fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015A7r 199.99??

  
 
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.5 #1A7r 199.99??
chez wrote:
ecarlino wrote
chez wrote
Tariq Gibran wrote
millsart wrote
Tariq Gibran wroteIf it was anyone else but Sony, I would think it could possibly have been some sort of crazy, viral marketing trick. Now it's coming off as just another PR blunder rooted in incompetency. I think they really could have handled this better from a PR standpoint.
I'd say that as bad as Sony may look, it also rather paints human nature pretty poorly too.

Obvious pricing mistake and you have people trying to order 10 of them, lots of threads on the internet about filing class action lawsuits "forcing" Sony give sell people the 10 camera's they ordered at the error price etc.

There certainly is something to be said for incompetency, but also for things like blind greed and entitlement.

Mind you I see nothing wrong with placing an order for one in the event it goes through. I mean, hey, maybe Sony would choose to honor it and if so, more power to ya!

For me, its really the issue of knowing its a mistake, knowing the only reason you ordered 10+ was you wanted to resell them for a profit on Ebay, and then when it didn't pan out, raising a big fuss about it because you didn't get the "right" to make a quick $10k profit off of someone's error.

Again though, most people are pretty cool about it, but the few percent that aren't and are talking lawyers are something else....
Yeah, I agree. That's ridiculous behavior and Sony is covered by their terms and conditions in any case here in the U.S. so those people are wasting their time. My point is more that Sony should have found a way to make a little good PR lemonade from the initial mistake instead of the way this played out.
what exactly is wrong with the way Sony handled the mistake?

Personally I think the people jumping in and trying to get a camera on the cheap because of a mistake says plenty about today's society.

Quick question to everyone. If you knew you got more money in change than you were supposed to, would you give back the excess amount?
First of all - it cracks me up that people are quick to criticize anyone for placing an order (of any qty). There are plenty of examples where companies want to blow out inventory and even at crazy prices (e.g. $200 for an a7r) because it generates buzz. If it turned out the prices were legit and you stood back and passed on the offer, how dumb would you feel? For those who were quick and placed an order while the offer was available, they should be commended for reacting quickly. There are entire industries that buy old inventory at 10 cents on the dollar and re-sell via various channels. If someone wants to step in and buy 10 @ $200 with the intention of helping Sony get rid of their inventory and in the process they make a few bucks for the hassle via ebay or something, GOOD FOR THEM (btw, i ordered 2 b/c i thought they'd be great with a pair of Batis lenses, so i wasn't thinking about reselling but don't hate me b/c i ordered 2 !).

Second of all, it amazes me that a large corporate website could be so poorly managed that there aren't checks and balances to prevent something like this (if it was in fact a mistake). But then again, i've never been impressed with Sony's software, so i shouldn't be surprised.
I agree with you...but do you really think the majority of the people that placed orders really thought Sony was blowing out their stock? Really? Even after they learned about it in this thread where people were talking about it being a mistake...and they still put in their orders.

Sorry...but I don't buy this. I believe the majority of people down deep knew it was a mistake and were rushing in to get a piece before Sony fixed the mistake. Let's not be too naïve here.


the total elapsed time from the first post on this thread until there is a post saying that Sony took the a7r off of their website was just under 3 hours. anyone placing an order during that time had every reason to believe it was a legitimate offer, all the while knowing it was a crazy good price. the internet (and i don't mean idiots making mistakes and companies not having checks and balances - i mean the web/viral way of marketing everything) has given everyone enough of a reason to think that offer was valid. frankly, i'm just pissed i didn't think to order 10, because that would have been a good business opportunity had Sony truly been trying to blow out their inventory. it certainly never occurred to me to criticize someone who actually got off their ass and place an order.
Jun 03, 2015 at 12:17 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.5 #2A7r 199.99??
howard wrote:
chez wroteThe only difference between taking advantage of Sony's mistake and taking advantage of a cashiers mistake is Sony is a big bad corporation. I see no difference in trying to take advantage of a mistake.
Most people see a difference in these cases. For one thing, in the Sony case, the price is published, and they have their terms and conditions to protect them, and they can decide to honor it or not. Furthermore, the transaction was pending at the discretion of the corporation's further examination. Something can be said that when a corporation builds a sophisticated website and have all the legal conditions to protect themselves, the onus is on them to make sure of the quality of their publications.

In the cashier analogy, the transaction is instantaneous and there is no mechanism for
...Show more →

People's actions speak for themselves...and yes I judge people by their actions.

I still see someone trying to take advantage of an honest mistake...you can swing it anyway you like, whether one is covered by some legal garbage...which I am pretty sure the majority of people that placed their orders had no idea Sony covered themselves...it is still trying to gain something from someone else's mistake.
Jun 03, 2015 at 12:19 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.5 #3A7r 199.99??
chez wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote
chez wrote
Tariq Gibran wrote
millsart wrote
Tariq Gibran wroteIf it was anyone else but Sony, I would think it could possibly have been some sort of crazy, viral marketing trick. Now it's coming off as just another PR blunder rooted in incompetency. I think they really could have handled this better from a PR standpoint.
I'd say that as bad as Sony may look, it also rather paints human nature pretty poorly too.

Obvious pricing mistake and you have people trying to order 10 of them, lots of threads on the internet about filing class action lawsuits "forcing" Sony give sell people the 10 camera's they ordered at the error price etc.

There certainly is something to be said for incompetency, but also for things like blind greed and entitlement.

Mind you I see nothing wrong with placing an order for one in the event it goes through. I mean, hey, maybe Sony would choose to honor it and if so, more power to ya!

For me, its really the issue of knowing its a mistake, knowing the only reason you ordered 10+ was you wanted to resell them for a profit on Ebay, and then when it didn't pan out, raising a big fuss about it because you didn't get the "right" to make a quick $10k profit off of someone's error.

Again though, most people are pretty cool about it, but the few percent that aren't and are talking lawyers are something else....
Yeah, I agree. That's ridiculous behavior and Sony is covered by their terms and conditions in any case here in the U.S. so those people are wasting their time. My point is more that Sony should have found a way to make a little good PR lemonade from the initial mistake instead of the way this played out.
what exactly is wrong with the way Sony handled the mistake?

Personally I think the people jumping in and trying to get a camera on the cheap because of a mistake says plenty about today's society.

Quick question to everyone. If you knew you got more money in change than you were supposed to, would you give back the excess amount?
Instead of customers receiving order cancellation notices which list a false reason for the order cancellation (and in some cases, stopping an in-progress shipment which confirms the reason above is false), Sony should have at least stated the reason as a pricing error. PR wise, they could have gone much further by doing such things as offering the customer first in line shipping of the replacement model (in the case of the A7r), a 5% discount on other Sony products and so forth. Either of those would have been a win-win. Instead, Sony comes off as being completely out of touch and reinforces the public image of being a tech company that is incompetent when it comes to internet/ data, security, etc.

Most people do the right thing in my experience when it comes to lost wallets, returning excess change and so on. These examples have absolutely no relation to this case as I have previously explained (at least if one uses logic and not emotion or prejudice).
I personally am not offended by the way Sony dealt with the issue. My eyes are more open to the way individuals have dealt with a known mistaken price. Why do you really think Sony owes these people that jumped onto a known mistake hoping to capitalize on an honest mistake.

The only difference between taking advantage of Sony's mistake and taking advantage of a cashiers mistake is Sony is a big bad corporation. I see no difference in trying to take advantage of a mistake.

Now don't go and tell me that people here did not think this was a typo
...Show more →

I don't think that Sony "owes these people" anything. I'm suggesting that Sony could have benefited by turning a mistake into a PR win and increased customer loyalty, etc.

Because of the nature of an order (it's only an offer to buy something and must be reviewed and accepted by Sony, who is covered by their own terms and conditions for things such as pricing errors), this is not like a cashier's mistake as the sale did not get to that point. You can't "take advantage" of a willing participant (who had total control over the entire process).

It's very odd that many Sony products were listed with extremely low prices. It wasn't just the A7r. That does seem to suggest that it was something more than just a simple typo/ data entry mistake going on at Sony.

Jun 03, 2015 at 12:34 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.5 #4A7r 199.99??
chez wrote:
howard wrote
chez wroteThe only difference between taking advantage of Sony's mistake and taking advantage of a cashiers mistake is Sony is a big bad corporation. I see no difference in trying to take advantage of a mistake.
Most people see a difference in these cases. For one thing, in the Sony case, the price is published, and they have their terms and conditions to protect them, and they can decide to honor it or not. Furthermore, the transaction was pending at the discretion of the corporation's further examination. Something can be said that when a corporation builds a sophisticated website and have all the legal conditions to protect themselves, the onus is on them to make sure of the quality of their publications.

In the cashier analogy, the transaction is instantaneous and there is no mechanism for the cashier to reverse it.

You speak for yourself that is fine, but don't think your perspective is the only one and use it to judge others.
People's actions speak for themselves...and yes I judge people by their actions.

I still see someone trying to take advantage of an honest mistake...you can swing it anyway you like, whether one is covered by some legal garbage...which I am pretty sure the majority of people that placed their orders had no idea Sony covered themselves...it is still trying to gain something from someone else's mistake.


you didn't know then, nor do you know now, that it was a mistake.

the only thing people knew then was that a company was offering a 'old' product at a crazy price. that happens a lot these days.

the only thing we know now is that Sony has cancelled most if not all of the orders.

we still do not know that it was IN FACT a mistake.

you're very quick to assume that you know the mind of the consumers (and have a very negative opinion of them) and yet also assume it was nothing more than an honest mistake at Sony.

i think the only stupid thing about all of this is how much time we all have (myself included) wasted on this thread.
Jun 03, 2015 at 01:17 PM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.5 #5A7r 199.99??
ecarlino wrote:
chez wrote
howard wrote
chez wroteThe only difference between taking advantage of Sony's mistake and taking advantage of a cashiers mistake is Sony is a big bad corporation. I see no difference in trying to take advantage of a mistake.
Most people see a difference in these cases. For one thing, in the Sony case, the price is published, and they have their terms and conditions to protect them, and they can decide to honor it or not. Furthermore, the transaction was pending at the discretion of the corporation's further examination. Something can be said that when a corporation builds a sophisticated website and have all the legal conditions to protect themselves, the onus is on them to make sure of the quality of their publications.

In the cashier analogy, the transaction is instantaneous and there is no mechanism for the cashier to reverse it.

You speak for yourself that is fine, but don't think your perspective is the only one and use it to judge others.
People's actions speak for themselves...and yes I judge people by their actions.

I still see someone trying to take advantage of an honest mistake...you can swing it anyway you like, whether one is covered by some legal garbage...which I am pretty sure the majority of people that placed their orders had no idea Sony covered themselves...it is still trying to gain something from someone else's mistake.
you didn't know then, nor do you know now, that it was a mistake.

the only thing people knew then was that a company was offering a 'old' product at a crazy price. that happens a lot these days.

the only thing we know now is that Sony has cancelled most if not all of the orders.

we still do not know that it was IN FACT a mistake.

you're very quick to assume that you know the mind of the consumers (and have a very negative opinion of them) and yet also assume it was nothing more than an honest mistake at Sony.

i
...Show more →

I very much doubt that Sony would have knowingly offered the A7r for such a low price. They could probably have exhausted whatever inventory was left of the A7r cameras for substantially more than $199.99. Without question in mind there was either an error made or Sony had been hacked for such a ridiculously low price.

Rich
Jun 03, 2015 at 01:29 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.5 #6A7r 199.99??
No way it was deliberate . It was a common mistake, issue is it was on a Sunday and no one caught it. Just think how many times you post on a thread here and either you made a spelling error or your damn device did it for you. I can't count the times. If it was a deliberate marketing maneuver don't you think 200 dollars was way to excessive. Maybe 500 dollars off retail but not what happened. And yes we are all wasting time on a human error or a disgruntled employee . Look at it this way did you ever really think you where that damn lucky to steal one for 200 bucks. That's fantasy not reality. Lol

Case in point I'm a Italian from New Jersey I could not get one off the back off a truck that cheap. ROTFLMAO

Just kidding
Jun 03, 2015 at 04:09 PM
millsart
Offline
Details
p.5 #7A7r 199.99??
ecarlino wrote:
the total elapsed time from the first post on this thread until there is a post saying that Sony took the a7r off of their website was just under 3 hours. anyone placing an order during that time had every reason to believe it was a legitimate offer, all the while knowing it was a crazy good price. the internet (and i don't mean idiots making mistakes and companies not having checks and balances - i mean the web/viral way of marketing everything) has given everyone enough of a reason to think that offer was valid. frankly, i'm just pissed
...Show more →


Oh good lord....

So you think Sony would legitimately need to unload these at just $199, yet at the same time wish you could of ordered 10 because its a good "business opportunity", ie; you know darn well they are worth way more than that and you wanted to sell them.

Also I have no issue with anyone who tried to place and order and hoped maybe they'd get one. My issue is with people who are still throwing a little tantrum they aren't getting their 10 camera's that Sony "owes them". Its an absurd since of entitlement
Jun 03, 2015 at 04:43 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.5 #8A7r 199.99??
millsart wrote:
ecarlino wrotethe total elapsed time from the first post on this thread until there is a post saying that Sony took the a7r off of their website was just under 3 hours. anyone placing an order during that time had every reason to believe it was a legitimate offer, all the while knowing it was a crazy good price. the internet (and i don't mean idiots making mistakes and companies not having checks and balances - i mean the web/viral way of marketing everything) has given everyone enough of a reason to think that offer was valid. frankly, i'm just pissed i didn't think to order 10, because that would have been a good business opportunity had Sony truly been trying to blow out their inventory. it certainly never occurred to me to criticize someone who actually got off their ass and place an order.
Oh good lord....

So you think Sony would legitimately need to unload these at just $199, yet at the same time wish you could of ordered 10 because its a good "business opportunity", ie; you know darn well they are worth way more than that and you wanted to sell them.

Also I have no issue with anyone who tried to place and order and hoped maybe they'd get one. My issue is with people who are still throwing a little tantrum they aren't getting their 10 camera's that Sony "owes them". Its an absurd since of entitlement



I'm not suggesting I know what was going on with Sony. That's been my point: nobody did on Sunday nor do they now. I've only tried to suggest that there have been plenty of other examples that turned out to be amazing opportunities and nobody should be criticized for having tried to get 1 or 10.

Jun 03, 2015 at 05:28 PM
Jman13
Online
Details
p.5 #9A7r 199.99??
Oh come on. You honestly thought they were selling their flagship mirrorless camera for 90% off? At 1/7th the price of the lower specced A7 that already has had a replacement for 6 months?

Honestly?

It is absolutely not true that no one knew. I didn't even bother to place the order because I knew it would be reversed. Almost everyone who ordered knew it was going to be canceled but ordered on the incredibly slim chance that a few slipped through.
Jun 03, 2015 at 05:46 PM
millsart
Offline
Details
p.5 #10A7r 199.99??
ecarlino wrote:
I'm not suggesting I know what was going on with Sony. That's been my point: nobody did on Sunday nor do they now. I've only tried to suggest that there have been plenty of other examples that turned out to be amazing opportunities and nobody should be criticized for having tried to get 1 or 10.



Who in their right mind would buy 10 camera's if it wasn't because they knew it was a pricing mistake and hoped they could sell at least 9 of them ?

And again, while I personally wouldn't buy 10, I did not have issues with those who tried. I have issue with those who tried, failed, and are now throwing a fit about how Sony "owes" them.

Its like someone that purposely spills something on the floors, slips on it, and then gets mad they didn't get a cash settlement even though they purposely fell.

Its absurd to see people talking lawyers because their get rich quick scheme didn't pan out....
Jun 03, 2015 at 06:50 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.5 #11A7r 199.99??
millsart wrote:
ecarlino wroteI'm not suggesting I know what was going on with Sony. That's been my point: nobody did on Sunday nor do they now. I've only tried to suggest that there have been plenty of other examples that turned out to be amazing opportunities and nobody should be criticized for having tried to get 1 or 10.
Who in their right mind would buy 10 camera's if it wasn't because they knew it was a pricing mistake and hoped they could sell at least 9 of them ?

And again, while I personally wouldn't buy 10, I did not have issues with those who tried. I have issue with those who tried, failed, and are now throwing a fit about how Sony "owes" them.

Its like someone that purposely spills something on the floors, slips on it, and then gets mad they didn't get a cash settlement even though they purposely fell.

Its absurd to see people talking lawyers because
...Show more →

I may have missed it, but who is talking about lawyers over this?

Jun 03, 2015 at 07:01 PM
CalBoy87
Offline
Details
p.5 #12A7r 199.99??
For me, what's interesting is the fact that Sony DID HONOR this price. One order for $199 went through, was even shipped. I believe the only reason for Sony request to return it, was posting it online and creating an unnecessary buzz around this particular transaction. I think the orders were filled with $199 price tag as long as they were in stock. We'll see if in couple weeks some buyers will come forward, bragging about 200 bucks A7r deal.
Jun 03, 2015 at 07:05 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.5 #13A7r 199.99??
Jman13 wrote:
Oh come on. You honestly thought they were selling their flagship mirrorless camera for 90% off? At 1/7th the price of the lower specced A7 that already has had a replacement for 6 months?

Honestly?

It is absolutely not true that no one knew. I didn't even bother to place the order because I knew it would be reversed. Almost everyone who ordered knew it was going to be canceled but ordered on the incredibly slim chance that a few slipped through.


Ok, you know everything.
Jun 03, 2015 at 07:06 PM
millsart
Offline
Details
p.5 #14A7r 199.99??
ecarlino wrote:
I may have missed it, but who is talking about lawyers over this?



There are photo enthusiast sites other than just FM, and while this is a pretty mature and level headed audience, the same can't be said for all discussion sites
Jun 03, 2015 at 07:09 PM
steveashe
Offline
Details
p.5 #15A7r 199.99??
I doubt it was just a simple mistake by one person on a Sunday morning. I have to believe a company the size of Sony has a process to change the price of anything over a certain $ amount on a commerce site that handles customer transactions; if they don't obviously they should. I think "mistakes" like this reflect poorly on the corporate governance of the company.
Jun 03, 2015 at 07:20 PM
Jman13
Online
Details
p.5 #16A7r 199.99??
I know this, as did pretty much every other person in this thread. And I'm pretty sure you know this too and are simply trying to make a buck.

ecarlino wrote:
Jman13 wroteOh come on. You honestly thought they were selling their flagship mirrorless camera for 90% off? At 1/7th the price of the lower specced A7 that already has had a replacement for 6 months?

Honestly?

It is absolutely not true that no one knew. I didn't even bother to place the order because I knew it would be reversed. Almost everyone who ordered knew it was going to be canceled but ordered on the incredibly slim chance that a few slipped through.
Ok, you know everything.

Jun 03, 2015 at 07:53 PM
steveashe
Offline
Details
p.5 #17A7r 199.99??
And as long as we're talking about "doing the right thing", it would have been a class move for Sony to send anyone that ordered the camera at $199 a little note apologizing for their mistake and thanking them for being a Sony customer. That would be such an easy thing to do.

I thank the Fred Miranda site for allowing this sort of discourse to carry on. This is not necessarily about a camera, it's really about connecting with others.
Jun 03, 2015 at 07:57 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.5 #18A7r 199.99??
Jman13 wrote:
I know this, as did pretty much every other person in this thread. And I'm pretty sure you know this too and are simply trying to make a buck.

ecarlino wrote
Jman13 wroteOh come on. You honestly thought they were selling their flagship mirrorless camera for 90% off? At 1/7th the price of the lower specced A7 that already has had a replacement for 6 months?

Honestly?

It is absolutely not true that no one knew. I didn't even bother to place the order because I knew it would be reversed. Almost everyone who ordered knew it was going to be canceled but ordered on the incredibly slim chance that a few slipped through.
Ok, you know everything.


I'm a commodity trader by profession, I make my living by jumping on oppty....I don't need to make a few bucks reselling cameras, though I would not criticize anyone who did. I'm also familiar with how companies unload old inventory, often at crazy prices.

I'm not suggesting I thought it was 90% or even 10% but it was above 0% that the deal could have been legit.

All you geniuses who are chiming in saying there was zero chance are free to sit back and let every crazy deal pass by.

Jun 03, 2015 at 08:05 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.5 #19A7r 199.99??
The deal is over (or never was). Can we move on now?
Jun 03, 2015 at 08:08 PM
pdmphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #20A7r 199.99??
At $199 I would have been more than happy shooting with an A7r - with no complaints
Jun 03, 2015 at 08:11 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister