fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20155Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?

  
 
Daan B
Offline

p.1 #15Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Thinking about adding a 5Ds (r) to my kit. My main camera/reference the past years is the 5D2. So...

How would the 5Ds (r) compare to the 5D2 for ISO when used at the same resolution (20 MP)? For example when down-sizing in post.

And I assume the same shutterspeeds I use with the 5D2 will be sufficient when using the 5Ds (r) at the same resolution?

How about dynamic range: does the 5Ds (r) still suffer from vertical and horizontal banding in the shadows (when pushing), like the 5D2?

Thanks!
Sep 29, 2015 at 09:46 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.1 #25Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
My 5DsR replaced my 5DII. (Actually, I kept the 5DII, so far at least, as a backup/second body.)

If your goal is to create 20MP raw files, I'm not sure that it makes sense to upgrade. The advantage of the 5Ds(R) is largely (though not quite only) its ability to produce higher resolution images that will make larger prints with excellent quality.

That aside...

I don't see any banding in photographs from the 5DsR and the dynamic range seems quite good to me. I often push things significantly in post when appropriate without problems. (Since I'm sure it will come up — been there, done that — yes, Nikon and Sony sensors are the current dynamic range champions, but the 5DsR has a very wide dynamic range, too.)

There is a popular misconception floating around that you must use higher shutter speeds with higher resolution cameras. However, if you are making prints of some particular size, you can use exactly the same shutter speeds whether you are shooting 21MP raw files or 50.6MP raw files and your prints will not be affected any differently by camera or subject motion. (If your goal is to produce significantly larger prints, attending to all factors that affect sharpness becomes increasingly important.)

Good luck.

Dan
Sep 29, 2015 at 10:19 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.1 #35Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Daan B wrote:
Thinking about adding a 5Ds (r) to my kit. My main camera/reference the past years is the 5D2. So...

How would the 5Ds (r) compare to the 5D2 for ISO when used at the same resolution (20 MP)? For example when down-sizing in post.


The 5DS will look a little better.


And I assume the same shutterspeeds I use with the 5D2 will be sufficient when using the 5Ds (r) at the same resolution?


I haven't tested that, but would assume it, yes.


How about dynamic range: does the 5Ds (r) still suffer from vertical and horizontal banding in the shadows (when pushing), like the 5D2?

Thanks!


No, the vertical and horizontal banding does not appear any more.
Sep 29, 2015 at 10:20 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.1 #45Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
I have a 5D2 that I used for a few years until it got relegated to backup when I got the 5DS.

5DS photos downsized to 5D2 size (or printed same size) look a little cleaner, at least at sizes where noise is detectable. Sizes below that are (by definition) basically the same, though the 5DS photos may have a certain je ne sais quoi about them for a slight edge even if it is likely that skilled photographers could not reliably tell them apart in a 'double blind' set of A/B comparisons.

The 5DS/R can be cropped very significantly, which is a big advantage and for most people will be more useful than making super large prints. My impression (not tested) is that cropped 5DS photos are still cleaner than uncropped 5D2 photos.

Banding issues are gone, not seen. The 5DS/R shadows are lovely. You can push (and pull) the 5DS/R photos or sections more easily.

I used to avoid shooting the 5D2 above ISO 1250 unless it was the last resort. With the 5DS I am much more relaxed about going to 1600 and up.

Shutter speeds are only an issue if you crop significantly. If you shoot the 5DS and crop to 7D2 dimensions, you will have to up the shutter speed by crop-factor proportions (1.6x) to retain the same amount of blur as a percentage of picture dimensions.

But, and this is a big advantage, the 5DS shutter and mirror assembly are better than their predecessors. This means you can shoot at a bit lower shutter speed and more quietly. I haven't quantified it myself but it seems to be about 2/3 stop as a guess. (Yet another thing I should give a comprehensive test with or without the 5D2.)
Sep 29, 2015 at 11:08 AM
Ziffl3
Offline
Details
p.1 #55Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
There are several areas to look at your question:

Files out of camera:
I have the 5DIII a 1/2 step below the 1DX... but basically they are brothers in file quality.
The 5DII is a solid step or more below in workability/banding.... at 3200 and above.


The 5DS/R is right there with the 5DIII/1DX. It actually has better files as far as banding and workability than the 5DIII (I have to look into 1DX comparison at a wedding).
The 5DIII wins at high ISO when compared to the 5DS(R). ....ISO 4000+ we are talking about noise level.

5DS(R): Colors are very nice... in the canon world. Love the sharpness you will see straight out of camera.

Shooting experience:
Overall, night and day difference in comparison to the 5DII.
AF is solid and rocks. You can use all your AF points.... as in cross points.
Really nice selectable size of AF point.
Better menu layout + more software feature built into camera.

Nothing like pulling out a quick HDR image or a double exposure.

Ability to have 50meg sensor or shoot in M.

Dual slots for peace of mind. if that matter to you.

It is like a 2 generational jump in technology/software.

One down side.... either carry multiple batteries or grip the 5DS(R). Gripped camera will last through the entire wedding (all day).

-Mark
Sep 29, 2015 at 11:50 AM
Daan B
Offline
Details
p.1 #65Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Thanks guys!

High res (50 MP) will be used for studio/product/interior shooting. Low res (20mp or less) is for (low light) events.

I just want to be sure I can get both out of the camera without serious limitations
Sep 29, 2015 at 03:08 PM
Daan B
Offline
Details
p.1 #75Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Ziffl3 wrote:
One down side.... either carry multiple batteries or grip the 5DS(R). Gripped camera will last through the entire wedding (all day).


How much stills do you get from one full battery? Are these the same batteries the 5D2 uses?

Sep 29, 2015 at 03:09 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.1 #85Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Daan B wrote:
How much stills do you get from one full battery? Are these the same batteries the 5D2 uses?


I am getting about 200 per half (more or less, not exact) battery charge, with some (not a lot) of Live View and some IS. Other users will probably have more exact measures. I haven't checked the in-camera-menu battery report, so I might be using less than half a charge (I still have 2 of 4 bars on the indicator).

The 5DS/R also uses 5D2 and 5D3 batteries.
Sep 29, 2015 at 04:08 PM
Ziffl3
Offline
Details
p.1 #95Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Daan B wrote:
Ziffl3 wroteOne down side.... either carry multiple batteries or grip the 5DS(R). Gripped camera will last through the entire wedding (all day).
How much stills do you get from one full battery? Are these the same batteries the 5D2 uses?


Somewhere around 350-ish. maybe 400 tops.
I was able to get much better performance gripped. 1000+

-Mark

Sep 29, 2015 at 05:59 PM
gqllc007
Offline
Details
p.1 #105Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
When you shoot in RAW does it matter which picture style you choose? I thought in RAW it doesnt matter and it only gets applied to jpeg's? I read a review where the guy used neutral and used sharpen at "1'. Also is there a setting like 1.6X so the camera acts like a APS-c camera?
Sep 29, 2015 at 07:02 PM
dehowie
Offline
Details
p.1 #115Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Haven't used it without the grip but using IS on every shot and no live view easily netted 1500 images with reviews of images.
No banding at all.
Re DR it has all the DR I need and the ability to lift shadows is very good.
Extremely capable camera and the files just jump from detail.
Sep 29, 2015 at 07:31 PM
isaacimage
Offline
Details
p.1 #125Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Daan B wrote:
Ziffl3 wroteOne down side.... either carry multiple batteries or grip the 5DS(R). Gripped camera will last through the entire wedding (all day).
How much stills do you get from one full battery? Are these the same batteries the 5D2 uses?



800-900 shots per charge during event.
Lens used 24-70 & 70-200

Hope it helps
Sep 29, 2015 at 11:26 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.1 #135Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
gqllc007 wrote:
When you shoot in RAW does it matter which picture style you choose? I thought in RAW it doesnt matter and it only gets applied to jpeg's? I read a review where the guy used neutral and used sharpen at "1'. Also is there a setting like 1.6X so the camera acts like a APS-c camera?


Picture Style affects the HistoBlinkyMeter, but not the Raw image.

It matters little what Picture Style you use, so long as you use it consistently with Raw and learn by experience just how much pushing and pulling you can do or need to do relative to what you see on the rear LCD histogram (RGB) and checking for blinkies in the picture. Even so, it seems that Neutral or Faithful (I use the latter) and conservative settings are a good base for getting the most consistent information from the HistoBlinkyMeter.

The camera is like a musical instrument. If you blow too hard on a reed in a woodwind instrument you get a bad tone, but you want to have your reed always consistently at the same level of moisture when playing so you can know the limits and know when you are getting close. (I do not play woodwinds.)
Sep 30, 2015 at 01:46 PM
killersnowman
Offline
Details
p.1 #145Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Man i used a mk2 for a long time and i know the banding in shadows you are talking about... With that said, the 5dsr has non of that. Its high iso performance up to 6400 is actually really really really good. Its a better camera in every regard

Oct 01, 2015 at 08:06 AM
dclark2171
Offline
Details
p.1 #155Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
I am currently using the 5dii and shadows are downright ugly if you have to pull a little. I used the 5DS and the DR is much improved. However, also using a Nikon and A7R, the shadows are way smoother to my eyes if you pull a little. However, not enough to merit a switch.
Oct 01, 2015 at 10:07 AM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.1 #165Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Ziffl3 wrote:
The 5DIII wins at high ISO when compared to the 5DS(R). ....ISO 4000+ we are talking about noise level.



Having owned both, I would have to qualify that statement. If you are looking at pixel-level noise, then sure, you can argue the MkIII wins. If, however, you are looking at same-size prints (or output in general), then 5Ds/r, no question.
Oct 01, 2015 at 10:16 PM
mb126
Offline
Details
p.1 #175Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Jeff wrote:
Ziffl3 wroteThe 5DIII wins at high ISO when compared to the 5DS(R). ....ISO 4000+ we are talking about noise level.
Having owned both, I would have to qualify that statement. If you are looking at pixel-level noise, then sure, you can argue the MkIII wins. If, however, you are looking at same-size prints (or output in general), then 5Ds/r, no question.


Wow, that is pretty amazing.
Any idea why there was so little excitement when this thing came out? Seemed like everyone just said "yawn, looks like they stuck a 50mp sensor on a 5D3" at the time
Oct 02, 2015 at 10:24 AM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.1 #185Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?

mb126 wrote:
Wow, that is pretty amazing.
Any idea why there was so little excitement when this thing came out? Seemed like everyone just said "yawn, looks like they stuck a 50mp sensor on a 5D3" at the time


What is amazing?

They pretty much did stick a 50MP sensor in the MkIII and call it good; the intervalometer is nice to have built-in, but other than that, pretty much the same body (that eats batteries).

That being said, the difference in the sensor is dramatic; not so much the resolution, but the latitude in pulling shadow tones. The MkIII was a great camera that I relied on for nearly everything, but I wouldn't go back.
Oct 03, 2015 at 10:54 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.1 #195Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Jeff wrote:
That being said, the difference in the sensor is dramatic; not so much the resolution, but the latitude in pulling shadow tones. The MkIII was a great camera that I relied on for nearly everything, but I wouldn't go back.


This seems to be so extremely difficult to fathom for users who have not experience the 5DS R, especially those who have already got used to the excellent clean shadows from Sony. They think this improvement is insignficant because the DR measured per pixel is the same as before. The downsampling effect is very noticeable from 50 to 20 MP, and the quality, the distribution of the noise is so much nicer with the 5DS R to start with than previous 5D versions.
Oct 04, 2015 at 07:05 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.1 #205Ds at 20MP: noise and shutterspeeds?
Don't forget the completely new mirror box makes the camera more stable at slower shutter speeds. Just as a guess based on using the 5DS for a while, but not a specific test, I'd say the gain is about 2/3 stop. Might be more.

Over the 5D3, there is more than just 50 MPx vs 20 MPx. There is the mirror box, improved DR, the intervalometer, no banding, and several other tweaks and improvements.

But don't forget that the OP Daan asked about comparing it to the 5D2. It is even more of an improvement from my 5D2. For 5D2 owners, the 5DS/R is a brilliant upgrade.

Oct 04, 2015 at 07:59 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister