fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)

  
 
chez
Offline
Details
p.10 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)


jctriguy wrote:
zlatko wrote
artd wroteIt is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.
I didn't say otherwise. Of course it is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer. No doubt, many analytical and engineering minded people are good photographers. It is good to be analytical and engineering minded. However, people whose criticisms of Canon are laced with technical terms about sensor design, fabrication and measurement are not representative of either professional or amateur photographers generally, but are likely narrowly representative of engineers with specialized technical knowledge of sensor design, fabrication and measurement. Their concerns about outcompeting the competition in one benchmark number (low ISO DR) don't necessarily reflect the concerns of photographers generally. Moreover, the reliance on Canon by some of the world's most renowned photographers suggests that outcompeting the competition on this one benchmark number is not nearly as important as some people here make it out to be.
I seriously question some of the poster here who throw out the sensor fabrication specs like they actually understand what impact that has. I know several people do actually work in that field, but others just say it to sound smart and try to justify their endless incorrect predictions and claims.

Also interesting that others don't understand that the world continues to move ahead and change. What made sense 2 years ago, doesn't necessarily make sense now. Saying that high MP wasn't needed several years ago was completely accurate. Canon is still the market leader in sales, they clearly didn't need
...Show more →

Let's be clear here, Canon's revenue has dropped the last couple years and is still pointing in that direction. That is not good for business no matter what spin is put onto it. They are releasing new gear in attempts to regain this lost revenue.
Mar 24, 2015 at 04:52 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.10 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)


artd wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
artd wrote
zlatko wroteThe fact is that Canon cameras — including Canon sensors with their current DR — are very competitive in both professional and amateur photography.
I agree. That's why I still own Canon gear. At the same time, while Canon is extremely competitive as a system, I would love to see a Canon camera that is more competitive in regards to dynamic range.

I also agree that there have been some hypercritical voices in these discussions that exaggerate the issue and its impact. The problem is, trying to counter someone's exaggeration with more exaggeration isn't a very effective strategy and doesn't lead to reasonable discussion.

It is possible to still think Canon's cameras are good and also think that their sensors could be better.

It is possible to be critical of Canon's limitations, yet still use them to make good photos.

It is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.
Who said otherwise?
Someone who, after the OP provided a technical analysis of 5DS DR, made a witty turn on the OP's mispelling of analyzed and to imply he was being anal, along with making comments about those who would like DR improvements as moaning and thinking the sky is falling. And then then applied the label of "Forumtography" as a disparaging term for people choosing to discuss the topic. And wrote that "actual photographers" don't care about "gear wars" implying that if you actually are interested in gear comparisons and analysis you must not be a real photographer.

(Plus someone else who wrote
...Show more →

Now who could that have been? I got my ideas.
Mar 24, 2015 at 04:54 PM
Rajan Parrikar
Offline
Details
p.10 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote:
<I I I my my I I my I I deleted>

We get it. We understand that Sony makes really nice sensors. Asked and answered. Can we please move on?

Dan


Would you please move on? I am interested in the topic started by the OP. You can find other threads that interest you instead of forcing your choices on others here.


Edited on Mar 24, 2015 at 04:56 PM · View previous versions
Mar 24, 2015 at 04:56 PM
Access
Offline
Details
p.10 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Guys it has nothing to do with patents, there are thousands of ways to increase DR and Sony's method is only one of them. We have already seen other methods demonstrated whether it was Fuji's use of photosites with different sensitivities in some of their older compact cameras or MLs use of dual ISO mode where similar photosites use different sensitivity. Yet another method has to do with global shutter and multiple captures created from the same exposure. In short, there is a multitude of different ways to achieve the same thing and each has their own advantages, disadvantages, or none of the above. Some of the methods I outline are even highly scaleable and would allow for nearly infinite DR.

If you know anything about how big business works -- well there is any number of ways it works. Sometimes decisions are made based purely on the ego of a single person, or such; but generally, decisions are made based on ROI (return on investment). The company looks at the probable cost to implement or develop a new technology, the chance of success or failure, and other factors. And they compare this to the additional profit they are likely to reap due to having that new development, feature, etc. And if that ratio is less than 1.0x, it doesn't make much sense to proceed.

Many companies want a ratio of at least 1.2x or 1.3x before they even think about pursuing a new develpment, due to the risk and undertainty that is involved in making such judgements.

Now going back to this point, think of how much actual profit Canon stands to gain if they were to develop a sensor that beat the rest in terms of DR? B'cos I honestly think that number is pretty limited and not worth the cost of development. In the end, it's just a numbers game.
Mar 24, 2015 at 05:05 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.10 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
jctriguy wrote:
retrofocus wroteYour renewed attempt to shut down any kind of discussion which reveals potential (since we don't know it fully yet!) drawbacks of Canon's new sensor does not work. Sorry.
You mean discussions that say the sensor has very similar DR performance to other canon FF sensors? Is anyone learning anything new here? Canon certainly never said the DR was higher in this sensor. This topic is really not a discussion, it is a simple fact.

Now, if this was a topic on the overall image quality and comparisons to other camera systems, that would be an actual discussion.

As it is, these DR 'discussions' just turn to the same tired argument with both sides digging in. You either buy a camera with higher DR or you don't.


Hey JC...I'll ask again. If you know what the discussion is about in this thread, and you are sick and tired of hearing this same discussion...over and over...what the hell are you still reading this thread? Is itnjust to come onto thread and disrupt it? Seems to me the title of the thread was very clear. Why not just ignore this thread and move onto something that does not annoy you.

Walks away shaking head....
Mar 24, 2015 at 05:10 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.10 #6Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Rajan Parrikar wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote<I I I my my I I my I I deleted>

We get it. We understand that Sony makes really nice sensors. Asked and answered. Can we please move on?

Dan
Would you please move on? I am interested in the topic started by the OP. You can find other threads that interest you instead of forcing your choices on others here.


Exactly. If someone is tired of discussing DR...then THEY should move on. This thread is all about DR...what did they expect to be discussed in the thread? Still shaking my head.
Mar 24, 2015 at 05:16 PM
cgarcia
Offline
Details
p.10 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I apologize for the "boring" adjective... I still was in the hope of some improvement, and this didn't occur, and quickly shared this info which many of us were waiting for.

I'm aficionado to a quick online synonym dictionary and many times search for the proper word when I have a similar one in mind. Note that I'm not native english. This time I didn't, but still was not too far, at least to the point of being classified a troll (there are better forums out there for trolls). An official synonym (albeit likely a bit rough) for 'unexciting' is just 'boring':

http://dico.isc.cnrs.fr/dico/en/search?b=1&r=unexciting

In fact, google translates both unexciting and boring as just the same "aburrido" spanish word. Talking about Spanish, I remember a post in another forum (by another person) which used the term "the bomb" referring to a new product. Many members became perplex, because 'the bomb' is something really bad for english-speaking people, while it is a very good thing for spanish ones ("la bomba"). But I'll bear this in mind for the future, the day Canon reach 15 stop DR I'll be very carefull not to use 'the bomb'...
Mar 24, 2015 at 05:19 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.10 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote:
there are thousands of ways to increase DR


Good to know ... maybe somebody should tell Canon. Since it is so easily done ... maybe you could write them a letter outlining how they can achieve "nearly infinite DR".

That, or maybe the question should be "Why hasn't SoNikon" done so already if it is so readily capable to achieve?


Edited on Mar 24, 2015 at 05:40 PM · View previous versions
Mar 24, 2015 at 05:33 PM
ben egbert
Offline
Details
p.10 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Every Ford I ever owned had a tendency to oveheat, before I switched to Toyota, I was a Chevy guy and Chevys did not. I had 1940 and 1948 cars and a 1965 Ford truck. I always wondered why they did not use bigger radiators or water pumps or tune them to run cooler.

But millions of Fords were sold and people swear by them. Each company has its own traits. Many American cars still use push rod engines, about 60 years after that technology became obsolete. But they still sell cars.





Mar 24, 2015 at 05:38 PM
Access
Offline
Details
p.10 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Rustybug, just b'cos there is a multitude of ways to do something, doesn't mean it's easy.

Or if there is a truly 'easy' way, finding that easy way may require a lot of effort and cost in itself as the different methods that sound 'easy' are investigated.

Edited on Mar 24, 2015 at 05:44 PM · View previous versions
Mar 24, 2015 at 05:42 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.10 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wroteYour renewed attempt to shut down any kind of discussion which reveals potential (since we don't know it fully yet!) drawbacks of Canon's new sensor does not work. Sorry.
You mean discussions that say the sensor has very similar DR performance to other canon FF sensors? Is anyone learning anything new here? Canon certainly never said the DR was higher in this sensor. This topic is really not a discussion, it is a simple fact.

Now, if this was a topic on the overall image quality and comparisons to other camera systems, that would be an actual discussion.

As it is, these DR 'discussions' just turn to the same tired argument with both sides digging in. You either buy a camera with higher DR or you don't.
Hey JC...I'll ask again. If you know what the discussion is about in this thread, and you are sick and tired of hearing this same discussion...over and over...why are you still reading this thread? Is it just to come onto thread and disrupt it? Seems to me the title of the thread was very clear. Why not just ignore this thread and move onto something that does not annoy you.


edited parts of your post...lets keep it civil here.

Cher, you totally missed the point of my post. Not uncommon with you or others around here.

The title of this thread is a statement. Someone analyzed some raw files and made a statement of fact (unless you doubt his analysis). The 'discussion', using the term loosely, is then only vaguely related to the title of the thread. It is another in an endless string of such discussions from both sides of the DR 'issue'. It seems that only one side really has an issue and desire to convert everyone else.
Mar 24, 2015 at 05:43 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.10 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote:
Rustybug, just b'cos there is a multitude of ways to do something, doesn't mean it's easy.

Or if there is a truly 'easy' way, finding that easy way may require a lot of effort and cost in itself as the different methods that sound 'easy' are investigated.


Gotcha ... thanks for the clarification.
Mar 24, 2015 at 05:48 PM
AJSJones
Offline
Details
p.10 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote:
Guys it has nothing to do with patents, there are thousands of ways to increase DR and Sony's method is only one of them. We have already seen other methods demonstrated whether it was Fuji's use of photosites with different sensitivities in some of their older compact cameras or MLs use of dual ISO mode where similar photosites use different sensitivity. Yet another method has to do with global shutter and multiple captures created from the same exposure. In short, there is a multitude of different ways to achieve the same thing and each has their own advantages, disadvantages, or
...Show more →
Yeahbut, those workarounds do not use a single exposure with all pixels contributing equally to the image - resolution and luminance. That's what we are talking about. To get it all in one exposure with the DR of the Exmor type sensor seems to require on chip ADC. How should Canon change things to get it all in one exposure - no cheating by workarounds? If they could, they probably would have, no? ML's approach may well be just fine for anyhting other than the lens/aperture/operator combination that maximizes the use of 50MP ...
Mar 24, 2015 at 07:09 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.10 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
jctriguy wrote:
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wroteYour renewed attempt to shut down any kind of discussion which reveals potential (since we don't know it fully yet!) drawbacks of Canon's new sensor does not work. Sorry.
You mean discussions that say the sensor has very similar DR performance to other canon FF sensors? Is anyone learning anything new here? Canon certainly never said the DR was higher in this sensor. This topic is really not a discussion, it is a simple fact.

Now, if this was a topic on the overall image quality and comparisons to other camera systems, that would be an actual discussion.

As it is, these DR 'discussions' just turn to the same tired argument with both sides digging in. You either buy a camera with higher DR or you don't.
Hey JC...I'll ask again. If you know what the discussion is about in this thread, and you are sick and tired of hearing this same discussion...over and over...why are you still reading this thread? Is it just to come onto thread and disrupt it? Seems to me the title of the thread was very clear. Why not just ignore this thread and move onto something that does not annoy you.
edited parts of your post...lets keep it civil here.

Cher, you totally missed the point of my post. Not uncommon with you or others around here.

The title of this thread is a statement. Someone analyzed some raw files and made a statement of fact (unless you doubt his analysis). The 'discussion', using the term loosely, is then only vaguely related to the title of the thread. It is another in an endless string of such discussions from both sides of the DR 'issue'. It seems that only one side really has an issue and desire to convert everyone else.


Still did not answer my question. If you are sick and tired discussing DR, why are you still contributing to a thread that was discussing DR? Maybe down deep you like to discuss ( argue ) for the sake of it.

I get nothing out of discussions on AF tracking for birds in flight so I just ignore those threads. You should try to ignore threads that don't interest you.
Mar 24, 2015 at 07:36 PM
artd
Offline
Details
p.10 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
While folks rage on about how much greater DR benefits them ... is there an application where the lesser DR is beneficial, or at least a trade-off is incurred in some regard, and how might that be?

Unfortunately I've seen nothing beneficial about having less DR. I've seen nothing to suggest that somehow having less DR capability in the sensor results in a beneficial trade-off, either in my own experience with Canon and non-Canon sensors, or in any other reported experiences.


My point is this ... is Canon's decision to remain @ current and longstanding DR based on some rationale that some folks aren't aware of. It strikes me as very hard to believe that Canon hasn't changed their DR because they can't, but rather they consistently choose not to for some rationale of other preference that isn't being given credence to ... i.e. maybe something in regard to the publishing industry, etc.

My guess is I think the only rationale at work is money, nothing more or less noble than that. Not being critical of Canon for that, they are in business to make as much money as they can, after all. Yes, it's true that there are patents on the column parallel ADC that Sony uses on their sensors. Could Canon figure out a different way to get to the same result with a different technological advance? Maybe. Would it cost a lot of R&D money? Probably.

My speculation would be that either they haven't been able to technically figure out a way to do it that doesn't violate the Exmor patent, or they've calculated there is no need to invest in developing a new breakthrough sensor technology when subtle refinements still allow them to put out another generation of successful cameras.

While I understand either of those scenarios as business realities, it doesn't mean I won't be disappointed.

Mar 24, 2015 at 08:23 PM
Access
Offline
Details
p.10 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
AJSJones wrote:
one exposure with the DR of the Exmor type sensor seems to require on chip ADC. How should Canon change things to get it all in one exposure - no cheating by workarounds? If they could, they probably would have, no? ML's approach may well be just fine for anyhting other than the lens/aperture/operator combination that maximizes the use of 50MP ...

What is 'cheating'? What is 'workaround'? These things are irrelevant, the only thing that matters is the qualities of the final product (photo) that is produced. It really doesn't matter how we get there if we are able to produce good results in that final product without detectable artifacts. The sensor might as well be a 'black box'.

Most of these methods would require hardware changes and those are often expensive, requiring lots of money as well as time, both active worker time and time spent waiting for a fabrication attempt. And often it takes multiple attempts to 'get it right'.

Example hardware changes would be things like the ability to set each pixel to a different ISO (ML has shown the hardware can already set each line of pixels to different ISO); a fast global shutter that is compatible with either multiple readouts over the course of a single exposure, or multiple additive exposures; the ability to read back an amplified photosite voltage multiple times with differing gain (ISO), and so on. Once the hardware supports modes like this, it opens up a lot of possibilities for algorithms to increase the DR substantially. Of course there are no guarantees, some attempts may be dead ends, others may only give a partial success, but that is the nature of research.
Mar 24, 2015 at 08:35 PM
NormanPCN
Offline
Details
p.10 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
If you are sick and tired discussing DR, why are you still contributing to a thread that was discussing DR?


I think I need to re-read this thread. I must have missed the "discussion". I have picked up on discussions of religion or cult or whatever the prefered word is. Brand religion/cult, technology religion/cult and so on. No matter the side or the "discussion", the answer is self evident to each side and other other side simply just does not get it.

There was a Ford and Chevy metaphor in this thread. OMG is that ever a massive historic "religious" war. I am speaking as someone from the muscle car era and I am a total Mustang/Ford man. Mustang versus Camaro. Yikes! I'll never own a GM product. There is no logic and/or reasoning to this. It just is...and yes all you GM people just don't get it.

Mar 24, 2015 at 08:48 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.10 #18Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote:
Now going back to this point, think of how much actual profit Canon stands to gain if they were to develop a sensor that beat the rest in terms of DR? B'cos I honestly think that number is pretty limited and not worth the cost of development. In the end, it's just a numbers game.


Exactly, it's not a technology decision but a business decision. If low ISO DR was a difference maker in regards to competitors sales then Canon would be prioritizing it far more. As it is they can still wait it out. Look at the 5D3. It's still on the Amazon top 20 in DSLR sales while the D800/D800E/D810/D750 all with greater low ISO DR are behind it.
Mar 24, 2015 at 09:03 PM
whumber
Offline
Details
p.10 #19Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
whumber wroteNew semi-conductor fabrication facilities are astronomically expensive and Canon's production volume is dropping off a cliff with the death of P&S cameras and their lack of any cell phone cameras.
Inferring they are standing pat, until they develop their next gen "organic" or "Foveon-like" non-Bayer array sensor @ paradigm shift / quantum leap, rather than incur the expense for a half-step (not to be confused with half-stop) incremental improvement.


It has nothing to do with moving to anything as fancy as organic or foveon style sensors. It's all about how much circuitry you can fit onto the chip. Canon is still building their sensors with a 500nm process while all of the other manufacturers are using 180nm (or 90nm in Samsung's case) processes. This allows other manufacturers to put more circuitry directly on the chip (like A/D converters) whereas they just won't fit onto the chip without eating up an unreasonable amount of sensor area in Canon's case. Moving to a smaller process requires a completely new fabrication facility which is incredibly expensive. With the P/S market all but dead, it's very likely that the DSLR market simply won't be large enough over the next ten years to make that investment worthwhile. Samsung, Sony, Toshiba, etc. are all deeply involved with cell phone cameras so they have enough volume coming from those markets to make further investments economically viable. That said, Canon's recent acquisition of Axis could be good for the DSLR division as it could encourage further investment in semiconductor infrastructure.
Mar 24, 2015 at 09:27 PM
Access
Offline
Details
p.10 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
whumber wrote:
It has nothing to do with moving to anything as fancy as organic or foveon style sensors. It's all about how much circuitry you can fit onto the chip. Canon is still building their sensors with a 500nm process while all of the other manufacturers are using 180nm (or 90nm in Samsung's case) processes. This allows other manufacturers to put more circuitry directly on the chip

Actually it's both. That number before the "nm" is just a number. And many people oversimplify or get hung up over one prominent number without realizing that number is just part of the story. It's like the people who obsess over CPU clock speed of the PCs believing that is the end-all or be-all of performance, when it is not the actual case.

I'm not saying the number isn't important, but it's really just part of the story. If Canon decided that more DR was worth pursuing, there are plenty of things they could try without having to go to a much finer process. And they probably would pursue those methods first, as it is like you pointed out, the expense of a new process is considerable.
Mar 24, 2015 at 10:29 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister