fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.18 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
johnvanr wrote:
Dan


What about Samsung photographers?



I believe they will one day inherit the earth. They've had a hell of a time lately.
Jun 17, 2015 at 01:09 AM
vpPhoto
Offline
Details
p.18 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
After reading interview on imaging-resource.com I wouldn't expect much from AF accuracy and speed in worse than ideal light conditions with adapted Canon lenses. It's simple physics, the phase detection pixels on sensor are just too small (and can't be made bigger) and noisy in comparison to SLRs dedicated PDAF chips. Here are some important quotes from the interview regarding this subject:

...in terms of autofocus, we are using a hybrid focus, so first we use the phase-detection focus to get close to the object. Then near the object, we start to use contrast AF to get a clear peak...

This answered a question I'd always had about on-chip phase-detect focusing, in that the image sensor pixels are quite small, and have to be read out quickly (meaning must have a short exposure time), to have a responsive AF system. The phase-detect pixels are also shaded, to "see" only light rays coming from one side or the other, so they're only getting half as much light as normal image-forming ones. Under low-light conditions, both factors result in a small focus signal with lots of noise on it. Contrast-detect AF is more capable under those conditions, because it's looking across a larger...Show more →

Test with Canon 2.8/24-70 L II:
Sony's Mark Weir noted that this was the first time a full-frame mirrorless camera could focus traditional SLR lenses as fast as SLRs could. He noted that in this mode, the A7R Mark II was using only phase-detect AF, vs the two-stage hybrid approach Maki-san mentioned earlier.

I did find that the camera could sometimes get a little confused when the subject was far out of focus, sometimes initially moving in the wrong direction, but when the subject was out of focus by an amount more typical of real-world situations, it was remarkably fast.
Clearly consequence of small phase-detect structures, dedicated chip with big structures can detect correct direction in significantly further OOF position.

Compare to dedicated AF chips (images and quotes from the-digital-picture.com):

Canon 7D AF chip:
http://media.the-digital-picture.com/Images/Tips/Canon-EOS-DSLR-Autofocus-Explained/AFexplained_Image3.jpg


Canon 1DX AF chip:
http://media.the-digital-picture.com/Images/Tips/Canon-EOS-DSLR-Autofocus-Explained/AFexplained_Image4.jpg


When looking at the diagonal f/2.8 sensors, it's apparent that they are much more widely spaced than the f/5.6 sensors - almost to the edges of the chip. This accounts for the longer baseline that results in greater accuracy than the f/5.6 sensors.

I'm curious, if Canon can combine the dual-pixel AF pixels into bigger virtual structures on 70D and 7DII, to overcome some of the limitations of dedicated on-sensor PDAF pixels.
Jun 17, 2015 at 03:00 AM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.18 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
vpPhoto wrote:
I'm curious, if Canon can combine the dual-pixel AF pixels into bigger virtual structures on 70D and 7DII, to overcome some of the limitations of dedicated on-sensor PDAF pixels.


I read the Canon patent and they have also patented quad pixel arrangement and methods using unequal sized masks and other variations. Whether or not we will ever see these alternatives come to light only they know.
Jun 17, 2015 at 03:52 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.18 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
vpPhoto wrote:
After reading interview on imaging-resource.com I wouldn't expect much from AF accuracy and speed in worse than ideal light conditions with adapted Canon lenses. It's simple physics, the phase detection pixels on sensor are just too small (and can't be made bigger) and noisy in comparison to SLRs dedicated PDAF chips.


The A7RII AF system is using both phase and contrast detect AF, so I guess the A7IIR will by definition be more accurate than any Canon DSLR (using PDAF only, and not the pathetic Liveview focusing system). It probably won't be as fast or track as well as a 1DX, or compete in situations like low light levels or strongly defocused lens. But despite the theoretical objections, the several clips that are available now suggest the A7RII is plenty fast for most situations even when using adapted Canon lenses.

This camera is not primarily designed for 'action/event shooters' who value AF speed in all conditions, high framerate, battery capacity etc. over ultimate image quality (as in high resolution, maximum DR and best possible focus accuracy). But for most other uses the A7RII looks like an excellent compromise to me, a real step up from the DSLR with its AF accuracy woes and high quality video limitations (both by definition).
Jun 17, 2015 at 04:30 AM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.18 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
OMG. My decision for buying a 5DS/R vs. an A7R II is flipping on a flopping gate circuit.

Need more info...

(Dalek says, "Exterminate!").


For what it's worth, here is a comparison of the A7II to the Nikon D750:
http://www.soundimageplus.com/soundimageplus/2015/6/14/sony-a7-ii-compared-to-nikon-d750
The author decided to sell the A7II and keep the D750.
Jun 17, 2015 at 04:54 AM
vpPhoto
Offline
Details
p.18 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
technic wrote:
The A7RII AF system is using both phase and contrast detect AF, so I guess the A7IIR will by definition be more accurate than any Canon DSLR (using PDAF only, and not the pathetic Liveview focusing system). It probably won't be as fast or track as well as a 1DX, or compete in situations like low light levels or strongly defocused lens. But despite the theoretical objections, the several clips that are available now suggest the A7RII is plenty fast for most situations even when using adapted Canon lenses.


No question, that with native lenses the AF will work fine. Heck, even my old A7, when I had the opportunity to test it with Batis 1.8/85, focused fine for 90% of my photography.
My point is, that Sony uses PDAF only for quick rough focus acquisition and fine tuning is done via CDAF (as quoted from interview), but with adapted Canon lenses only PDAF is used (again as quoted). It may be good enough for wide-angle lenses where focusing errors are covered with deep DOF. And only WA are used in all videos (why? Fast primes would give more light to the PD pixels) and even then the camera sometimes struggles to acquire focus.
I'm curious how accurate and reliable it will be with fast primes (1.4/35, 1.x/50, 1.x/85, 2/135...) or big whites, where DOF counts in centimeters. All the DR and megapixels are worthless on misfocused shot (this doesn't apply only to Sony of course)...
Jun 17, 2015 at 05:20 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.18 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
vpPhoto wrote:
My point is, that Sony uses PDAF only for quick rough focus acquisition and fine tuning is done via CDAF (as quoted from interview), but with adapted Canon lenses only PDAF is used (again as quoted).


OK, I understand your point now. I just wondered if this is a hard limitation, why it could not use CDAF as well with adapted lenses (with lower speed, obviously). Are we sure about this limitation?

If there is no CDAF fine-tuning possible, it could indeed mean that AF is less accurate with adapted lenses. On the other side, even though the accuracy would be (potentially) lower it still has the advantage over DSLRs that the PD sensors are on-chip instead of in the mirrorbox, so it does away with the systematic errors that plague DSLR AF accuracy (no micro-adjustment necessary). Will be interesting to see in practice which of the two issues is a bigger factor for getting optimally focused images.

With my (old) Canon DSLR the PDAF inaccuracy (depending on body/lens combo) and the even bigger inaccuracy of the optical viewfinder are major problems. I'm really looking forward to a camera that ditches this problem for good, even if it means some new limitations like lower speed in certain conditions.

Edited on Jun 17, 2015 at 05:43 AM · View previous versions
Jun 17, 2015 at 05:37 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.18 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
We know too little yet about the AF performance of the A7r II with adapted Canon lenses, but my hunch is:

Those who plan on selling their Canon cameras and keep their Canon lenses for use with the A7r II with AF are in for a lot of frustration.

Those who buy an A7r II for use with native AF lenses or IBIS with manual focus lenses, and see any AF perfomance as a bonus, are in for a lot of satisfaction.
Jun 17, 2015 at 05:40 AM
vpPhoto
Offline
Details
p.18 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
technic wrote:
I just wondered if this is a hard limitation, why it could not use CDAF as well with adapted lenses (with lower speed, obviously). Are we sure about this limitation?


The only source currently is quote from the interview. Maybe it can be just misunderstanding of interviewer, or maybe it can be fixed in later firmware update. We don't have enough information yet.
I will definitely wait for more tests and experiences of actual owners of this camera before getting too excited or even considering ditching my 1DsIII, 1DIV, A7 combo.

technic wrote:
If there is no CDAF fine-tuning possible, it could indeed mean that AF is less accurate with adapted lenses. On the other side, even though the accuracy would be (potentially) lower it still has the advantage over DSLRs that the PD sensors are on-chip instead of in the mirrorbox, so it does away with the systematic errors that plague DSLR AF accuracy (no micro-adjustment necessary). Will be interesting to see in practice which of the two issues is a bigger factor for getting optimally focused images.


Well, even on A7 (it has a cluster of on chip PDAF pixels too) is dedicated submenu for AF microadjustment...



Edited on Jun 17, 2015 at 06:35 AM · View previous versions
Jun 17, 2015 at 06:06 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.18 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
technic wrote:
OK, I understand your point now. I just wondered if this is a hard limitation, why it could not use CDAF as well with adapted lenses (with lower speed, obviously). Are we sure about this limitation?



It is probably because of the slow EF lens communication. This slow communication is one of the main reasons CDAF is so slow with EF lenses. Sony probably made this choice to keep AF speed high.
Jun 17, 2015 at 06:27 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.18 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
vpPhoto wrote:
technic wroteI just wondered if this is a hard limitation, why it could not use CDAF as well with adapted lenses (with lower speed, obviously). Are we sure about this limitation?
Only source currently is quote from the interview. Maybe it can be just misunderstanding of interviewer, or maybe it can be fixed in later firmware update. We don't have enough information yet.
I will definitely wait for more tests and experiences of actual owners of this camera before getting too excited or even considering ditching my 1DsIII, 1DIV, A7 combo.


For now using different bodies for different jobs/situations is the best approach. But I strongly prefer one body that can handle almost anything and I don't need super-fast AF and super-tough build (like most landscape, architecture, travel etc. photographers I guess). So the A7RII looks promising, trying to combine the best of DSLR and mirrorless: top quality sensor for still image AND video, nice EVF (even if I would try to use the slow Liveview on my Canon DSLR in daylight, it won't work due to poor screen visibility), tilt screen, plenty of improvements compared to earlier A7 models, accurate AF (but maybe not using AF with Canon lenses?). What a difference with the incremental or even one step forward, two steps back model policy from Canon ...

But I have done enough official beta testing in my life, so would never pre-order such a new camera ;-)
Jun 17, 2015 at 06:36 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.18 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
technic wroteOK, I understand your point now. I just wondered if this is a hard limitation, why it could not use CDAF as well with adapted lenses (with lower speed, obviously). Are we sure about this limitation?
It is probably because of the slow EF lens communication. This slow communication is one of the main reasons CDAF is so slow with EF lenses. Sony probably made this choice to keep AF speed high.

Yes, that makes sense - the way these AF lenses designed for DSLRs are controlled electronically doesn't match very well with the demands from CDAF, the same would apply using Canon EF lenses on EOS-M.

But if A7RII AF with adapted lenses proves not accurate enough in some situations, I hope Sony will provide the option to add CDAF finetuning for situations where accuracy is more important than speed. Although using MF with focus confirmation could be an acceptable alternative (e.g. I don't need fast AF in low light conditions).
Jun 17, 2015 at 06:43 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.18 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
OMG. My decision for buying a 5DS/R vs. an A7R II is flipping on a flopping gate circuit.

Need more info...

(Dalek says, "Exterminate!").

alundeb wrote:
Jim, you are not in a hurry. Sit back and enoy the flip fliop and the endless discussions about A7r II AF that are going to emerge.


Good points. Thanks, Anders.
Jun 17, 2015 at 07:08 AM
vpPhoto
Offline
Details
p.18 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
technic wrote:
But I strongly prefer one body that can handle almost anything and I don't need super-fast AF and super-tough build (like most landscape, architecture, travel etc. photographers I guess). So the A7RII looks promising, trying to combine the best of DSLR and mirrorless: top quality sensor for still image AND video, nice EVF (even if I would try to use the slow Liveview on my Canon DSLR in daylight, it won't work due to poor screen visibility), tilt screen, plenty of improvements compared to earlier A7 models, accurate AF (but maybe not using AF with Canon lenses?). What a difference
...Show more →

According my experiences with plain A7, for your kind of photography is the A7 series perfectly ready.
Depending on your needs I would get used plain A7 with Zony 16-35 lens and Commlite adapter for Canon TS-E lenses (if you use them) and try the system, before buying 3200USD A7RII. (I understand, that If you need print big, A7r(II) is better option and if you do night cityscapes, then sensor reflections on old A7 are real issues).

I enjoy my A7 as a walk around and travel camera with small MF lenses, but there are little annoyances that may or may not be important to you and most of them definitely wouldn't be fixed even in A7RII.

- in bright sunny day the EVF is not bright enough
- EVF and shutter lag (not important for lanscape and architecture)
- weird AWB - it's okay in daylight, but mixed artificial lighting is just terrible
- "Sony colors", this is highly subjective point, sometimes it works but often I need to tweak the shots beyond my patience... Again, in landscape/architecture A7 delivers for me, but portraits are real pain... DISCLAIMER: I'm used to 1DsIII colors
- for one day trip I need at least 1 spare battery (i don't like to turn the camera on and off after every shot) and on longer trips, don't forget to recharge every night
- poor ergonomics with bigger and heavy lenses
- poor ergonomics when shooting winter landscapes - buttons are just too small for gloves
- focus peaking is unusable when DOF is thin
- display can't be turned completely off in auto EVF/display mode
- when you switch to EVF mode and review photos, they show only in EVF. Even if you don't look into it
- from ISO 200 up, Canon has finer noise in middle tones and highlights
- even with Sony's Image data RAW converter you won't get exactly same results as in camera JPEG (colorwise)
- LiveView doesn't work with tethering (solved in A7S and up)
- poorly placed +zoom button in playback

I do like size and weight with small lenses, EVF zoom with manual focus lenses, EVF in dim light, tiltable LCD, cleaner shadows are welcome bonus but not earth shaking in actual use, BW JPEG profile, level in EVF, integrated Wi-Fi, button customization, good ISO up to 6400 (but over 3200 I prefer 1DIV).


Edited on Jun 17, 2015 at 08:32 AM · View previous versions
Jun 17, 2015 at 08:23 AM
AJSJones
Offline
Details
p.18 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
vpPhoto wrote:
...
Well, even on A7 (it has a cluster of on chip PDAF pixels too) is dedicated submenu for AF microadjustment...


That is only for use with the pellicle mirror adapter for A mount lenses LA-EA4, for "normal" off-sensor PDAF where MFA is needed.
Jun 17, 2015 at 08:24 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.18 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
technic wrote:
For now using different bodies for different jobs/situations is the best approach. But I strongly prefer one body that can handle almost anything and I don't need super-fast AF and super-tough build (like most landscape, architecture, travel etc. photographers I guess).


It's the ONLY approach as you are never going to satisfy everyone with one body. Your exceptions already prove that. The gulf between a 1DX like body and an A7 like body will never be bridged because of pure personal preference on ergonomics.
Jun 17, 2015 at 08:26 AM
vpPhoto
Offline
Details
p.18 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
AJSJones wrote:
vpPhoto wrote...
Well, even on A7 (it has a cluster of on chip PDAF pixels too) is dedicated submenu for AF microadjustment...
That is only for use with the pellicle mirror adapter for A mount lenses LA-EA4, for "normal" off-sensor PDAF where MFA is needed.


Thank you for clarification, since I don't own any native lens for FE mount.
Jun 17, 2015 at 08:34 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.18 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
vpPhoto wrote:
According my experiences with plain A7, for your kind of photography is the A7 series perfectly ready.


I do landscape/cityscape type photography for which A7 series would be fine, but also nature/macro, primarily flying dragonflies which is a special type of 'action'. I have to travel light and often there are opportunities for both types of shots, that's why I would prefer one body. I have considered buying just an A7(r) body for landscape type shots only (cheap temporary solution, but need extra body) or a Nikon D750 for both types of photography (does everything I want, except that I can't use my Canon lenses and need to buy lots of new glass).

Thanks for the list of 'small annoyances'; although most of these would not be an issue for me I'm aware that there is a downside compared to Canon DSLRs. But I think I can live with those in return for the better sensor, tilt screen, small/light body etc.

---------------------------------------------

ggreene wrote:
It's the ONLY approach as you are never going to satisfy everyone with one body. Your exceptions already prove that. The gulf between a 1DX like body and an A7 like body will never be bridged because of pure personal preference on ergonomics.


Yes, you can't satisfy everyone with one body. But I think you can have an FF body that a large percentage of photographers would be happy with for general use. And IMHO the A7RII is much closer to that, more balanced, than the Canon FF cameras which for me are all variations on the same theme: fast/tough/big/heavy, limited DR, limited video quality, no tilt screen etc. - great if you want that (e.g. wedding/event/sports shooters), less so if you don't need/want that. 6D is lighter but that's about the only advantage for me compared to the other FF Canons ;-)

Some may insist on having the 'perfect' tool for every job and accept that they need several different cameras, for others having one body that works pretty good for almost everything is worth some compromise in ergonomics and performance in extreme conditions.
Jun 17, 2015 at 10:07 AM
RobCD
Offline
Details
p.18 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
johnvanr wrote:
charlesk wroteSome good posts in this thread. Thanks to you from another Canon user frustrated with year after year of seeing other companies pushing the envelope while Canon acts like it's still 2005 and basically ignores its customers.

I don't really want to switch. I want Canon to give me a reason to give it my money. And the 5Ds, while certainly interesting, is not enough to do it.

I'm hoping for the 5D4, but Canon continues to have a smug attitude, seemingly simply not caring that it is being left behind technologically.
I don't get this. Canon still offers what's probably the best pro series camera with the 1D X, its lens line is amazing and constantly improving, it upgrades its offerings while making sure the interface stays familiar and generally when they introduce a lens or a camera, it works as intended.

Then we have Sony, which has us pay dearly for its experiments with body and lens lines that change quicker than the seasons and introduces what are in essence beta cameras that need to be quickly followed by a model that actually works as intended.



This is a little bit of a catch 22 since the best way to make sure a camera works as intended upon release is to not change much. Canon is an expert in that category but I think that is part of the problem for some people while others will appreciate this if their needs require reliability, service, support, and familiarity over the benefits of new technology and features. Personally, I'd prefer the option to "beta" test a camera that pushes the limits or have the option to wait for others to test it first instead of my only option being to choose from camera A, B, C when I want to choose D and it doesn't exist.

I also don't understand the comment about making you pay dearly when you have the option of thoroughly evaluating a camera before buying with virtually unlimited information from reviews, user reports, videos, and the option to rent. Unlike years ago where it might have been more difficult to discover all of the details of a camera without buying it, in 2015 the choice is really yours whether you want to beta test or not.
Jun 17, 2015 at 01:18 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.18 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RobCD wrote:
This is a little bit of a catch 22 since the best way to make sure a camera works as intended upon release is to not change much. Canon is an expert in that category but I think that is part of the problem for some people while others will appreciate this if their needs require reliability, service, support, and familiarity over the benefits of new technology and features. Personally, I'd prefer the option to "beta" test a camera that pushes the limits or have the option to wait for others to test it first instead of my only option
...Show more →

To a certain degree I think we have the 1D3 and its AF issues to thank for some of this extra caution. Canon took a huge hit in reputation for that. That was a time when many sports photographers went to Nikon. It took a while to convince people that Canon's AF was solid again.

It did not help matters that Canon handled the whole issue so badly.
Jun 17, 2015 at 02:08 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister