Gregg,
The FoA gets 200,000 people a summer that see the Pageant of the Masters, but very few of them are "buyers." Non Pageant attendance (just those going to see the art) isn't even close to the Sawdust's 150,000 summer visitors, most of whom buy something, big or small.
As a painter, the Sawdust allows us to sell prints of our original paintings, which the FoA does not. Prints are 80% of my sales, money wise. That doesn't affect photographers though, because they can obviously sell prints of their photos at either show. Many artists do both shows, but, surprisingly, I found my sales went up after I just concentrated on one show (the Sawdust).
Kelly