p.24 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
Rusty, you are making the assumption that no new photographers are entering FM on a daily basis or are getting interested into landscape photography. FM is a very large world wide community that has the vast majority of members being quiet members sitting in the background gathering information. The very small group of active forum participants might know all about the different cameras options out there, but i don't think you can speak for those you don't even know exist.
To me these new high mpix Canon cameras target landscape photography where DR is a very important topic. Talking about options out there for landscape photography is good in my opinion and trying to squash it is something totally wrong. ...Show more →
You are assuming / projecting that this is a landscape photography thread / discussion ...
Maybe we should start one dedicated to that ... if that's the context / platform we wish to address the silent readers. Then they wouldn't be mired in non-landscape dialogues about Canon's DR and it's relative approach to non-landscape uses.
Maybe trying to mix "landscape" focus and Canon's DR discussions may be too wide of a coverage for a good exchange among our fellow members ... particularly given the OP.
p.24 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
I guess the assumption discussing dynamic range on a high mpix camera might be of interest to landscape photography. These new Canon cameras are not geared towards street, sports or other event photography, but I can see them being used a lot by landscape photographers. Don't you feel a discussion on dynamic range of a high mpix camera might be of interest to landscape photographers.
+1 @ dynamic range and high MP could be of interest to a landscape photographer.
BUT ... that high MP could be just as useful to a fashion photographer, a macro photographer, a bird photographer, a surfing photographer, etc.
The advance in MP opens a plethora of utility beyond that of landscape ... many of which aren't necessarily concerned by extreme DR the same way as some (i.e. not all) landscapes might be. Landscape is not the holy grail of photography for which all others should bow to. Lassoing the thread by the throat of landscape superiority really is unfair to ... ummm, those silent readers ... others who have interests in Canon's DR @ other than ISO 100 or ISO 200 (which is where any meaningful difference is really relegated to).
p.24 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote: chez wroteI guess the assumption discussing dynamic range on a high mpix camera might be of interest to landscape photography. These new Canon cameras are not geared towards street, sports or other event photography, but I can see them being used a lot by landscape photographers. Don't you feel a discussion on dynamic range of a high mpix camera might be of interest to landscape photographers.+1 @ dynamic range and high MP could be of interest to a landscape photographer.
BUT ... that high MP could be just as useful to a fashion photographer, a macro photographer, a bird photographer, a surfing photographer, etc.
The advance in MP opens a plethora of utility beyond that of landscape ... many of which aren't necessarily concerned by extreme DR the same way as some (i.e. not all) landscapes might be. Landscape is not the holy grail of photography for which all others should bow to. Lassoing the thread by the throat of landscape superiority really is unfair to ... ummm, those silent readers ... others who have interests in Canon's DR @ other than ISO 100 or ISO 200 (which is where any meaningful difference is really relegated to).
I agree high mpix does not automatically imply landscape...but high mpix and DR...which is what the original topic of this thread was about, does really go hand-in-hand with landscape photography. I for one am interested in these new cameras for landscape photography...awaiting for actual released versions to see how well they perform. Might sell my 5d2 and invest into a higher mpix camera.
Rusty...what is your interest in these new cameras. What would you be shooting where you need more pixels?
p.24 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I don't have a burning need for the 50MP (although I'd find a use for it ) ... I just have an (unhealthy ) passion for the no AA filter. I'd be good with about 28-30 MP and no AA filter (which is why I looked hard @ the A7R & D800E, but they don't fit my other needs).
More DR would be fine ... but I can live with Canon's current (given the recent knowledge of patent issues vs. expectations of Canon changing their DR and / or their DR approach) DR just fine. Probably goes back to my years of shooting FujiChrome 50 @ -1/2 EV latitude. Canon's DR smokes that for latitude and I learned my "workarounds" fairly proficiently, so I'm okay @ status quo for DR more than one way to skin a cat.
Probably shooting more of the same that shows in my TOP 15 ... a compilation from landscape to nature to still life to abstract.
The one thing that I would probably add to my objectives would be to take a stab at "birding". The high MP could make for some interesting times ... even if you're tossing 80% of it away @ cropping.
Thanks for asking.
And you ... what would a 5Ds or 5DsR mean for your work?
p.24 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
I don't have a burning need for the 50MP (although I'd find a use for it ) ... I just have an (unhealthy ) passion for the no AA filter. I'd be good with about 28-30 MP and no AA filter (which is why I looked hard @ the A7R & D800E, but they don't fit my other needs).
More DR would be fine ... but I can live with Canon's current (given the recent knowledge of patent issues vs. expectations of Canon changing their DR and / or their DR approach) DR just fine. Probably goes back to my years of shooting FujiChrome 50 @ -1/2 EV latitude. Canon's DR smokes that for latitude and I learned my "workarounds" fairly proficiently, so I'm okay @ status quo for DR more than one way to skin a cat.
Probably shooting more of the same that shows in my TOP 15 ... a compilation from landscape to nature to still life to abstract.
The one thing that I would probably add to my objectives would be to take a stab at "birding". The high MP could make for some interesting times ... even if you're tossing 80% of it away @ cropping.
Thanks for asking.
And you ... what would a 5Ds or 5DsR mean for your work?...Show more →
I mainly focus on landscape photography and print / sell large prints to the new home / home renovation markets. I am always looking for improvements in cameras that make my work easier to accomplish. Higher pixels is definitely a plus as I print up to 4'x7' in size...so the more the better.
I too have worked for years with film ( still do for B&W ) and have learned techniques to deal with limited dynamic range...and yes the DSLR world has greatly expanded on dynamic range compared to chromes. But I am still looking at technology advancing and always plan to take advantage of these advances...why not?
Most of my lenses are Canon mount, so it only makes sense to keep an eye on the Canon side to see where they are going with cameras. I look at photo equipment like tools...getting the best one for the job. Just like my wood working tools are from different manufactures ( Makita, Robi, Craftsman etc.... ) so is my camera gear. I try to keep track of the different camera brands out there, see where they are going, see if they have something to offer to make my life easier.
p.24 #6Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
whumber wrote: mogul wroteMy little Sony A77II tracks just fine at 12fps with more af points. The 1Dx can only shoot jpegs at its fastest rate.
edit: looks as if my answer to a comment that was deleted.The A77II isn't quite comparable to the 1DX/D4s for tracking at high frame rate. At it's maximum speed with tracking you don't have any control of shutter speed nor can you have the lens stop down. As for JPGs on the 1DX, that's only true for the 14fps which doesn't allow tracking either. RAW at 12fps is no problem though.
At 12fps, the only thing locked is aperture (3.5) in aperture mode, by vary the other 2 variables (iso and shutter) control is maintained. I do not contend that the 77II is as capable as the top 2 of the line cameras but it is competitive. My response was to a comment (since pulled) that the 1dx was the standard and Canon had a lock on the superiority of its AF module.
p.24 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
mogul wrote:
I do not contend that the 77II is as capable as the top 2 of the line cameras but it is competitive. My response was to a comment (since pulled) that the 1dx was the standard and Canon had a lock on the superiority of its AF module.
My 1DX AF is outstanding but I think Canon has upped the ante on initial AF lock in low contrast, low light with the 7D2. From my testing it is quicker to grab onto something. Bodes well for the 1DX2.
p.24 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote: I mainly focus on landscape photography and print / sell large prints to the new home / home renovation markets. I am always looking for improvements in cameras that make my work easier to accomplish. Higher pixels is definitely a plus as I print up to 4'x7' in size...so the more the better.
Given the large prints you make, MFD would be the ideal camera for your needs. Shooting with a full frame sensor is rarely going to be your best option. I took at a look at the Canon 5Ds specs and realized I needed MFD to satisfy many of my clients, and begrudgingly, pulled the trigger. You may want to start saving your pennies. The 5D3 will still be my go-to body in most cases, but it's nice to have two cameras that cover all my requests from clients.
p.24 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Deezie wrote: Earlier quotechez wrote: I mainly focus on landscape photography and print / sell large prints to the new home / home renovation markets. I am always looking for improvements in cameras that make my work easier to accomplish. Higher pixels is definitely a plus as I print up to 4'x7' in size...so the more the better.Given the large prints you make, MFD would be the ideal camera for your needs. Shooting with a full frame sensor is rarely going to be your best option. I took at a look at the Canon 5Ds specs and realized I needed MFD to satisfy many of my clients, and begrudgingly, pulled the trigger. You may want to start saving your pennies. The 5D3 will still be my go-to body in most cases, but it's nice to have two cameras that cover all my requests from clients.
Just too big and cumbersome to lug around, especially on muti-day treks into the wilderness. The Sony comes in at a fraction of the cost, weight and bulk and most likely delivers 95% of the quality of MFD. That said, I do lug my 4x5 outfit on longer treks...but not multi-day.
The Pentax system sure looks nice...might be worth renting for a few days.
p.24 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Deezie wrote: Earlier quotechez wrote: I mainly focus on landscape photography and print / sell large prints to the new home / home renovation markets. I am always looking for improvements in cameras that make my work easier to accomplish. Higher pixels is definitely a plus as I print up to 4'x7' in size...so the more the better.Given the large prints you make, MFD would be the ideal camera for your needs. Shooting with a full frame sensor is rarely going to be your best option. I took at a look at the Canon 5Ds specs and realized I needed MFD to satisfy many of my clients, and begrudgingly, pulled the trigger. You may want to start saving your pennies. The 5D3 will still be my go-to body in most cases, but it's nice to have two cameras that cover all my requests from clients.
Just curious to know what part of the specs of the 5Ds that are limiting, what MFD system you chose and how much more you expect of that system, quantified.
p.24 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I wonder if us Canon shooters might be 'able' to have an actual Canon gear discussion; what to, how to, my experiences doing this or that, without another member bringing up 'low DR' as an issue.
No doubt this notion is impossible, but to actually converse about what we enjoy about our Canon bodies and/or all lenses/accessories would be quite refreshing. Other gear manufactures have their forums and I'm guessing that's why Fred designed FM in said manor.
I truly enjoy my Canon gear, have since late 1978 and it still works wonders for what I shoot. And when I find something lacking it's off to the other forums for advice, information and images.
The lack of civility at times with this DR discussion is down right ugly and there's no need for it, and there certainly are many that find it unwanted. We should all 'STOP' the bickering and use/contribute to this wonderful forum in a way that promotes this inspiring art form and abandon whose gears are better/bigger.
There is so much more beauty around us that can be shared, that can inspire, how about focusing on such and make this place of imagery as humbling via conversation/debate as it is with those still and moving moments we share, that inspire new thought. A cripple's dream perhaps, tho I'll not be holding my breath contemplating it's arrival, for this wanting at time seems but a pipe dream...
p.24 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
StillFingerz wrote:
There is so much more beauty around us that can be shared, that can inspire, how about focusing on such and make this place of imagery as humbling via conversation/debate as it is with those still and moving moments we share, that inspire new thought. A cripple's dream perhaps, tho I'll not be holding my breath contemplating it's arrival, for this wanting at time seems but a pipe dream...
Cheers,
Jerry
And surely we would share all of this beauty that surrounds us, on this lovely home orb we all live on, if only our Canon EOS cameras had a decent enough dynamic range so we could capture it and share it
p.24 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
Ummm...thread about no increase in DR in Canon's latest cameras and you expected what when you entered this thread? Obviously it's about DR and obviously there will be comparisons to other Cameras.
I think most of us were simply expecting that it should be PRIMARILY a discussion about Canon, Canon's DR, and Canon's other cameras ... it is after all a Canon Forum.
DR in general ... education points about DR, sure. Justification, rationalization, preferences about the other brands ... go start a thread "Why I like other brands better than Canon" or "Why I augment Canon with SoNikon." or "Why Landscape shooters might not buy the new 5Ds / 5DsR", or any other topic of discussion that suits a person.
Maybe we should be discussing the DR of T-Max or the DR of the Leica DMR or the DR of Hasselblads ... why is it that SoNikon's has license to intrude the conversation just because it has a different DR. Heck, we should be talking about the Fuji S3/S5 since it has more DR than Canon. I should be talking about my glorious SLR/C since it has DR. If the fact that a camera has a different DR than Canon opens Pandora's Box, then we should be talking about the DR of Polaroid film and Daguerreotypes and the DR of a cold scanner hacked into an 8X10 camera.
The problem here is that folks are using any excuse they can to grant themselves unbridled liberty to intrude on the topic ... which is Canon's DR (specifically in the new model) ... and yet, they continue to clearly persist despite plenty of requests to cease doing so. That is just plain rude, and disrespectful ... if you want to start your own thread to discuss what it is you want to discuss, then PLEASE go start another thread. There's plenty of space to do so ... Fred is REALLY GOOD TO US in that regard. No one is trying to silence you ... just read the sign at the front door as to which sandbox you've come to play in.
FM'ers tend to "go silent" when the discussion isn't to their interest. But, that is a different matter from being intrusive and disruptive to a discussion that is to their interest. For that they tend to speak up. Please try to understand the difference. It shouldn't be that hard ... people have politely (before some turned rude) asked, so it isn't like it is difficult to know.
BTW, Sony has a different DR than Leica ... maybe you could take the A7R discussion over there for a while ... especially since A7R users play with M glass too. Be sure and let them know all the reasons you use the A7R instead of a Leica. I'm certain they'll be very glad to hear how much better the A7R is than their Leica's.
I mean seriously ... walk into a Ford dealer and start talking about Chevy's. Do you not EXPECT that folks in the Ford garage would rather discuss Fords than your desire to discuss Chevy's? If you want to talk stroker vs. high RPM engines, sure they'll welcome that. But if all you are going to do is repetitively sing the praises of the Chevy ... what do you EXPECT their response to be? Just keep telling them how you are just there to share your opinion ... what do you EXPECT their response to that is going to be? Probably not nearly as polite as (most) folks have tried to be here @ FM.
Do you really not think that Ford guys already know about Chevy offerings ... and if they are inquisitive, that they wouldn't ... oh gee, IDK ... go ask a Chevy guy over in the Chevy garage?
You want to ask them what they think about the new Camaro or Corvette, sure why not ... but to keep prodding them with how great the Camaro or Corvette is when you already know they are Mustang guys AND when they tell you they don't care to discuss the Camaro / Vette right now ... what, you're gonna just keep on jacking them up about how much you love your Corvette.
p.24 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
BTW, Sony has a different DR than Leica ... maybe you could take the A7R discussion over there for a while ... especially since A7R users play with M glass too. Be sure and let them know all the reasons you use the A7R instead of a Leica. I'm certain they'll be very glad to hear how much better the A7R is than their Leica's.
In fact this discussion happened after the A7 series was released and also in some treads last year in the Alt forum. I followed most of those discussions since I was (and am) very interested in the pros and cons of each system in comparison. Many Leica users were very open to the A7 technology and added it to their existing Leica camera(s). The advantage in Sony's sensor was fairly undisputed, but the issue was adaptability with some M series wide angle lenses on the A7/A7R sensors. Only recently improved corner sharpness was achieved on the A7 series cameras by replacing the thicker sensor glass with a thinner one similar to Leica M cameras for example (interesting discussions there, too).
p.24 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
In fact this discussion happened after the A7 series was released and also in some treads last year in the Alt forum. I followed most of those discussions since I was (and am) very interested in the pros and cons of each system in comparison. Many Leica users were very open to the A7 technology and added it to their existing Leica camera(s). The advantage in Sony's sensor was fairly undisputed, but the issue was adaptability with some M series wide angle lenses on the A7/A7R sensors. Only recently improved corner sharpness was achieved on the A7 series cameras by replacing the thicker sensor glass with a thinner one similar to Leica M cameras for example (interesting discussions there, too). ...Show more →
Yes, I was very participating in those discussions ... that was a long time ago, and we had a very long discussion when it was a current issue. So, if Leica announced a new camera today ... should that warrant a rehash of what we already know about Sony over in the Alt Forum. My point was that Leica users ARE well aware of the Sony BECAUSE it is was such "BIG NEWS" ... yet, that is now "OLD NEWS". The A7R is old news (albeit very good news for some).
Leica users don't need an incessant reminder of the A7R any more than Canon users do. Just like the comment that the majority of those who "need" the A7R have already gone down that path (or are aware of plans to do so), those Leica M glass fans who have clamored for years for something like the A7R, they too are already aware of the A7R and have (largely) made their decisions (or at least research) into the matter. A daily, weekly, thread rehash isn't necessary ... yet, here in the Canon Forum, we are getting the rehash despite clear & concise requests for it to diminish @ "not necessary". BTW, there is always the search feature if folks want to read up on the A7R threads again ... we just don't need the incessant rehash of advocacy.
I really don't enjoy spelling this out ... I'd rather geek out on charts & graphs or theory ... like the one chart about shadow dynamic range and ISOless ISO, to better understand where a given Canon camera's "sweet spot" might be or where it's "weak spot" might be. That would be helpful to me, and I think for others as well. Seeing the step pattern @ interval ISO's could be helpful as well to understand how you might make your "bumps" (up or down) to retain the optimal DR for your camera.
Hearing about the A7R again, not so much. Trying to come up with a thirty-seventh different polite way to ask folks to refrain from the repetitive, A7R love fest, not so much either. I get why some folks turn rude (but that still is no excuse to be rude) after asking nicely. Of course, they are much more concise than I ... even though folks have asked very simply "Please Stop".
To that point, I'd still like mttran to return some clarification ... lest I fumble along with the information myself. I think it could be pertinent to the topic of Canon's DR (without the need to advocate for the A7R, etc.).
If I'm driving a Mustang, I really don't need to hear all day about how much better a Ferrari engine is. I just want to hear how much better I can make my Mustang run. We can talk "Ferrari Love" another time and another place ... but here & now doesn't help when I'm trying to better understand my Mustang, unless you are using it somehow to help me with my Mustang. Telling me the Ferrari is faster on the Autobahn or how much you enjoyed driving the streets of Monte Carlo in your Ferrari while pretending it was the Grand Prix, doesn't do me much good at learning how to get the most out of my Mustang.
p.24 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Deezie wrote:
Given the large prints you make, MFD would be the ideal camera for your needs. Shooting with a full frame sensor is rarely going to be your best option. I took at a look at the Canon 5Ds specs and realized I needed MFD to satisfy many of my clients, and begrudgingly, pulled the trigger. You may want to start saving your pennies. The 5D3 will still be my go-to body in most cases, but it's nice to have two cameras that cover all my requests from clients.
Alundeb wrote:
Just curious to know what part of the specs of the 5Ds that are limiting, what MFD system you chose and how much more you expect of that system, quantified. ...Show more →
I shoot advertising campaigns for the film studios and tv networks. Often this mean ripping up files for building sides and bus sides, so medium format digital is not only preferred, it is directly asked for. The 5D3 is fine for billboards because the viewing distance is rarely from close up, so the artifacts and pixelation goes unnoticed.
p.24 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Deezie wrote: Earlier quoteDeezie wrote:
Given the large prints you make, MFD would be the ideal camera for your needs. Shooting with a full frame sensor is rarely going to be your best option. I took at a look at the Canon 5Ds specs and realized I needed MFD to satisfy many of my clients, and begrudgingly, pulled the trigger. You may want to start saving your pennies. The 5D3 will still be my go-to body in most cases, but it's nice to have two cameras that cover all my requests from clients.
Alundeb wrote:
Just curious to know what part of the specs of the 5Ds that are limiting, what MFD system you chose and how much more you expect of that system, quantified.I shoot advertising campaigns for the film studios and tv networks. Often this mean ripping up files for building sides and bus sides, so medium format digital is not only preferred, it is directly asked for. The 5D3 is fine for billboards because the viewing distance is rarely from close up, so the artifacts and pixelation goes unnoticed.
That didn't answer any of my questions, but thank you anyway. If clients require it, there isn't much you can do.
p.24 #18Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I went back to read the OP data and the OP makes mention of the "fake ISO" @ 6400 and above. It got me thinking about the Shadow Dynamic Range chart from earlier with the step increments to see if there was a correlation (shown in the 6D, not the 5Ds / 5DsR).
I didn't really see a strong correlation here @ the 6400 ISO mark, except for the small dip that occurs ... but, it did reinforce the concept @ the steps being taken. Specifically, it appears as though the 1/3 & 2/3 ISO increment bumps remain as the lower whole EV value before taking on the characteristics of the next whole value.
So, while the overall DR maximum may have not changed significantly, I'm curious to the utility of the intervals. The OP's data is only presented in the form of the whole EV's (i.e. 100, 200, 400, etc.), I'm curious if his data would reveal similar "sliding steps" rather than an assumed linear progression for the 1/3 & 2/3 step increments that is shown below.
So, when one considers the concept of "no change" to Canon DR, it might be a case of truth that no change to the maximum DR exists, it may have incurred a change to how the response to shadow DR occurs WITHIN the ISO / DR relationship.
While I do NOT profess to understand and correctly interpret the chart below, it strikes me additionally, to note that the A7R takes a dip (similar ,but larger than the 6D @ 6400) into a negative value for Shadow Dynamic Range. I'm not sure what to make of that or how to properly interpret that data point ... but it does create a desire to understand what that phenomenon presents or how it occurs. Initial thoughts include that it is also indicative of a "fake ISO" and it is merely a matter of more light being collected and thus the cause / effect of the DR response differences.
I do see per DXO that Sony "fudges" their ISO a bit more than others. I've got no real issue with that per se (since I was an ISO 50 junkie anyway), but it does raise the point @ the fundamental aspect that more light = less noise, so if the sensor is really an ISO 73 instead of an ISO 100 (whereas Canon is ISO 80 instead of 100), more light = less noise is of little surprise. That 7 ISO diff may not sound like much, but on an exponential scale, it certainly doesn't hurt.
My initial response to the negative value is that if the positive values infer that changes in ISO aid Shadow Dynamic Range, then such a negative value would infer that a change to that ISO would be a detractor from Shadow Dynamic Range impact by the ISO change. However, I also note that the bottom of that negative dip appears correlated to the appx ISO 73 (which would align with DXO indication of the true ISO for the A7R) Again, not my chart / data and we've not heard from the author for explanation.
It may seem to some that the 1/3 intervals are "splitting hairs" ... but if Canon has adopted a "sliding step" approach, then a bump in ISO of 2/3 without penalty (if that holds true) could mean that shooting @ 1250 instead of 1600 or @ 160 instead of 200 (et all) could be an employable strategy to retain better DR before the next "hit" to DR comes along at the next full ISO interval. Again, not my data, just trying to understand what it is telling us.
I'd be curious to see the 5Ds / 5DsR data plotted in this form as well to see what if any changes are reflected in this Shadow Dynamic Range presentation. For that, we'll likely have to wait for the author to update.
p.24 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
ggreene wrote: alundeb wrotePeople go into the Sony forum all the time and make posts about what has not been improved in new Sony cameras. No problem at all.The same few people again and again and again, and in non related threads?
No, and I don't think it is a good thing to mention it out of context.
There are similar problems regarding format comparisons in the alternative forum. In many threads about small sensor cameras and their lenses, some people, myself included, want to compare those lenses with the full format equivalent. That has often led to fights similar to here, with the exception that people don't even agree on equivalence.
I just want to share my observation that it takes to sides to make a fight, and in this case the thread started with actual, relevant data.