why it couldn't be built into a later version of the firmware.
Personally I don't think magnification is as necessary with the SL as it is with other EVF cameras.


Thanks Adam. I do hope they fix that with an upgrade. I think it depends on the lens whether you will want/need magnification. In the 35 to 90 range at f/2 or narrower you might do just fine without it, but I suspect Rich is right for a lens like the 280 Telyt APO. It might be useful for wide angles as well.

Individual ability and vision might matter too. I suspect I will want to use magnification even with the excellent EVF, because my vision is only about 20:40 close up even with correction, but I am not surprised that you can get good results without using it. Anyway, thanks for the report.
Nov 26, 2015 at 12:02 PM
uhoh7
Offline
Details
p.27 #12Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
edwardkaraa wrote:
Charlie, the benefits of a slightly thicker cover are quite obvious. Better IR filtration, less breakage tendency, auto sensor cleaning. The thin cover has caused Leica huge problems with the M8/9.

But no problems at all with the M240. And Kolari is now using .8mm

The M9 simply had the wrong glass and interface with the sensor. Looks like they have now solved it but we will wee.

Auto sensor cleaning is a non-issue. My A7.mod requires no more and cleaning than the original, and a blower is better than the shaker anyway.

As to IR, where are the problems with M240, or D810? Sure in certain studio circumstances, tungsten light some might want a filter. It can be added. If this was a huge issue the camera would not be loved by so many. The upside is great clean files in most natural light.

"I do see some IR contamination when very deep shadows are opened up, but the M isn’t alone in this regard, and I’m talking six stops or more below 18%." Michael Reichmann

Do you have a problem with this, Edward?

As to breakage, yes the thin glass will break easier. It happens, but rarely, so one must take care.

Decisions, choices have upsides and downsides. The upsides for improved handling of steep ray angles outweigh the downsides, both today and in the future. Today, we can use all our favorite film lenses to best advantage, and tommorrow we can have some small fast zooms

The very fact we are all chasing this trait should tell us something.
Nov 26, 2015 at 01:00 PM
uhoh7
Offline
Details
p.27 #13Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
JaKo wrote:
Charlie, perhaps this is a good point in time [2015] to consider that Leica M glass enthusiasts who admire Leica glow, Mandler’s look, hazy/painterly transitions may not necessarily be the primary target for Leica’s new opening stores.

You and many alike may be troubled by the possibility of Leica is going forward and this time they maybe parting with the idea of compatibility with old M39/M lenses. But let’s face it, it’s all about $$$ after all and Leica is frequently ‘Under New Management’ to stay in business.

Consider this; some new Leica digital camera buyers get brand spanking new M240/MP and
...Show more →

I always enjoy your posts, and they usually have me thinking Here is one vey obvious clue that Leica will not desert the M lovers with collections big and small: Look at the M240. Look at the M262. Spitting image really of the M2. Now I really don't care about that, it's the lens friendly aspect which is paramount, but obviously Leica is terrified to leave this look. That should tell you something.

If Leica wants a fully "modern" camera, the M mount itself has to go. Now, Sony has proven some will just accept they need a whole new bunch of lenses. Fuji has made a system from the ground up. There is the Leica compact.

The most forward thinking move would be to make a very compact T mount or a new mount with an entirely new lenset, on the "interchangeable Q" theme, which would still do M, but allow for modern light sealing and AF, etc. That's a bit ambitious, though.

@Steve
Well I think we have perhaps settled on a common belief when it comes to the ray angle issue, and now I understand your views, and nuances better
Nov 26, 2015 at 01:48 PM
flash
Offline
Details
p.27 #14Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
uhoh7 wrote:
edwardkaraa wroteCharlie, the benefits of a slightly thicker cover are quite obvious. Better IR filtration, less breakage tendency, auto sensor cleaning. The thin cover has caused Leica huge problems with the M8/9.
But no problems at all with the M240. And Kolari is now using .8mm

The M9 simply had the wrong glass and interface with the sensor. Looks like they have now solved it but we will wee.

Auto sensor cleaning is a non-issue. My A7.mod requires no more and cleaning than the original, and a blower is better than the shaker anyway.

As to IR, where are the problems with M240, or D810? Sure in certain studio circumstances, tungsten light some might want a filter. It can be added. If this was a huge issue the camera would not be loved by so
...Show more →

As someone who shoots people more than hills it's certainly an issue for me. Even with UV/IR filters on my lenses I get uncorrectable shots with IR contamination. Furthermore some lenses, especially ultra wides can't use IR filters. Landscape photographers like Reichman won't see it but street and portrait photographers will have to deal with it, often.

Also, and I don't know if it's related, I have significantly lower levels of purple fringing on my Noctilux (and Summilux) on my new SL than any of my M's. I was actually close to selling my Noctilux because I wasn't using it on the M's. On the SL it's so much better. Some slight blue fringing but very little nasty purple fringing at all. It's a fantastic combination.

Gordon
Nov 26, 2015 at 02:09 PM
uhoh7
Offline
Details
p.27 #15Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
flash wrote:
uhoh7 wrote
edwardkaraa wroteCharlie, the benefits of a slightly thicker cover are quite obvious. Better IR filtration, less breakage tendency, auto sensor cleaning. The thin cover has caused Leica huge problems with the M8/9.
But no problems at all with the M240. And Kolari is now using .8mm

The M9 simply had the wrong glass and interface with the sensor. Looks like they have now solved it but we will wee.

Auto sensor cleaning is a non-issue. My A7.mod requires no more and cleaning than the original, and a blower is better than the shaker anyway.

As to IR, where are the problems with M240, or D810? Sure in certain studio circumstances, tungsten light some might want a filter. It can be added. If this was a huge issue the camera would not be loved by so many. The upside is great clean files in most natural light.

"I do see some IR contamination when very deep shadows are opened up, but the M isn’t alone in this regard, and I’m talking six stops or more below 18%." Michael Reichmann

Do you have a problem with this, Edward?

As to breakage, yes the thin glass will break easier. It happens, but rarely, so one must take care.

Decisions, choices have upsides and downsides. The upsides for improved handling of steep ray angles outweigh the downsides, both today and in the future. Today, we can use all our favorite film lenses to best advantage, and tommorrow we can have some small fast zooms

The very fact we are all chasing this trait should tell us something.
As someone who shoots people more than hills it's certainly an issue for me. Even with UV/IR filters on my lenses I get uncorrectable shots with IR contamination. Furthermore some lenses, especially ultra wides can't use IR filters. Landscape photographers like Reichman won't see it but street and portrait photographers will have to deal with it, often.

Also, and I don't know if it's related, I have significantly lower levels of purple fringing on my Noctilux (and Summilux) on my new SL than any of my M's. I was actually close to selling my Noctilux because I wasn't using it on
...Show more →

Gordon, that's very interesting and might explain some of these choices. When you have a chance can you post some examples of IR contamination from the 240?
Nov 26, 2015 at 04:46 PM
flash
Offline
Details
p.27 #16Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
I'll have to hunt for samples. Most of the uncorrectable ones get deleted pretty quickly. All the M's have IR issues. The M8 was the worst and well documented. The M9 is the best but not great. The M240 is somewhere in-between the M8 and M9.

If I come across any I'll post them up.

Gordon
Nov 26, 2015 at 05:37 PM
flash
Offline
Details
p.27 #17Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Here's an example of the difference I'm seeing in finding between the M and SL regarding purple fringing. Both with same Noctilux at 0.95. Crap photos but they'll give you an idea of the differences. M is on top.

Blue2.jpg by Gordon Cahill, on Flickr

Blue1.jpg by Gordon Cahill, on Flickr

Edit: here's the Noctilux on the A7R2

Blue3 A7R2.jpg by Gordon Cahill, on Flickr

Gordon

Edited on Nov 26, 2015 at 08:11 PM · View previous versions
Nov 26, 2015 at 05:53 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.27 #18Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
naturephoto1 wrote:
adamdewilde wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
adamdewilde wroteSL+Zoom in hand.. You're welcome to ask me whatever.
Hi Adam,

Can you you move the magnification function from the bottom left to the top right or better yet the front button?
Hi Steve,

No you can't. But I don't see why it couldn't be built into a later version of the firmware.
Personally I don't think magnification is as necessary with the SL as it is with other EVF cameras.
Hi Adam,

I don't know about that. I missed focus with the camera and my tripod mounted Leica R 280mm f4 Apo Telyt lens when we tried it at PhotoPlus on October 22.

Rich


I said "I don't think magnification is AS necessary". Of course results may vary. Individual scene, skill level, luck etc. But it's not AS necessary as with other EVF cameras I've used.


Gordon - I'll have to test for this.. Sounds promising from what you've been describing.
Nov 26, 2015 at 06:44 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.27 #19Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
flash wrote:
Here's an example of the difference I'm seeing in finding between the M and SL regarding purple fringing. Both with same Noctilux at 0.95. Crap photos but they'll give you an idea of the differences. M is on top.

https://farm1.staticflickr.com/566/22705758144_e7e7850e8f_h.jpgBlue2.jpg by Gordon Cahill, on Flickr

https://farm6.staticflickr.com/5647/22705763904_cf0cb53485_h.jpgBlue1.jpg by Gordon Cahill, on Flickr

Gordon


Excellent news! The SL does appear to have less purple fringing/CA issues and very usable.

With my 50 Nocti f/1.0 and 75 Lux, the M9/MM were the best, some CA on the M240, at times unusable, fine on the A7s but the worst on the A7rII where the CA/purple fringing in effect made the image unusable with any back lighting.

There are obviously many factors that affect the performance of lenses in combination with the newer sensors and not just the sensor glass cover thickness.
Nov 26, 2015 at 07:03 PM
hiepphotog
Offline
Details
p.27 #20Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
flash wrote:
Here's an example of the difference I'm seeing in finding between the M and SL regarding purple fringing. Both with same Noctilux at 0.95. Crap photos but they'll give you an idea of the differences. M is on top.

https://farm1.staticflickr.com/566/22705758144_e7e7850e8f_h.jpgBlue2.jpg by Gordon Cahill, on Flickr

https://farm6.staticflickr.com/5647/22705763904_cf0cb53485_h.jpgBlue1.jpg by Gordon Cahill, on Flickr

Gordon


I think this has to do with the tone curve. It just means that the highlights get blown-out more in the M.
Nov 26, 2015 at 08:06 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister