fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!

  
 
justruss
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
snapsy wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
RustyBug wroteAnd a $645 swing from their discounted 5DsR ... hmmm, 5Ds sales must be lagging expectations
Every so often I like to follow up on things that represent certain presumptions about pricing and success. In this thread, one idea was that availability of the Canon camera via gray market sales at lower prices is an indicator of it being a sales failure. (Others recognize the familiar pattern with almost any camera: initial shortages with sales at or above list, greater availability but at a firm list price, those in the know discover that they can negotiate lower costs, cameras enter the gray market and become available at lower than list prices without regular warranty, manufacturer starts to offer bundling deals and other discounts...)

If you follow the "lower pricing indicates product failure" line of thinking, what to make of this: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1392200

For my part, I think it means the same thing that it meant here — a normal and expected development over time.

Dan
The A7RII price you linked is currency arbitrage for imported bodies, the same as applies to the grey-market 5DS/R imports. That's a separate phenomena from the typical downward pricing trend of models.


To be fair, the two aren't entirely exclusive phenomenon happening without relation to one another.

From about the day the A7rII became available (and likely the 5DsR), those arbitrage opportunities existed. The are countries where the A7rII has been selling for the equivalent of $2600 at retail, on a one-off basis, with full local warranty (2+ years) the whole time, with included free stuff (memory card, bags). And my guess is that a number of people (for instance, the guys who run the shop and don't get a lot of local sales; remember their buy cost is lower than their sell cost, so let's say they get them for $2,400 or less) probably picked up a couple and flogged them away from home for the full $3,200 (give or take $100) for the first couple weeks, taking big profits.

Over time, as the hype drops, and some kind of market efficiency returns (early adopters have paid their premium, there are copies available, with full warranty in your home town), those involved in making a buck on currency arbitrage lower their prices-- because making $100 to $400 on such an easy sell can still be mightily profitably (notably if local currency is weak, and local per capita income is low).

None of this says anything about any product being a failure.

But it does say something about flow of supply catching up to demand, and it can be predictive of the beginning of dropping prices. These cameras (5Ds/A7rII) have a LOT of margin built into their release prices that the manufacturers know will let them squeeze out that extra bit of profit in the first 3-6 months of sales. They are smart because they get to sell their wares at different prices to different buyers all by slightly staggering their price model (kinda like the "If you ask, we'll give you a 10% discount" concept, which allows a product to be sold at two different prices without sacrificing total profit). If I can move 100,000 units in the first year, better for the first 200,000 units to go for a $400 premium than to sell them all at the lower prices I sell the next 800,000 thousand for.
Oct 14, 2015 at 12:43 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
justruss wrote:
None of this says anything about any product being a failure.


Precisely the point I made when some misinterpreted the same pricing trend as a sign of the failure of another camera.

These are normal, predictable changes that affect essentially all cameras.
Oct 14, 2015 at 12:48 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
Of course the price could drop by half, and the product wouldn't necessarily be a failure. As long as it's profitable over the course of its manufacturing run-- even indirectly in the form of halo sales, accessory sales, image, advertising, whatever-- it's not a failure from the point of view of the manufacturer.

From the point of view of the consumer-- barring major feature changes via firmware or some other update-- the product is either a failure or not a failure, on an individual basis, based on what it provides the buyer... not sales numbers or price changes.

I don't really care so much about defending a product as a failure or not. I LIKE to see price drops, because it makes all future purchases cheaper for me. At this stage, anyone who buys early in a product's life and then gets bent out of shape that the price drops dramatically ("hurting resale") is naive. Kinda like the guy who drives a new car off the lot and then finds out how much the thing has gone down in value after the first 6 months. It's definitely a pet peeve of mine to see complaints by people who buy Camera A... and then get angry at the manufacturer for offering an improved item in the not distant future, or a much lower price. If you don't expect this to happen, you're purchasing under imagined consumer conditions.
Oct 14, 2015 at 12:55 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
+1 @ failure vs. popularity vs. supply & demand vs. arbitrage vs. price are very different things.

My earlier reference was to the 5Ds being discounted more deeply (on one occasion) than the 5DsR as in indication of the unanticipated response to those two cameras being inverse to what may have been anticipated / planned for.

In no regard was that meant to be suggestive of any kind of a failure ... just laws of supply & demand, alive & well.
Oct 14, 2015 at 05:18 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
RustyBug wrote:
+1 @ failure vs. popularity vs. supply & demand vs. arbitrage vs. price are very different things.

My earlier reference was to the 5Ds being discounted more deeply (on one occasion) than the 5DsR as in indication of the unanticipated response to those two cameras being inverse to what may have been anticipated / planned for.

In no regard was that meant to be suggestive of any kind of a failure ... just laws of supply & demand, alive & well.


But even that had speculation built into it. Could be about demand/supply anticipation being wrong. Could also be about the freight shipment with one of the cameras being delayed for some unforeseen reason. Or production impacted on one of the cameras for want of some random part not shared between the two, or some part used for both but in cycle for only one when the production was delayed (see Apple, which sources many items of the same part from multiple vendors/manufacturers, including its processors-- the same model-- in the current iPhone 6s from TSMC and Samsung, each of which is on a slightly different node).

Or it could be about an imbalance between supply/demand. Us mortals (who don't have the inside view) will never know, but we can speculate like experts on the InterwebZ.
Oct 14, 2015 at 05:36 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
gdanmitchell wrote:
justruss wroteNone of this says anything about any product being a failure.
Precisely the point I made when some misinterpreted the same pricing trend as a sign of the failure of another camera.

These are normal, predictable changes that affect essentially all cameras.


Normal, predictable changes for a camera lower in demand than expected. As I pointed out here earlier, the 5Ds(R) came too late to the market with a high initial sales price, and both models have now to compete with the D810 and especially the A7R II (the latter seems in high demand, therefore not too much of a price reduction yet with the exemption of a few cases). A bit sad, because principally the 5Ds(R) is finally the needed high MP FF camera lacking in Canon's line for too long. But the majority of those who desired higher MP FF sensors in the last years already added another camera system or fully switched.
Oct 14, 2015 at 07:04 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
Bias is a funny thing. With sufficient bias someone will interpret the same trends to mean opposite things. For example, when the Brand A true believer sees Brand B cameras on sale, True Believer takes that as evidence of the failure of Brand B. But what Brand A is on sale, it is a normal thing and an opportunity to get a great product for less.

A wonderful logical experiment is to simply ask the question: "What does it mean when the price of a new product goes down over time?"

With cameras, of every brand that I've ever known of, the cycle works roughly like this:

1. The camera is announced and a list price named. Early adopters place advance orders and even make deposits and down payments in order to ensure that they will get the first units.

2. The camera becomes available, but initially not in sufficient quantities to satisfy demand. The most impassioned buyers will do anything to get one of the first copies, include paying premiums above the list price.

3. The camera becomes more widely available, but perhaps goes in and out of stock as shipments arrive and sell out. The camera sells for list price, with the exception of a few insiders who can call in a favor or two.

4. Initial demand is met, production rates increase, more units are in the distribution channel, and supply and demand being to equalize. Smart buyers may be able to negotiate a lower price, but many still pay list.

5. As the channels fill and demand is met, those who play games with international exchange rates and different regional pricing begin to supply gray market product at lower prices. This is natural, as the route from manufacturer to gray market is bit more circuitous and takes a bit longer. The price has to be lower since buyers won't pay regular price for products that lack the same warranty coverage. Meanwhile new non-gray market pricing remains in the list price region.

6. As the initial market is saturated, the manufacturer begins to offer special pricing — rebate offers, bundles, and occasional sales. Patient buyers can get new non-gray-market product for discount prices, even as lower as the gray market prices.

7. Eventually used product and refurbished product joins gray market products, all of which tend to make list price a bit more difficult to sustain. Deals become more common and more frequent for this reason and because the "new thing" is no longer quite so new.

8. Over a period of perhaps a year or more the pricing continues to soften and it is regularly possible to get much lower pricing on new products. And rumors of the "next thing" start to arise, causing some who did not get the recently new product to consider waiting for the next thing — again decreasing demand and softening prices.

9. Eventually credible reports and rumors about the next generation product appear and the pricing of the previous product continues to decline, with lots more options for used, gray market, and refurbished product.

10. As the next generation arrives, the bottom drops out of the pricing for the previous product... and the cycle starts again.

Specifically in the case of the 5Ds and 5DsR it appears that Canon may have overestimated the interest in the AA-filtering 5Ds and underestimated the interest in the non-AA-filtering 5DsR. (Many of us actually received emails from vendors when the cameras first became available, encouraging us to switch our orders from the 5DsR to the 5Ds.) The pricing changes did not reflect a weakness in the 5Ds/5DsR camera concept or product line, though the initial drops in the 5Ds prices may well have reflected this missed guess about the balance between the two cameras.

Aside from the wishful negative thinking of a few folks (see my first paragraph) the 5DsR seems to be very well received and it seems to be penetrating the market for such a camera quite well. I suspect that Canon is quite happy with its sales. The pricing trend seems to be pretty much in line with the normal, expected progression.

It doesn't take a genius to see this pattern in the market. It repeats almost every time a new camera comes out, no matter what manufacturer produces it.

Edited on Oct 14, 2015 at 06:09 PM · View previous versions
Oct 14, 2015 at 05:13 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
gdanmitchell wrote:
Specifically in the case of the 5Ds and 5DsR it appears that Canon may have overestimated the interest in the AA-filtering 5Ds and underestimated the interest in the non-AA-filtering 5DsR. (Many of us actually received emails from vendors when the cameras first became available, encouraging us to switch our orders from the 5DsR to the 5Ds.) The pricing changes did not reflect a weakness in the 5Ds/5DsR camera concept or product line, though the initial drops in the 5Ds prices may well have reflected this missed guess about the balance between the two cameras.


I agree with the statement in regard to 5Ds vs. 5DsR. But certainly I disagree with the second part - the Canon 5Ds(R) does not stand alone in the market as you make it sound, it has now serious and in some areas better products to compete with. The severe drop of the 5Ds(R) in the market is an adjustment especially towards the A7R II. If I could put bets on which camera sells better, I would put my bets on the A7R II.

Oct 14, 2015 at 05:30 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
retrofocus wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
justruss wroteNone of this says anything about any product being a failure.
Precisely the point I made when some misinterpreted the same pricing trend as a sign of the failure of another camera.

These are normal, predictable changes that affect essentially all cameras.
Normal, predictable changes for a camera lower in demand than expected. As I pointed out here earlier, the 5Ds(R) came too late to the market with a high initial sales price, and both models have now to compete with the D810 and especially the A7R II (the latter seems in high demand, therefore not too much of a price reduction yet with the exemption of a few cases). A bit sad, because principally the 5Ds(R) is finally the needed high MP FF camera lacking in Canon's line for too long. But the majority of those who desired higher MP FF
...Show more →

Again with the baseless opinions paraded as facts. Any chance you can post some data to support your claim that the majority of users have already switched away from Canon?
Oct 14, 2015 at 09:11 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
retrofocus wrote:
But the majority of those who desired higher MP FF sensors in the last years already added another camera system or fully switched.




I'd believe that the majority of those who desired higher MP FF sensors have very closely evaluated the prospects of adding another camera or switching with the offerings of SoNikon while waiting for the 5Ds(R) to arrive on the scene ... but, that is a rather different thing from what you're suggesting.
Oct 14, 2015 at 09:58 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
gdanmitchell wrote:
Bias is a funny thing. With sufficient bias someone will interpret the same trends to mean opposite things. For example, when the Brand A true believer sees Brand B cameras on sale, True Believer takes that as evidence of the failure of Brand B. But when Brand A is on sale, Brand A True Believer thinks this is a normal thing and an opportunity to get a great product for less....

... Aside from the wishful negative thinking of a few folks (see my first paragraph) the 5DsR seems to be very well received and it seems to be penetrating
...Show more →

Oct 14, 2015 at 10:11 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
RustyBug wrote:
retrofocus wroteBut the majority of those who desired higher MP FF sensors in the last years already added another camera system or fully switched.


I'd believe that the majority of those who desired higher MP FF sensors have very closely evaluated the prospects of adding another camera or switching with the offerings of SoNikon while waiting for the 5Ds(R) to arrive on the scene ... but, that is a rather different thing from what you're suggesting.


So far I did not see any 5Ds(R) camera out there when shooting with other photographers, but several ones upgrading or getting the A7R II (and some have gotten the D810 but this was already a while ago). Again, I don't think that the 5Ds(R) is a bad camera, but it simply arrived too late and overpriced to the market (regarding overpricing, the A7R II has the same issue, but IMO the A7R II offers benefits which were discussed earlier).
Oct 15, 2015 at 05:37 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
retrofocus wrote:
RustyBug wrote
retrofocus wroteBut the majority of those who desired higher MP FF sensors in the last years already added another camera system or fully switched.


I'd believe that the majority of those who desired higher MP FF sensors have very closely evaluated the prospects of adding another camera or switching with the offerings of SoNikon while waiting for the 5Ds(R) to arrive on the scene ... but, that is a rather different thing from what you're suggesting.
So far I did not see any 5Ds(R) camera out there when shooting with other photographers, but several ones upgrading or getting the A7R II (and some have gotten the D810 but this was already a while ago). Again, I don't think that the 5Ds(R) is a bad camera, but it simply arrived too late and overpriced to the market (regarding overpricing, the A7R II has the same issue, but IMO the A7R II offers benefits which were discussed earlier).


Is this your evidence of what cameras are selling? Really, this is unbelievably weak 'evidence'. If we are going with this standard, I have seen one a7x in the field since they were released. I guess hardly any have been sold.
Oct 15, 2015 at 06:05 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
Was there a timing / relationship impact between the A7R II and the 5Ds(R) ... sure, why not.

Does the A7R II hit the market in a place that the 5Ds(R) doesn't ... sure, why not.
Does the A7R II offers some things that the 5Ds(R) doesn't ... sure, why not.

But, now that the 5Ds(R) is out there ... and we have a well-established, known deficiency in the AF arena with the A7R II, we'll just have to watch how it unfolds as more folks come to realize that the A7R II is still a crippled duck (despite the acknowledged improvements). The hopes of the better adaptation has been a dangled carrot from the Song of the Siren, but the story is unfolding and I think that the 5Ds(R) will reveal itself to be a viable camera in areas that the Sony isn't.

For those shooting the shorter FL's, the Sony is seemingly viable as a niche adjunct. But not everybody has the budget ($$$ or bag space) for carrying an extra niche camera. The group that frequents here is largely a rather advanced / eclectic / esoteric group with certain weighted regard to the areas the Sony is viable for. The amount of consideration we have for manual focus with short lenses, is probably not representative of the larger photographic community where folks do shoot longer lenses with AF.

I mean, if I want to get better IQ / reach / pixels to work with ... I kinda want to be able to use it for any glass in my bag. Yet, with the A7R II, I'm impacted from using my 100-400L II in AF at the long end ... and don't even think about adding a TC. Imo, that is a limited, crippled duck, that is only able to serve a niche portion of my shooting.

I mean, the value of the additional pixels for cropping / reach seems like a waste if you can't effectively use it beyond a certain focal length, anyway.

Given the choice of 42MP with 200mm (ballpark limits of consistent AF functionality) vs. 50MP with 560mm ... well, you do the math. Heck, even the little 700D @ 18MP or the 5D3 @ 22MP with 400mm is better than 42MP with 200mm if you can't trust your 200mm to function properly on the Sony when you need it.

Oh yeah, and that IBIS ... ummm (honest question) if you are using a zoom, do you have to reprogram the body for the different focal lengths when you go from 100mm to 400mm or 560mm ... or does it make the adjustment for IBIS automatically you as you zoom or add the TC, based on exif data?

Yup, you're probably right that the majority of Canon shooters looking for a high MP FF sensor have bought anouther body or already switched ... but, even if they had already bought the A7R or A7R II ... do you think they'll continue to live with that crippling AF restriction now that the 5Ds(R) has filled THAT void and can handle both wide and long end of the spectrum, whereas the Sony is suspect at best (200mm-300mm), and clearly can't (400mm + TC) at worst? Check the Sony B&S and see how many that are selling Sony's are coming back to Canon, citing they "tried" and it wasn't all that it was cracked up to be compared to the DSLR. Gee, I wonder what aspect(s) they were referring to?

Sony may have hit the timing of the market well (they're good at that, so props are in order), but I think the 5Ds(R) is here for the long haul, even if it is a little slow to pick up steam compared to the reception (deserved) of the A7R II. At the end of the day ... I want what works. And for longer stuff, well the Sony simply doesn't work the same way the Canon does.






Oct 15, 2015 at 06:42 AM
dclark2171
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
RustyBug wrote:
Was there a timing / relationship impact between the A7R II and the 5Ds(R) ... sure, why not.

Sony may have hit the timing of the market well (they're good at that, so props are in order), but I think the 5Ds(R) is here for the long haul, even if it is a little slow to pick up steam compared to the reception (deserved) of the A7R II. At the end of the day ... I want what works. And for longer stuff, well the Sony simply doesn't work the same way the Canon does.




I think it all comes down to what you need. I'm a pro Architectural -interior shooter who has used Canon for years. Telephoto photography and auto focusing is not a priority. However Dynamic range is a big deal since many budgets, even with high end clients, make it less cost effective to set up elaborate interior lights and traditional pro photography set ups. Unfortunately, HDR/Blending is becoming the norm for higher end. Even with bracketing, extreme shadows and highlights can become a problem in post. Although, we can always work around and find a solution, higher DR allows a little more flexibility in those bracket shots. I've used the 5ds and it's a GREAT camera. I've also used A7R (version 1) and it's great as well. From experience, for my shooting methods and situations, the A7R makes life a little easier

1. EVF, especially outdoor, for manual focusing tilt/shift lenses

2. Focus magnification thru view finder

3. Sony's iPhone remote app. no need for my Camranger unit hooked to camera

4. DR in post


I'm just talking for my situation. When I use flashes, I shoot manual (non TTL) anyway. If I shot sports, the 1DX would be my choice. If I needed telephotos, I would just use the 5ds.

I love both the 5Ds and the A7 series cameras much the same. Slight edge for my situation to the SONY. I can make it work with ANY camera. However, when I an, I try to make things easier. At the end of the day, no matter what one uses, the end Client is not going to notice what camera you are using, just the quality photography you present.
Oct 25, 2015 at 06:36 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister