fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
Monito
Offline
Details
p.27 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Paul Mo wrote:
Nice eyes. Nice lips. But that green hair...


And blue eyeballs.

And it looks like there is some aliasing of colours in the hair (not just green) but it is hard to tell what is going on without access to the original sized image.

Can that image be salvaged?
Jul 16, 2015 at 11:02 AM
KKFung
Offline
Details
p.27 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/pmw0e4j71u4m5oc/AABlCb7BR6h3L4bHRAIOl2Afa?dl=0

Above link for downloading A7rII raw file found from another forum, just for you guys reference
Jul 30, 2015 at 03:18 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.27 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Monito wrote:
Paul Mo wroteNice eyes. Nice lips. But that green hair...
And blue eyeballs.

And it looks like there is some aliasing of colours in the hair (not just green) but it is hard to tell what is going on without access to the original sized image.

Can that image be salvaged?


Easily. It is mostly a very crappy WB issue.






Jul 30, 2015 at 04:00 AM
secondclaw
Offline
Details
p.27 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
ggreene wrote
Fred Miranda wroteThe lack of f/2.8 zooms and super telephoto lenses for the Sony A7 bodies is a concept decision based on weight and size. Sony and Zeiss are pretty much concentrating on quality fast primes and f/4 zooms. It is a compromise many photographers can't afford to have for their photography needs. (Sports, photojournalists, etc.)
Design a pro body then for faster zooms. I don't think sports photographers discount Sony as much as you seem to hear about. There is just nothing there to entice us. Sony has packed a lot of nice features in the A7R2. Seems like they could easily compete with a 1DX2 or D5 at the $4000-$4500 price point. There are a heck of lot of mid level shooters that would think about it. Both Canon and Nikon are rapidly out pricing a lot of sports shooters. 1DX2 and D5 with new tech could be pushing $7000-$8000.
I'm at Pan Am games and can say that it is still at least 80-90% canon. Lots of big bodies and bigger lenses. A few with smaller bodies, but mostly 1D size. The market seems to have shifted back to canon after the upgraded bodies and super tele's. Sony has such a huge mountain to climb if they want to break into the sport world. Bodies first and lenses second.


I volunteered at Pan Am Games, in Press Ops, and worked as Photo Staff (green vest) most of the time. I had an opportunity to observe cameras that photographers brought. I also spoke with the head of Press Operations, who is a sports photographer himself. In addition, I volunteered at the Olympics in Sochi, and several times worked in access control at the media compound, so I could also observe what photographers brought.

It is not 80-90% Canon, it is about 50-50 ...
Interestingly, there were also reporters that we allowed into photo position, and they came with smaller all in one cameras, and these were mostly Nikon (but there were never enough of these people to conclude anything).
Now, our photo positions were allowing photographers to use shorter lenses (400-500 tops), it's possible where longer lenses were used, things would have been different.
Our head of Press Ops also told me that it's about 50-50 when I asked.
And yes, for Canon it was all 1D something body, I am not familiar with Nikons pro bodies, so I am not sure what was brought.
Jul 30, 2015 at 06:26 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.27 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
secondclaw wrote:
jctriguy wrote
ggreene wrote
Fred Miranda wroteThe lack of f/2.8 zooms and super telephoto lenses for the Sony A7 bodies is a concept decision based on weight and size. Sony and Zeiss are pretty much concentrating on quality fast primes and f/4 zooms. It is a compromise many photographers can't afford to have for their photography needs. (Sports, photojournalists, etc.)
Design a pro body then for faster zooms. I don't think sports photographers discount Sony as much as you seem to hear about. There is just nothing there to entice us. Sony has packed a lot of nice features in the A7R2. Seems like they could easily compete with a 1DX2 or D5 at the $4000-$4500 price point. There are a heck of lot of mid level shooters that would think about it. Both Canon and Nikon are rapidly out pricing a lot of sports shooters. 1DX2 and D5 with new tech could be pushing $7000-$8000.
I'm at Pan Am games and can say that it is still at least 80-90% canon. Lots of big bodies and bigger lenses. A few with smaller bodies, but mostly 1D size. The market seems to have shifted back to canon after the upgraded bodies and super tele's. Sony has such a huge mountain to climb if they want to break into the sport world. Bodies first and lenses second.
I volunteered at Pan Am Games, in Press Ops, and worked as Photo Staff (green vest) most of the time. I had an opportunity to observe cameras that photographers brought. I also spoke with the head of Press Operations, who is a sports photographer himself. In addition, I volunteered at the Olympics in Sochi, and several times worked in access control at the media compound, so I could also observe what photographers brought.

It is not 80-90% Canon, it is about 50-50 ...
Interestingly, there were also reporters that we allowed into photo position, and they came with smaller all in
...Show more →
At the sidelines of the events that was absolutely not my experience. I saw a sea of white lenses at every event. Might be different for press conferences or interviews, but the actual sport images looked to be mostly canon. I was in several press areas at several venues and had the same experience at all. Lots of gripped 5d size bodies as well, not all 1D.

Jul 30, 2015 at 06:40 AM
secondclaw
Offline
Details
p.27 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
secondclaw wrote
jctriguy wrote
ggreene wrote
Fred Miranda wroteThe lack of f/2.8 zooms and super telephoto lenses for the Sony A7 bodies is a concept decision based on weight and size. Sony and Zeiss are pretty much concentrating on quality fast primes and f/4 zooms. It is a compromise many photographers can't afford to have for their photography needs. (Sports, photojournalists, etc.)
Design a pro body then for faster zooms. I don't think sports photographers discount Sony as much as you seem to hear about. There is just nothing there to entice us. Sony has packed a lot of nice features in the A7R2. Seems like they could easily compete with a 1DX2 or D5 at the $4000-$4500 price point. There are a heck of lot of mid level shooters that would think about it. Both Canon and Nikon are rapidly out pricing a lot of sports shooters. 1DX2 and D5 with new tech could be pushing $7000-$8000.
I'm at Pan Am games and can say that it is still at least 80-90% canon. Lots of big bodies and bigger lenses. A few with smaller bodies, but mostly 1D size. The market seems to have shifted back to canon after the upgraded bodies and super tele's. Sony has such a huge mountain to climb if they want to break into the sport world. Bodies first and lenses second.
I volunteered at Pan Am Games, in Press Ops, and worked as Photo Staff (green vest) most of the time. I had an opportunity to observe cameras that photographers brought. I also spoke with the head of Press Operations, who is a sports photographer himself. In addition, I volunteered at the Olympics in Sochi, and several times worked in access control at the media compound, so I could also observe what photographers brought.

It is not 80-90% Canon, it is about 50-50 ...
Interestingly, there were also reporters that we allowed into photo position, and they came with smaller all in one cameras, and these were mostly Nikon (but there were never enough of these people to conclude anything).
Now, our photo positions were allowing photographers to use shorter lenses (400-500 tops), it's possible where longer lenses were used, things would have been different.
Our head of Press Ops also told me that it's about 50-50 when I asked.
And yes, for Canon it was all 1D something body, I am not familiar with Nikons pro bodies, so I am not sure what was brought.
At the sidelines of the events that was absolutely not my experience. I saw a sea of white lenses at every event. Might be different for press conferences or interviews, but the actual sport images looked to be mostly canon. I was in several press areas at several venues and had the same experience at all. Lots of gripped 5d size bodies as well, not all 1D.


I never worked in press conference areas, only at sports photo positions on the field. It's very possible that both yours and my observation is anecdotal.
All I can say is that after Olympics and Pan Am Games, I have not observed a single instance of dominance of one manufacturer.

Jul 30, 2015 at 07:00 AM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.27 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Bodies change but lenses don't...if your company or you own the lens, it is a forever thing. They are expensive to replace and many were bought in the film era.
Jul 30, 2015 at 07:08 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.27 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
Bodies change but lenses don't...if your company or you own the lens, it is a forever thing. They are expensive to replace and many were bought in the film era.


Including all the new version II lenses and the new 200-400 that was on several cameras? I think photo agencies either buy and sell or get loaners for events. I didn't see many old lenses from the film days at a major international sporting event.
Jul 30, 2015 at 07:13 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.27 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
secondclaw wrote:
jctriguy wrote
secondclaw wrote
jctriguy wrote
ggreene wrote
Fred Miranda wroteThe lack of f/2.8 zooms and super telephoto lenses for the Sony A7 bodies is a concept decision based on weight and size. Sony and Zeiss are pretty much concentrating on quality fast primes and f/4 zooms. It is a compromise many photographers can't afford to have for their photography needs. (Sports, photojournalists, etc.)
Design a pro body then for faster zooms. I don't think sports photographers discount Sony as much as you seem to hear about. There is just nothing there to entice us. Sony has packed a lot of nice features in the A7R2. Seems like they could easily compete with a 1DX2 or D5 at the $4000-$4500 price point. There are a heck of lot of mid level shooters that would think about it. Both Canon and Nikon are rapidly out pricing a lot of sports shooters. 1DX2 and D5 with new tech could be pushing $7000-$8000.
I'm at Pan Am games and can say that it is still at least 80-90% canon. Lots of big bodies and bigger lenses. A few with smaller bodies, but mostly 1D size. The market seems to have shifted back to canon after the upgraded bodies and super tele's. Sony has such a huge mountain to climb if they want to break into the sport world. Bodies first and lenses second.
I volunteered at Pan Am Games, in Press Ops, and worked as Photo Staff (green vest) most of the time. I had an opportunity to observe cameras that photographers brought. I also spoke with the head of Press Operations, who is a sports photographer himself. In addition, I volunteered at the Olympics in Sochi, and several times worked in access control at the media compound, so I could also observe what photographers brought.

It is not 80-90% Canon, it is about 50-50 ...
Interestingly, there were also reporters that we allowed into photo position, and they came with smaller all in one cameras, and these were mostly Nikon (but there were never enough of these people to conclude anything).
Now, our photo positions were allowing photographers to use shorter lenses (400-500 tops), it's possible where longer lenses were used, things would have been different.
Our head of Press Ops also told me that it's about 50-50 when I asked.
And yes, for Canon it was all 1D something body, I am not familiar with Nikons pro bodies, so I am not sure what was brought.
At the sidelines of the events that was absolutely not my experience. I saw a sea of white lenses at every event. Might be different for press conferences or interviews, but the actual sport images looked to be mostly canon. I was in several press areas at several venues and had the same experience at all. Lots of gripped 5d size bodies as well, not all 1D.
I never worked in press conference areas, only at sports photo positions on the field. It's very possible that both yours and my observation is anecdotal.
All I can say is that after Olympics and Pan Am Games, I have not observed a single instance of dominance of one manufacturer.


Do we have similar observations of Sony cameras at a sporting event? I only saw one in the hands of a spectator, none with any of the accredited photo staff. I'm sure there were many more in the crowds, but I don't spend much time in the piblic seating areas, so I can't really say much about what spectators were using.
Jul 30, 2015 at 07:19 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.27 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
Bodies change but lenses don't...if your company or you own the lens, it is a forever thing. They are expensive to replace and many were bought in the film era.


Many Canon pro shooters at major events are using new cameras and lenses provided as loaners by Canon. As a member of CPS Canada, I get regular email requests for members to identify if they're planning to attend upcoming major sports or fashion events, so that Canon can determine how much loaner gear to bring to the event, plus to figure out how much on-site service will be needed.

I don't have a link at hand, but I recall seeing threads showing the on-site Canon loaner storage room for the 2012 Olympics. The amount of top-level gear was staggering, and it was all available as loaners for pros to shoot the event.
Jul 30, 2015 at 07:22 AM
secondclaw
Offline
Details
p.27 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
secondclaw wrote
jctriguy wrote
secondclaw wrote
jctriguy wrote
ggreene wroteDesign a pro body then for faster zooms. I don't think sports photographers discount Sony as much as you seem to hear about. There is just nothing there to entice us. Sony has packed a lot of nice features in the A7R2. Seems like they could easily compete with a 1DX2 or D5 at the $4000-$4500 price point. There are a heck of lot of mid level shooters that would think about it. Both Canon and Nikon are rapidly out pricing a lot of sports shooters. 1DX2 and D5 with new tech could be pushing $7000-$8000.
I'm at Pan Am games and can say that it is still at least 80-90% canon. Lots of big bodies and bigger lenses. A few with smaller bodies, but mostly 1D size. The market seems to have shifted back to canon after the upgraded bodies and super tele's. Sony has such a huge mountain to climb if they want to break into the sport world. Bodies first and lenses second.
I volunteered at Pan Am Games, in Press Ops, and worked as Photo Staff (green vest) most of the time. I had an opportunity to observe cameras that photographers brought. I also spoke with the head of Press Operations, who is a sports photographer himself. In addition, I volunteered at the Olympics in Sochi, and several times worked in access control at the media compound, so I could also observe what photographers brought.

It is not 80-90% Canon, it is about 50-50 ...
Interestingly, there were also reporters that we allowed into photo position, and they came with smaller all in one cameras, and these were mostly Nikon (but there were never enough of these people to conclude anything).
Now, our photo positions were allowing photographers to use shorter lenses (400-500 tops), it's possible where longer lenses were used, things would have been different.
Our head of Press Ops also told me that it's about 50-50 when I asked.
And yes, for Canon it was all 1D something body, I am not familiar with Nikons pro bodies, so I am not sure what was brought.
At the sidelines of the events that was absolutely not my experience. I saw a sea of white lenses at every event. Might be different for press conferences or interviews, but the actual sport images looked to be mostly canon. I was in several press areas at several venues and had the same experience at all. Lots of gripped 5d size bodies as well, not all 1D.
I never worked in press conference areas, only at sports photo positions on the field. It's very possible that both yours and my observation is anecdotal.
All I can say is that after Olympics and Pan Am Games, I have not observed a single instance of dominance of one manufacturer.
Do we have similar observations of Sony cameras at a sporting event? I only saw one in the hands of a spectator, none with any of the accredited photo staff. I'm sure there were many more in the crowds, but I don't spend much time in the piblic seating areas, so I can't really say much about what spectators were using.


No Sony at the photo positions.
Interestingly, in Russia many spectators carried Sony nex5/6. Haven't seen any Sony cameras at Pan Am.



Jul 30, 2015 at 07:50 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.27 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
mogul wroteBodies change but lenses don't...if your company or you own the lens, it is a forever thing. They are expensive to replace and many were bought in the film era.
Many Canon pro shooters at major events are using new cameras and lenses provided as loaners by Canon. As a member of CPS Canada, I get regular email requests for members to identify if they're planning to attend upcoming major sports or fashion events, so that Canon can determine how much loaner gear to bring to the event, plus to figure out how much on-site service will be needed.

I don't have a link at hand, but I recall seeing threads showing the on-site Canon loaner storage room for the 2012 Olympics. The amount of top-level gear was staggering, and it
...Show more →

This was the first year in many that I didn't attend the F1 race in Montreal. Of course this year I got the CPS email for the first time that they had loaner gear at the race Would have loved to have demoed the 400 f/2.8 and 500 f/4 (the two big boys that I don't own and want to own). I will go next year and hopefully they will be there again with loaners!!


Canon room at 2012 Olympics....




Jul 30, 2015 at 07:52 AM
dgdg
Offline
Details
p.27 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I thought that was Peter's closet.
Jul 30, 2015 at 08:22 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.27 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
And people wonder why we see so many white lenses at these events...when they are given out to be used.
Jul 30, 2015 at 08:37 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.27 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
secondclaw wrote:
It is not 80-90% Canon, it is about 50-50


My guess would be it to be about 65-70% Canon glass and 30-35% Nikon glass, so, I could believe 50-50 Canon-Nikon But pack a lunch if this is meant that I would believe it to be 50% Canon bodies and 50% Sony bodies.
Jul 30, 2015 at 08:48 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.27 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
And people wonder why we see so many white lenses at these events...when they are given out to be used.


When you are the market leader, you can take these sort of steps. Do you think Sony could get the same penetration at an event if they gave away free gear to use?
Jul 30, 2015 at 08:49 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.27 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
chez wroteAnd people wonder why we see so many white lenses at these events...when they are given out to be used.
When you are the market leader, you can take these sort of steps. Do you think Sony could get the same penetration at an event if they gave away free gear to use?


Don't know...but I bet if McDonalds was giving away burgers at the Pan Am games, you'd see everyone with a big Mac. Make your own conclusions.
Jul 30, 2015 at 08:53 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.27 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
jctriguy wrote
chez wroteAnd people wonder why we see so many white lenses at these events...when they are given out to be used.
When you are the market leader, you can take these sort of steps. Do you think Sony could get the same penetration at an event if they gave away free gear to use?
Don't know...but I bet if McDonalds was giving away burgers at the Pan Am games, you'd see everyone with a big Mac. Make your own conclusions.


Make your own guesses, fabrications and assumptions. Are you actually trying to say that Sony could overtake Canon at a major international event by simply offering free gear for pros to use? I'll make my conclusions and say that is a load of BS.

And McD's is only at the Olympics, not PanAm's.
Jul 30, 2015 at 09:02 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.27 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote
chez wroteAnd people wonder why we see so many white lenses at these events...when they are given out to be used.
When you are the market leader, you can take these sort of steps. Do you think Sony could get the same penetration at an event if they gave away free gear to use?
Don't know...but I bet if McDonalds was giving away burgers at the Pan Am games, you'd see everyone with a big Mac. Make your own conclusions.
Make your own guesses, fabrications and assumptions. Are you actually trying to say that Sony could overtake Canon at a major international event by simply offering free gear for pros to use? I'll make my conclusions and say that is a load of BS.

And McD's is only at the Olympics, not PanAm's.


It's obvious and you know damn well that Sony is not in the sports market. I also know that Cannon provides free equipment at these major events to the pro's so that people like you count the number of white lenses and feel good you use the same camera as all those pro's. It's a psychological play that works very well. Proof is right here.
Jul 30, 2015 at 09:07 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.27 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
jctriguy wrote
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote
chez wroteAnd people wonder why we see so many white lenses at these events...when they are given out to be used.
When you are the market leader, you can take these sort of steps. Do you think Sony could get the same penetration at an event if they gave away free gear to use?
Don't know...but I bet if McDonalds was giving away burgers at the Pan Am games, you'd see everyone with a big Mac. Make your own conclusions.
Make your own guesses, fabrications and assumptions. Are you actually trying to say that Sony could overtake Canon at a major international event by simply offering free gear for pros to use? I'll make my conclusions and say that is a load of BS.

And McD's is only at the Olympics, not PanAm's.
It's obvious and you know damn well that Sony is not in the sports market. I also know that Cannon provides free equipment at these major events to the pro's so that people like you count the number of white lenses and feel good you use the same camera as all those pro's. It's a psychological play that works very well. Proof is right here.


Don't get so upset about these things. Just pointing out how illogical your arguments are, no big deal. You implied that Sony could just flood the market with free gear, just like McDonalds could give away free Big Macs and flood the market. Why say that if you know so well that Sony doesn't have a viable sports product line? Just empty words to fill a forum?

PS thanks for the psychological assessment...much appreciated...those might get deleted as well (like most of your posts on another recent thread)

Edited on Jul 30, 2015 at 09:15 AM · View previous versions
Jul 30, 2015 at 09:13 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister