fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)

  
 
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.3 #1TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
secondclaw wrote:
Interesting! And EVF is off at that time also?

jhinkey wrote
secondclaw wroteBecause unlike an OLED display, an LCD monitor draws constant power regardless of 'color' on the screen.
A screen powered and all black, versus screen covered with lots of stuff, will have exactly same power draw.
An OLED display is different. Black color pixels draw no power, while colored pixels draw more power than LCD (that's why OLED is more power draining, unless it powers off a portion of its image).

If the back screen was OLED, when camera is exposing and blanking out the screen, there would indeed be power savings.

And a note - Deactivate Monitor only blanks it out, doesn't power it off.

dandrewk wrote
TheEmrys wroteOkay, these are the numbers from Gary Friedman's excellent book, where he slapped on a voltmeter to the a7:

---

Deactivate Monitor: No Power Savings

---
I think something may have been lost in translation here. How can there be zero power savings when the monitor is turned off? LCD screens require power, and the brighter the image the more power is being used. Even with the exposure info still shown, the rest of the screen is black.
Hmmm . . . when I deactivate the rear monitor on my A7RII the screen is absolutely dark - no light at all. When the monitor is on and showing black - you can see very low illumination. It looks to me that when I deactivate the monitor it is truly off. I can't say what the display electronics are doing - they may still be sucking power by sending display information signals to the monitor which is simply not displaying them because it's de-powered.


No, EVF is on when the proximity detector turns it on. Appears to be no light at all (not even any low level glow) when the EVF gets switched "off" by the eye detector.
Sep 02, 2015 at 12:01 AM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.3 #2TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
TheEmrys wrote:
It very well could be off. My post abo e was only for the a7/r and probably the s.

jhinkey wrote
secondclaw wroteBecause unlike an OLED display, an LCD monitor draws constant power regardless of 'color' on the screen.
A screen powered and all black, versus screen covered with lots of stuff, will have exactly same power draw.
An OLED display is different. Black color pixels draw no power, while colored pixels draw more power than LCD (that's why OLED is more power draining, unless it powers off a portion of its image).

If the back screen was OLED, when camera is exposing and blanking out the screen, there would indeed be power savings.

And a note - Deactivate Monitor only blanks it out, doesn't power it off.

dandrewk wrote
TheEmrys wroteOkay, these are the numbers from Gary Friedman's excellent book, where he slapped on a voltmeter to the a7:

---

Deactivate Monitor: No Power Savings

---
I think something may have been lost in translation here. How can there be zero power savings when the monitor is turned off? LCD screens require power, and the brighter the image the more power is being used. Even with the exposure info still shown, the rest of the screen is black.
Hmmm . . . when I deactivate the rear monitor on my A7RII the screen is absolutely dark - no light at all. When the monitor is on and showing black - you can see very low illumination. It looks to me that when I deactivate the monitor it is truly off. I can't say what the display electronics are doing - they may still be sending display information signals to the monitor which is simply not displaying them because it's de-powered.

I seem to recall from my A7R days that when the monitor was off, it was just displaying "black", but you would still see a glow from the light leakage.

Even in a completely dark room I cannot see any light from the rear monitor of the A7RII when it's either switched to the EVF or it's set to off in the menu.

Sep 02, 2015 at 12:04 AM
saintiwari
Offline
Details
p.3 #3TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
I thout that's not what the OP is saying. He is saying it will be completely off when you do that trick.

TheEmrys wrote:
Correct. It is "displaying" a black screen rather than turning it off.

Sep 02, 2015 at 09:54 AM
TheEmrys
Offline
Details
p.3 #4TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
Right, for the a7rII, not the a7, r or s.

saintiwari wrote:
I thout that's not what the OP is saying. He is saying it will be completely off when you do that trick.

TheEmrys wroteCorrect. It is "displaying" a black screen rather than turning it off.

Sep 02, 2015 at 10:55 AM
dandrewk
Offline
Details
p.3 #5TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
zlatko wrote:
dandrewk wroteYes, ALWAYS turn it off when not actively shooting, and you will save TONS of power.

This has never been more true since IBIS. If you generally walk around with the power on and lens cap off, your camera will try and stabilize your walking motion, full time. That sucks up a lot of power.
With the A7II, I get the impression that the IBIS is not always on, but only when you half press the shutter. But I may be wrong.


Right, <slaps forehead>, what I -meant- to say was:

Some folks have pre-focus set to "on". The combination of this setting, while walking round with lens cap off, camera on, will eat up a battery in a hurry.
Sep 02, 2015 at 05:00 PM
Stoffer
Offline
Details
p.3 #6TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
jhinkey wrote:
TheEmrys wroteIt very well could be off. My post abo e was only for the a7/r and probably the s.

jhinkey wrote
secondclaw wroteBecause unlike an OLED display, an LCD monitor draws constant power regardless of 'color' on the screen.
A screen powered and all black, versus screen covered with lots of stuff, will have exactly same power draw.
An OLED display is different. Black color pixels draw no power, while colored pixels draw more power than LCD (that's why OLED is more power draining, unless it powers off a portion of its image).

If the back screen was OLED, when camera is exposing and blanking out the screen, there would indeed be power savings.

And a note - Deactivate Monitor only blanks it out, doesn't power it off.

dandrewk wrote
TheEmrys wroteOkay, these are the numbers from Gary Friedman's excellent book, where he slapped on a voltmeter to the a7:

---

Deactivate Monitor: No Power Savings

---
I think something may have been lost in translation here. How can there be zero power savings when the monitor is turned off? LCD screens require power, and the brighter the image the more power is being used. Even with the exposure info still shown, the rest of the screen is black.
Hmmm . . . when I deactivate the rear monitor on my A7RII the screen is absolutely dark - no light at all. When the monitor is on and showing black - you can see very low illumination. It looks to me that when I deactivate the monitor it is truly off. I can't say what the display electronics are doing - they may still be sending display information signals to the monitor which is simply not displaying them because it's de-powered.
I seem to recall from my A7R days that when the monitor was off, it was just displaying "black", but you would still see a glow from the light leakage.

Even in a completely dark room I cannot see any light from the rear monitor of the A7RII when it's either switched to the EVF or it's set to off in the menu.



Intersting. Thanks for sharing. And thanks to the OP for the tip too.
Sep 03, 2015 at 01:02 AM
hiepphotog
Offline
Details
p.3 #7TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
TheEmrys wrote:
Right, for the a7rII, not the a7, r or s.

saintiwari wroteI thout that's not what the OP is saying. He is saying it will be completely off when you do that trick.

TheEmrys wroteCorrect. It is "displaying" a black screen rather than turning it off.


Make that the A7 and r then. My A7s LCD is completely off with this.
Sep 03, 2015 at 05:08 AM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.3 #8TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
Stoffer wrote:
jhinkey wrote
TheEmrys wroteIt very well could be off. My post abo e was only for the a7/r and probably the s.

jhinkey wrote
secondclaw wroteBecause unlike an OLED display, an LCD monitor draws constant power regardless of 'color' on the screen.
A screen powered and all black, versus screen covered with lots of stuff, will have exactly same power draw.
An OLED display is different. Black color pixels draw no power, while colored pixels draw more power than LCD (that's why OLED is more power draining, unless it powers off a portion of its image).

If the back screen was OLED, when camera is exposing and blanking out the screen, there would indeed be power savings.

And a note - Deactivate Monitor only blanks it out, doesn't power it off.

dandrewk wroteI think something may have been lost in translation here. How can there be zero power savings when the monitor is turned off? LCD screens require power, and the brighter the image the more power is being used. Even with the exposure info still shown, the rest of the screen is black.
Hmmm . . . when I deactivate the rear monitor on my A7RII the screen is absolutely dark - no light at all. When the monitor is on and showing black - you can see very low illumination. It looks to me that when I deactivate the monitor it is truly off. I can't say what the display electronics are doing - they may still be sending display information signals to the monitor which is simply not displaying them because it's de-powered.
I seem to recall from my A7R days that when the monitor was off, it was just displaying "black", but you would still see a glow from the light leakage.

Even in a completely dark room I cannot see any light from the rear monitor of the A7RII when it's either switched to the EVF or it's set to off in the menu.
Intersting. Thanks for sharing. And thanks to the OP for the tip too.


Also, though it's much harder to see effectively, but when the EVF is "off" I cannot see any glow in the viewfinder either - so it likely is truly powered off.

Again, it could be that the display driver electronics are still fully sucking power and just the physical display is de-powered, but this would be silly if they did that unless those display electronics need to be fully powered and sending signals in order to quickly have the display turn back on (which is does indeed do very quickly).
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:57 AM
Csaba
Offline
Details
p.3 #9TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
Having an A7II i was excited to read this tip, but not due to the energy saving thing. I cannot use my lcd flipped as it turns off most of the times switching for the viewfinder . But unfortunately there is no such custom key settings option in this camera.
Sep 03, 2015 at 10:36 AM
dmward
Offline
Details
p.3 #10TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
The "manual" switching is most useful for making sure the LCD doesn't go dark when I'm using the LCD like a waist level view finder. I like doing this, but the sensor kept switching to the EVF which is a pain. the manual switching solves the problem. If it improves battery life so much the better.

But, like Guy I have a bunch and they do need to be used and recharged.
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:09 PM
dennishh
Offline
Details
p.3 #11TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
Really good information about the Wi-Fi but the rest is about the A7 not the A7r2 which has an additional function to turn off the monitor and not just deactivate it. Hope the updates the book and does tests on the A7r2. I also hope that Sony will comment on this feature.
Sep 06, 2015 at 12:24 PM
Jim Sanderson
Offline
Details
p.3 #12TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
? Saw this thread. Got my a7r ii a couple of days ago. Camera comes with no custom function assigned to the bottom position of the wheel on the back of the camera. Assigned function MONITOR/VIEWFINDER to the down/bottom position. It turns off/on the monitor. Viewfinder is only on when looking through the viewfinder. Tada.....as an aside, was out shooting hummers this morning and found that my Canon 600mm version 1 works fine in autofocus. Some had said it did not for them.
Sep 07, 2015 at 08:17 AM
dennishh
Offline
Details
p.3 #13TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
Just found another advantage to assigning the MONITOR/VIEWFINDER to a button on the A7Rll. When shooting tethered to capture one in the studio live view works really well so there's no need to have either the monitor or the viewfinder on, which means no power for either will be used when shooting tethered. If you want to take a look at the set through the camera all you have to do put your eye up to the viewfinder which activates it. Major plus for the A7rll and studio shooting. When I first was setting up I was having problems with the USB transfer with a long cable to the other side of the studio so I bought a Cable MattersĀ® SuperSpeed USB 3.0 Type A Male to Female Active Extension Cable 5 Meters/16.4 Feet from Amazon which works extremely fast with USB 2. http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00DMFB5OK?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00
Sep 07, 2015 at 01:49 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.3 #14TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
dennishh wrote:
Just found another advantage to assigning the MONITOR/VIEWFINDER to a button on the A7Rll. When shooting tethered to capture one in the studio live view works really well so there's no need to have either the monitor or the viewfinder on, which means no power for either will be used when shooting tethered. If you want to take a look at the set through the camera all you have to do put your eye up to the viewfinder which activates it. Major plus for the A7rll and studio shooting. When I first was setting up I was having problems with
...Show more →

Yes, when trying to use longer USB cables, cable quality matters . . . .

I have yet to try it tethered - I want to tether to my Android tablet, which I also use with my D800 when on the tripod. Has anyone tethered to the A7RII with an Android tablet - I would use it just for control, not for transferring the images to the tablet.
Sep 07, 2015 at 05:05 PM
dennishh
Offline
Details
p.3 #15TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
I've used the Sony Wi-Fi app to control the camera and transfer JPEG's to my tablet, works great.
Sep 07, 2015 at 05:52 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.3 #16TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
dennishh wrote:
I've used the Sony Wi-Fi app to control the camera and transfer JPEG's to my tablet, works great.


Do you have a choice to transfer them or not? Also, how's the lag time between telling it to take a shot and it actually doing it?
Sep 07, 2015 at 06:25 PM
dennishh
Offline
Details
p.3 #17TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
You can only transfer JPG's to a phone or tablet the RAW's are stored on the card.. No lag time to the shutter release and you can touch focus with FE lenses on the tablet screen.
Sep 07, 2015 at 07:19 PM
zwinters
Offline
Details
p.3 #18TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
Does anyone know of a decent solution for the original a7 / a7r

We do not have the "Finder/Monitor" option within the custom key settings. I would love to manually pop back and forth between the viewfinder and monitor, or even between "auto" and "off".

Thoughts?
Sep 08, 2015 at 04:31 PM
Lee Saxon
Offline
Details
p.3 #19TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
This was a helpful and very straightforward post that a lot of people found very controversial and confusing. Strange.
Sep 08, 2015 at 04:41 PM
adamdean
Offline
Details
p.3 #20TURN Off LCD Monitor A7r2 (really....)
I have an A7r2 and am using this function with the C1 button. I wanted to do this with my A7R as well but even with the latest 2.0 update, it doesn't seem to have the 'Finder/Monitor Sel' options under the Custom options. Any suggestions or is this just not possible with the A7R?
Mar 12, 2016 at 05:18 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister