fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.69 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I'm brand agnostic, even though I'm vested in Canon.

If Canon brought out a camera that functions the EXACT SAME as the A7R II ... guess what, it is still crippled in the longer AF department ... I'm gonna pass.
Great that it is smaller, has EVF, BSI, tilting display, more programmable buttons, etc. But, if it can't do the job, it can't do the job. I'm gonna pass, no matter who's name is on it.

Keep the main thing, the main thing ... I just want a camera that fully functions with ALL my glass. But, I guess that's not an en vogue concept these days ... too old school for some, I suppose.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1383491/3?keyword=steam#13243676
Oct 15, 2015 at 07:33 AM
Rajan Parrikar
Offline
Details
p.69 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
Rajan Parrikar wrote
NCAndy wroteSony just added in a new firmware uncompressed 14 bit raw to the A7rII Not really sure what that means because I have never used the camera.

http://www.bhphotovideo.com/explora/photography/news/sony-adds-uncompressed14-bit-raw-a7r-ii?utm_medium=Email&utm_campaign=NewAnnouncement&utm_source=SonyRX1RII%20151014&utm_content=Explora&utm_term=Sony-A7RII-Firmware
Sony is truly on a tear while Canikon are asleep.
It is difficult to take that remark seriously, as the feature mentioned has been standard in Canon cameras for about 10 years. Wait a minute. Canon provides losslessly compressed 14 bits RAW, while Sony still only provides uncompressed, large files or lossy compressed. This is a minor point in any case. The 5DS R is the most refined and complete camera I have ever owned, and Canon is churning out new breathtaking lenses faster than I can buy them.


The absence of uncompressed RAW was a serious limitation on the Sony body and that situation has been redressed. It is Sony that is currently pushing the innovation envelope whereas Canon is delivering warmed over stale soup insofar as the camera bodies are concerned. Currently I work with 2 Canon 5DS bodies with which I have no complaints, but that doesn't blind me to the obvious ingenuity that Sony has recently displayed.

As a user of the best of Canon glass (and Zeiss optics) I agree with you that Canon has been active on that front.



Oct 15, 2015 at 07:51 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.69 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Rajan Parrikar wrote:
It is Sony that is currently pushing the innovation envelope whereas Canon is delivering warmed over stale soup insofar as the camera bodies are concerned.


There are different ways to see that. Canon has perfectioned their main course on the menu to taste better than ever. Sony introduces fancy new cuisine and have to work hard to make the customers accept it, because there were so many things that didn't taste right in the first iterations. There are even new issues introduced with the A7rII that will need to be addressed in the next iteration, like the slow rolling shutter in silent mode, sensor cleaning restrictions because of IBIS, and long exposure noise. There is a cost to push the envelope and I am glad someone does it, but sometimes there is no better thing than going to your old favourite restaurant and enjoy your meal that is better than ever.
Oct 15, 2015 at 08:06 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.69 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
The brand humping posters who think that wading into forums to continuously post in your face messages about why one brand sucks eggs and the other is god's gift to photography shed little light on anything aside from the posters' own personal issues. (Mostly best to ignore them. Replying gives them, I think, a kind of perverse pleasure and provoking anger is at least partially their goal.)


GDan wrote also: "Sometime I might find myself in a situation where I'll remember that "little mirror" idea and find it useful. ;-)"

A perfect fit here - use your mirror and hold it against yourself!




Edited on Oct 15, 2015 at 08:09 AM · View previous versions
Oct 15, 2015 at 08:08 AM
Rajan Parrikar
Offline
Details
p.69 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
Rajan Parrikar wroteIt is Sony that is currently pushing the innovation envelope whereas Canon is delivering warmed over stale soup insofar as the camera bodies are concerned.
There are different ways to see that. Canon has perfectioned their main course on the menu to taste better than ever. Sony introduces fancy new cuisine and have to work hard to make the customers accept it, because there were so many things that didn't taste right in the first iterations. There are even new issues introduced with the A7rII that will need to be addressed in the next iteration, like the slow rolling shutter in silent mode, sensor cleaning restrictions because of IBIS, and long exposure noise. There is a cost to push the envelope and I am glad
...Show more →

I have no disagreement with the above.

