fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread

  
 
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.3 #1The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
I agree with most of what you write, but here is where we disagree.

As you said, my DOF is slightly-increased with the D500, but my light transmission is still optimal. The part you're forgetting is that my DX increases my reach, while simultaneously allowing me to keep my ISO down.

To achieve the same framing in an FX, I would have to crop, thereby diminishing the image to get the same framing. This is why the D500 is actually preferable to an FX on the 400mm, for wildlife anyway. All the way across the DR continuum, the D500 beats the D850
...Show more →

I'm not forgetting the "reach" of the D500. It's important to note that it's reach is perceived, rather than a true optical reach. Basically, the crop factor didn't cause the "reach" to decrease the DOF to a 600mm equivalent at the same distance as it did to the FoV, just as cropping in post doesn't create a more shallow DOF. This is why the effective aperture changes when considering the DOF.

I'm also not overlooking the light transmission (since I mentioned it first). However, it's important to note that with the same lens on a full frame body with a similar pixel density, the full frame sensor would be receiving more light overall. Tony Northrup has some great content on the subject of crop vs full frame. I highly recommend it. It's also why many people wanted lens specifically designed for DX (with larger apertures than the relative FX lenses).

The main problem with your argument is that you keep saying that you need to crop a D850 image to D500 size, even though you are acknowledging the benefits when you can fill the frame. Like you, I wouldn't be satisfied with such a heavy crop. I would want to fill the frame as best I could. That may mean improving my field craft and getting closer, or start utilizing blinds and hides, wearing camo, etc, or I'm just using the wrong focal length. The fact that there are many photographers already filling the frame with a FX camera just tells me it is possible and I have a lot of room to grow and for improvement. I don't think anyone is buying the D850 to intentionally always crop to DX size, but it's nice that you can do so. Of course, you can always compromise, and just use a DX crop body.

I'm actually trying to tell you that your 400mm f/2.8 has even more potential than you are giving it, but it's okay if you don't think so. :P


May 26, 2019 at 01:59 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.3 #2The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
I am not missing the point; I believe you just don't want to admit it. By all accounts, the 400 FL ED is the finest super-telephoto made, wide-open. It's not just the Ephotozine review and graph, its everyone who's ever used the lens. It's virtually unanimous. LenScore, that you linked to, also says so. If you don't want to concede this point, so be it.



Nope, you are missing my point...maybe not your point. My point is the ephotozine data can't be compared lens to lens. That is a scientific fact because nothing was standardized including the camera body used and the y-axis of the graphs.

As I said in my earlier post, that doesn't preclude the 400FL from being the sharpest super tele ever made wide open, it just can't be used as a data point to support it compared to other lenses. And funny enough the ephotozine graph you keep referencing shows the 400FL to be sharper at both f/4 and f/5.6 vs f/2.8 so I don't know where your claim of f/2.8 being the sharpest aperture for the lens is even coming from?

Yes for the lenses LenScore tested the 400FL was the best. But as I mentioned, the newer lenses aren't tested on LenScore so we have no way to know how the Canon 400III or Sony 400GM compare....again we can't use ephotozine charts to compare across brands (or even within a brand) because of their non-standardized testing methods.

I never once said the 400FL isn't the sharpest so I don't have to concede the point one way or the other. At this point, based on all the data I can find on the internet all I can say is that there is no data to show which of the three current 400/2.8 lenses is the sharpest (Canon Mk3, Nikon FL or Sony GM). Therefore, I have no idea...I'm pretty sure I could get the same result out of all of them when it came down to a final image no matter which one actually would test the best.

May 26, 2019 at 03:15 PM
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.3 #3The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
The main problem with your argument is you admitted you couldn't do any of these things you recommend using the 400mm + FX, yourself. You mentioned you were either cropping, or using a 1xTC, admitting you always fell short.


Yes, 400mm + FX is too short for me currently. I also stated it's not too short for many photographers, and I have a lot of room to grow and improve, both in field craft and photography. However, you seem to be resorting to personal attacks now. It's okay, that's what people without solid factual arguments do.

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
It seems you never considered using a DX camera for its intended purpose: reach.


You missed the part where I use the D500. I chose that compromise for me. The rest, you're just making up as you go along I think. I never argued that the D850 out resolves the D500. Face reality, what would you rather have, a D850 file cropped from 45MP to 40MP or 30MP, or a 20.1MP D500 file? You wanted a 400mm f/2.8 to have the best lens you could buy, but then you have a D850 and try to use it like a D500... Don't place your shortcomings onto me.

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
The concept of reach isn't just theoretical, it is actual.


I'm not talking theory. DX didn't magically make your 400mm a 600mm. It's still a 400mm cropped to a 600mm FoV. If you think they're equal, then maybe you might like the P900 or P1000 for their "reach".

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Another problem with your argument is you think the D850 is "equal" to the D500 as an action camera, too.


And there you go making up more stuff. Quote me saying that. Do you actually take pictures of action? Because a bunny scared stiff, a bird perched, and a flower (was the flower going to run away?) don't scream action shots to me. You needed 400mm and 600mm effective to get close to a flower? I can play this game, too.

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
I can tell by your tone you look down on DX cameras in general...


You're placing a tone where there was none. That's on you. As I am a DX user, you couldn't be more wrong. I would not be honest if I pretended the advantages of the D850 didn't exist. However, I am now looking down on you. You just lost all credibility.

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
I understand what you're getting at ... in order to get closer, one needs to get a longer lens, use a TC, or do what I do, and use the finest DX camera made. I chose C


I don't think you do get it. I explicitly stated it, but it was still over your head. Maybe a diagram in the form of a children's book would help you?

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Another reason I don't go to a 600mm is it doesn't have the specs of the 400mm, contained in my handle. The 400mm does.


What? Who told you to go to 600mm? I think you're having a conversation in your head that only you can hear.

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Right now, I use my D850 for its intended purpose: when I know I can fill the frame (landscape, portrait, macro). Being able to fill the frame with wildlife is by no means certain, or even likely, with a D850 + 400 FL ED combo. You said so yourself.


Wildlife is never certain, but that isn't even close to what I said. I've filled the frame enough with the 300mm PF on the D500 (450mm equiv FoV) to know it is possible. I also don't live in a bubble where I only see my own photos. It's very possible. But as you say, competency matters. I'm not there yet after my short time doing this as a hobby. You're not there yet after many years. To each their own.

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Don't worry: I am also saving up for an 800mm, which is when I will decide to use a FF


And then you'll probably decide it's the best thing ever for every purpose since you chose it, create another fake alias, and start the nonsense all over, again. Well, there's the benefit that you can get even closer to... flowers...

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
But let's concede the realities that have been laid out regarding the resolution + DR of cropped FX images being inferior compared to D500 images.


I think you conceded reality a while ago. Maybe you should come back to it. Do you really think a D850 image cropped to say 40MP would be inferior to a 20.1MP D500 image? You're talking about extreme crops, and only extreme crops. I think it's kind of amazing you can crop a D850 image so much and still have something in the ballpark of a D500 image. In fact, you admittedly can't even fill the frame with the D500, something I have no problem with at 400mm.

None of the photos you've taken and shown here in this thread set them apart from the 500mm PF, which is what started this whole conversation. My ability (or lack of) has nothing to do with it. You can attack me all you like. It doesn't prove your point about the 400mm f/2.8. It only shows your character.

Edited on May 26, 2019 at 04:16 PM · View previous versions
May 26, 2019 at 04:04 PM
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.3 #4The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
dan.h wroteI'm actually trying to tell you that your 400mm f/2.8 has even more potential than you are giving it, but it's okay if you don't think so. :P
Tell you what, Dan

Just for you, the next time I go out with the 400mm (tomorrow morning), I will do so with the D850 + 400 FL ED, see what I can come up with, and post the images


Don't hurt yourself. Tell the guys in the white coats that escort you around to not leave you out in the sun too long.
May 26, 2019 at 04:13 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.3 #5The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Lance B wroteI usually use a shoulder type strap, a Luma Loop camera strap, which is very comfortable and easy to use. Even so, wielding it around chasing birds is still more difficult than the light 500 f5.6 PF especially on my Z7.
If I may make a constructive suggestion, Lance: I notice you use your 400 FL ED with various TCs most often. I did with mine as well. The trouble is, I quickly noticed the image quality I achieved, while "very good," was actually nothing special. Decent, but the same image quality was achievable with other lens combos.

I realized very quickly that I didn't pay all this money to have a "pretty good" 540mm f/4 (1.4 TC), or a so-so 800mm f/5.6 (2x TC). No, what I invested my money in was to enjoy "the sharpest super-telephoto lens on the planet,
...Show more →
Lance B wroteIt's image quality like this that makes me want to get my 400 f2.8E FL VR out again.


Thank you for your kind words on my images.

I appreciate your advice, but I do realise all of what you have suggested, I have been shooting the 400 for 4 years now and know it inside out. When using the 400 bare, I generally try to keep it at f4 or wider, depending on the subject and subject to camera distance. If the subject warrants f5.6 or f8 or whatever due to short camera to subject distance (thus narrowing the DOF), I will use that. If the subject is further away, I will always try to go for f4 or so, or if I am really trying to blur the background. I also try to get as close to my subjects as I can trying to negate the use of TC's, but that is not always possible and thus I will use a TC when I have no option. Using the 1.4x TCIII, the resultant IQ is so close to the 600 f4 that it would not warrant buying it over the 400 f2.8E and this is why I chose it over the 600 f4 for that versatility and the fact that bare it arguably gives the best IQ of any of the Nikon exotics when bare. F4 is about where this lens is at it's best and when using the 1.4x TCIII I generally use it at f4 (f5.6), which is where the lens is at it's best with the 1.4x TCIII, IMO. However, it is also just as sharp at f5.6 bare but when the 1.4x TCIII is added making it f8, then f5.6 ceases to be as good as f4 (f5.6 with the TC).

As much as I love to use the 400 for it's results, I also like the ease of the 500 f5.6PF due to size and weight and also the results are excellent. When I go out for the day, I am not always sure of what I will find or what I may decide to take photos of or what may come my way. I therefore take a kit which now consists of Z7 + 14-30, 24-70, 70-200 and the 500 f5.6PF and this is easy enough to carry in one backpack. This covers me for pretty much any eventuality or what I decide to do in a whim. However, if I take the 400, it is way too difficult to fit in one bag and thus it rarely sees the light of day unless I decide to specifically go out and shoot birds which I don't do as much these days. Sydney has become very crowded over the last 5 years due to immigration (100,000 per years for at least 5+ years!) and it is just so much more difficult to get around do to the infrastructure not keeping up with this and thus means going way further afield to do birding and I just don't always have the time to dedicate to this. The thing is, if I do go further afield, I also do not want to miss the opportunities for landscapes and other photography and thus a full kit is generally required - see above. I will not leave part of my kit in the car and thus necessitates carrying it all with me. Back full circle to taking a lightweight kit and leaving the 400 at home. Having said that, the Z7 + 14-30, 24-70 and 70-200 is waaay lighter and smaller than my previous kit of D850, Tamron 15-30 f2.8, 24-70 f2.8E VR, 70-200 f2.8E FL VR and 400 f2.8E FL VR, which means that I may try the Z7 kit + 400, but it also means less likelyhood of taking BIF or tracking shots. However, it is not always a priority to take BIF and tracking shots as I generally rather taking bird portraits and using the fabulous IQ of the 400 to get that look.
May 26, 2019 at 04:26 PM
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.3 #6The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
arbitrage wrote:
My point is the ephotozine data can't be compared lens to lens. That is a scientific fact because nothing was standardized including the camera body used and the y-axis of the graphs.


IIRC, ephotozine themselves state this. I believe they even stated before that their methodology has changed and can't be compared.

I will say that I have no doubt that the 400mm f/2.8 is a phenomenal lens. It gets praised by highly respected professionals, and many images here and elsewhere demonstrate it. I would just reinforce what arbitrage stated, and take such comparisons with a grain of salt, and not use them as your sole data point to make decisions on.
May 26, 2019 at 05:15 PM
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.3 #7The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
I looked at your Flickr account, and truly do admire your photography. Especially your post processing. Let's just leave it at that.


Thanks. I pretty much hit "Auto" in lightroom for everything. Then the photo takes a trip through photoshop for noise removal with Neat Image. I may or may not apply a post crop vignetting back in lightroom afterwards. Now you know my secret.
May 26, 2019 at 06:06 PM
chambeshi
Offline
Details
p.3 #8The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
dan.h wrote:
arbitrage wroteMy point is the ephotozine data can't be compared lens to lens. That is a scientific fact because nothing was standardized including the camera body used and the y-axis of the graphs.
IIRC, ephotozine themselves state this. I believe they even stated before that their methodology has changed and can't be compared.

I will say that I have no doubt that the 400mm f/2.8 is a phenomenal lens. It gets praised by highly respected professionals, and many images here and elsewhere demonstrate it. I would just reinforce what arbitrage stated, and take such comparisons with a grain of salt, and not use them as your sole data point to make decisions on.


Year in, Year out, this debate on the "best" / "most-ideal" Telephoto keeps going around across the different forums:
1. Wildlife Photography = biodiversity and the majority of images focus in on the actual organisms, with environscapes also featuring - eg Brad Hill's portfolio for exemplar environscapes.

2. The latter usually require optics of shorter focal lengths, while portraits of organisms (especially vertebrates) are often taken with telephotos reaching out to 800mm and even more in rarer cases. Then, obviously, we have macro close ups drilling into microscopic scales.

3. Choice of one's telephoto optics hinges on several factors. Obviously IQ and image quality, including bokeh, with speed (ie f4 or f2.8) being important. Speed also hinges on the ISO envelope of one's cameras [eg Z7 vs Z6; D500 vs D850 vs D5]. AF speed is also a factor, but nearly all top quality telephotos focus fast.

4. Haptics is a major factor in selecting one's telephoto(S), Thus Lance , myself and many others seized on the 500 PF eagerly because of its unique combination of weight to not only handle and hand hold over sustained encounters. The 1.5kg can not only be handhold for 30-60sec vs but even several minutes, when encountering an amenable subject. Then there's travel of course, not only draconian constraints of boarding with big glass on to airlines but also age and individual physique.

5. The big pachyderm in almost all outdoor studios is Reach - getting telephoto reach out to frame the subject - ideally without cropping. Thus the 600 f4 is the mainstream birder's lens, and a 800mm would be ideal. But getting 800 with top IQ costs the most all round unless one uses a Teleconverter.

6. Love 'em, or hate 'em Teleconverters are Key to get Reach at optimal cost and haptics of travel and hiking. The penalties on IQ vary but the 400 f2.8E handles all 2 very very well indeed QED. The 500 PF incurs an hit with TC14 but this can be justified and also managed by not trying to rely on it for quality at longer distances. The 600 4E and 800 f5.6E have the IQ edge as stand alone primes, but at the triple extra costs of $$$$ and practicalities of travel. Here, and most fortunately, the 400 f2.8E does very well with all 3 TCs, but best with TC14 III

There does appear to be some sample variation across the current Nikon TCs but it's hard to identify reliably et alone quantify how much.

In conclusion, a recent parallel debate over the past couple of months confirms:

https://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/62371976

A. There is an acute scarcity of Robust quantitative data that assesses all these telephotos on FX DSLRs with HR sensors - i.e. on sensors in the league of a D8*0, or D850 / Z7. Lensrentals put out some data on 400 primes but admitted this focal length is at the outer limit of their apparatus....so it's very hard to compare reliable MTFs across the 600 guild and longer - either of primes or a 400 prime with TCs etc. You can read about the challenges Nasim encountered at PL testing the 800 f5.6E Nikkor!

https://photographylife.com/reviews/nikon-800mm-f5-6e-vr

B. We have complementary choices among lenses. And despite Point A above, we see the evidence in the uncountable numbers of high quality images. These stream out across media and into prints (eg see award winning entries in Natural History Museum Wildlife Photographer of the Year Competition). So no surprises that the consensus is ALL the exotic-telephoto Nikkor primes are excellent choices. This includes the 500 PF. Individual Choices are subject to the MIX of local factors Where and How you shoot, and What subjects....

The top end Sigma super zooms and 200-500 f5.6E Nikkor are also excellent at the price, and so is the 80-400 G if one finds a decent copy and carefully sets its AFFT @400mm. And of course zooms confer added bonuses of Range-of Reach + Means-to-Frame

Edited on May 27, 2019 at 06:28 AM · View previous versions
May 27, 2019 at 02:27 AM
chambeshi
Offline
Details
p.3 #9The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
While the 400 f2.8E is my top telephoto lens, and often with TCs, the 500 PF works as hard. And I travel with both, and a 300 PF and 70-200 f2.8E. The main reason is I shoot 2 or ideally 3 rigs in a car, or at least I hike with 2 cameras and up to 5 lenses. Often it's the 500 PF with a 70-200.

As with taking 2 cameras, the second reason is redundancy + backup should a lens break down or be broken
May 27, 2019 at 02:45 AM
RandyR
Offline
Details
p.3 #10The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
300mm is of no use to me for wildlife and I don't like TCs, especially on the 300pf which is amazing at f/4
May 27, 2019 at 11:27 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.3 #11The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Regarding #3, hands-down, the 300 PF + TCs is the king of all "light, user-friendly" field lenses. No contest. No other field lens (from any manufacturer) comes close to what an unburdened joy the 300 PF + a couple of TCs is to carry in the field. Even the 500 PF doesn't qualify, as it is more than 3x the weight of the 300 PF.


The highlighted statement is far from the truth.
300PF weight is 755g
500PF weight is 1460g

If you want 500mm out of the 300PF you need the 1.7TC at 250g
If you just want 420 then 1.4TC is 190g.

So bare lens to bare lens we have a just less than 2x weight.
If we add on one or the other TC then we have between 54% and 45% increase in weight from the 300/TC to the 500PF.

I agree that the 300PF +/- TCs is the king but the 500PF isn't 3x the weight, not even close and especially not once you add a TC to the 300PF to get close to the 500PFs focal length and aperture.

PS...some 400FL owners need to start posting more photos to break up the lens debate!!
May 27, 2019 at 01:11 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.3 #12The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Agreed, will do so later. Thought I was going this morning. It's an overcast day, so will try to this afternoon.


Hope you get out this afternoon but isn't it already 9:30PM in Berlin?
May 27, 2019 at 01:25 PM
TANG0F0XTR0T
Offline
Details
p.3 #13The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
I have the 500mmE FL and a 300mm 2.8 VR. I get 2.8 with my 300mm and the 500mm can be hauled around all day without issue and gives me great IQ and reach.

All that being said, I've been tempted to trade them both in to fund a 400mm 2.8E FL for the all in one ultimate tele-photo exotic. There happens to be one for sale used at the moment which puts the price a bit more within my reach. Question is, will I regret the decision when I already have 2 great lenses.......

Decisions, decisions......
May 27, 2019 at 01:50 PM
chambeshi
Offline
Details
p.3 #14The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
This might seem off topic to this thread, but it's interesting, let alone useful, to understand the history in the origins of a lens. This is especially true of these exotic prime super telephotos of the calibre of the big, fast Nikkors.

Here's an excerpt from the 1001 Nights Essay by optical maestro Haruo Sato. He pays tribute to one "Gifted Sato" - aka "Genius Sato" who we can thank for many of the best Nikkor telephotos.
"The lenses he designed include the AI AF-S Zoom-Nikkor 80-200mm f/2.8D IF-ED as well as 300mm, 400mm, and 500mm AF-I lenses, and 300mm, 400mm, 500mm, and 600mm prime and 200-400mm and 1200-1700mm zoom AF-S lenses."

https://imaging.nikon.com/history/story/0067/index.htm

It's particularly interesting reading how well Sato San corrected axial chromatic aberration: "Sato primarily designed telephoto zoom lenses and super-telephoto lenses, but well before the coming digital age was predicted, he also brought about innovations in the correction of axial chromatic aberration. With the switch from AI to AF, fast telephoto NIKKOR lenses changed significantly. That was the result of perfect (more than adequate) chromatic aberration compensation. Sato's promise was to ensure that when teleconverters were used with lenses utilizing new designs, the levels of performance and chromatic aberration exhibited by the teleconverter/lens combination was superior to that of other lenses of the time with the equivalent final focal length (combined lens/teleconverter focal length). For example, he decided to design a new 300mm f/2.8 lens. When a 2x teleconverter was used with the newly designed 300mm lens, performance and chromatic aberration characteristics had to be better than those of the current 600mm f/4 lens. A 2x teleconverter increases axial chromatic aberration by four times. Therefore, axial chromatic aberration for the newly designed lens had to be reduced to 1/4 that of the current stand-alone lens (with double the focal length)."

Note the earlier model before the current 300 f2.8G VRII still rates high in IQ, as do the earlier 400 f2.8 versions. "Genius Sato" has updated these designs to the current E models. This was in private correspondence with Haruo Sato San, earlier this year. He passed on my grateful thanks to his colleague who designed these Nikkor telephotos - and namely the 400 f2.8E FL :-)


Edited on May 28, 2019 at 02:19 PM · View previous versions
May 28, 2019 at 05:09 AM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.3 #15The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
Having owned and used both the 300 f2.8G VRII and now the 400 f2.8E FL VR, I would have to say that they are the best lenses I have ever used and are minimally affected by all the TCs as it is part of their design parameters.
May 28, 2019 at 05:23 AM
rico
Offline
Details
p.3 #16The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
chambeshi wrote:
... as well as 300mm, 400mm, and 500mm AF-I lenses, and 300mm, 400mm, 500mm, and 600mm prime and 200-400mm and 1200-1700mm zoom AF-S lenses."
...
It's particularly interesting reading how well Sato San corrected axial chromatic aberration: "Sato primarily designed telephoto zoom lenses and super-telephoto lenses, but well before the coming digital age was predicted, he also brought about innovations in the correction of axial chromatic aberration.

No question that Sato-san has known his business for a long time, and is a genius. I'm an asshole about LCA (axial color) and was stunned to see the performance of the 300 AF-I in this regard. I also have the matched 2x teleconverter (yet to use). The AF-I actually has 4 ED elements rather than 3 of the later models. Here's an example from two weeks ago under the harshest lighting:



Z6, Nikkor 300/2.8 AF-I wide open. Crops are 200% scale and you can see the rhinestone speculars are in pin-point focus with no fringing whatsoever. Edge crop is also free of TCA (lateral color). Not bad for a design from three decades ago. Given the same designer, I'm eager to acquire the 400E one day: it's crazy that the first two elements are fluorite!
May 29, 2019 at 09:03 AM
chambeshi
Offline
Details
p.3 #17The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
Wow! Hyper Acuity thanks be to Nikkor, and in low light thanks be to Nikon Z!

It was with mixed feelings that I traded in my 300 f2.8G VRII, which served very well (and with TCs). For that much more reach - out to 800 f5.6 with TC2III. Yes, the 400 f2.8E FL is indeed a stunning Nikkor :-)

One often reads across forums the reports by owners of how very pleased they are with the earlier models of the 300 f2.8 AFI and AFS models designed by "Genius Sato"

http://www.photosynthesis.co.nz/nikon/serialno.html#300

Off thread topic, but does anyone know which of the "D" models with AF-I and AFS are still capable of autofocus on the Z Nikon cameras?
May 29, 2019 at 12:02 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.3 #18The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
@chambeshi According to the FTZ compatibility doc from Nikon, AF is supported for these Nikkors: AF-S Type G, E, and D; AF-P Type G and E; AF-I Type D. There are 15 pages of fascinating detail and warnings. Of course, no-one here would try to attach their pre-Ai glass, right?
May 29, 2019 at 02:16 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.3 #19The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RazorSharpWO wrote:
chambeshi wroteWow! Hyper Acuity thanks be to Nikkor, and in low light thanks be to Nikon Z!

It was with mixed feelings that I traded in my 300 f2.8G VRII, which served very well (and with TCs). For that much more reach - out to 800 f5.6 with TC2III. Yes, the 400 f2.8E FL is indeed a stunning Nikkor :-)

One often reads across forums the reports by owners of how very pleased they are with the earlier models of the 300 f2.8 AFI and AFS models designed by "Genius Sato"

http://www.photosynthesis.co.nz/nikon/serialno.html#300

Off thread topic, but does anyone know which of the "D" models with AF-I and AFS are still capable of autofocus on the Z Nikon cameras?
All of us appear to have a similar history: move from the sensational 300mm f/2.8 ... to the even more sensational 400mm FL ED.


I think we see the versatility of an f2.8 exotic when using TC's and thus get the longer 400 f2.8. I mean, it is without peer.
May 29, 2019 at 04:48 PM
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.3 #20The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RazorSharpWO wrote:
All of us appear to have a similar history: move from the sensational 300mm f/2.8 ... to the even more sensational 400mm FL ED.


I think this is going to be the path that I take as well. While I personally have no problem with it's rendering, I'm kind of tired of waiting for that 500mm PF, and I've been wanting to take that next step up for a while. The 300mm f/2.8 has always looked very attractive to me. I think I will always find value in it. My only hesitation is that I think Nikon will come out with a newer FL 'E' version the moment I purchase one.
May 29, 2019 at 07:22 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister