fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread

  
 
ctulhu
Offline
Details
p.2 #1The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
I have to say it again. DAMN GOOD IMAGES!!!!!!!! LanceB Kudos to you!
Apr 24, 2017 at 12:31 AM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.2 #2The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
ctulhu wrote:
I have to say it again. DAMN GOOD IMAGES!!!!!!!! LanceB Kudos to you!


Thank you very much once again, ctulhu. Much appreciated!
Apr 24, 2017 at 02:22 AM
TimMunsey
Offline
Details
p.2 #3The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
Lance you get every drop of goodness possible out the kit, always great to see what paradise looks like.

Tim
Apr 24, 2017 at 06:27 AM
Elijah
Offline
Details
p.2 #4The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
400mm f/2.8E is my favorite walk around lens... Fits in my pocket, love it









Sep 12, 2017 at 05:25 PM
la puffin
Offline
Details
p.2 #5The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
D5 + 1.4x TC III, pretty heavy crop. I really like the balance of the E over the G.

http://www.shoaps.com/samples/1715.jpg
Oct 01, 2018 at 05:54 PM
nuclearjock
Offline
Details
p.2 #6The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
la puffin wrote:
D5 + 1.4x TC III, pretty heavy crop. I really like the balance of the E over the G.

http://www.shoaps.com/samples/1715.jpg


That's because the E version is balanced, the G is not.
Oct 01, 2018 at 06:38 PM
la puffin
Offline
Details
p.2 #7The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
nuclearjock wrote:
That's because the E version is balanced, the G is not.


When I used it on a Gimbal or with a ballhead, it was fine. However, I basically only did that for AF tuning. The balance became really apparent when used on a monopod, which I use every game I shoot.
Oct 02, 2018 at 12:25 AM
RandyR
Offline
Details
p.2 #8The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
I NEVER EVER shoot mine at anything but f/2.8. On the D5 for sports there has never been anything better. The weight and balance makes this a huge improvement for me. Even at my advanced age I can HH this lens in a pinch. The 400g was a pig. For sports I shoot on a monopod. Walking the sidelines the drop in weight is very noticeable. And the foot and hood are big improvements

https://www.carolinasportsphotography.com/img/s/v-10/p3435101352-4.jpg

https://www.carolinasportsphotography.com/img/s/v-10/p3435101354-4.jpg

https://www.carolinasportsphotography.com/img/s/v-10/p3435101351-6.jpg
May 25, 2019 at 05:09 PM
bs kite
Offline
Details
p.2 #9The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
This is in response to BS Kite's post here, so as not to further hijack the 500 PF thread with off-topic trivia.

bs kite wroteUnless the photographer shoots off a tripod, shooting a lens all day means *carrying it all day*.

Regardless of balance, the 400 2.8 FL weighs over 8 pounds, while the 500 PF weighs 3.2 pounds.
While the prospect of carrying this lens appears daunting, this is only true if you physically carry it by hand. I can honestly tell you, it is virtually unnoticeable deploying a Blackrapid Strap to do so. It is actually easy to carry 8 lb across your shoulders and torso, hands-free, for hours. I know, I have done so.

bs kite wroteI suspect that among all super telephotos, the 400 2.8 FL renders the sharpest images with the creamiest bokeh.

The 400 2.8 FL is so exciting, that I could *almost* convince myself that it could actually be my principle handheld supertelepho lens.
Yes, exactly, on the first part. This is why I finally made the plunge and bought it.

On the second part, like you,
...Show more →
bs kite wroteBut in reality, I am not going to lug it around while lifting it up and down to my face......all day long.

If I had the 500 PF *and* the 400 2.8 FL, eventually, the 400 2.8 would be staying home.

The only exception would be when I know I would be shooting off a tripod for most of that day. And if I can, I will always opt to free myself from a tripod.


I too have the Black Rapid strap and will not go out without it. You are right, it does disperse the weight of the rig to the extent that it’s not a problem. I use the strap in my work on the water. I figure it’s inevitable that the D850/lens (200-500) will one day be knocked from my hands as I am pulling it back, after shooting over the gunwale. But with the strap firmly attached and locked (and I do periodically check it) the rig cannot end up “deep-sixed”.

One day I discovered the importance of periodically checking the hook/lock. Getting back into my vehicle I was just about ready to lower the lens to the strap from having it briefly cradled in my arms. At the last second I visually checked the hook and somehow the spring-gate had opened and the hook was disconnected. Had I released the weight of the rig onto the strap, the rig would have smashed into the pavement.

Yes, I can imagine that 400 2.8 FL shots taken at 2.8 to 4 can be very exciting. And it would be exciting to couple it with my D500 too! A 600 2.8 that is super sharp?! Maybe I will get one someday, but not for now. And I cannot imagine holding the 400 2.8 FL lens up, waiting for the moment that Arbitrage described in a post on the last page. Holding the 400 2.8 FL up for long, while waiting for that moment, would be torture. I suppose one could pump dumbbells for months, until the deltoids turn in to coconuts.

Regarding the 500 PF, I think it is about agility and lightness, more than anything else.

And here are some of LanceB’s exciting images I found on pBase, taken with the 400 2.8 FL.

https://pbase.com/image/159316961

Great light and exciting subjects!



Edited on May 25, 2019 at 05:26 PM · View previous versions
May 25, 2019 at 05:19 PM
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.2 #10The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
For this reason, I only shoot with the bare lens now, which is equivalent to a 600mm f/2.8 on my D500.


The depth of field is actually affected by the crop factor. So, it's equivalent to a 600mm f/4.2. However, it's only the depth of field affected, not the light transmission. So, it's still an aperture of f/2.8 in all other aspects.

I would argue the strap only helps inbetween shooting, not when shooting. Having a shoulder strap isn't going to help me keep a 400mm f/2.8 on a perched hawk while waiting 20 minutes for it to fly or hunt. I don't own a 400mm f/2.8, but I do own a Sigma S 150-600mm (lighter than the 400mm f/2.8), and I can maybe keep the lens on the bird handheld for 8 minutes before I start feeling fatigue. And yes, I do use the technique you described in the other thread. It still gets tiresome, requiring to put the lens down and rest, possibly missing the moment. I can keep the 300mm PF+TC on a bird for much much longer, and I would guess I could do the same with the 500mm PF. That is what makes the PF lens more handholdable. I can also manuever the 300mm PF+TC while in an awkward position more easily. There are times when, if you want the shot, you might have to go into a less than ideal position and use a less than ideal technique. It's not even really debatable that a smaller and lighter lens is easier to do these things with. But yes, that smaller and lighter lens comes with compromises.

I don't think you'll find anyone arguing that the 500mm PF is better than the 400mm f/2.8 optically. Like you, I prefer to take my best lens with me into the field. For me, the 500mm PF would be a step up. For others, it would be a step down. The 500mm PF is also good enough, that sometimes, the compromises are very acceptable.
May 25, 2019 at 05:20 PM
RandyR
Offline
Details
p.2 #11The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
as great a lens as the 400e is I can't imagine choosing it over my 500pf for wildlife. As it is now my 500e sits at home as well because of the 500pf. For BIF nothing compares.
May 25, 2019 at 05:38 PM
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.2 #12The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
bs kite wrote:
One day I discovered the importance of periodically checking the hook/lock. Getting back into my vehicle I was just about ready to lower the lens to the strap from having it briefly cradled in my arms. At the last second I visually checked the hook and somehow the spring-gate had opened and the hook was disconnected. Had I released the weight of the rig onto the strap, the rig would have smashed into the pavement.


It's always a good idea to tug on or check the connection to make sure it's solid before use. The BlackRapid straps are famous for that clasp/carabiner coming undone (and the fastener coming unscrewed). Each generation seems to improve upon the last, but BlackRapid still seems to have flaws. I also highly dislike the plastic buckles/clips. AFAIK, BlackRapid has also never specified the weight limitations of the straps, fasteners, or carabiners. People just assume they're safe to use with a heavy lens.

My personal favorite is a Magpul MS4® Dual QD Sling GEN2. The nylon webbing feels more substantial than BlackRapid's, and there are no flimsy plastic buckles or clips. I use a RRS L-bracket on my camera body that has QD connection points for when I use a lighter lens, and a RRS arca-swiss compatible clamp with a QD connection attached to the lens foot of heavier lens. The whole thing is rated to take some serious abuse and weight. Unlike BlackRapid, where the carabiner moves freely across the strap, the magpul has to move across your body. I actually prefer this for quite a few reasons, but I think this is getting pretty far off topic.
May 25, 2019 at 05:53 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #13The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RandyR wrote:
as great a lens as the 400e is I can't imagine choosing it over my 500pf for wildlife. As it is now my 500e sits at home as well because of the 500pf. For BIF nothing compares.


Yep, my 500E also sits at home because of the PF.
May 25, 2019 at 06:05 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.2 #14The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
I haven't used my 400 f2.8 in months due to the 500 f5.6PF.
May 25, 2019 at 08:08 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.2 #15The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Here are some recent images with the bare 400 FL ED lens + the D500. All, save the first, were taken @ f/2.8. The first was taken @ f/4.

http://www.thenaturephotographer.club/thumbnails/1/1_thumb_0000002581_large.jpg
Desert Cottontail (Sylvilagus audubonii) ~ Nikon D500 + Nikkor 400mm f/2.8 FL ED ~ 1/320 | f/4 | 640 ISO

http://www.thenaturephotographer.club/thumbnails/1/1_thumb_0000002583_large.jpg
American Bushtit (Psaltriparus minimus) ~ Nikon D500 + Nikkor 400mm f/2.8 FL ED ~ 1/8000 | f/2.8 | 320 ISO

http://www.thenaturephotographer.club/thumbnails/1/1_thumb_0000002584_large.jpg
American Bushtit (Psaltriparus minimus) ~ Nikon D500 + Nikkor 400mm f/2.8 FL ED ~ 1/3200 | f/2.8 | 320 ISO

http://www.thenaturephotographer.club/thumbnails/1/1_thumb_0000002585_large.jpg
American Bushtit (Psaltriparus minimus) ~ Nikon D500 + Nikkor 400mm f/2.8 FL ED ~ 1/2500
...Show more →

It's image quality like this that makes me want to get my 400 f2.8E FL VR out again. There is no doubting the 400's stunning IQ, just that the 500 f5.6PF is so convenient and easy to use.
May 25, 2019 at 10:00 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.2 #16The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Lance B wroteIt's image quality like this that makes me want to get my 400 f2.8E FL VR out again.
Thanks. My point exactly. Seeing the difference (especially blown-up at full-size in your workflow) is so satisfying ...

Lance B wroteThere is no doubting the 400's stunning IQ, just that the 500 f5.6PF is so convenient and easy to use.
Well, not sure how you usually deploy, but that Sling has changed my perspective. The 400 FL ED is as easy to deploy as the 300 PF. Not as light, of course, but as ready and easy to deploy.

In fact, on today's outing, I carried both: the 400 FL ED hung down at my left hip, and the 300 PF was holstered on my chest via a Cotton Carrier.

My left hand always grasps the foot of the 400 FL ED and, the moment
...Show more →

I usually use a shoulder type strap, a Luma Loop camera strap, which is very comfortable and easy to use. Even so, wielding it around chasing birds is still more difficult than the light 500 f5.6 PF especially on my Z7.
May 26, 2019 at 12:54 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #17The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
If I may make a constructive suggestion, Lance: I notice you use your 400 FL ED with various TCs most often. I did with mine as well. The trouble is, I quickly noticed the image quality I achieved, while "very good," was actually nothing special. Decent, but the same image quality was achievable with other lens combos.

I realized very quickly that I didn't pay all this money to have a "pretty good" 540mm f/4 (1.4 TC), or a so-so 800mm f/5.6 (2x TC). No, what I invested my money in was to enjoy "the sharpest super-telephoto lens on the planet,
...Show more →

I'm not an MTF or Imatest expert but I don't think you can use all those MTF charts to compare lenses. All of them were shot on different cameras and the 400FL one doesn't even have a numeric scale on it. The 400 was on D600, the 600 was on D750, the 500PF was on D810 and the 400III was on 5DSR. If you could compare those numbers it would say the 600FL shows less resolution than the 500PF by a significant margin which I doubt is the case.

I think those graphs are useful to show how a given lens performs at each aperture as you have brought up. But if you look closely the 400FL is best at f/4, second best at f/5.6 and then at f/2.8. The Canon best at f/4 and f/5.6 (with f/5.6 corners better which is meaningless as my corners are going to be in smooth buttery bokeh anyways) and pretty much tied between f/2.8 and f/8.

The 400FL may well be the best of the bunch but that conclusion can't be drawn from the Ephotozine charts. The LenScore charts would make sense to compare as they are all done on the same 200MP sensor but they have closed up shop (University project) and therefore none of the newest lenses like 500PF or 400III are available.
May 26, 2019 at 07:13 AM
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.2 #18The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Regarding the issue of reach, one thing not mentioned, by any reviewer, is the fact you can shoot the 400mm FL ED at half the ISO of the others, which (aside from the fact the 400 out-resolves the others) improves the image quality greatly, over and above its superior sharpness & CA-control, wide-open.


Steve Perry talks about the benefit of faster glass in quite a few of his reviews, including his 500mm PF review. In fact, he wrote an entire post about it and references it in several other reviews.

Amazing High ISO – The End Of Fast Glass?
May 26, 2019 at 11:17 AM
dan.h
Offline
Details
p.2 #19The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
I realized very quickly that I didn't pay all this money to have a "pretty good" 540mm f/4 (1.4 TC), or a so-so 800mm f/5.6 (2x TC). No, what I invested my money in was to enjoy "the sharpest super-telephoto lens on the planet, from f/2.8 - f/4," with "the most beautiful bokeh, subject separation, and and CA-free color-rendering available."


Keep in mind that when paired with the D500, you are not getting the "most beautiful bokeh, subject separation, and and CA-free color-rendering available". It is probably the best that you can do on a D500, but it only improves with a comparative full frame body. You are shooting at an effective DOF of f/4, when you could be shooting at a real f/2.8. The dynamic range would also improve when you can shoot at an even lower ISO, which I imagine can only enhance the color rendering and resolution.

RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
Since it is impossible to carry all these lenses at the same time, we have to make a decision which one we're going to carry. For many, it's the 600mm, because of its reach + f/4. For others, it's the 500 f/4 because of its weight + very good IQ @ f/4.


If I shot full frame, I would often find 400mm too short and this is where (for me) the focal length of the other lens mentioned would trump the benefits the 400mm f/2.8 lens provides, or I would use a TC.

I don't like to criticize other's photos, especially wildlife, as I do not know what the photographer intended, nor do I know the environment or conditions the photo was taken in. I can only guess at what I may have done differently if it were possible to do so. While your cottontail photo is in focus and shows a lot of detail, I don't think it exhibits the potential of a f/2.8 lens if you intended to show off a nice creamy background. The rabbit is sideways, so I'm not sure you needed to increase the DOF. A full frame body with the 500mm PF @ f/5.6 might have even had a better background (due to increased focal length, but the distance to subject would need to change, unless you cropped it).

This is also where I value the size and weight of the 500mm PF over something like the 400mm f/2.8. I would have, if possible, found an angle where I could lay down flat on the ground (yes, in the mud or whatever else), and blown out the background entirely with a very low angle shot. The lightweight and size of the 500mm PF makes it much quicker and easier to maneuver like that (for me anyway).
May 26, 2019 at 12:17 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #20The Nikon 400 f2.8E FL VR Official Thread
RzrShpWdOpnAPO wrote:
However, that said, the very fact the 400 FL ED shows such outstanding resolution on a D600, where the others can't get to on better cameras, is telling. Also, two additional truths manifest: 1) it is sharper @ f/2.8 than either the 600 FL ED or 500 PF are, anywhere within their effective ranges, and (2) the 400 FL ED's CA measurement is lowest @ f/2.8, virtually non-existent, which is a lower measurement than either lens, anywhere within their effective ranges. (Same with the Canon 400 III.)

The 600mm is actually the poorest performer of the bunch wide-open. The 500mm FL
...Show more →

Again, I think you are missing the point...none of those values can be compared between lenses. The 400FL doesn't even have a numeric Y-axis scale so who knows what the actual values are. As you can see from the other ones that do have values on the Y-axis they aren't using the same scale for every lens. eg the Canon goes to 4500, the 500PF's scale goes to 3500 and the 600FL only goes to 3000 so who knows what the scale is supposed to be for the 400FL. And because the 500PF was shot on the higher res sensor, you can't say if it is better or worse MTF versus the 600FL (or the Canon shot on an even higher res sensor).

I don't know why ephotozine doesn't standardize their tests on a given body for each company (you still won't be able to compare a Nikon to a Canon) but at least you could compare the Nikon lenses against each other.

Anyways, as soon as you start handholding a lens your realized linepairs will tank anyways and all of these lenses even out in that regard.
May 26, 2019 at 01:45 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister