Been playing around witha 5Ds loaner for a few days, some things I notice in comparison to the 5D2:
- much faster shutter lag/black out times.
- no more banding, even when pushing the shadows slider to +100 in LR.
- Still purple/green areas when opening up shadows (to the max), but way less than with 5D2
- 5Ds RAW files seem more contrasty when opening up in LR
- MRAW and SRAW fall apart together much earlier in (heavy) post than RAW (same for 5D2 IIRC)
- overall faster shutterspeeds are needed when shooting handheld (minimum of 2x FL)
- ISO1600/3200 looks good (similar to 5D2) when downsizing the 50MP files to 20-30MP
- more complicated than the 5D2 to master (all the AF capabilities)
5DS minimum handheld shutter speeds can actually be lowered because the mirror box is substantially better and because you have the 1/8 or 1/4 or more extra shutter lag options.
Minimum handheld shutter speeds need to be increased only if you are enlarging more, such as by viewing at 100%.
On the other hand, one of the reasons (but far from only reason) to get the 5DS is to enlarge more, including possibly printing bigger.
But if you are printing or viewing an image at the same image dimensions (say 19 x 13 inches or say 30 x 20 inches), then the amount of camera shake will be the same among all full-frame sensor/film cameras (discounting 5DS mirror box advantage).
killersnowman wrote:
Let me say this... The 5dsr is better at every iso, at full resolution, than the 5d2 is at its full resolution and equivalent iso. .
The 5dsr is better without downressing
I don't know about the 5Dsr, only about the 5Ds... and it is a better camera than the 5D2 for sure in every respect. Well, maybe I like the grip on the 5D2 better
But you can't compare full res 20MP files to 50MP files for noise IMO.
Looking at pixel level (50MP vs 20MP) I don't think the 5Ds ISO1600-3200 files are better than the 5D2 for noise.
My 5DSR arrived a couple of weeks ago, so I'm still exploring it. So far it looks like battery usage is similar to my 7DII: around Canon's low-end spec if used for individual shots spaced a bit—landscapes, for example. Go to bursts and the images/charge go up dramatically. When I'm shooting a large macro stack (click, wait a fraction of a second, then click again), I get several hundred shots/charge. Shooting wildlife/birds in short bursts, I get more/charge (haven't used an entire charge yet, so don't know "how many", but it's more than with a macro stack. Shoot individual images and it's around 200-300 shots/charge. The 5DSR and 7DII battery usage isn't nearly as predictable as my 1D3/1D4 bodies.
Image quality has surprised me. Nowhere near the noise I expected. I just shot a series of deer at dusk, ISO 3200, and noise was acceptable for most of my uses. Noise at ISO 100-400 is very good unless you're pixel peeping. DR is also better than I'd anticipated and for me, is more than adequate for 98% or so of what I shoot.
Regarding picture style: I read a piece of Canon's literature that said picture style is read/used for Raw images processed by DPP and other Canon software. Capture One (my Raw processor), ACR and others don't use it as far as I can tell.
Cropping: The camera only crops JPEGs. If you want smaller Raw files, it's mRaw/sRaw; if you want to crop, shoot the full Raw and crop as desired.
I think an overlooked feature is he ability to set shutter delays in MLU. Also, the AF system is outstanding, even in low light such as deep dusk. Low light focusing seems more accurate and faster than my 1D4.
Consider renting a 5DS and trying it under your own shooting conditions.
Coming from a 5D Mk II, the 5DS is not exactly a revelation, but just a better camera in most every respect. Like going from a Mercedes C-class to an E-class, or BMW 3-series to a 5-series. Having skipped the 5D Mk III there are some body/ergonomics things to get used to plus the overwhelming AF options menu (actually, the menus in general). But overall, as others have said, I wouldn’t go back to a Mk II certainly (I sold my Mk II and a Sony A7S and some lenses to fund the 5DS purchase).
Reaching back a little further, to film days, I shot mostly 6x7 (aka “67”) on a variety of cameras (Mamiya RZ, Mam7, Pentax 67) and if you’re coming from this background I have to say there is a striking similarity between 5DS files and 67 negs. scanned on an Imacon. They (Canon) seemed to have thought of this too: if you display the 6x4 gridlines in the viewfinder, the first set of grid lines in from the edges (horizontally) correspond almost exactly to 67 film’s aspect ratio (1.16:1).
Furthermore, you can add cropping information for image review and Live View shooting. Crucially, this cropping info. is written into the the metadata and is respected by ACR/Lightroom when you bring the files into post. For the cropping info. (only available in Live View or image review), there are a wealth of options available from 6x6, 4x5, 6x7, 5x7, etc.
This is HUGE (for me) and much better than the competing solutions from e.g. Nikon on the D8xx series. I’m currently using the gridlines to frame for a 6x7 AR and setting cropping info. to 4x5 to give a little extra “breathing room” around the crop in post. I’m very happy.
One of the reasons I didn’t upgrade to the 5D Mk III (and maybe it had all these features too, I don’t know) was that the focusing screen couldn’t be replaced and I had a Brightscreen in my 5D Mk II with 4x5 crop marks etched into it for framing. I have multiple long term projects which I began on film (4x5 large format and 67 med. format) and now I can add files from the 5DS to these projects and everything sequences very well together with the (massive) extra resolution and framing/cropping options. As I said, I’m very happy with this camera so far (about 1 week in)!
geoffsm wrote:
Coming from a 5D Mk II, the 5DS is not exactly a revelation, but just a better camera in most every respect.
That sums up my initial positive reaction to my 5DsR. In every way (except possibly burst mode frame rate) it seems at least as good and mostly better than my 5D2, a camera that served my very well. But it also seems very comfortable and familiar to me, which is exactly what I want — I basically picked it up and started using it with little need to relearn things.
It seems I need +40 shadow adjustments for the 5Ds in LR to match a 5D2 file. The 5Ds RAW files look much more contrasty than the 5D2 RAW files in LR. Anyone else noticed this?
I think it is because the 5DS has more dynamic range and there may be some variation among Raw converters. I've been enjoying the crunchiness of the 5DS and loving what can be brought out in the shadows.
Monito wrote:
I think it is because the 5DS has more dynamic range and there may be some variation among Raw converters. I've been enjoying the crunchiness of the 5DS and loving what can be brought out in the shadows.
I almost always raise the "shadows" value some, and in quite a few cases I raise it a lot. There is no one-size-fits-all recipe for conversion, but I often increase contrast a bit, lower highlights, and raise shadows.
Monito wrote:
I think it is because the 5DS has more dynamic range and there may be some variation among Raw converters. I've been enjoying the crunchiness of the 5DS and loving what can be brought out in the shadows.
I noticed there is much difference in contrast/color in how LR and Canon (DPP) handle the RAW files.
The 5D2 RAW files are more 'flat', meaning the blacks are more open and the highlights are toned down in comparison to the 5Ds RAW files in LR. It certainly takes a different approach in post. But the 5Ds shadows can indeed be opened up without much penalties (which is not the case with 5D2 RAW files).
Daan B wrote:
It seems I need +40 shadow adjustments for the 5Ds in LR to match a 5D2 file. The 5Ds RAW files look much more contrasty than the 5D2 RAW files in LR. Anyone else noticed this?
That's a bug in LR. There's threads around the web how to fix it.
skid00skid00 wrote: Daan B wroteIt seems I need +40 shadow adjustments for the 5Ds in LR to match a 5D2 file. The 5Ds RAW files look much more contrasty than the 5D2 RAW files in LR. Anyone else noticed this?That's a bug in LR. There's threads around the web how to fix it.
That would explain why the 5Ds files look so different from 5D2/3 files in LR. I have searched the internet and came across a few mentioning this also, but no threads with solutions. Care to share some of the threads where the fix is explained? Thanks!
"We deliberately used a stronger tone curve (more contrast) when building the Adobe Standard color profiles for the Canon EOS 5DS and 5DS R. It is similar to the tone curve in the Camera Standard color profile. This makes the images have more "pop" though as you've observed, shadow areas may have less visible detail (by default)."
Daan B wrote:
It's no bug... Eric Chan from Adobe:
"We deliberately used a stronger tone curve (more contrast) when building the Adobe Standard color profiles for the Canon EOS 5DS and 5DS R. It is similar to the tone curve in the Camera Standard color profile. This makes the images have more "pop" though as you've observed, shadow areas may have less visible detail (by default)."
Daan B wrote:
It's no bug... Eric Chan from Adobe:
"We deliberately used a stronger tone curve (more contrast) when building the Adobe Standard color profiles for the Canon EOS 5DS and 5DS R. It is similar to the tone curve in the Camera Standard color profile. This makes the images have more "pop" though as you've observed, shadow areas may have less visible detail (by default)."