fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20155DSR has more DR than 5DIII

  
 
dmcphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #15DSR has more DR than 5DIII
Herb wrote:
dmcphoto wroteI have the 5DSR and I'm finding the battery life to be surprisingly short. I am not sure how it compares to the 5D3 as my other cameras are 1DX and 1DS3, but some anecdotal playing around with the camera does suggest that battery life could be a problem. Both cameras (5DS and 5DSR) should be identical in this regard.
Doesn't the 5DIII battery grip fit this camera as well?


I assume the 5D3 grip fits the 5DS/5DSR well since Canon is selling it, though RRS says their 5D3 plates don't fit the 5DS/5DSR. OTOH Canon reinforced and stiffened the tripod mounting area on the 5DS and 5DSR apparently because they thought the higher resolution needed better coupling to a tripod, but they did not reinforce the tripod mounting area on the grip. Regardless, I want to use this camera hiking so I don't want a grip anyway. Spare batteries are the lightest weight solution.
Jul 08, 2015 at 05:12 AM
Ziffl3
Offline
Details
p.3 #25DSR has more DR than 5DIII
Herb wrote:
dmcphoto wrote
Ziffl3 wrote
big country wrotei do not have the R, but i have been shooting the 5DS at weddings, engagements and some birds w/ the 5DS. honestly, if it were 6-8 fps, and had a bigger buffer, and could go a little higher on the native ISO this would be pretty close to my ultimate camera.
I would resemble this remark..... 6-8fps ... I am okay with 5fps, but 6-8 would be cool.
The buffer ... there is a place that could use a bump. This would be my 1 gripe.

Native ISO .... I am okay with the 6400.

The other spot is battery life. Need the grip for weddings... but this could be me.
I am not in the mood to carry additional batteries when shooting all day.

I need to get into the last wedding I shot to understand the colors.

-Mark
I have the 5DSR and I'm finding the battery life to be surprisingly short. I am not sure how it compares to the 5D3 as my other cameras are 1DX and 1DS3, but some anecdotal playing around with the camera does suggest that battery life could be a problem. Both cameras (5DS and 5DSR) should be identical in this regard.
Doesn't the 5DIII battery grip fit this camera as well?


Yes....

Jul 08, 2015 at 09:51 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #35DSR has more DR than 5DIII
SoftImage wrote:
In any case I agree with Kevindar's comment above. Lifting shadows with any camera is poor man's bracketing. We need much better sensors to replace multi shot bracketing, fill flash or filters.


Wondering if you understand that with high DR cameras you will still need to lift shadows? (No current display medium can handle the DR of current cameras, so the way we take advantage of larger-than-output DR is by lifting shadows, etc. The advantage of a camera with larger DR is that you can do so with fewer artifacts and/or from a wider range source.)

Dan
Jul 08, 2015 at 11:29 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.3 #45DSR has more DR than 5DIII
gdanmitchell wrote:
SoftImage wroteIn any case I agree with Kevindar's comment above. Lifting shadows with any camera is poor man's bracketing. We need much better sensors to replace multi shot bracketing, fill flash or filters.
Wondering if you understand that with high DR cameras you will still need to lift shadows? (No current display medium can handle the DR of current cameras, so the way we take advantage of larger-than-output DR is by lifting shadows, etc. The advantage of a camera with larger DR is that you can do so with fewer artifacts and/or from a wider range source.)

Dan


By default, higher DR cam always record better data than lower DR cam. This implies better IQ as the more DR you have and this is most critical point that you always leave it out.
Jul 08, 2015 at 06:40 PM
whumber
Offline
Details
p.3 #55DSR has more DR than 5DIII


gdanmitchell wrote:
SoftImage wroteIn any case I agree with Kevindar's comment above. Lifting shadows with any camera is poor man's bracketing. We need much better sensors to replace multi shot bracketing, fill flash or filters.
Wondering if you understand that with high DR cameras you will still need to lift shadows? (No current display medium can handle the DR of current cameras, so the way we take advantage of larger-than-output DR is by lifting shadows, etc. The advantage of a camera with larger DR is that you can do so with fewer artifacts and/or from a wider range source.)

Dan


That's true, but a camera that achieves high dynamic range via higher full well capacity will give better image quality than a camera that achieves it by lowering shadow noise.
Jul 08, 2015 at 06:57 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #65DSR has more DR than 5DIII
whumber wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
SoftImage wroteIn any case I agree with Kevindar's comment above. Lifting shadows with any camera is poor man's bracketing. We need much better sensors to replace multi shot bracketing, fill flash or filters.
Wondering if you understand that with high DR cameras you will still need to lift shadows? (No current display medium can handle the DR of current cameras, so the way we take advantage of larger-than-output DR is by lifting shadows, etc. The advantage of a camera with larger DR is that you can do so with fewer artifacts and/or from a wider range source.)

Dan
That's true, but a camera that achieves high dynamic range via higher full well capacity will give better image quality than a camera that achieves it by lowering shadow noise.


I'm not debating that at all... just reminding folks that in order to use the higher DR you must do work in post. Many know this. Many don't.

By the way, to say it once again (for perhaps the 150th time... ;-), higher DR is a useful thing for those who do more than use SOOC photographs. How useful and for what purposes and at what costs (financial and functional) are for each photographer to decide, and there are multiple right decisions.

YMMV,

Dan
Jul 08, 2015 at 07:27 PM
skibum5
Offline
Details
p.3 #75DSR has more DR than 5DIII
molson wrote:
In some real-world applications, I've found the 5D SR to have more dynamic range than the D810, but the extra latitude available is in the highlights, not in the shadows like the Nikony sensors.

This is a single exposure, and no ND grad filters were used:


You are tricking yourself. These sensors do linear capture. You are just getting tricked by default placement of mid-tone point or something.
Jul 08, 2015 at 10:58 PM
SoftImage
Offline
Details
p.3 #85DSR has more DR than 5DIII
gdanmitchell wrote:
SoftImage wroteIn any case I agree with Kevindar's comment above. Lifting shadows with any camera is poor man's bracketing. We need much better sensors to replace multi shot bracketing, fill flash or filters.
Wondering if you understand that with high DR cameras you will still need to lift shadows? (No current display medium can handle the DR of current cameras, so the way we take advantage of larger-than-output DR is by lifting shadows, etc. The advantage of a camera with larger DR is that you can do so with fewer artifacts and/or from a wider range source.)

Dan


Yes, I understand that.

I was referring to Kevindar's comment: 'I have also discovered that nothing beats bracketing when possible in terms of image quality. shadows pushed three stops, at best, are equivalent to ISO 800 (if there was no read noise amplification, in a perfect world), and are still inferior to shadows at iso 100 when is what you get when you bracket.'.

In practical terms higher DR=shadow lifting when scene DR is high. We ETTR to avoid blowing highlight and then lift shadows in the post to recover as much detail as possible or needed. But as Kevindar pointed out lifting shadow will produce inferior results than bracketing even if a Exmor is used. All sensors (including Sony) will have improve further before we can forget about bracketing etc. At the moment Exmor sensors do give us a better latitude in shadow lifting.


Jul 08, 2015 at 11:37 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.3 #95DSR has more DR than 5DIII
skibum5 wrote:
molson wroteIn some real-world applications, I've found the 5D SR to have more dynamic range than the D810, but the extra latitude available is in the highlights, not in the shadows like the Nikony sensors.

This is a single exposure, and no ND grad filters were used:
You are tricking yourself. These sensors do linear capture. You are just getting tricked by default placement of mid-tone point or something.



Too bad I was never able to get that trick to work in three years of using the Nikony sensors...

Ignorance is bliss, as they say...
Jul 09, 2015 at 06:16 AM
Ziffl3
Offline
Details
p.3 #105DSR has more DR than 5DIII
skibum5 wrote:
molson wroteIn some real-world applications, I've found the 5D SR to have more dynamic range than the D810, but the extra latitude available is in the highlights, not in the shadows like the Nikony sensors.

This is a single exposure, and no ND grad filters were used:
You are tricking yourself. These sensors do linear capture. You are just getting tricked by default placement of mid-tone point or something.


Linear ... okay .. but there are different amount of logical bits available on the bright/high side and goes down as you move to the shadow.

-Mark

Jul 09, 2015 at 07:00 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.3 #115DSR has more DR than 5DIII
SoftImage wrote:
In any case I agree with Kevindar's comment above. Lifting shadows with any camera is poor man's bracketing. We need much better sensors to replace multi shot bracketing, fill flash or filters.


Absolutely. The over processed 3-5 stop shadow pushes I've seen from Exmor sensors leave a lot to be desired especially when you are talking about people as subjects. The skin tones and colors do not look right. Miles and miles away from fill flash.
Jul 09, 2015 at 07:10 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #125DSR has more DR than 5DIII
ggreene wrote:
SoftImage wroteIn any case I agree with Kevindar's comment above. Lifting shadows with any camera is poor man's bracketing. We need much better sensors to replace multi shot bracketing, fill flash or filters.
Absolutely. The over processed 3-5 stop shadow pushes I've seen from Exmor sensors leave a lot to be desired especially when you are talking about people as subjects. The skin tones and colors do not look right. Miles and miles away from fill flash.


I think we need to be cautious about characterizing that capabilities of any camera based on the worst examples of post-processing we can find. I've seen examples of poor post processing work from Canon, Nikon, Sony and every other camera.

In fact, it is quite possible (and more common) to push shadows in ways that are effective and which do not result in an awful looking photograph.

When it comes to the question of whether pushing or blending is best, the answer is, in my experience, "it depends." I've seem beautiful work done both ways.

Dan
Jul 09, 2015 at 08:46 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister