fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
Monito
Offline
Details
p.53 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
You know, it really doesn't matter. People will buy what they want to buy, based on their own research and preferences. There will always be people who say it was a bad idea to buy it, but it really doesn't matter. Really, it doesn't matter.


gdanmitchell wrote:
:-) I'm with you. I've long held that it really doesn't matter at all what brand one chooses to use, and that most initial brand decisions are made on the basis of a whim, an accident, or a self-confirming belief.


Yes. The photographer is far and away the biggest variable in the process of making photographs, even when the photographer is very experienced, but more so when the photographer is a gearhead. Brands are somewhere below even the distant second and third variables.
Oct 06, 2015 at 04:40 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.53 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
They are toys to me, [...] branch war [...]


For most photographers they are tools which is why they are much less passionate about them. I'm sure you are not a child, but your use of the word "toys" explains a lot.
Oct 06, 2015 at 04:43 AM
dclark2171
Offline
Details
p.53 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I think its great people are arguing over this stuff. just means there are more than two major players (Nikon/Canon) now in the 35mm FF market. Plus, Pentax is coming on board. All the competition will improve everyones equipment.


Oct 06, 2015 at 04:47 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.53 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Gunzorro wrote:
mttran wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
jcolwell wroteYou know, it really doesn't matter. People will buy what they want to buy, based on their own research and preferences. There will always be people who say it was a bad idea to buy it, but it really doesn't matter. Really, it doesn't matter.
:-)

I'm with you.

I've long held that it really doesn't matter at all what brand one chooses to use, and that most initial brand decisions are made on the basis of a whim, an accident, or a self-confirming belief. Why did I get a Minolta film SLR back in the day? I have no idea. Why did I end up shooting (mostly) Canon when I moved to digital? My brother had a Canon camera? Would my photography be any different if had gotten a Nikon film camera back in the day? Not likely. What if I had followed the Nikon path with digital? My photography would be essentially the same.

It won't convince a few folks here — nothing will — but I've seen enough photography by people using all kinds of brands and all kinds of different gear to understand that while the camera isn't irrelevant, people can and do produce excellent work with an astonishing range of gear.

Sony makes some fine and very interesting gear. Canon makes some excellent and quite useful gear. Nikon produces excellent cameras and lenses. I'm fascinated by some things that Pentax has done. I know folks who love their Olympus cameras. My Fujifilm system does beautiful work. There is great gear in 4/thirds, cropped format, full frame, MF, you name it.

It must be sort of embarrassing eventually for some folks to be such brand whores that they actually develop opinions of other people based on which camera brand they use! How in the world does that make any sense at all? ;-)

Carry on...

Dan
They are toys to me, I take whatever makes my canon lenses shine. It seems like you trap yourself to a "whores" branch war in your own word, lol
"a "whores" branch war in your own word"

Whatever the "F" that means!

Thanks again for the insistent Sony sales pitch.


At least he said he was done with this thread. We can only hope he is a man of his word
Oct 06, 2015 at 05:03 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.53 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RobDickinson wrote:
a7r2 looks quite soft there


Ouch, looks even softer then the original A7R.

dclark2171 wrote:
I think its great people are arguing over this stuff. just means there are more than two major players (Nikon/Canon) now in the 35mm FF market. Plus, Pentax is coming on board. All the competition will improve everyones equipment.


I agree. Would love to see Sony compete against the 1DX2/D5. I'm not looking for cheap. I'm looking for a pro level body for around $4000-$5000. Canikon's $7000+ flagships are a bit ridiculous in price.

The A7 series is just too small, too fragile for heavy sports work. Ergonomics suck on them. Rumors of a pro level A9 might be interesting though. Maybe Sony is waiting for Canon and Nikon to show their hand then release something to steal the thunder?
Oct 06, 2015 at 06:57 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.53 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Darned Leica shooters — basically defective human beings! ;-)

Your point about instinctive tribalism is, I think, accurate. On the other hand, it has been pointed out that while there is an evolutionary benefit to groupthink tribal behavior, there is also an evolutionary benefit when not all members of the tribe buy into it, especially when the instinctive tribalist behavior sometimes is the cause of evolutionary challenges.

In any case, there is a difference between having some "tribal" tendencies in the form of pleasant feelings about brand (or a sports team or a university, etc) and going over the line to become obsessively and harmfully wild-eyed crazy about it, to the point that one loses contact with reality and, for example, begins to imagine that the rest of the world sees things the way you do, or that fans of that team, graduates of that school, drivers of those cars, or users of those cameras have some inherent moral flaws.

We can find a few examples around here, I'm afraid.

justruss wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteIt must be sort of embarrassing eventually for some folks to be such brand whores that they actually develop opinions of other people based on which camera brand they use! How in the world does that make any sense at all? ;-)
Actually, I think it makes a lot of sense from a fundamental, evolutionary biology standpoint.

Humans, like most primates, are a factional, tribal/clan-driven species with a few extra quirks. Safety in numbers is an interesting concept in that 10 is probably safer than 2, but if the whole planet is 100, a faction of 100 is like all of a sudden having no faction at all (individuals) unless we're sophisticated enough (I think we have the tools, but haven't developed the culture) to get the faction of 100 to work just right.

Look out at the world and we can
...Show more →

Monito wrote:
[Yes. The photographer is far and away the biggest variable in the process of making photographs, even when the photographer is very experienced, but more so when the photographer is a gearhead. Brands are somewhere below even the distant second and third variables.


And while there are, no doubt, differences among brands and models and formats and all the rest, the issue is that it is literally impossible to come to any objective conclusion about which brand, model, etc. is actually "best." They can all be excellent for producing the work that the photographers is trying to produce.

And beyond that, even if one imagines that there is a "best brand" that rules over all others, it is a waste of everyone's time (including the deluded person's own time) to have to fight out some interminable "brand war" that really is no more real than the war between sports Team A and Team B. (But don't you go dissing my Giants!)

Feel free to like your Leica, canonize your Canon, feel sweet about your Sony, go numb over Nikon, and all the rest, but keep a bit of perspective!

Dan
Oct 06, 2015 at 07:11 AM
dehowie
Offline
Details
p.53 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RobDickinson wrote:
dehowie wroteLol..a comparison of a 52 MP Camera that's fitted with a rubbish lens vs a Sony with a Zeiss?
You can't be serious can you to call that a comparison?
Better idea put the Zeiss on the Canon and see how it looks...
Talk about confirmation bias..actually just call it bias.
Sorry are you talking about the sigma 70mm 2.8 macro? because from memory there are few lenses sharper.


And one of the lenses that is quite a bit sharper is the Zeiss 55mm.
In fact the mtf for the Sigma compared to even the Canon 24-70/2.8II is quite a bit worse.
Seems to me the test was far from a level playing field...
Oct 06, 2015 at 08:11 AM
dehowie
Offline
Details
p.53 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
dehowie wroteLol..a comparison of a 52 MP Camera that's fitted with a rubbish lens vs a Sony with a Zeiss?
You can't be serious can you to call that a comparison?
Better idea put the Zeiss on the Canon and see how it looks...
Talk about confirmation bias..actually just call it bias.
Sony can't help it that their lenses are the best out there with a few exceptions...tests are done as a system.


And Canon as a System do not produce quality lenses?
I'm not sure if your just being sarcastic or simply have no idea.
I will assume the former.
You may not of heard of the Canon 24-70/2.8II.
Its mtf leaves the Sigma 70mm for dead and is at least as good as the Zeiss prime and would be a far more suitable candidate for a test of this form.
Given it and the Zeiss are very close it would of been ideal rather than lumbering the Canon with a less capable lens.
As for Sony making the best lenses I think the MTF charts do all the talking...there is a reason why Sony make the cameras to accept Canon glass and it's not because it's worse...
Oct 06, 2015 at 08:21 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.53 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
The ardent fan knows and acknowledges shortcomings while still advocating for his team ... the delusional fan blatantly ignores them. And yet, on any given Sunday
Oct 06, 2015 at 08:30 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.53 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
The ardent fan knows and acknowledges shortcomings while still advocating for his team ... the delusional fan blatantly ignores them. And yet, on any given Sunday


Which leads me to think about the 49ers... :-(
Oct 06, 2015 at 09:02 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.53 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
dehowie wroteLol..a comparison of a 52 MP Camera that's fitted with a rubbish lens vs a Sony with a Zeiss?
You can't be serious can you to call that a comparison?
Better idea put the Zeiss on the Canon and see how it looks...
Talk about confirmation bias..actually just call it bias.
Sony can't help it that their lenses are the best out there with a few exceptions...


Sadly, the opposite is true when it comes to lenses manufactured by Sony... which I suppose is why they parasitically rely on customers using Canon lenses with adapters.
Oct 06, 2015 at 09:29 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.53 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Boy for a thread in which people complained about the topic and how it just keeps on going...those same complainers are here right to the bitter end in this thread. Seems they enjoy these types of discussions just as much as others.
Carry on boys, carry on...I love a good chuckle once in a while.
Oct 06, 2015 at 10:12 AM
panicatnabisco
Offline
Details
p.53 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
"If you have nothing to contribute, dont post" -Chez

more than a chuckle from me

gdanmitchell wrote:
Which leads me to think about the 49ers... :-(


I'm calling it right now, its a lost season. Hello Singletary era version 2
Oct 06, 2015 at 10:20 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.53 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
panicatnabisco wrote:
"If you have nothing to contribute, dont post" -Chez

more than a chuckle from me

gdanmitchell wroteWhich leads me to think about the 49ers... :-(
I'm calling it right now, its a lost season. Hello Singletary era version 2


Someone with more time than I have could have some fun collecting the shared wisdom of certain posters at FM and simply using quotes from their earlier posts to reply to them. ;-)

Yeah, one news report made a pointed reference to the recent performance being the worst since Singletary. Sigh.

Dan
Oct 06, 2015 at 10:26 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.53 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
It struck me that I haven't yet made a direct comparison of my A7r and 5DSR with the same lens. A very good candidate would be the C/V Nokton 58 mm f/1.4 SL in Nikon mount. It is brand neutral, it is a top level performer stopped down, it is relatively light and compact, with easy precision manual focus, and it doesn't have floating elements. The latter is important to avoid problems with adapter thickness.

I set up for a quick shoot with a very sturdy tripod. Manual focussing in LiveView at f/4 for maximum moire on the roof of the yellow house, then stopped down to f/8. Manual exposure ISO 100, 1/10 sec with self-timer release.

For such comparisons to be fair, the images need to be compared at the same magnification, so I both uprezzed the A7R and downrezzed the 5DSR so they could be compared with the native size of the other camera. Processed in Capture One, Custom WB picked on a white fence, all sharpening and NR set to 0, standard film curve. Uprezzing / downrezzing directly from C1 to TIFF. These are then 100% crops of the resulting files.

http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/5DSR_A7R_Comp_zpsywcnrabg.png
Oct 06, 2015 at 10:49 AM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.53 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Wow the moire is really evident in the Canon, making it an extreme candidate for PP skills.
Oct 06, 2015 at 11:05 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.53 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
Wow the moire is really evident in the Canon, making it an extreme candidate for PP skills.


I kind of expected that reaction from the Sony Camp. Now that the Canon images are crisper, being crisp is a bad thing.
Oct 06, 2015 at 11:08 AM
Peter Figen
Offline
Details
p.53 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
There's moiré in the Sony roofs as well, just not as much. But seriously, this is not a hard fix in post. I don't know the NR or sharpening settings that were used in C1 to process these files, but they matter too, and the Detail slider can really make a difference when trying to extract that last little bit. C1 also has a Moiré removal tool, which can be quite effective, depending on the moiré.
Oct 06, 2015 at 11:17 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.53 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
It struck me that I haven't yet made a direct comparison of my A7r and 5DSR with the same lens. A very good candidate would be the C/V Nokton 58 mm f/1.4 SL in Nikon mount. It is brand neutral, it is a top level performer stopped down, it is relatively light and compact, with easy precision manual focus, and it doesn't have floating elements. The latter is important to avoid problems with adapter thickness.

I set up for a quick shoot with a very sturdy tripod. Manual focussing in LiveView at f/4 for maximum moire on the roof of the
...Show more →

The A7R photo seems slightly misfocused to me (visible in the white window frames of the yellow house), more visible in the uprezzed version in the upper right corner image. Taking this into account, I don't think there is a big difference between those files.
Oct 06, 2015 at 11:27 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.53 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wroteIt struck me that I haven't yet made a direct comparison of my A7r and 5DSR with the same lens. A very good candidate would be the C/V Nokton 58 mm f/1.4 SL in Nikon mount. It is brand neutral, it is a top level performer stopped down, it is relatively light and compact, with easy precision manual focus, and it doesn't have floating elements. The latter is important to avoid problems with adapter thickness.

I set up for a quick shoot with a very sturdy tripod. Manual focussing in LiveView at f/4 for maximum moire on the roof of the yellow house, then stopped down to f/8. Manual exposure ISO 100, 1/10 sec with self-timer release.

For such comparisons to be fair, the images need to be compared at the same magnification, so I both uprezzed the A7R and downrezzed the 5DSR so they could be compared with the native size of the other camera. Processed in Capture One, Custom WB picked on a white fence, all sharpening and NR set to 0, standard film curve. Uprezzing / downrezzing directly from C1 to TIFF. These are then 100% crops of the resulting files.

http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/5DSR_A7R_Comp_zpsywcnrabg.png
The A7R photo seems slightly misfocused to me (visible in the white window frames of the yellow house), more visible in the uprezzed version in the upper right corner image. Taking this into account, I don't think there is a big difference between those files.


I don't think so. There is no difference in actuance in either the closer or further objects, that would have been an indicator of different focus. They were very carefully focused at f/4 to peak moire, and then stopped down to f/8. In fact, there was more moire in the Sony viewfinder during focussing than in the Canon Viewfinder. A more reasonable explanation is shutter vibration from the A7r.
Oct 06, 2015 at 11:33 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister