p.8 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote: timparkin wroteWhat is interesting is that the Sony A7Rii red filter is very thick. This is why the Sony A7Rii doesn't look like it's clipping as easily in lightroom. It is in fact clipping at the same time in the green channel but the red channel doesn't clip until later. This can be confirmed looking at the ratio's of the green, red and blue channel in the Rawdigger screenshots..Here are the 3x3 color matrices from the EXIF data of the A7r vs A7rII raw files:
p.8 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
justruss wrote:
Yes, now I'm even more confused. Is the A7r2 really showing 2/3 stop less dynamic range than the A7r-- but better color tonality so it looks, in actual images, like more?
I'll take color over DR ... (says the one shooting SLR/C). I can always bracket to expand DR if really needed.
My .02 has been that Fuji and Kodak have had better knowledge of color than Canon & Nikon @ film makers vs. camera makers (historically). Sony comes in from the TV / video side of things entering into the mix in the photographic realm.
As such, the race is then on to see if a camera mfr can learn to make great color, or can a color mfr learn to make a great camera.
At the moment, it seems as though Sony is starting to bridge the gap (and of course their relationship with Nikon) on their end of things in the camera making department. In that regard, the trajectory is beginning to take on some interesting shapes. I've always thought that Canon should align with the folks @ Kodak to strengthen that position, much as how Panny & Leica are aligned, etc.. I'm wondering if they will ever look to do so, but at this stage, it seems as Canon remains at trying to go it alone, while others are JV'ing.
p.8 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote: snapsy wrotetimparkin wroteWhat is interesting is that the Sony A7Rii red filter is very thick. This is why the Sony A7Rii doesn't look like it's clipping as easily in lightroom. It is in fact clipping at the same time in the green channel but the red channel doesn't clip until later. This can be confirmed looking at the ratio's of the green, red and blue channel in the Rawdigger screenshots..Here are the 3x3 color matrices from the EXIF data of the A7r vs A7rII raw files:
p.8 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote: justruss wroteYes, now I'm even more confused. Is the A7r2 really showing 2/3 stop less dynamic range than the A7r-- but better color tonality so it looks, in actual images, like more?
I'll take color over DR ... (says the one shooting SLR/C). I can always bracket to expand DR if really needed.
Depends. Many situations don't allow for bracketing. I'd rather have both rather than needing to compromise.
p.8 #5Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote: RustyBug wrotejustruss wroteYes, now I'm even more confused. Is the A7r2 really showing 2/3 stop less dynamic range than the A7r-- but better color tonality so it looks, in actual images, like more?
I'll take color over DR ... (says the one shooting SLR/C). I can always bracket to expand DR if really needed.Depends. Many situations don't allow for bracketing. I'd rather have both rather than needing to compromise.
Chez,
I think you totally missed my point (my bad for not being more clear).
Given the choice between the extra 2/3 stop DR of the A7R vs. the color tonality of the A7R II ... I'd forego the DR advantage of the A7R in favor of the color advantage of the A7R II (assuming its confirmation). This choice is consistent with my longstanding choice to shoot the SLR/C for its color, rather than its DR as a primary driver for my decision. If 2/3 stop is going to represent a "deal breaker" for an image ... I probably need to be bracketing anyway (even with the 2/3 stop advantage) to achieve maximum IQ.
Going back to film, I've always chosen color over latitude ... i.e. lower ISO chromes vs. negatives as my preference. Yet understanding the diff's when I needed to switch over to VPS for weddings.
p.8 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
Going back to film, I've always chosen color over latitude ... i.e. lower ISO chromes vs. negatives as my preference. Yet understanding the diff's when I needed to switch over to VPS for weddings.
I agree and prefer chrome over neg in many situations. I was very tempted to keep my A900 as is still the best color camera I have used but the A7Rii is reminding me of it. Only time will tell...
Difficult to compare these things visually but the target took up about 75% of the width of the frame and it's got default sharpening and noise reduction in lightroom. I then set a black point and a white point at either end of each 'bar'. The 'shifts' are to compensate for differences in channel clipping across cameras.
and finally a color error comparison of A7R and A7Rii - not particularly relevant in a Canon forum - I'll get the Canon colorchecker done when I'm back on Saturday (just off to visit Canon UK nr Heathrow).
p.8 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote: timparkin wrotesnapsy wrotetimparkin wroteWhat is interesting is that the Sony A7Rii red filter is very thick. This is why the Sony A7Rii doesn't look like it's clipping as easily in lightroom. It is in fact clipping at the same time in the green channel but the red channel doesn't clip until later. This can be confirmed looking at the ratio's of the green, red and blue channel in the Rawdigger screenshots..Here are the 3x3 color matrices from the EXIF data of the A7r vs A7rII raw files:
I think I have an idea of what this means but it might help for you to explain ...My guess is that there is little difference again.. :-) if anything the red filter is weaker than the A7R..
Tim
I'm not familiar with how Imatest generates those numbers but the scale between the A7r and A7rII look off - all the A7r numbers in the matrix are higher. If my interpretation of the Sony color matrix from the EXIF is correct then your post about the A7rII having a stronger red channel would be right.
p.8 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote: timparkin wrotetimparkin wrotesnapsy wrotetimparkin wroteWhat is interesting is that the Sony A7Rii red filter is very thick. This is why the Sony A7Rii doesn't look like it's clipping as easily in lightroom. It is in fact clipping at the same time in the green channel but the red channel doesn't clip until later. This can be confirmed looking at the ratio's of the green, red and blue channel in the Rawdigger screenshots..Here are the 3x3 color matrices from the EXIF data of the A7r vs A7rII raw files:
I think I have an idea of what this means but it might help for you to explain ...My guess is that there is little difference again.. :-) if anything the red filter is weaker than the A7R..
TimI'm not familiar with how Imatest generates those numbers but the scale between the A7r and A7rII look off - all the A7r numbers in the matrix are higher. If my interpretation of the Sony color matrix from the EXIF is correct then your post about the A7rII having a stronger red channel would be right.
Looks like I need to do some reading. Never investigated these color matrices before
p.8 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
A bit outa my league, but a few things catch my attention .. yet, still appreciative.
One being the variance in the grays in the middle of the Imatest chart. Two, being that we are, making adjustments from both ends first, without any adjustment to the middle. Would it change the results if we first adjusted the middle before addressing the extremes?
Also, how about just posting the unadjusted results first before we start tinkering with them to compensate for endpoint channel response variance, and letting Adobe whacking at it with NR & sharpening, etc. ? It would be nice to see the raw data of the raw file first, I think.
p.8 #11Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Looks like I need to do some reading. Never investigated these color matrices before
Tim, perhaps a preface to your original article, at the top of the page in italic type, should explicitly acknowledge this.
Something along the lines of:
"Thanks to all who have come here to read my original article ostensibly comparing the three cameras. For those of you with a very technical bent, who already understand the complexities of testing things in this way and who will read very carefully may find the following useful. Others who might come here thinking that these test images of captures pushed in all sorts of extreme ways represent what you are actually going to see from any of these cameras, should stop and take a deep breath and study up a bit first. It is extraordinarily unlikely that you will even see a real photograph from any of these cameras that remotely resembles what you see in these extreme test image, and you should not presume that the differences that may be visible in this torture test will be visible in your photographs. In fact, all three of these cameras produce extraordinary high levels of image quality that will satisfy the most careful and discriminating photographers, and those choosing any of the cameras will almost certainly be very happy with the results."
All of us find it useful and informative to test our equipment. However, in this case I relearned important lessons about such testing. It is very hard to do properly. While it was my goal to show an objective test, variables in how the cameras were tested sneaked into the results and they affected the accuracy of my original report. In addition, I now realize that I made unwarranted assumptions about the ways the different cameras are designed and how they work, assumptions that caused me to think that the tests were more comparable then they actually are. I'm currently working to better understand these important factors."
p.8 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
Sony comes in from the TV / video side of things entering into the mix in the photographic realm.
Is that really right? Didn't Sony inherit photographic know-how from Minolta rather than only coming from a TV/video side? I know next to nothing about Minolta's photographic color knowledge base prior to being absorbed by Sony, or exactly what exactly transpired between the two companies in 2006, so I am sincerely asking.
p.8 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote: RustyBug wroteSony comes in from the TV / video side of things entering into the mix in the photographic realm.Is that really right? Didn't Sony inherit photographic know-how from Minolta rather than only coming from a TV/video side? I know next to nothing about Minolta's photographic color knowledge base prior to being absorbed by Sony, so I am sincerely asking.
You are right...they inherited a lot of Minolta knowledge...they were smart and did not start from scratch here.
p.8 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote: Earlier quoteLooks like I need to do some reading. Never investigated these color matrices beforeTim, perhaps a preface to your original article, at the top of the page in italic type, should explicitly acknowledge this.
Something along the lines of:
"Thanks to all who have come here to read my original article ostensibly comparing the three cameras. For those of you with a very technical bent, who already understand the complexities of testing things in this way and who will read very carefully may find the following useful. Others who might come here thinking that these test images of captures pushed in all sorts of extreme ways represent what you are actually going to see from any of these cameras, should stop and take a deep breath and study up a bit first. It is extraordinarily unlikely that you will even see a real photograph from any of these cameras that remotely resembles what you see in these extreme test image, and you should not presume that the differences that may be visible in this torture test will be visible in your photographs. In fact, all three of these cameras produce extraordinary high levels of image quality that will satisfy the most careful and discriminating photographers, and those choosing any of the cameras will almost certainly be very happy with the results."
All of us find it useful and informative to test our equipment. However, in this case I relearned important lessons about such testing. It is very hard to do properly. While it was my goal to show an objective test, variables in how the cameras were tested sneaked into the results and they affected the accuracy of my original report. In addition, I now realize that I made unwarranted assumptions about the ways the different cameras are designed and how they work, assumptions that caused me to think that the tests were more comparable then they actually are. I'm currently working to better understand these important factors."
Are telling me to post an apology for getting it wrong? I may do if you could show me how it's wrong.
Which assumptions did I get wrong?
Which important lessons did I relearn?
I honestly think it's pretty presumptuous to ask this when you haven't explained how I got it 'wrong' and I don't accept it's wrong in the first place.
p.8 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote: Earlier quoteLooks like I need to do some reading. Never investigated these color matrices beforeTim, perhaps a preface to your original article, at the top of the page in italic type, should explicitly acknowledge this.
Something along the lines of:
"Thanks to all who have come here to read my original article ostensibly comparing the three cameras. For those of you with a very technical bent, who already understand the complexities of testing things in this way and who will read very carefully may find the following useful. Others who might come here thinking that these test images of captures pushed in all sorts of extreme ways represent what you are actually going to see from any of these cameras, should stop and take a deep breath and study up a bit first. It is extraordinarily unlikely that you will even see a real photograph from any of these cameras that remotely resembles what you see in these extreme test image, and you should not presume that the differences that may be visible in this torture test will be visible in your photographs. In fact, all three of these cameras produce extraordinary high levels of image quality that will satisfy the most careful and discriminating photographers, and those choosing any of the cameras will almost certainly be very happy with the results."
All of us find it useful and informative to test our equipment. However, in this case I relearned important lessons about such testing. It is very hard to do properly. While it was my goal to show an objective test, variables in how the cameras were tested sneaked into the results and they affected the accuracy of my original report. In addition, I now realize that I made unwarranted assumptions about the ways the different cameras are designed and how they work, assumptions that caused me to think that the tests were more comparable then they actually are. I'm currently working to better understand these important factors."
p.8 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote: gdanmitchell wroteEarlier quoteLooks like I need to do some reading. Never investigated these color matrices beforeTim, perhaps a preface to your original article, at the top of the page in italic type, should explicitly acknowledge this.
Something along the lines of:
"Thanks to all who have come here to read my original article ostensibly comparing the three cameras. For those of you with a very technical bent, who already understand the complexities of testing things in this way and who will read very carefully may find the following useful. Others who might come here thinking that these test images of captures pushed in all sorts of extreme ways represent what you are actually going to see from any of these cameras, should stop and take a deep breath and study up a bit first. It is extraordinarily unlikely that you will even see a real photograph from any of these cameras that remotely resembles what you see in these extreme test image, and you should not presume that the differences that may be visible in this torture test will be visible in your photographs. In fact, all three of these cameras produce extraordinary high levels of image quality that will satisfy the most careful and discriminating photographers, and those choosing any of the cameras will almost certainly be very happy with the results."
All of us find it useful and informative to test our equipment. However, in this case I relearned important lessons about such testing. It is very hard to do properly. While it was my goal to show an objective test, variables in how the cameras were tested sneaked into the results and they affected the accuracy of my original report. In addition, I now realize that I made unwarranted assumptions about the ways the different cameras are designed and how they work, assumptions that caused me to think that the tests were more comparable then they actually are. I'm currently working to better understand these important factors."
DanAre telling me to post an apology for getting it wrong? I may do if you could show me how it's wrong.
Which assumptions did I get wrong?
Which important lessons did I relearn?
I honestly think it's pretty presumptuous to ask this when you haven't explained how I got it 'wrong' and I don't accept it's wrong in the first place.
p.8 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote:
What is interesting is that the Sony A7Rii red filter is very thick. This is why the Sony A7Rii doesn't look like it's clipping as easily in lightroom. It is in fact clipping at the same time in the green channel but the red channel doesn't clip until later. This can be confirmed looking at the ratio's of the green, red and blue channel in the Rawdigger screenshots..
Personally I think the A7R is going to be the bargain of the century as people start to sell it and it becomes a £600 to £800 second hand camera. The A7Rii is more refined for me and does seem to be getting better colour - like I remember from the A900 - this could be due to the thicker filters..
The thicker filter array seems to contradict to me that the performance of (ultra)wide angle rangefinder lenses which had color casts in the corners of the frame in the A7R are now better performing on the A7R II. What I read before was that a thicker filter stack would even worsen the problem (that's why the Kolari modification uses a thinner glass plate on top to reduce the size of the filter stack). Any explanation for this contradiction (if it is any, not sure!)?
p.8 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote: RustyBug wroteSony comes in from the TV / video side of things entering into the mix in the photographic realm.Is that really right? Didn't Sony inherit photographic know-how from Minolta rather than only coming from a TV/video side? I know next to nothing about Minolta's photographic color knowledge base prior to being absorbed by Sony, or exactly what exactly transpired between the two companies in 2006, so I am sincerely asking.
Good point ... yes, they pulled in Minolta (camera mfr). My main point was their professional film / TV / video base (like Kodak & Fuji) was additional outside the realm of camera mfr (hardware) who previously left the aspect of color expertise to film mfr's ... i.e. drop in a roll of your choosing. It wasn't a slam against Sony, it was credence to their strength in color (along with Minolta) similar to Kodak & Fuji from their previous (non photographic still camera mfr) industry experience.
With Fuji doing their own thing, that leaves Kodak as a potential JV ... something that I think could be excellent, but I figure Canon will stick to being Canon. If Fuji made FF ... I'd likely be tracking them much more. I was interested by their S5 and the super CCD and the X-trans, but again, they never stepped into the FF arena.
The Sony A900 caught my attention ... but the stars never aligned for me with glass, then Sony turned their attention to crop, then to mirrorless ... now coming back to FF and mirrorless seeming to make some gainful strides. Just seems like nobody has the whole package put together yet ... choose your poison(s).
p.8 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
A bit outa my league, but a few things catch my attention .. yet, still appreciative.
One being the variance in the grays in the middle of the Imatest chart. Two, being that we are, making adjustments from both ends first, without any adjustment to the middle. Would it change the results if we first adjusted the middle before addressing the extremes?
Also, how about just posting the unadjusted results first before we start tinkering with them to compensate for endpoint channel response variance, and letting Adobe whacking at it with NR & sharpening, etc. ? It would be nice to see the raw data of the raw file first, I think....Show more →
Yep I'll upload those as soon as I get an internet connection working reasonably on this bloody train!!!
p.8 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote: RustyBug wroteA bit outa my league, but a few things catch my attention .. yet, still appreciative.
One being the variance in the grays in the middle of the Imatest chart. Two, being that we are, making adjustments from both ends first, without any adjustment to the middle. Would it change the results if we first adjusted the middle before addressing the extremes?
Also, how about just posting the unadjusted results first before we start tinkering with them to compensate for endpoint channel response variance, and letting Adobe whacking at it with NR & sharpening, etc. ? It would be nice to see the raw data of the raw file first, I think.Yep I'll upload those as soon as I get an internet connection working reasonably on this bloody train!!!
Actually I think I'll have to upload the raw files as the signal to noise is awful.. I'm over at Canon tonight/tomorrow and they should have enough bandwidth to upload them..