hiepphotog wrote: freaklikeme wrotesnapsy wrotefreaklikeme wroteschlotz wrotedoes the addition of the electronic 1st curtain eliminate the shutter shockEFCS probably wouldn't have fixed the problem on the 7r. I have it turned off on the a7 because I get more consistent exposure when making panos without it, but I don't get shutter shock, even using it the same way I used the a7r (hanging off a bellows/tech camera). I bet it was the little metal frame built around the sensor to support the mount that caused that particular problem. It's a prominent design difference between the 7 and 7r and would explain why the problem was evident when the camera was hanging off the back of a tripod-mounted lens/bellows but not when hand-holding.It's true the A7 didn't suffer from shutter shock even with EFCS off. But the A7r would definitely have benefited from an EFCS - its shock is caused by the long duration following the first curtain opening, an interval that occurs while the exposure is happening. The second curtain has much less time to affect the exposure since most of its vibration propagates after the curtain has closed.But that's not a fix, it's a work-around.Like you, I do notice the exposure inconsistency with EFCS, especially with wider angle, and my A7s does have the shutter shock issue as well. According to Sony, this new A7r actually has a new curtain shutter that is designed for vibration reduction. We'll see what that means.
I doubt the new camera will have the same problem. I will be curious to hear what people moving directly from the a7r to the II say about the size.
I also have a little food for thought for those of you using your 7r as a digital back in some capacity- not only is the 7rII larger, but the location of the ports differs significantly. This wasn't anything I had considered since I kept the 7 specifically for this purpose, but I'm without it for a bit so I substituted the 7II and discovered that, while I still had full movement on a Cambo Actus, the mutil-port of the 7II sits right above a thick portion of the rear standard, and not the little divot cut out for it like it does on the 7. So my choices were to either go without a remote release or only use the camera in landscape orientation. Then I took it home and put it on my Mamyia bellows with a custom thin-adapter solution that allows me to get to infinity with some MF lenses, and discovered the grip interferes the shift there. Just something to consider before you put your 7r up for sale.
The A7rII looks impressive!!! I plan to follow the camera after its release and see how the AF performs, especially with Canon lenses. I also hope to get an understanding of how the new sensor performs. If I was really honest with myself, I have four real issues with the body.
First, the price. Justified or not, it is to high for me (in part because I feel the price might fall pretty quickly and that always ends up feeling pretty bad). I will continue to use my Canon system (5DIII); so this is a second (third, actually) body for me. Second, no native high quality 24-70 lens. This may be a show stopper for me. Sure, I may be able to use my Canon 24-70 2.8 II on it; but, I will be surprised if the AF turns out to be solid. But, I need a high quality native 24-70 period. Third, battery life. The day the A7rII was announced I shoot an engagement shoot that ended up having 1,400 images. This hardly put a dent in my 5DIII battery which I used for two more projects in the following days before swapping in a fresh battery and I think the original battery still had more than half its capacity. Finally, I may wait and see what the Canon 5D4 and Canon 5DSr have to offer; and compare these bodies to the A7rII.
But no doubt at the right price point for me, I think this would be a great addition to my kit.
Phillip Reeve wrote:
I am surprised how hyped the camera is here.
Sure the features sound great but they won't improve my pictures that much.
For me it's not so much about improving the quality of pictures I'm already taking, but creating entirely new possibilities.
The completely silent shutter option and IBIS opens up a host of discrete street and lowlight shooting oportunities where I simply wouldn't have bothered trying before. The ability to AF with Canon and other EF mount gives me a huge number of new lens options. I also shoot video from time to time and the difference in quality between the not-really-HD video of the α7ʀ and 4K high bitrate codec in the α7ʀ II justify the upgrade alone since I've repeatedly considered buying an α7s just for the video.
Suffice to say I will be upgrading as soon as I can, however I need to see where the UK price lands - to put this in perspective for anyone wincing at the $3200 release price - I wish I could get this camera for only $3200
First, the price. Justified or not, it is to high for me (in part because I feel the price might fall pretty quickly and that always ends up feeling pretty bad). I will continue to use my Canon system (5DIII); so this is a second (third, actually) body for me. Second, no native high quality 24-70 lens. This may be a show stopper for me. Sure, I may be able to use my Canon 24-70 2.8 II on it; but, I will be surprised if the AF turns out to be solid. But, I need a high quality native 24-70 period. Third, battery life. The day the A7rII was announced I shoot an engagement shoot that ended up having 1,400 images. This hardly put a dent in my 5DIII battery which I used for two more projects in the following days before swapping in a fresh battery and I think the original battery still had more than half its capacity. Finally, I may wait and see what the Canon 5D4 and Canon 5DSr have to offer; and compare these bodies to the A7rII.
But no doubt at the right price point for me, I think this would be a great addition to my kit....Show more →
I'm impressed you get that much out of your 5Dmk3 batteries. Best I every got was 800images before I swapped batteries. "1,400 and still 50%" is outstanding.
To me the hype or dilema on battery life is over rated. It takes 5sec to swap a battery and they're small and weigh nothing.
Matt Grum wrote: Phillip Reeve wroteI am surprised how hyped the camera is here.
Sure the features sound great but they won't improve my pictures that much.For me it's not so much about improving the quality of pictures I'm already taking, but creating entirely new possibilities.
The completely silent shutter option and IBIS opens up a host of discrete street and lowlight shooting oportunities where I simply wouldn't have bothered trying before. The ability to AF with Canon and other EF mount gives me a huge number of new lens options. I also shoot video from time to time and the difference in quality between the not-really-HD video of the α7ʀ and 4K high bitrate codec in the α7ʀ II justify the upgrade alone since I've repeatedly considered buying an α7s just for the video.
Suffice to say I will be upgrading as soon as I can, however I need to see where the UK price lands - to put this in perspective for anyone wincing at the $3200 release price - I wish I could get this camera for only $3200 ...Show more →
Even I like what Sony is doing with their A7 series cameras in general, I am a bit surprised about this very positive hype about the A7R II. Yes, I understand that the camera includes a lot more features and improvements than expected. But....
a) I didn't see any more detailed test review yet - especially in regard to sensor and AF with third party lenses, how much better is it? 10%? Or more than 50%?
b) In general, I am very cautious to be an early adaptor with cameras. Most of newly released cameras from any brand require a firmware update soon after to get rid of some bugs. Hopefully the A7R II won't have an issue which can't be fixed with a firmware update. All of this is still unknown before the camera is released.
c) Another question which was only raised a few times earlier I find important, too - will all the MF lens adapters work the same still as with the A7R? This is interesting because I read remarks here that some A7 lens adapters did not work as well with the A7 II.
d) Very important at least for my usage is the functionality with rangefinder lenses - will they work better with this backlit sensor? Are there visible improvements in image quality? If so, how much? Again 10% or much higher? Or - in a worst case scenario - did Sony change something to push consumers towards Sony/Zeiss lenses by making some changes in the sensor which makes it harder to use MF lenses? I certainly don't hope so, but this is also not clear yet.
e) Price: Mentioned by someone earlier here, but it is really interesting that new cameras nowadays seem to get more expensive even manufacturing cost for a mirrorless body should be less. The $3200 is at least $500 above a more settled and reasonable price for this camera. Maximum price I personally would pay for a new version of this camera at some point is $2500.
To sum it up, I didn't make my mind yet if I should upgrade from my A7R to the A7R II. I need more consolidated information how much better those improvements are for my usage to balance the price/performance ratio.
This camera is calling to me to be put in my bag but in reality we really know nothing about this new sensor. The images that Sony has shown us are truly spectacular, but are not sufficient to be judged by themselves. My A7r is producing incredibly detailed and sharp images which allows me to wait for six months till all the information is available. It will be difficult to wait but a rental body might be the best way to go for evaluation purposes and wait for the price point to come down to $2800 or so where it should be.
Ordering mine as soon as it's possible for pro use. Don't need AF or IBS, existing lenses good enough at 36mp will be good enough with 6mp more I assume. Certain features will be nice like the better shutter, hope colours and DR will improve and EVF and controls will be better. Won't be a 'game changer' for me and for other A7r / MF lens shooters who use a tripod I doubt it will either. Not convinced it's video features will stack up to much in reality so will continue with the A7s and wait for the A7sII - please may it have 10bit...........
dennishh wrote:
This camera is calling to me to be put in my bag but in reality we really know nothing about this new sensor. The images that Sony has shown us are truly spectacular, but are not sufficient to be judged by themselves. My A7r is producing incredibly detailed and sharp images which allows me to wait for six months till all the information is available. It will be difficult to wait but a rental body might be the best way to go for evaluation purposes and wait for the price point to come down to $2800 or so where it should be....Show more →
Here is my feeling on the Sensor. At least the last several have been brilliant and the latest made was for 50mpx that went to Phase One, Hassy, Pentax and Leaf. I tested the Leaf Credo 50 extensively and just given the track record of that our A7r, A7s and A7II. Sensor performance is really about the last thing I am worried about. Second generation cameras almost always are just about perfect and Sony is not going to blow it here. Seriously if your not going to buy a Sony sensor you only game in town nowadays is go Canon at least in the higher end stuff.
From the few images i saw already it truly is the last of my worries and lets face it any AF improvement on the A7r even if it matches the A7II or exceeds it is like getting a invite into heaven. Anything is better than the A7r when it comes to AF. I also believe the AF for Canon and Sony lenses improvement. Im not sure why I keep hearing conspiracy theories on this. Im a reviewer and tester also, we are not going to put our reputations on the line and lie about any performance improvements unless its at least at 75 percent of what the marketing says. Its not worth the risk to embellish any performance gains. Im talking more about the Sony ambassadors they simply are not going to overstate something too much, maybe slightly but not intentional. To much risk for them. I know I have been here and i never over embellish anything. Not worth the risk and I don't get paid either. Not saying others do or do not and its always best to test yourself as I have found out many times. Im just not buying into some of these conspiracy theories that some folks are worried about. Sony has already taken a bath on the A7r they are not going to repeat that.
I also believe just to settle the PR crap they will fix the raw compression with a option. The compression is really because Sony has always been big on Video and this was just a outtake of that and I think they finally figured it out that Still folks don't want that stuff.
BTW they are NOT going to make a big deal about it either , because that would say they made a mistake. That will not happen, it will be a very quiet fix and may just show up in the production model.
Obviously open for debate my comments but I really have a good feeling this time around. I knew exactly what I was getting into with the A7r and I knew it was 75 percent good. This one Im putting it at 95 percent in my mind.
GMPhotography wrote:
Obviously open for debate my comments but I really have a good feeling this time around. I knew exactly what I was getting into with the A7r and I knew it was 75 percent good. This one Im putting it at 95 percent in my mind.
I agree about those predictions.
My thoughts regarding the hype are like:
The gap between A7r and the latest Canon DSLR AF is enormous. There is room for a huge improvement, and still have use for a Canon DSLR for AF on top of that.
How much gain will there be from BSI? My guess is maximum 1/3 stops. The high maximum ISO is probably more due to lower read noise at high ISO than better fill factor from BSI.
Fixing the shutter vibration and adding IBIS is more like catching up with the competition and the sisters than groundbreaking news.
All in all, a major improvement, but for me personally it does not change the game, just an expected improvement in a mk II camera.
alundeb wrote: GMPhotography wroteObviously open for debate my comments but I really have a good feeling this time around. I knew exactly what I was getting into with the A7r and I knew it was 75 percent good. This one Im putting it at 95 percent in my mind.I agree about those predictions.
My thoughts regarding the hype are like:
The gap between A7r and the latest Canon DSLR AF is enormous. There is room for a huge improvement, and still have use for a Canon DSLR for AF on top of that.
How much gain will there be from BSI? My guess is maximum 1/3 stops. The high maximum ISO is probably more due to lower read noise at high ISO than better fill factor from BSI.
Fixing the shutter vibration and adding IBIS is more like catching up with the competition and the sisters than groundbreaking news.
All in all, a major improvement, but for me personally it does not change the game, just an expected improvement in a mk II camera. ...Show more →
You prefer the Canon 5Ds series anyway as you outlined well enough in the Canon forum. So what is your point here again?
From what I read from you, your agenda in the Canon forum and here is more than obvious to support existing Canon sensor/camera technology and attempting to devalue Sony's.
What was the point of your post?From what I read from you, your agenda in the Canon forum and here is more than obvious to support existing Canon sensor/camera technology and attempting to devalue Sony's.
That is wrong, I make objective analysis for rational decisions. You did not answer my question.
GMPhotography wrote:
BTW nice discussion folks. Its really nice to hear many points of view on this. In all honesty this cam should have been what the original A7r should have been . At least the issues fixed out of the gate. Thats what owners of the D750 and D810 say about the D600 and D800 lol
alundeb wrote: GMPhotography wroteObviously open for debate my comments but I really have a good feeling this time around. I knew exactly what I was getting into with the A7r and I knew it was 75 percent good. This one Im putting it at 95 percent in my mind.I agree about those predictions.
My thoughts regarding the hype are like:
The gap between A7r and the latest Canon DSLR AF is enormous. There is room for a huge improvement, and still have use for a Canon DSLR for AF on top of that.
How much gain will there be from BSI? My guess is maximum 1/3 stops. The high maximum ISO is probably more due to lower read noise at high ISO than better fill factor from BSI.
Fixing the shutter vibration and adding IBIS is more like catching up with the competition and the sisters than groundbreaking news.
All in all, a major improvement, but for me personally it does not change the game, just an expected improvement in a mk II camera. ...Show more →
I agree with much of what you have said here. I too think the ISO improvement will be a 1/3 of a stop at most and more likely 1/6 of a stop. I also agree fixing the shutter shock problem is just doing what should have been expected to start out with. With AF I also agree that for tracking AF there is a huge gap between the A7r and something like the Canon 5D MKIII (but not so much the 5D MKII). But I see AF as a bit more complicated than that. The one shot AF on the Sony A7 series is quite good and in some ways superior to the Canon and at least very close when evaluated overall.
I also think it makes no sense to say that IBIS is more like catching up with the competition. Nobody else has that and everyone has some lenses that would benefit from it that do not have lens based image stabilization. For Canon for example, think of the 135L or the 85L or even the 50L in low light. I see this feature as more than just catching up.
I also think that although fixing the shutter shock is just catching up, the actual shutter is quite a bit more than that. First it is rated for 500,000 actuations, which is a lot more than something like the Canon 5D series has ever had. Second, the silent mode will really be useful for some.
I also think that 4K internal video is a feature that will be very much appreciated by some and not available in something like the Canon 5Ds.
So, I can certainly see why from your perspective the Canon 5Ds would be a better choice. However, I think it is more than the expected improvement for a MK II model. The extent of the upgrade with a new sensor, a new AF system, a new shutter, IBIS, and 4K internal video is more than I have seen for any upgrade to a MK II.
alundeb wrote:
Steve, regarding IBIS I was thinking more of the A7 II that has it already. And I am not that much into video.
There are probably many who wouldn't be interested in video but 4K as a 24/30 fps stills capture mechanism can be pretty compelling even for photographers. Here's a 4K frame grab from an NX1:
GMPhotography wrote:
I posted this on my forum as well as I always think these are fun to do. What are the FM folks thoughts.
Well we have till June 17 to order and August 20th to ship to our doors. I thought it would be interesting to see what folks game plan maybe. Are we selling current models for it or not buying it
Are we working our lens system around in FE mounts , possible buying more Canon glass. Or staying pat till you see what works or not. In the meantime the 2 Batis lenses will come on the market what are you doing there. Buying, hiding, trading.
Let's also say for fun if you need two bodies what would be the best combination.
Are you buying for video or stills.
Let's hear your thought process on this whole matter . Let's also hear your concerns and exuberance for it or not.
Make it fun, we have not spent a dime YET. Oh and what bank will you need my rented ski mask for. ...Show more →
Hi GMPhotography, etal,
10 years ago I was toting around a Canon 30D and a Sony VX2000 for my outdoor stills and video needs. When the Canon 5D2 came out I grabbed a lightly-used one in the spring of 2009 off the B&S board and swore to myself that the days of dragging both a stills and video setup outdoors was finally over...it seemed that Canon had answered my dreams for a "one-camera" solution. A usable ISO 6400, more MP than I'd dreamed off, and, well, a "not quite" full-HD video experience. I thought, "the future has finally arrived!", as I anticipated what goodies and improvements Canon would offer with its next releases.
And then...Canon fell asleep.
The plus side of their slumbering was that I have been able to content myself with this aging gear while I reallocated some resources to other interests. And I was still able to maintain a reserve for new bodies when the time was right. So I won't be needing your ski mask.
Then, along came Sony and their sensors, and I found myself getting educated about their a7-series and Nikon's offerings, too boot! And now I had some creative choices which Canon was still not offering to me in regards to DR performance, low light capabilities, but, alas, everything was still "just" HD. Enter, now, in-camera 4K video recording.
The a7R II ticks all those items on my list. My search for a one-camera solution just increased by one!
But, I've been a patient man, so far, so I don't see myself rushing out to be amongst the early adopters of this camera. By year's end I would expect the marketplace to be inhabited by an a7S II, and maybe some sort of 4K DSLR from both Nikon and Canon (maybe Sony, too?). And, amongst those choices I would find myself tending towards an a7S II, that it followed in its predecessor's footsteps and provided extremely high-ISO performance. (Woodcock mating flight at nightfall, or mama Owl heading out to find food for her chicks in late, deep twilight anyone?!)
Given all this wishful and hopeful thinking, (and to answer your question) my ideal two camera solution would be 1 ultra-low-light 4K stills/video camera and 1 daytime 4K stills/video camera. What the a7R II is offering me most, at this point, is hope that my long wait for some new creative tools is almost at an end! That RX10 II is looking like a pretty nifty daytime walk-around B-camera!
Anyhoo, thanks for the diversion from an otherwise serious day!