Oct 15, 2015 at 08:08 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.69 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Innovation ... cool stuff.

Electric and hybrid cars ... innovative. But when it comes time to get the job done, sometimes you just need a good old reliable fossil fuel combustion engine. Maybe someday we'll see the sky-ways littered with drones and the highways full of electric-semi's ... but for now if you need to move a big payload reliably, the innovation isn't up to the task to keep things moving along.

An electric car will get the groceries just fine ... it's probably not the best choice for starting a moving company just yet.

Sony's innovation(s) (cool as they are) simply doesn't provide for those who want the workhorse on the long end with their Canon glass to get the job done. If you're willing to switch out your long glass for Sony Alpha glass + adapter on a Sony E-body, that's a different animal. But if you're vested in your Canon (or Nikon) long glass, the Sony innovations aren't doing you any pragmatic favors for their utilization that I can see.
Oct 15, 2015 at 08:19 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.69 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Innovation ... cool stuff.

Electric and hybrid cars ... innovative. But when it comes time to get the job done, sometimes you just need a good old reliable fossil fuel combustion engine. Maybe someday we'll see the sky-ways littered with drones and the highways full of electric-semi's ... but for now if you need to pull a big load reliably, the innovation isn't up to the task to keep things moving along.

Sony's innovation(s) (cool as they are) simply doesn't provide for those who need the workhorse on the long end with their Canon glass.


And Canon's slow pace by still only having bulky and heavy DSLR camera gear with no big jump in sensor technology other than the looooooong waited/needed for admittedly good high MP count might make others add or switch to another system. Question also is if those who need good AF with long tele lenses are really needing the pricy 5Ds(R) or rather the 5D MkIII (or soon MkIV?) instead. The 5Ds(R) is a good camera, but came too late to the market and finds itself a bit outdated now competing against newer technology out there which has its own benefits (size, weight reduction and lens adaptability).
Oct 15, 2015 at 08:31 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.69 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Rajan Parrikar wrote:
It is Sony that is currently pushing the innovation envelope whereas Canon is delivering warmed over stale soup insofar as the camera bodies are concerned.


That's why you recently paid a lot of good money to buy two (2) warmed over stale soups.
Oct 15, 2015 at 08:39 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.69 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Outdated ... really. Which FF camera has surpassed it's pixel count?

Besides, every year a new model truck comes out that would "outdate" last years model. Yet a good truck will keep doing the job it was made for for decades. The whole "outdated" concept is folly. My TV is outdated, my microwave is outdated, my laptop is outdated, my phone is outdated, my software is outdated, my bike is outdated, my hammer is outdated, my chisel is outdated ... but, the ones that I chose are all still getting the job done, done well, and done to my satisfaction.

"Outdated" is consumerism folly ... and yet even with all the innovation of the Sony ... the freakin' camera still can't AF my long glass (and never will). So much for innovation vs. outdated equipment. Innovation that diminishes functionality ... well, if that's what you consider innovative over outdated, that's your perspective. I'll stick with functionality over innovation if it is going to require such a significant degradation in functionality. My 2004 SLR/C or 1D MK II or 700D will still properly AF my 100-400L II on the long end.

Can all the combined innovation(s) of the 2015 Sony muster up enough wherewithal to say the same thing?

The answer is clearly "No." The only way you get long glass AF with Sony is to go buy Sony long glass (or third party) and an SLT body (eating more light through the SLT), or mount it to a Sony adapter (eating more light & subject to damage) for the E-mount body.

If that's what you call innovation ... you can keep it. I'll stick with outdated and functionality that simply works as designed rather than the rigamarole imposed by said innovation.

Edited on Oct 15, 2015 at 08:58 AM · View previous versions
Oct 15, 2015 at 08:45 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.69 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Outdated ... really. Which FF camera has surpassed it's pixel count?

Besides, every year a new model truck comes out that would "outdate" last years model. Yet a good truck will keep doing the job it was made for for decades. The whole "outdated" concept is folly. My TV is outdated, my microwave is outdated, my laptop is outdated, my phone is outdated, my software is outdated, my bike is outdated, my hammer is outdated, my chisel is outdated ... but, the ones that I chose are all still getting the job done, done well, and done to my satisfaction.

"Outdated" is
...Show more →

I said it clearly above that the high MP count of the new Canon cameras is good. Outdated related to using the same camera body as the 5D MkII/III from years ago, no tilt screen, no internal WiFi, etcetc. My point was to say that the 5Ds(R) has now a much harder time to compete against other competitive FF models out there than if Canon had released it a few years earlier especially when Nikon released the D800(E) series. Really, what Canon needs now is a competitive FF mirrorless camera with good sensor technology.
Oct 15, 2015 at 08:52 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.69 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:

Really, what Canon needs now is a competitive FF mirrorless camera with good sensor technology.


Which would essentially serve the same reduced functionality imposed by the Sony mirrorless (given the latest technology we've seen from Sony) ... i.e. brand agnostic. The same could apply to Nikon.

Would it be an optional offering, sure ... why not. But, I still don't think that Canon's strong base of long glass shooters would be clamoring for the reduced functionality it would compromise, unless they do innovate a different technology for mirrorless than currently exists.

I'm sure that Canon knows the market impact of the Sony A7R II. I doubt they will come out with a Sony clone anytime soon. Then again, maybe they do ... IDK.

All I know is that the Sony mirrorless doesn't work with all my glass as well as the Canon does. Pretty simple.

So, when it comes time to choose an upgrade for my venerable SLR/C ... the Sony is "out".



Edited on Oct 15, 2015 at 09:16 AM · View previous versions
Oct 15, 2015 at 09:04 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.69 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
retrofocus wroteReally, what Canon needs now is a competitive FF mirrorless camera with good sensor technology.
Which would essentially serve the same reduced functionality imposed by the Sony mirrorless (given the latest technology we've seen from Sony) ... i.e. brand agnostic.

Would it be an optional offering, sure ... why not. But, I still don't think that Canon's strong base of long glass shooters would be clamoring for the reduced functionality it would compromise, unless they do innovate a different technology for mirrorless than currently exists.


Rusty, I agree with you here - my impression also is that Canon's base now is more directed towards the sports/events/wedding/wildlife shooting. That could very well be the reason why Canon might not consider moving too quickly into this mirrorless direction, pretty much gives up to compete with mirrorless here. If this is a good long term strategy is a different topic to discuss. In the end it is all good, because we all have choices now as long as we are not hooked to just one brand.
Oct 15, 2015 at 09:10 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.69 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
+1 @ choices ... sometimes too many.

Sometimes I open the knife drawer ... and just reach in my pocket instead.
Oct 15, 2015 at 09:14 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.69 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Monito wrote:
That's why you recently paid a lot of good money to buy two (2) warmed over stale soups.


One of your best posts. Ever. ;-)

For the record, I think it would (will?) be a fine thing if (when?) Canon (and Nikon) get their non P&S mirrorless products to the stage where they believe they will do more than be "me, too" products.

I don't know how many times I need to write this, but — one more time! — I like mirrorless cameras for some purposes. My non-Canon mirrorless camera system is my preferred system for portions of my work, particularly travel photography, street photography, and night street photography. If I wasn't so well served for the rest of my photography by the Canon and non-Canon equipment I have chosen to use, I might well get the very interesting and compelling Sony mirrorless system for my street/travel photography.

You see, I really do believe — despite the unending attempts by a (very) few folks to suggest otherwise — what I've been saying all along: There are a bunch of brands that produce really interesting and competent gear that smart, aware photographers might choose to use. I use more than one brand! I have photography colleagues and friends who use just about every brand and format you can name, and they all do wonderful work and have fine personal reasons for choosing the gear they choose to use. In some ways Brand A might be better for a given photographer. In other ways Brand B or Brand C might be better. But they are all useful and interesting and competent brands — including both brands that I use and a number of brands that I don't.

I have nothing against Sony or Nikon or Pentax or Olympus or [fill in your favorite brand].

I have nothing against photographers who choose to use one or more of those other systems in their work.

I am increasingly fed up with people looking to pick a personal fight about a camera brand, of all bizarre things, and who will even go so far as to invent imaginary positions for other folks just so that they can, or so it appears, have something to argue with.*

One of the biggest (and most obvious) ironies in camera forums comes when those who beat their particular brand dead horse (pick one, any one) until only horseburger remains then show up and suggest that the subjects of their personalizations are the ones making horseburger.

Mirror, indeed.

Next time someone wants to suggest that I'm a brand fanboy, quote that italicized text with your post. In the meantime, I'm not about to argue with someone's imaginary notions of what they would like to fantasize that I think, just to gratify their need for a straw man subject for their angst. ;-)

Dan

PS: At the suggestion of another FM'er, I have added underlining to the bold and italic print. Not that it will help... ;-)

*Yes, on occasion I have misinterpreted someone's post and accidentally disagreed with something they didn't actually write — an error that I regret and for which I'm sorry.

Edited on Oct 15, 2015 at 12:51 PM · View previous versions
Oct 15, 2015 at 09:30 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.69 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
The answer is clearly "No." The only way you get long glass AF with Sony is to go buy Sony long glass (or third party) and an SLT body (eating more light through the SLT), or mount it to a Sony adapter (eating more light & subject to damage) for the E-mount body.


What is this mythical unicorn "Sony long glass" you speak of?

Are you referring to the modestly competent 70-400G II zoom, or are you talking about the 300 f2.8 and 500mm f4 which are so popular they are only manufactured on special order, like Canon's 1200mm f5.6L?
Oct 15, 2015 at 09:45 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.69 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I don't know about horse-burger, but we've got a horse butcher in town that sells horse salami.

Actually, they do sell horse burger meat-- $6/lb (converted from €12/kilo).

Horses for, erm... courses. (And burgers.)
Oct 15, 2015 at 09:46 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.69 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
I don't know about horse-burger, but we've got a horse butcher in town that sells horse salami.

Actually, they do sell horse burger meat-- $6/lb (converted from €12/kilo).

Horses for, erm... courses. (And burgers.)


That would be "horses for main courses?" ;-)

(Please tell me you aren't having horse for dessert...)
Oct 15, 2015 at 09:48 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.69 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Monito wroteThat's why you recently paid a lot of good money to buy two (2) warmed over stale soups.
One of your best posts. Ever. ;-)

For the record, I think it would (will?) be a fine thing if (when?) Canon (and Nikon) get their non P&S mirrorless products to the stage where they believe they will do more than be "me, too" products.

I don't know how many times I need to write this, but — one more time! — I like mirrorless cameras for some purposes. My non-Canon mirrorless camera system is my preferred system for portions of my work, particularly travel photography, street photography, and night street photography. If I wasn't so well served for the rest

You see, I really do believe — despite the unending attempts by a (very) few folks to suggest otherwise — what I've been saying all along: There are a bunch of brands that produce really interesting and competent gear that smart, aware photographers might choose to use. I use more than one brand! I have photography colleagues and friends who use just about every brand and format you can name, and they all do wonderful work and have fine personal reasons for choosing the gear they choose to use. In some ways Brand A might be better for a given photographer. In other ways Brand B or Brand C might be better. But they are all useful and interesting and competent brands — including both brands that I use and a number of brands that I don't.

I have nothing against Sony or Nikon or Pentax or Olympus or... I have nothing against photographers who choose to use one or more of those other systems in their work. I am increasingly fed up with people looking to pick a personal fight about a camera brand, of all bizarre things, and who will even go so far as to invent imaginary positions for other folks just so that they can, or so it appears, have something to argue with.

One of the biggest (and most obvious) ironies in camera forums comes when those who beat their particular brand (pick one) dead horse until only horseburger remains then show up and suggest that the subjects of their personalizations are the ones making horseburger.

Mirror, indeed.

Next time someone wants to suggest that I'm a brand fanboy, quote that italicized text with your post. In the meantime, I'm not about to argue with someone's imaginary notions of what they would like to fantasize that I think, just to gratify their need for a straw man subject. ;-)
...Show more →


I think you should have underlined some parts too, Dan
Oct 15, 2015 at 09:56 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.69 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
RustyBug wroteThe answer is clearly "No." The only way you get long glass AF with Sony is to go buy Sony long glass (or third party) and an SLT body (eating more light through the SLT), or mount it to a Sony adapter (eating more light & subject to damage) for the E-mount body.
What is this mythical unicorn "Sony long glass" you speak of?

Are you referring to the modestly competent 70-400G II zoom, or are you talking about the 300 f2.8 and 500mm f4 which are so popular they are only manufactured on special order, like Canon's 1200mm f5.6L?


Hey ... I was giving them as much credence as I could in the essence of "fair play". You could still get the Tammy or Sigma for the Sony A mount and adapt it, too. But, for those who have done their homework ... well, I think they already know the score.

Personally, I think a person would be far better off to go to Nikon than Sony if you have an interest in long glass. The recent 200-500 / 5.6 is a really interesting attraction to mate with the D810 or D7200 for general use (i.e. not Big White or Nikon's best). But, in any regard ... long glass and Sony is not going to be a preferred option for many, particularly not for those already vested in their Canon longer glass, imo.

Oct 15, 2015 at 10:00 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.69 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
Monito wroteThat's why you recently paid a lot of good money to buy two (2) warmed over stale soups.
One of your best posts. Ever. ;-)

For the record, I think it would (will?) be a fine thing if (when?) Canon (and Nikon) get their non P&S mirrorless products to the stage where they believe they will do more than be "me, too" products.

I don't know how many times I need to write this, but — one more time! — I like mirrorless cameras for some purposes. My non-Canon mirrorless camera system is my preferred system for portions of my work, particularly travel photography, street photography, and night street photography. If I wasn't so well served for the rest of my photography by the Canon equipment I have chosen to use, I might well get the very interesting and compelling Sony mirrorless system for my street/travel photography.

You see, I really do believe — despite the unending attempts by a (very) few folks to suggest otherwise — what I've been saying all along: There are a bunch of brands that produce really interesting and competent gear that smart, aware photographers might choose to use. I use more than one brand! I have photography colleagues and friends who use just about every brand and format you can name, and they all do wonderful work and have fine personal reasons for choosing the gear they choose to use. In some ways Brand A might be better for a given photographer. In other ways Brand B or Brand C might be better. But they are all useful and interesting and competent brands — including both brands that I use and a number of brands that I don't.


I have nothing against Sony or Nikon or Pentax or Olympus or... I have nothing against photographers who choose to use one or more of those other systems in their work. I am increasingly fed up with people looking to pick a personal fight about a camera brand, of all bizarre things, and who will even go so far as to invent imaginary positions for other folks just so that they can, or so it appears, have something to argue with.

One of the biggest (and most obvious) ironies in camera forums comes when those who beat their particular brand (pick one) dead horse until only horseburger remains then show up and suggest that the subjects of their personalizations are the ones making horseburger.

Mirror, indeed.

Next time someone wants to suggest that I'm a brand fanboy, quote that italicized text with your post. In the meantime, I'm not about to argue with someone's imaginary notions of what they would like to fantasize that I think, just to gratify their need for a straw man subject. ;-)
I think you should have underlined some parts too, Dan


Good idea! And I just used a yellow highlighter pen on my monitor and it is even more obvious now... ;-)

Edited on Oct 15, 2015 at 10:15 AM · View previous versions
Oct 15, 2015 at 10:03 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister