fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!

  
 
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
gdanmitchell wrote:
Canon will eventually do what Nikon did between the D800/D800e pairing and the eventual merging into one truly AA-filter-free D810.


+1 @ they were hedging their bets for consumer sentiment on the issue. It looks like they were anticipating they would need to "wean" folks away from the AA filter ... only to find out that more folks than anticipated have already been weaned by the likes of other Mfr's results.

A possible "left-handed, silver lining" to this revelation is the number of Canon shooters that did NOT move away from Canon to the other mfr's enticement (or who are abandoning augmentation thereof), who were eager to move into the realm of less AA impediment to their light with a Canon body.

Given the pixel size of the 5Ds vs. the other existing AA-less model pixel sizes, the more diminutive pixel size incurs even less risk than those of larger pixel sizes, so following the D810 with a comparable / competing model does seem viable, now that Canon shooters seem to be expressing their preference (with their wallets).
Aug 26, 2015 at 07:21 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
gdanmitchell wrote:
The speculation is that the 5DsR sold much better than Canon expected and that the 5Ds sold less well. They may have incorrectly predicted the balance between the two.


I'll take it a step further. Canon messed up making two versions to begin with. Nikon already went through this process with the D800/D800E. There was no need to tread that ground again.

Aug 26, 2015 at 07:21 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
ggreene wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteThe speculation is that the 5DsR sold much better than Canon expected and that the 5Ds sold less well. They may have incorrectly predicted the balance between the two.
I'll take it a step further. Canon messed up making two versions to begin with. Nikon already went through this process with the D800/D800E. There was no need to tread that ground again.



Granted, but did you want to be the person responsible for just an 5DsR if it didn't move well with that executive decision on your head. The "double refraction" assembly meant little change / risk to the mfr process. A true no-AA filter would have meant something a little more different via engineering / mfr process (diff stack thickness) ... hence hedging incurred less risk.

The presence of the 5Ds as a comparative probably has helped sell the 5DsR even more than if it didn't exist at all. While that may be incidental to the hedging / balance expectations, I think the 5DsR would have a lesser sales pace if the 5Ds wasn't alongside it for the comparison.



Edited on Aug 26, 2015 at 07:34 AM · View previous versions
Aug 26, 2015 at 07:28 AM
ComicDom1
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
Bubble wrote:
ComicDom1 wroteIs that seller an authorized Canon Dealer? That is a very important question? Next are those U.S. Models or Gray Market?

If you look closely it appears warranty is through the seller not through Canon. So after that first year is up then who will service it?
Jason
oh no...not again. We get this reply every single time Fred post this kind of deal.

here is your answer.
http://www.canonpricewatch.com/blog/2015/08/hot-lowest-yet-eos-5ds-for-2699-import-from-getitdigital-ebay/


Well there is a simple way to find out. Call Canon and ask them. Sorry just reading some thing a web site is posting about what Canon is Historically going to do does not set my wallet at ease.

Jason

Edited on Aug 26, 2015 at 07:35 AM · View previous versions
Aug 26, 2015 at 07:29 AM
nntnam
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
This is way cheaper than the price in Japan where the caneras are made! How is this even possible?
Aug 26, 2015 at 07:34 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
RustyBug wrote:
Granted, but did you want to be the person responsible for just an 5DsR if it didn't move well. The presence of the 5Ds as a comparative probably has helped sell the5DsR even more than if it didn't exist at all. While that may be incidental to the hedging / balance expectations, I think the 5DsR would have a lesser sales pace if the 5Ds wasn't alongside it for the comparison.


This was never a general use camera so sales were going to be tied to people looking for a 50MP sensor who are probably also looking for the very best in sharpness at pixel level. If Canon missed that dynamic then they need better market analysis.
Aug 26, 2015 at 07:38 AM
RobertLynn
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
Canon...

ComicDom1 wrote:
Is that seller an authorized Canon Dealer? That is a very important question? Next are those U.S. Models or Gray Market?

If you look closely it appears warranty is through the seller not through Canon. So after that first year is up then who will service it?
Jason

Aug 26, 2015 at 07:44 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
ggreene wrote:
RustyBug wroteGranted, but did you want to be the person responsible for just an 5DsR if it didn't move well. The presence of the 5Ds as a comparative probably has helped sell the5DsR even more than if it didn't exist at all. While that may be incidental to the hedging / balance expectations, I think the 5DsR would have a lesser sales pace if the 5Ds wasn't alongside it for the comparison.
This was never a general use camera so sales were going to be tied to people looking for a 50MP sensor who are probably also looking for the very best in sharpness at pixel level. If Canon missed that dynamic then they need better market analysis.


How do you know that more people want the 5DS than the 5DS R? We know that Canon probably produced fewer 5DS R. The short supply of the 5DS R does not prove that the demand itself is higher.

Nikon removed the AA filter in the D810 because of the very high cost saving, and they could get away with it. It is not a universally good idea to remove the AA filter. Many photographers wanting high resolution also want the AA filter.
Aug 26, 2015 at 07:45 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
ggreene wrote:
RustyBug wroteGranted, but did you want to be the person responsible for just an 5DsR if it didn't move well. The presence of the 5Ds as a comparative probably has helped sell the5DsR even more than if it didn't exist at all. While that may be incidental to the hedging / balance expectations, I think the 5DsR would have a lesser sales pace if the 5Ds wasn't alongside it for the comparison.
This was never a general use camera so sales were going to be tied to people looking for a 50MP sensor who are probably also looking for the very best in sharpness at pixel level. If Canon missed that dynamic then they need better market analysis.


Well, they were probably watching how so many folks on FM express that the AA issue is just "internet hype" and they were too concerned about moire' and false color.

Looks like the wallets started singing a different tune.



alundeb wrote:
How do you know that more people want the 5DS than the 5DS R? We know that Canon probably produced fewer 5DS R. The short supply of the 5DS R does not prove that the demand itself is higher.

Good point.



Edited on Aug 26, 2015 at 07:49 AM · View previous versions
Aug 26, 2015 at 07:45 AM
RobertLynn
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!

After the warranty period Canon would service it.
ComicDom1 wrote:
Bubble wrote
ComicDom1 wroteIs that seller an authorized Canon Dealer? That is a very important question? Next are those U.S. Models or Gray Market?

If you look closely it appears warranty is through the seller not through Canon. So after that first year is up then who will service it?
Jason
oh no...not again. We get this reply every single time Fred post this kind of deal.

here is your answer.
http://www.canonpricewatch.com/blog/2015/08/hot-lowest-yet-eos-5ds-for-2699-import-from-getitdigital-ebay/
Well there is a simple way to find out. Call Canon and ask them. Sorry just reading some thing a web site is posting about what Canon is Historically going to do does not set my wallet at ease.

Jason

Aug 26, 2015 at 07:45 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
nntnam wrote:
This is way cheaper than the price in Japan where the caneras are made! How is this even possible?


One word...."arbitrage"
Aug 26, 2015 at 07:56 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
ggreene wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteThe speculation is that the 5DsR sold much better than Canon expected and that the 5Ds sold less well. They may have incorrectly predicted the balance between the two.
I'll take it a step further. Canon messed up making two versions to begin with. Nikon already went through this process with the D800/D800E. There was no need to tread that ground again.


I suspect that Canon will come to agree with the realization that they could have simply released one AA-filter-free model with essentially the same effect, and with less confusion for consumers. (I've read that there is a fine balance between attracting consumers by offering choice and confusing consumers by offering unclear choices — and since it seems that AA-filtering is hardly necessary in such cameras, the latter may have been the unplanned result for both Nikon and Canon with their initial offerings.)

nntnam wrote:
This is way cheaper than the price in Japan where the caneras are made! How is this even possible?


Product pricing is not something that is always susceptible to rational analysis. ;-)

There is almost certainly some exchange rate stuff going on here, and maybe some price lowering by Canon in some international markets. To speculate: If you were Canon and you wanted to move the slower-selling 5Ds models, would it look better for you if the price drop on that model came as a direct reduction (e.g. - sale or rebate from authorized dealers) in your major markets or if you sort of looked the other way and "allowed" some sales to occur via the gray market?

- - -

Regarding the meaning of the gray market pricing...

The discount on the 5DsR seems to be relatively typical of what we see with gray market prices once new products become available by that route. Gray market prices typically do not represent a direct lowering of the price by the manufacturer — that comes later in the form of rebates and bundles — and gray market prices must be lower than regular prices, or the gray market would not exist. (Given a choice between "authorized" product and gray market product at the same price, who would choose gray market, with its warranty questions and so forth?) Bottom line: Nothing unusual here related to the 5DsR.

On the other hand, the discount on the 5Ds seems larger than a typical gray market discount. My feeling is that it does represent a lower demand than Canon expected for the version of the camera with the AA filter. A company that discovers a trend like that with a new product typically wants to move that slower selling product and rebalance is production and delivery, and the lower pricing accomplishes that.

Folks who are comfortable with gray market purchases from sources other than the major vendors and who like the 5Ds model may want to take advantage of the likely short-lived opportunity to get this camera at a significantly reduced price.

Dan

Edited on Aug 26, 2015 at 09:35 AM · View previous versions
Aug 26, 2015 at 08:17 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
alundeb wrote:
How do you know that more people want the 5DS than the 5DS R? We know that Canon probably produced fewer 5DS R. The short supply of the 5DS R does not prove that the demand itself is higher.


How do we know that Canon produced fewer 5Ds/R's? Has Canon ever released that kind of info? They may well have, I just never realized it.
Aug 26, 2015 at 08:50 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
ggreene wrote:
alundeb wroteHow do you know that more people want the 5DS than the 5DS R? We know that Canon probably produced fewer 5DS R. The short supply of the 5DS R does not prove that the demand itself is higher.
How do we know that Canon produced fewer 5Ds/R's? Has Canon ever released that kind of info? They may well have, I just never realized it.


I only heard the word on the street, the dealers said they got fewer from Canon. 1 5DS R per 4 5DS or something.
Aug 26, 2015 at 08:59 AM
markd61
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
alundeb wrote:
Nikon removed the AA filter in the D810 because of the very high cost saving, and they could get away with it. It is not a universally good idea to remove the AA filter. Many photographers wanting high resolution also want the AA filter.

Nikon uses an AA/anti AA assembly in front of its sensor that maintains the cover glass thickness for proper performance with its lenses.
Arguably that is even more expensive than a plain AA filter.
Aug 26, 2015 at 10:09 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
markd61 wrote:
alundeb wroteNikon removed the AA filter in the D810 because of the very high cost saving, and they could get away with it. It is not a universally good idea to remove the AA filter. Many photographers wanting high resolution also want the AA filter.
Nikon uses an AA/anti AA assembly in front of its sensor that maintains the cover glass thickness for proper performance with its lenses.
Arguably that is even more expensive than a plain AA filter.


I know they use that in the D800E, but do they use that in the D810 as well? That would be a very expensive glass...
Aug 26, 2015 at 10:12 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
markd61 wrote:
alundeb wroteNikon removed the AA filter in the D810 because of the very high cost saving, and they could get away with it. It is not a universally good idea to remove the AA filter. Many photographers wanting high resolution also want the AA filter.
Nikon uses an AA/anti AA assembly in front of its sensor that maintains the cover glass thickness for proper performance with its lenses.
Arguably that is even more expensive than a plain AA filter.


I don't think they still do that in the D810. They did do that in the D800 and D800e, much like Canon does in the 5Ds and 5DsR.

Dan
Aug 26, 2015 at 10:50 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
ggreene wrote:
RustyBug wroteGranted, but did you want to be the person responsible for just an 5DsR if it didn't move well. The presence of the 5Ds as a comparative probably has helped sell the5DsR even more than if it didn't exist at all. While that may be incidental to the hedging / balance expectations, I think the 5DsR would have a lesser sales pace if the 5Ds wasn't alongside it for the comparison.
This was never a general use camera so sales were going to be tied to people looking for a 50MP sensor who are probably also looking for the very best in sharpness at pixel level. If Canon missed that dynamic then they need better market analysis.


Yes....but we all forget to look outside the Canon island. Even 50MP resolution is the top resolution at the moment, there are other competitors out there which offer a bit lower resolution but other advantages which the 5Ds(R) does not have. Also, we need to consider the movement of users in the last 3 years (including myself here) who switched or added with another camera brand which offered already a higher MP sensor with better DR. Only few of those might actually return to Canon's 5Ds(R) class especially at the given price tag. So the reason for a low demand is not just because of the actual price tag of the 5Ds(R) cameras but also because of Canon's lack to have a high MP camera available in the past few years.

I can clearly say that I would have bought without doubt the 5DsR three years ago instead of the 5D MkIII before any FF mirrorless camera came along. Now the market is a very different one with alternative options out there. Most of the users who really needed or wanted a high MP/DR FF sensor left the Canon boat leaving mostly behind those who didn't need it. I would not be surprised if Canon will sell more 5D MkIV cameras in the future than 5Ds(R) cameras because action/sports/wildlife is now the main domain of Canon shooters.
Aug 26, 2015 at 10:57 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
gdanmitchell wrote:
markd61 wrote
alundeb wroteNikon removed the AA filter in the D810 because of the very high cost saving, and they could get away with it. It is not a universally good idea to remove the AA filter. Many photographers wanting high resolution also want the AA filter.
Nikon uses an AA/anti AA assembly in front of its sensor that maintains the cover glass thickness for proper performance with its lenses.
Arguably that is even more expensive than a plain AA filter.
I don't think they still do that in the D810. They did do that in the D800 and D800e, much like Canon does in the 5Ds and 5DsR.

Dan


I never got actual confirmation, but in the DPR studio comps, you can see the results diff @ the line drawing of the old family scene (note the rafters), as well as the 36-50 llpm range shows a diff.

NOTE: I did swap the lower right image between D800 / 5Ds (can't comp 5 at a time) and back again. Also, ISO diff's seem neglible. You can of course go comp the diff's however one might prefer.

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/image-comparison?attr18=daylight&attr13_0=nikon_d810&attr13_1=nikon_d800e&attr13_2=canon_eos5dsr&attr13_3=nikon_d800&attr15_0=raw&attr15_1=raw&attr15_2=raw&attr15_3=raw&attr16_0=100&attr16_1=50&attr16_2=100&attr16_3=50&normalization=full&widget=1&x=-0.6837074168710624&y=0.4173108635163619

The thing that folks aren't following is that when you strike something with a "direct blow", it delivers more energy than when you strike it with a "glancing blow" (vector forces). Refracting the light through an AA filter is redirecting the angle of impingement. Sure, you can offset the placement redirect with a second redirect, but it still takes its toll on the delivery of energy (note the contrast diff in the D810, and the crispness thereof as well). Also, note that even for AA filtered and reversal AA filter images, they still incur a false color / moire' when faced with such conditions ... it is just blurred. You can kinda do the same thing in post if you run into it.

It has been suggested that the diff between a true no-AA filter vs. reversal AA would be even more trivial than the diff between a reversal AA vs. regular AA filter. I'll leave that to you to consider for yourself, but I know which one shows greater contrast to my eye ... even without the extra resolution. In that regard, we can see (approximately) how the diff of AA vs. resolution compares in the 36mp vs. 50mp. To my eye, a naked AA is just more crisp than a reversed AA. Does the extra resolution of the 50MP with reversed AA equate / supersede the 36MP without AA as being more crisp ... your call.

Much is said that you can use USM to make up the diff @ contrast. Likewise, you can use PP to make up the diff on correction. Which direction you want to approach it from @ risk management. I find it most interesting though, that the reversal AA D800E reveals more/softer false color than the no-AA D810 (at a given frequency) in the llpm.

I have recently been getting moire' / false color with my 700D (and it's AA filter) with my upgrade in long glass @ some bird feathers, so there really isn't anything that is "fail safe" from the issue. You just have to choose your poison(s), and know your risk / reward relatively to your own shooting.


























Edited on Aug 26, 2015 at 12:11 PM · View previous versions
Aug 26, 2015 at 11:11 AM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Canon EOS 5DS for $2,699!
alundeb wrote:
Nikon removed the AA filter in the D810 because of the very high cost saving, and they could get away with it. It is not a universally good idea to remove the AA filter. Many photographers wanting high resolution also want the AA filter.


That is not true for the D810. You may be thinking of the old D800E, which has the AA effect removed in the less desirable way like the 5DSR.

Do you have a link to your source for Nikon's cost of an AA filter assembly vs producing one without? I am curious how you know the scale of the alleged cost savings.

I've literally not read a single complaint about the D810 not having an AA filter counterpart, so I'm not so sure Nikon "got away" with anything, but rather made the decision for measurable performance reasons. Seems to be working out pretty well for them. They have released numerous cameras without AA filters both before and after the D810 (Coolpix A, D7100, D7200, D3300, D5300, D5500)

markd61 wrote:
alundeb wroteNikon removed the AA filter in the D810 because of the very high cost saving, and they could get away with it. It is not a universally good idea to remove the AA filter. Many photographers wanting high resolution also want the AA filter.
Nikon uses an AA/anti AA assembly in front of its sensor that maintains the cover glass thickness for proper performance with its lenses.
Arguably that is even more expensive than a plain AA filter.


This is not true. The D810 does not employ this method. That is how the old D800E worked and the 5DSR.
Aug 26, 2015 at 11:18 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister