fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015A7rII game plan. What are you doing

  
 
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.8 #1A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Jman13 wrote:
You're also counting your time as free. My time is worth more than free. Since I do reviews, I need to put a few hundred frames through each piece of gear to properly evaluate things, and I do 20-30 reviews per year. That's 15,000 frames just on review gear. Not counting my personal work.

Even shooting modestly, tripod mounted and deliberate, I take 50-60 frames in a two hour outing. That's pretty meager. It also would still result in 100 frames a week MINIMUM, which is 5,200 frames a year. Even that, assuming good film and negligible processing (and assigning
...Show more →
rattymouse wrote
Jman13 wroteFilm plus development is not dirt cheap. At least not in the U.S. Decent films cost at least $7 for 24 exposures, then another $8-15 for developing/scanning and you're up to around $20 for 24 exposures. $0.83 every time you click the shutter isn't exactly cheap. At my current output, given review shooting and my own personal shooting, I'd spend over $15,000 a year if I shot only film. And I'm not a spray and pray guy.
Develop film yourself and costs drop to almost nothing. I can develop a roll of black and white film for under 20 cents. Twenty cents! Color for under $1. I shoot 500 or more rolls of film per year and the cost to me is negligible. I spent far more on digital playing the rat race buying new gear all the time.

Further, if you know the shot you want, if you can conceive of the image before the shot, then you certainly dont need $15,000 worth of film to execute it properly. Pros can and do make a profit shooting film. Not as many as there used to be, but they are still out there. You are a spray and pray type of shooter if your film costs exceed your budget.

Photography is never going to be a cheap hobby, but the cost difference of digital vs film is greatly over exaggerated in many cases. Numerous times I'll read a post from some hobbyist here, add up the gear that he lists as being owned and see it cost well over $6000 and he STILL wants more.

When indexed for inflation, film is still today very much dirt cheap.


In no way will film ever work for everyone, as evidence in the sales vs digital gear.

I participate in photography for the specific purpose of consuming my free time so the "cost" of my time is very desirable.

You can buy 500 rolls of Acros 120 (my primary film) for $2300. $2000 for 500 rolls of HP5+. We'll see who is still shooting as their primary camera a Sony A7 in 5 years here at the forum. Not just you, but anyone.



Jun 13, 2015 at 06:15 PM
dennishh
Offline
Details
p.8 #2A7rII game plan. What are you doing
All this discussion about film is bringing back quite disturbing memories. Many hours of mixing chemicals, processing film, breathing toxic fumes, wearing gloves to protect my skin, spotting prints and shooting hundreds of roles and sheets of film to make sure there are backups and the hope that one of them will come out to be a keeper. Nostalgia is a funny thing that I have no desire to revisit. The images that I am producing now are vastly superior in every way to all but just a few film images that I remember, but again I might be locking out the pain. For one I will never go back to film.
Jun 13, 2015 at 06:33 PM
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.8 #3A7rII game plan. What are you doing
dennishh wrote:
shooting hundreds of roles and sheets of film to make sure there are backups and the hope that one of them will come out to be a keeper.


If your technique or vision were better, you would not need to do this.

While I can't claim to have a 100% hit rate, I certainly dont need to shoot hundreds of shots and then "hope" one of them is a keeper.
Jun 13, 2015 at 06:46 PM
matanuska
Offline
Details
p.8 #4A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Phillip Reeve wrote:
I am surprised how hyped the camera is here.


That's pretty much what photography (and most other modern hobbies too for that matter) have become these days. They simply have become industries with lots of big money involved, and the hype is needed to drive ever increasing revenue requirements to keep the profits rolling in. Always gotta have the latest gizmos...

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate that the stunning levels of innovation and technology we are seeing today probably wouldn't be possible without all of this. But I for one am tired of riding this merry-go-round and I'm ready to take my downsized equipment collection off the table to try being frugal for a while.

Jun 13, 2015 at 07:11 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.8 #5A7rII game plan. What are you doing
schlotz wrote:
does the addition of the electronic 1st curtain eliminate the shutter shock


EFCS probably wouldn't have fixed the problem on the 7r. I have it turned off on the a7 because I get more consistent exposure when making panos without it, but I don't get shutter shock, even using it the same way I used the a7r (hanging off a bellows/tech camera). I bet it was the little metal frame built around the sensor to support the mount that caused that particular problem. It's a prominent design difference between the 7 and 7r and would explain why the problem was evident when the camera was hanging off the back of a tripod-mounted lens/bellows but not when hand-holding.
Jun 13, 2015 at 08:12 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.8 #6A7rII game plan. What are you doing
How did we get on film. That's a dirty word. Lol

Have not shot a piece of film in almost 20 years.
Jun 13, 2015 at 08:31 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.8 #7A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
How did we get on film. That's a dirty word. Lol

Have not shot a piece of film in almost 20 years.


"Dirty"? Or "dirt cheap" as some want us to believe?
Jun 13, 2015 at 08:46 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.8 #8A7rII game plan. What are you doing
freaklikeme wrote:
schlotz wrotedoes the addition of the electronic 1st curtain eliminate the shutter shock
EFCS probably wouldn't have fixed the problem on the 7r. I have it turned off on the a7 because I get more consistent exposure when making panos without it, but I don't get shutter shock, even using it the same way I used the a7r (hanging off a bellows/tech camera). I bet it was the little metal frame built around the sensor to support the mount that caused that particular problem. It's a prominent design difference between the 7 and 7r and would explain why the problem was evident when the camera was hanging off the back of a tripod-mounted
...Show more →

It's true the A7 didn't suffer from shutter shock even with EFCS off. But the A7r would definitely have benefited from an EFCS - its shock is caused by the long duration following the first curtain opening, an interval that occurs while the exposure is happening. The second curtain has much less time to affect the exposure since most of its vibration propagates after the curtain has closed.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:10 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.8 #9A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Kind of both.

Problem is in my world everything is I want it yesterday and film became extinct. Thats part of the business now, some guys in the Pro world can still get around it but for me that was not the case. Its expected to deliver immediately now. Not sure I miss it though, it was a hassle on several levels but the word cheap not sure i would say that shooting chromes. Kodachrome shooters like i was it was actually expensive, of course you billed for it. But today even though not a lot of soft goods in digital on the surface , there are a lot of expenses still. Computers, drives, memory cards, ram. It all adds up. I never did the cost comparisions but I never thought one was cheaper than the other. Its been so long for me now, it just resides in memory.

I will say this regardless of costs and such. Film was a huge learning experience for the growth of a photographer. To me you learned more because you had to nail everything down or you blew a job. So it taught you fast, because you screw up than you lose a client. Plus as you shoot your burning money right in front of you its not hidden like digital. Thats makes you very aware of what you are doing. People can argue the film vs digital all day long but bottom line I think no one will deny is it taught you to be a good photographer. At least it did for me.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:15 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.8 #10A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Shutter shock is yesterdays news. Now is that nice to hear or what. Im looking forward to not doing work arounds now. Plus I will enjoy a higher sync speed to boot. Its old news now folks lets move on to the next battlefield.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:19 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.8 #11A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Im going back to that film debate. Something most don't realize buying film cameras and even lenses back when where a lot cheaper than todays digital systems but the cost of film especially if you shot color and a lot of it, the costs of that at least for me was pretty dang expensive. It was nothing to spend a grand a month on film costs. Do the math that 12 K per year. Now do that cost analyses

Why I never did it , I don't want to know.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:29 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.8 #12A7rII game plan. What are you doing
rattymouse wrote:
Jman13 wroteFilm plus development is not dirt cheap. At least not in the U.S. Decent films cost at least $7 for 24 exposures, then another $8-15 for developing/scanning and you're up to around $20 for 24 exposures. $0.83 every time you click the shutter isn't exactly cheap. At my current output, given review shooting and my own personal shooting, I'd spend over $15,000 a year if I shot only film. And I'm not a spray and pray guy.
Develop film yourself and costs drop to almost nothing. I can develop a roll of black and white film for under 20 cents. Twenty cents! Color for under $1. I shoot 500 or more rolls of film per year and the cost to me is negligible. I spent far more on digital playing the rat race buying new gear all the time.

Further, if you know the shot you want, if you can conceive of the image before the shot, then you certainly dont need $15,000 worth of film to execute it properly. Pros can and do make a
...Show more →

So many severely flawed arguments here.

You set a situation where you do the absolute bare bones minimal costs for film and compare to excessive digital gear purchasing. That is an apples to oranges comparison. No one said you had to join the 'rat race' and buy all kinds of gear. Lots of people use digital and don't buy gear. I've spent well under 1k a year on camera gear, that is including a MF film system. I would spend significantly more on film, especially if you get it developed and scanned by someone else.

You also make the flawed argument that your way of shooting is the best way/only way. Who says someone shouldn't shot 15,000 frames a year? Who says they lack vision and skill to capture it with fewer frames? Quite an arrogant argument.

You seem to be an exception where you are trying to consume your time. Many people here have limited time and it is far more valuable than your time obviously.

Film can be cheap, but not nearly as cheap as digital.
Jun 14, 2015 at 06:29 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.8 #13A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Develop film yourself as a working Pro that takes valuable time in a lousy darkroom when your losing money not shooting. Film was not ideal folks at all. For working Pros around the globe it's very simple time is money. If your not shooting your not making money and even as a hobbyist your spending valuable time in a darkroom than your real job, your real family and your not making a nickel from it. But what all this has to do with a new camera release is beyond me. But if your tired of the costs of digital than simply stop chasing the latest tech. 10 year old digital cameras still work, 5 year even better ones. No one is twisting your arm as a hobbyist. For Pros it's far diffrent we have to keep up to at least a certain degree.
Jun 14, 2015 at 07:23 AM
howard
Offline
Details
p.8 #14A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Agree with the 2 posts above.

Don't get me wrong: I am not saying that digital photography equipment is cheap; I too wish things were cheaper. Nor am I arguing that film photography does not have its place; I believe it will be here to stay for a long time as it offers some unique artistic characteristics.

But I am arguing that the ongoing expenses with film is MUCH, MUCH higher than digital. Maybe for someone who already has a lab and who does not shoot many frames, the difference is minimized, but for a more typical workflow, the cost of film plus processing is a lot higher, even if we don't take time and lost opportunity cost into consideration. To argue otherwise by cherry-framing a corner-case situation is disingenuous, IMO.
Jun 14, 2015 at 07:37 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.8 #15A7rII game plan. What are you doing
I shoot both digital and film and enjoy both. They both can deliver outstanding results. The film process is long and tedious...but very enjoyable for me. Film does make me slow down and really focus on what I am trying to achieve. I know digital does not necessarily make you more careless, but the "zero cost" for each image and the ability to chimp readjust and shoot again does lead you to a different process. I hear many times people coming back with a thousand images from an outing...how many would have done that with film?

Both mediums are very capable and each have their strengths. A B&W photo from a nice 4x5 negative has a unique look and feel which digital just cannot replicate.
Jun 14, 2015 at 07:46 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.8 #16A7rII game plan. What are you doing
There are, as always, pros and cons to cost with film vs digital. Just a few points...

1) Film is it's own archive. Over time, this means less time and cost in storage, transferring to new archive media as technologies come and go, etc. For instance, my oldest digital images are on Syquest discs! How universally accessible are these now? These have been transferred multiple times over the years. Hard drives have limited, short life times as well and on and on the digital upgrade cycle goes...

2) Pre-digital, a professional shot a job, dropped the film off at the lab, picked the film up, edited and delivered to the client. How has digital changed this workflow? The photographer has now taken on the role of the lab. That includes the additional time and costs associated with providing this service (computers, drives, subsequent upgrade cycles and all the time for digital processing). As mentioned above, that's more time not shooting but in this case sitting in front of the computer instead! Often it's also the case in my experience that the editing stage is drastically more time consuming in the digital realm then it ever was with film. With film and an experienced photographer, fewer images overall were generally shot per job/ outing and I would argue that the quality (not technical but content/ getting the shot) was at least at the same level (from an experienced photographer). So, where say I might have shot 60-100 images on job X with film, I might shoot 600 digital images minimum. The result - more time spent editing, more processing, more storage requirements and so on.

3) For a professional, the cost of film and processing is charged to the client of course. Never did a client flinch at this expense on an invoice, probably because it was for a tangible (physical) thing. Charging a client for the digital equivalent (all of that digital processing, computer equipment overhead, additional editing) must also be done but with smaller clients, one might be surprised sometimes at the resistance for this if it's itemized on an invoice. Compounding the issue...In general, the fees an average pro photographer make have not increased in the digital age. If anything, I think they have gone down.

Anyway, it is apples to oranges depending on individual use. I'm sure digital is cheaper for some, film cheaper for others. There are also so many other pros and cons beyond cost to both. I don't know one commercial photographer that would ever go back to shooting film given all of the other advantages (immediate feedback, control over the entire process and so on). For other uses like fine art though, there are many who prefer film for a multitude of reasons.
Jun 14, 2015 at 07:48 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.8 #17A7rII game plan. What are you doing
All good points. I AM THE LAB NOW.

Its not a joke, but we have far more control over the outcome of the final file. BUT not all of us can charge for digital time. Film it was a expected cost to a client. Try doing that today and its really difficult to charge processing fees. Some folks can but most cannot
Jun 14, 2015 at 08:34 AM
Beni
Offline
Details
p.8 #18A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Back on topic, for my personal usage and my A7r lives in my bag and goes everywhere with me, the A7rII would be lovely for the following: image stabilisation in body, improved AF, silent shutter and better ergonomics. I have no need whatsoever for the new sensor and to be frank, for a personal camera, I can't justify the extra expenditure, at new body prices, just to answer quirks rather than real issues getting in the way of my vision.

However for a pro looking at a 5Dr or used to using Medium Format Digital the price is not only a non issue but a plus. I think most of us here are looking up at the price rather than looking down at just how cheap it is for what it provides.

Two different perspectives, both totally valid. I think the A7III will equalise the balance providing a solution which will be as great and well rounded a camera but at a more consumer friendly price and with more realistic megapixel counts for the majority.
Jun 14, 2015 at 10:00 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.8 #19A7rII game plan. What are you doing
You know much money I'm saving over MF. I can't count that high.

Feature set for me and output makes it a no way I'm passing. It fills a big void.
Jun 14, 2015 at 10:18 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.8 #20A7rII game plan. What are you doing
For the time being I will continue to use my A7r and I will not pre-order the A7rII. Hopefully when I am ready (maybe late in 2015?) the price of the new camera will drop below the initial list price of $3200.

Right now I have an order to be delivered next week (hopefully) for a new much faster and much more powerful laptop computer to allow me to process my images much faster and to help to deal with the need for a much larger hard drive.

With the new 42 MP sensor for the A7rII and now seeing that Charles K is selling his modified sensor A7r, maybe I will hold off on the Kolari Modified sensor of my A7r. Unlike Charles though, if I purchase the A7rII, I do not intend to sell my A7r, but would instead use the camera as a back-up and also a lighter weight camera body when needed.

I just returned from Shenandoah NP where my A7r produced outstanding results on the 36 MP sensor; I have a lot of images to process. After I have the new computer up and running, I am anticipating taking my A7r to Acadia NP in Maine within the next 2 weeks.

Rich
Jun 14, 2015 at 10:20 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister